Are Two Carrots Better Than One? The Effects of Adding Employment Services to Financial Incentive Programs for Welfare Recipients

Abstract

The Self-Sufficiency Project (SSP) was a social experiment conducted in two Canadian provinces during the 1990s that tested a generous financial incentive program for welfare recipients. A little-known subsidiary experiment, called SSP Plus, had a three-way design that tested the incremental effect of adding employment services to the generous financial incentive program. Employment services are viewed by many welfare analysts as an important component of an overall strategy for helping welfare recipients escape poverty and achieve stable employment. This paper presents the results of the SSP Plus experiment. Adding employment services encouraged more people to take up the earnings supplement, and it appeared to have long-term effects on full-time employment and welfare receipt. This might be because the services improved the jobs people obtained. Compared to program participants who lacked the added services, SSP Plus members had higher earnings and wage rates, and also appear to have held more sustainable jobs.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bloom

Dan

Hendra

Richard

Martinson

Karin

Scrivener

Susan

. 2005. The Employment Retention and Advancement Project: Early Results from Four Sites. Washington, D.C.: U.S Department of Health and Human Services, June.

Bloom

Dan

Michalopoulos

Charles

. 2001. How Welfare and Work Policies Affect Employment and Income: A Synthesis of Research. New York: MDRC, May.

Card

David

Hyslop

Dean

. 2005. “Estimating the Effects of a Time-Limited Earnings Subsidy for Welfare-Leavers.” Econometrica, Vol. 73, No. 6 (November), pp. 1723–70.

Card

David

Robins

Philip K.

, 1998. “Do Financial Incentives Encourage Welfare Recipients to Work? Evidence from a Randomized Evaluation of the Self-Sufficiency Project.” In Polachek

Solomon

, ed., Research in Labor Economics, Vol. 17, pp. 1–56. Stamford, Conn., and London: JAI Press.

Card

David

Robins

Philip K.

, 2005. “How Important Are ‘Entry Effects’ in Financial Incentive Programs for Welfare Recipients? Experimental Evidence from the Self-Sufficiency Project.” Journal of Econometrics, Vol. 125, No. 1–2 (March), pp. 113–39.

Ford

Reuben

Gyarmati

David

Foley

Kelly

Tattrie

Doug

with Jimenez

Liza

. 2003. Can Work Incentives Pay for Themselves? Final Report on the Self-Sufficiency Project for Welfare Applicants. Ottawa: Social Research and Demonstration Corporation, October.

Hotz

V. Joseph

Scholz

John Karl

. 2003. “The Earned Income Tax Credit.” In Moffitt

Robert A.

, ed., Means-Tested Transfer Programs in the United States. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Lei

Ying

Michalopoulos

Charles

. 2001. SSP Plus at 36 Months: Effects of Adding Employment Services to Financial Work Incentives. Ottawa: Social Research and Demonstration Corporation, July.

Lin

Winston

Robins

Philip K.

Card

David

Harknett

Kristen

Lui-Gurr

Susanna

. 1998. When Financial Incentives Encourage Work: Complete 18-Month Findings from the Self-Sufficiency Project. Ottawa: Social Research and Demonstration Corporation, September.

10.

Michalopoulos

Charles

Miller

Cynthia

Robins

Philip K.

Morris

Pamela

Gyarmati

David

Redcross

Cindy

Foley

Kelly

Ford

Reuben

. 2002. Making Work Pay: Final Report on the Self-Sufficiency Project for Long-Term Welfare Recipients. Ottawa: Social Research and Demonstration Corporation, July.

11.

Michalopoulos

Charles

Robins

Philip K.

Card

David

. 2005. “Making Work Pay for Itself: Evidence from a Randomized Social Experiment for Welfare Recipients.” Journal of Public Economics, Vol. 89, No. 1 (January), pp. 5–29.

12.

Ochel

Wolfgang

. 2001. Financial Incentives to Work—Conceptions and Results in Great Britain, Ireland, and Canada. Working Paper No. 627, Center for Economic Studies and Ifo Institute for Economic Research, Munich, Germany, December.

13.

Quets

Gail

Robins

Philip K.

Pan

Elsie C.

Michalopoulos

Charles

Card

David

. 1999. Does SSP Plus Increase Employment? The Effects of Adding Services to the Self-Sufficiency Project's Financial Incentives. Ottawa: Social Research and Demonstration Corporation, May.

14.

Robins

Philip K.

Michalopoulos

Charles

. 2001. “Using Financial Incentives to Encourage Welfare Recipients to Become Economically Self-Sufficient.” (Paper presented at the November 2000 conference “Welfare Reform Four Years Later: Progress and Prospects,” sponsored by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.) Economic Policy Review, Vol. 7, No. 2, pp. 105–23.

15.

Zabel

Jeffrey

Schwartz

Saul

Donald

Stephen

. 2006. “An Econometric Analysis of the Incremental Impact of SSP Plus.” SRDC Working Paper Series 06–06. Ottawa: Social Research and Demonstration Corporation, March.