Using large-scale, linked, employer–employee, Finnish panel data, the authors examine firms’ internal versus external hiring decisions more comprehensively than has prior literature. The results show that vacancies in job hierarchies are filled more often by horizontal moves than by promotions. Most horizontal moves are external and within the same job functions, so that internally promoted workers face external competitors occupying higher job levels. Compared to internally promoted workers, external and internal horizontal hires have stronger observable ability indicators (e.g., education, experience, prior work history) but weaker job performance in the year preceding the transfer. Internal and external horizontal hires have similar job histories.
AgrawalAnupKnoeberCharles R.TsoulouhasTheofanis. 2006. Are outsiders handicapped in CEO successions?Journal of Corporate Finance12(3): 619–44.
2.
ArthurMichael BernardRousseauDenise M.2001. The Boundaryless Career: A New Employment Principle for a New Organizational Era. New York: Oxford University Press.
3.
AudasRickBarmbyTimTrebleJohn. 2004. Luck, effort, and reward in an organizational hierarchy. Journal of Labor Economics22(2): 379–95.
4.
BakerGeorgeHolmströmBengt. 1995. Internal labor markets: Too many theories, too few facts. American Economic Review85(2): 255–59.
5.
BakerGeorgeGibbsMichaelHolmströmBengt. 1994. The internal economics of the firm: Evidence from personnel data. Quarterly Journal of Economics109(4): 881–919.
6.
Bayo-MorionesAlbertoOrtín-ÁngelPedro. 2006. Internal promotion versus external recruitment in industrial plants in Spain. Industrial and Labor Relations Review59(3): 451–70.
7.
BelzilChristianBognannoMichael. 2008. Promotions, demotions, halo effects, and the earnings dynamics of American executives. Journal of Labor Economics26(2): 287–310.
8.
BernhardtDan. 1995. Strategic promotion and compensation. Review of Economic Studies62(2): 315–39.
9.
BernhardtDanScoonesDavid. 1993. Promotion, turnover, and preemptive wage offers. American Economic Review83(4): 771–91.
10.
BidwellMatthew. 2011. Paying more to get less: The effects of external hiring versus internal mobility. Administrative Science Quarterly56(3): 369–407.
11.
BidwellMatthewKellerJ. R.2014. Within or without? How firms combine internal and external labor markets to fill jobs. Academy of Management Journal57(4): 1035–55.
12.
BidwellMatthewMollickEthan. 2015. Shifts and ladders: Comparing the role of internal and external mobility in managerial careers. Organization Science26(6): 1629–45.
13.
BognannoMichael L.2001. Corporate tournaments. Journal of Labor Economics19(2): 290–315.
14.
CassidyHugh. 2017. Task variation within occupations. Industrial Relations56(3): 393–410.
15.
CassidyHughDeVaroJedKauhanenAntti. 2016. Promotion signaling, gender, and turnover: New theory and evidence. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization126, Part A (June): 140–66.
16.
ChanWilliam. 1996. External recruitment versus internal promotion. Journal of Labor Economics14(4): 555–70.
17.
ChanWilliam. 2006. External recruitment and intrafirm mobility. Economic Inquiry44(1): 169–84.
18.
DeVaroJedKauhanenAntti. 2016. An “opposing responses” test of classic versus market-based promotion tournaments. Journal of Labor Economics34(3): 747–79.
19.
DeVaroJedMoritaHodaka. 2013. Internal promotion and external recruitment: A theoretical and empirical analysis. Journal of Labor Economics31(2): 227–69.
20.
DeVaroJedWaldmanMichael. 2012. The signalling role of promotions: Further theory and empirical evidence. Journal of Labor Economics30(1): 91–147.
21.
DeVaroJedGhoshSumanZoghiCindy. 2018. Job characteristics and labor market discrimination in promotions. Industrial Relations57(3): 389–434.
22.
DohmenThomas J.KriechelBenPfannGerard A.2004. Monkey bars and ladders: The importance of lateral and vertical job mobility in internal labor market careers. Journal of Population Economics17(2): 193–228.
23.
ErikssonTorOrtegaJaime. 2006. The adoption of job rotation: Testing the theories. Industrial and Labor Relations Review59(4): 653–66.
24.
FanXiaodongDeVaro.Jed2018. Does job hopping help or hinder careers? The signaling role of work history. California State University, East Bay.
25.
FrederiksenAndersKatoTakao. 2018. Human capital and career success: Evidence from linked employer-employee data. Economic Journal128(613): 1952–82.
26.
FrederiksenAndersHallidayTimothyKochAlexander K.2015. Within- and cross-firm mobility and earnings growth. ILR Review69(2): 320–53.
27.
FrederiksenAndersLangeFabianKriechelBen. 2017. Subjective performance evaluations and employee careers. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization134(February): 408–29.
28.
GathmannChristinaSchönbergUta. 2010. How general is human capital? A task-based approach. Journal of Labor Economics28(1): 1–49.
29.
GhoshSumanWaldmanMichael. 2010. Standard promotion practices versus up-or-out contracts. RAND Journal of Economics41(2): 301–25.
30.
GibbonsRobertWaldmanMichael. 2004. Task-specific human capital. American Economic Review94(2): 203–7.
31.
GibbonsRobertWaldmanMichael. 2006. Enriching a theory of wage and promotion dynamics inside firms. Journal of Labor Economics24(1): 59–107.
32.
GreenwaldBruce C.1986. Adverse selection in the labour market. Review of Economic Studies53(3): 325–47.
33.
HamermeshDaniel S.2007. Viewpoint: Replication in economics. Canadian Journal of Economics40(3): 715–33.
34.
JacobySanford M.2005. The Embedded Corporation. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
35.
JinXinWaldmanMichael. 2016. Lateral moves, promotions, and task-specific human capital: Theory and evidence. Mimeo. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University.
36.
KambourovGueorguiManovskiiIourii. 2009. Occupational specificity of human capital. International Economic Review50(1): 63–115.
37.
KauhanenAnttiNapariSami. 2012. Career and wage dynamics: Evidence from linked employer-employee data. In PolachekSolomon W.TatsiramosKonstantinos (Eds.), Research in Labor Economics, pp. 35–76. Bingley, West Yorkshire, UK: Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
38.
KeRongzhuLiJinPowellMichael. 2018. Managing careers in organizations. Journal of Labor Economics36(1): 197–252.
39.
LazearEdward P.OyerPaul. 2004. Internal and external labor markets: A personnel economics approach. Labour Economics11(5): 527–54.
40.
LazearEdward P.RosenSherwin. 1981. Rank-order tournaments as optimum labor contracts. Journal of Political Economy89(5): 841–64.
41.
MacLeodW. BentleyMalcomsonJames M.1988. Reputation and hierarchy in dynamic models of employment. Journal of Political Economy96(4): 832–54.
42.
MalcomsonJames M.1984. Work incentives, hierarchy, and internal labor markets. Journal of Political Economy92(3): 486–507.
43.
MedoffJames L.AbrahamKatharine G.1980. Experience, performance, and earnings. Quarterly Journal of Economics95(4): 703–36.
44.
MedoffJames L.AbrahamKatharine G.1981. Are those paid more really more productive? The case of experience. Journal of Human Resources16(2): 186–216.
45.
NapariSami. 2009. Gender differences in early-career wage growth. Labour Economics16(2): 140–48.
46.
OrtegaJaime. 2001. Job rotation as a learning mechanism. Management Science47(10): 1361–70.
47.
OwanHideo. 2004. Promotion, turnover, earnings, and firm-sponsored training. Journal of Labor Economics22(4): 955–78.
48.
PergamitMichael R.VeumJonathan R.1999. What is a promotion?Industrial and Labor Relations Review52(4): 581–601.
49.
PrendergastCanice. 1993. The role of promotion in inducing specific human capital acquisition. Quarterly Journal of Economics108(2): 523–34.
50.
Ricart i CostaJoan E.1988. Managerial task assignment and promotions. Econometrica56(2): 449–66.
51.
RoyalCarolAlthauserRobert P.2003. The labor markets of knowledge workers: Investment bankers’ careers in the wake of corporate restructuring. Work and Occupations30(2): 214–33.
52.
WaldmanMichael. 1984. Job assignments, signalling, and efficiency. RAND Journal of Economics15(2): 255–67.
53.
WaldmanMichael. 1990. Up-or-out contracts: A signaling perspective. Journal of Labor Economics8(2): 230–50.
54.
WaldmanMichael. 2003. Ex ante versus ex post optimal promotion rules: The case of internal promotion. Economic Inquiry41(1): 27–41.
55.
WaldmanMichael. 2013. Theory and evidence in internal labor markets. In GibbonsRobertRobertsJohn (Eds.), pp. 520–74. The Handbook of Organizational Economics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
56.
ZábojníkJánBernhardtDan. 2001. Corporate tournaments, human capital acquisition, and the firm size-wage relation. Review of Economic Studies68(3): 693–716.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
