Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2018-8
Legal but Deportable: Institutionalized Deportability and the Limits of Collective Bargaining among Participants in Canada’s Seasonal Agricultural Workers Program
This article explores how model temporary migrant worker programs (TMWPs) that permit seasonal return can institutionalize deportability or the possibility of removal among participants with legal status. It draws on the cases of two groups of workers who participated in the British Columbia–Mexico Seasonal Agricultural Workers Program (SAWP) and who managed to unionize and secure collective agreements (CAs). The author argues that the design and operation of SAWP constrains workers’ capacity to see out fixed-term contracts and to realize the promise of seasonal return. These inherent constraints lead to a form of institutionalized deportability, even among participants covered by CAs crafted to mitigate the possibility of unjust termination and premature repatriation and to address workers’ precarious transnational situation. Focusing on how deportability operates, the article analyzes immigration and labor laws and policies, CAs, key informant interviews, and testimony before British Columbia’s labor relations tribunal along with the decisions of that tribunal.
AguniasDovelynNewlandKathleen. 2007. Circular migration and development: Trends, policy routes, and ways forward. Policy Brief: Program on Migrants, Migration and Development. Washington, DC: Migration Policy Institute. Accessed athttp://www.migrationpolicy.org/pubs/MigDevPB_041807.pdf (July12, 2016).
3.
BasokTanya. 2000. He came, he saw, he stayed: Guest worker programmes and the issue of non-return. International Migration38(2): 215–38.
4.
BasokTanya. 2002. Tortillas and Tomatoes: Transmigrant Mexican Harvesters in Canada. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
5.
BasokTanyaBélangerDanielleRivasEloy. 2014. Reproducing deportability: Migrant agricultural workers in South-Western Ontario. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies40(9): 1394–1413.
6.
BauderHarald. 2006. Labor Movement: How Migration Regulates Labor Markets. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
7.
BinfordLeigh. 2009. From fields of power to fields of sweat: The dual process of constructing temporary migrant labor in Mexico and Canada. Third World Quarterly30(3): 503–17.
8.
BinfordLeigh. 2013. Tomorrow We’re All Going to the Harvest: Temporary Foreign Worker Programs and Neoliberal Political Economy. Austin: University of Texas Press.
9.
[BCLRC] British Columbia Labour Relations Code. 1996. RSBC 1996, Chapter 244. Victoria, British Columbia: Queen’s Printer.
10.
CastlesStephen. 2006. Guestworkers in Europe: A resurrection?International Migration Review40(4): 741–66.
11.
CastlesStephenMillerMark J.2009. The Age of Migration: International Population Movements in the Modern World. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
12.
CollyerMichael. 2012. Deportation and the micropolitics of exclusion: The rise of removals from the UK to Sri Lanka. Geopolitics17(2): 276–92.
13.
De GenovaNicholas. 2002. Migrant “illegality” and deportability in everyday life. Annual Review of Anthropology31: 419–47.
14.
De GenovaNicholas. 2010. Deportation, expulsion, and the international police of aliens. In De GenovaNicholasPeutzNathalie (Eds.), The Deportation Regime: Sovereignty, Space, and the Freedom of Movement, pp. 33–67. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
15.
De GenovaNicholasPeutzNathalie. 2010. Introduction. In De GenovaNicholasPeutzNathalie (Eds.), The Deportation Regime: Sovereignty, Space, and the Freedom of Movement, pp. 1–31. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
FaradayFayFudgeJudyTuckerEric (Eds.). 2012. Constitutional Labour Rights in Canada: Farm Workers and the Fraser Case. Toronto: Irwin.
19.
Floralia Plant Growers Ltd. and UFCW Local 1518. 2012. Collective Agreement Duration of September 23, 2012–September22, 2016.
20.
FudgeJudyMcPhailFiona. 2009. The temporary foreign worker program in Canada: Low-skilled workers as an extreme form of flexible labour. Comparative Labor Law and Policy Journal31: 5–46.
21.
GabrielChristina. 2012. Continental dissonance? The politics of migration in North America. In AyresJeffreyMacdonaldLaura (Eds.), Regional Integration in an Era of Political Economic Turbulence, pp. 219–48. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
22.
GabrielChristinaMacDonaldLaura. 2004. The hypermobile, the mobile and the rest: Patterns of inclusion and exclusion in an emerging North American migration regime. Canadian Journal of Latin American and Caribbean Studies29(57-58): 67–91.
23.
GabrielChristinaMacDonaldLaura. 2012. Debates on temporary agricultural worker migration in the North American context. In StraehleChristineTamara LenardPatti (Eds.), Legislating Inequality: Canada’s Temporary Migrant Worker Program, pp. 95–116. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
24.
GeigerMartinPécoudAntoine. 2010. The politics of international migration management. In GeigerMartinPécoudAntoine (Eds.), The Politics of International Migration Management, pp. 1–20. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
25.
GhoshBimal. 2012. A snapshot of reflections on migration management: Is migration management a dirty word? In GeigerMartinPécoudAntoine (Eds.), The New Politics of International Mobility: Migration Management and Its Discontents, pp. 25–30. Osnabrück, Germany: Institut für Migrationsforschung und Interkulturelle Studien, Universität Osnabrück.
26.
HahamovitchCindy. 2011. No Man’s Land: Jamaican Guestworkers in America and the Global History of Deportable Labor. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
27.
HennebryJennaMcLaughlinJanet. 2012. The exception that proves the rule: Structural vulnerability, health risks and consequences for temporary migrant farm workers in Canada. In StraehleChristineTamara LenardPatti (Eds.), Legislated Inequality: Temporary Labour Migration in Canada, pp. 117–38. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
28.
HennebryJennaPreibischKerry. 2012. A model for managed migration? Re-examining best practices in Canada’s seasonal agricultural worker program. International Migration50(1): 19–40.
29.
HindessBarry. 2000. Citizenship in the international management of populations. American Behavioral Scientist43(9): 1486–97.
30.
JensenHeather. 2013. Unionization of agricultural workers in Canada. Unpublished L.L.M. thesis. Victoria: University of Victoria. Accessible at http://hdl.handle.net/1828/4452.
31.
JensenHeather. 2014. A history of legal exclusion: Labour relations laws and British Columbia’s agricultural workers, 1937–1975. Labour/Le Travail73(1): 67–95.
LarsenMike. 2014. Indefinitely pending: Security certificates and permanent temporariness. In VoskoLeah F.PrestonValerieLathamRobert (Eds.), Liberating Temporariness? Migration, Work, and Citizenship in an Age of Insecurity, pp.76–96. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
34.
LathamRobertVoskoLeahPrestonValerieBretonMelisa. 2014. Introduction. In VoskoLeah F.PrestonValerieLathamRobert (Eds.), Liberating Temporariness? Migration, Work, and Citizenship in an Age of Insecurity, pp. 3–31. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
35.
MartinPhilip. 2006. Managing labor migration: Temporary worker programmes for the 21st century. International Symposium on International Migration and Development, Population Division, UN/POP/MIG/SYMP/2006/07. Turin, Italy: United Nations Secretariat.
36.
McLaughlinJanetHennebryJennaHainesTed. 2014. Paper versus practice: Occupational health and safety protections and realities for temporary foreign agricultural workers in Ontario. Perspectives interdisciplinaires sur le travail et la santé [Online] 16-2. Accessed at https://pistes.revues.org/3844 (July20, 2016).
37.
MezzadraSandroNeilsonBrett. 2013. Border as Method, or, the Multiplication of Labor. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
38.
NewlandKathleen. 2009. Circular migration and human development. United Nations Development Programme Human Development Reports Research Paper Series42: 1–30.
39.
PichéVictor. 2012. In and out the back door: Canada’s temporary worker programs in a global perspective. In GeigerMartinPécoudAntoine (Eds.), The New Politics of International Mobility: Migration Management and Its Discontents, pp. 113–22. Osnabrück, Germany: Institut für Migrationsforschung und Interkulturelle Studien, Universität Osnabrück.
40.
PlewaPiotrMillerMark J.2005. Postwar and post–Cold War generations of European temporary foreign worker policies: Implications from Spain. Migraciones Internacionales3(2): 58–83.
41.
PreibischKerry. 2010. Pick-your-own labor: Migrant workers and flexibility in Canadian agriculture. International Migration Review44(2): 404–41.
42.
PreibischKerryGrezEvelyn Encalada. 2013. Between hearts and pockets: Locating the outcomes of transnational homemaking practices among Mexican women in Canada’s temporary migration programmes. Citizenship Studies 17(6-7): 785–802.
43.
RajkumarDeepaBerkowitzLaurelVoskoLeah F.PrestonValerieLathamRobert. 2012. At the temporary-permanent divide: How Canada produces temporariness and makes citizens through its security, work, and settlement policies. Citizenship Studies16(3-4): 483–510.
RuhsMartinMartinPhilip. 2008. Numbers vs. rights: Trade-offs and guest worker programs. International Migration Review42(1): 249–65.
46.
RussoRobert. 2011. Case comment: Temporarily unchained: The drive to unionize foreign seasonal agricultural workers in Canada—A comment on Greenway Farms and UFCW. BC Studies169: 131–41.
47.
RussoRobert. 2012. Solidarity forever, Canadians never: SAWP workers in Canada. Unpublished PhD thesis. Vancouver: University of British Columbia. Accessible at http://hdl.handle.net/2429/42840.
48.
SatzewichVic. 1991. Racism and the Incorporation of Foreign Labor: Farm Labor Migration to Canada since 1945. New York: Routledge.
49.
SatzewichVic. 2007. Business or bureaucratic dominance in immigration policymaking in Canada: Why was Mexico included in the Caribbean seasonal agricultural workers program in 1974?International Migration and Integration (8): 255–75.
[STPS] Secretaría del Trabajo y Previsión Social (Secretariat of Labor and Social Welfare). n.d. Notice to the Employer – Seasonal Agricultural Workers’ Program.
52.
SharmaNandita. 2006. Home Economics: Nationalism and the Making of “Migrant Workers” in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
53.
Sidhu Sons Nursery Ltd. and UFCW Local 1518. 2010. Collective Agreement Duration of November 2, 2010–November 2, 2013.
54.
TalaveraVictorNúñezGuillermina G.HeymenJosiah. 2005. Deportation in the U.S.-Mexico borderlands: Anticipation, experience, and memory. In de GenovaNicholas (Ed.), The Deportation Regime: Sovereignty, Space, and the Freedom of Movement, pp. 166–95. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
55.
TuckerEric. 2012. Farm worker exceptionalism: Past, present, and the post-Fraser future. In FaradayFayFudgeJudyTuckerEric (Eds.), Constitutional Labour Rights in Canada: Farm Workers and the Fraser Case, pp. 30–56. Toronto: Irwin Law.
56.
[UFCW] United Food and Commercial Workers Union, Local 1518. 2009a. Submission to the British Columbia Labor Relations Board (July2).
57.
[UFCW] United Food and Commercial Workers Union, Local 1518. 2009b. Submission to the British Columbia Labor Relations Board (August13).
58.
[UN] United Nations. 2006. Governments can create “triple wins” for migrants, countries of origin, destination countries, Secretary-General tells General Assembly High-Level Dialogue. SG/SM/10634-GA/10495. Press Release. September14. Accessed at http://www.un.org/press/en/2006/sgsm10634.doc.htm (July12, 2016).
59.
VertovecSteven. 2008. Circular migration: The way forward in global policy?Canadian Diversity6(3): 36–40.
60.
VivianShannon. 2005. Be our guest: A review of the legal and regulatory history of US immigration policy toward Mexico and recommendations for combating employer exploitation of nonimmigrant and undocumented workers. Seton Hall Legislative Journal30: 189–98.
61.
VoskoLeah. 2014. Tenuously unionised: Temporary migrant workers and the limits of formal mechanisms designed to promote collective bargaining in British Columbia. Industrial Law Journal43(4): 451–84.
62.
VoskoLeah. 2016. Blacklisting as a modality of deportability: Mexico’s response to circular migrant agricultural workers’ pursuit of collective bargaining rights in British Columbia, Canada. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies42(8): 1371–87.
63.
WaltersWilliam. 2002. Deportation, expulsion, and the international police of aliens. Citizenship Studies6(3): 265–92.
64.
WellsDonMcLaughlinJanetLynAndreMendiburoAaron Diaz. 2014. Sustaining precarious transnational families: The significance of remittances from Canada’s seasonal agricultural workers program. Just Labor22: 144–67.
65.
WickramasekaraPiyasiri. 2011. Circular migration: A triple win or a dead end. Global Union Research Network Discussion Paper No. 15. Geneva: International Labor Office.
66.
WintersAlanWalmsleyTerrieWangZhen KunGrynbergRoman. 2003. Liberalising temporary movement of natural persons: An agenda for the development round. World Economy26(8): 1137–61.
67.
WongTom. 2015. Rights, Deportation, and Detention in the Age of Immigration Control. Redwood City, CA: Stanford University Press.
