This article seeks to address issues relating to sovereignty, law and sexual politics in colonial princely India through an examination of the Malabar Hill Murder Trial of 1925 in the Bombay High Court. In this particular case, the Hindu Maratha Maharaja of Indore was charged with the murder of his Muslim courtesan's lover. The ensuing trial illuminates two important developments in late colonial Indian law. First, it reveals how British courts empowered some Indian women as individual agents before the law, despite the restrictions of pardah (or seclusion), to contest and resist indigenous patriarchies. Second, it exposes the complex rela-tionship between Indian kingship and British paramountcy. Due to their position as semi-autonomous rulers, who were not under the restrictions of British Indian law, native princes were exempt from being tried in British Indian courts on the basis of their treaty regulations. This case discusses the extent to which the sexual desires and love unions of the Indian kings were affected by the princely state's fraught relationship with the colonial regime. In this in-stance, the Malabar Hill Murder trial cost the ruler his gaddi (throne) when he was compelled to abdicate.
Bawla Murder Trial, Part I. From Monday 27 Apr. 1925 to Thursday 7 May 1925, 1-206 in R/2 (418/14). Crown Representative's Residency Reports, India Office Library, London.
3.
Political Report from R.I.R, Glancy, Confidential Branch, Central India on 31 January 1925. ‘Malabar Hill Outrage (murder of Mr. Bawla) and the Alleged Connection of H.H. the Maharaja Holkar with it’ in R/2 (421/15), Crown Representative's Residency, Reports, India Office Library, London.
4.
Letter from Tukoji Rao to R.I.R. Glancy, C.S.I., C.I.E, Agent to the Governor General in Central India, Camp Bijasani, 26 Feb. 1926. ‘Minority Administration of Holkar State’ in R/2 (435/107), Crown Representative's Residency Reports, India Office Library, London.
5.
Letter from Major Ramprasad Dube, Rai Bahadur, Chief Minister to H.H. The Maharaja Holkar, to The First Assistant to the Agent to the Governor General in Central India, Indore, Darbar Office, Indore, 16 Dec. 1918. ‘Minority Administration of Holkar State’ in R/2 (435/107), Crown Representative's Residency Reports, India Office Library, London.
6.
Maharaja of Dhrangadhra, personal correspondence with the author, via letter, 16 March 2005.
7.
Maharaja of Dhrangadhra, personal correspondence with the author, via letter, 16 April 2005.
8.
Lee-Warner, W. ‘The Native States of India’, in British Empire Series, Volume 1: India, Ceylon, Straits Settlements, British Northern Borneo, Hong-Kong, London , 1899.
9.
Le Grand Jacob, G.Western India: Before and during the Mutinies, London , 1871.
10.
Agnes, F.Law and Gender Inequality: The Politics of Women's Rights in India, reprinted in Women and Law in India: An Omnibus, New Delhi , 2004.
11.
Anagol, P.The Emergence of Feminism in India 1850–1920, Aldershot , 2006.
12.
Ashton, S.R.British Policy towards the Indian States, 1905–1909, London , 1982.
13.
Barton, Sir W.The Princes of India, Reprint of 1934 edition, New Delhi , 1983.
14.
Ballhatchet, K.Race, Sex and Class under the Raj: Imperial Attitudes and Policies and Critics, London , 1980.
15.
Basu, M.Hindu Women and Marriage Law, reprinted in Women in Law in India: An Omnibus, New Delhi , 2004.
16.
Chandra, S.Enslaved Daughters: Colonialism, Law and Women's Rights, New Delhi , 2008.
17.
Chatterjee, I.Gender, Slavery and Law in Colonial India, New Delhi , 1999.
18.
Chatterjee, P. ‘The Nationalist Resolution of the Women's Question’, in Sangari and Vaid , eds, Recast-ing Women: Essays in Indian Colonial History, New Brunswick, NJ , 1990, pp. 233–53.
19.
Chatterjee, P.The Nation and Its Fragments: Colonial and Postcolonial Histories, Princeton , 1993.
20.
Chatterjee, P.A Princely Imposter: The Strange and Universal History of the Kumar of Bhawal, Princeton , 2002.
21.
Cohn, B. ‘Some Notes on Law and Change in North India’, in B. Cohn, An Anthropologist among the Historians and Other Essays, Delhi , 1987, pp. 554–71.
22.
Edwardes, S.M.Crime in British India: A Brief Review of the More Important Offences included in the Annual Criminal Returns with Chapters on Prostitution & Miscellaneous Matters, New Delhi , 1983.
23.
Fitze, K.Twilight of the Maharajas, London , 1956.
24.
Hyam, R. ‘The Sexual Life of Raj’, in Empire and Sexuality, Manchester , 1992, pp. 115–36.
25.
Jhala, A.Courtly Indian Women in Late Imperial India, London , 2008.
26.
Joshi, V.Polygamy and Purdah; Women and Society among Rajputs, Jaipur , 1995.
27.
Kabbani, R.Imperial Fictions: Europe's Myths of the Orient, London , 1994.
28.
Kapila, S. ‘ Masculinity and Madness: Princely Personhood and Colonial Sciences of the Mind in Western India, 1871–1940 ’, Past and Present, Vol. 187 (May), 2005, pp. 121–56 .
29.
Kasturi, M.Embattled Identities: Rajput Lineages and the Colonial State in Nineteenth-Century North India, New Delhi , 2002.
30.
Khan, S.M.The Begums of Bhopal: A Dynasty of Women Rulers in Raj India, London , 2000.
31.
Lal, R.Domesticity and Power in the Early Mughal World, Cambridge , 2005.
32.
Lambert-Hurley, S.Muslim Women, Reform and Princely Patronage: Nawab Sultan Jahan Begam of Bhopal, London , 2006.
33.
Lateef, S.Muslim Women in India: Political and Private Realities, 1890s–1980s, New Delhi , 1990.
34.
Lewis, R.Rethinking Orientalism: Women, Travel, and the Ottoman Harem, London , 2004.
35.
Loomba, A.Colonialism/Postcolonialism, New York , 2005.
36.
McLeod, J.Sovereignty, Power, Control: Politics in the States of Western India, 1916–1947, Leiden , 1999.
37.
Major, A.Sati, Sovereignty and Social Reform: The British Campaign against Sati in the Princely States, 1830–1860, Calcutta , forthcoming 2009.
38.
Metcalf, T.Ideologies of the Raj, Cambridge , 1995.
39.
Morrow, A.Highness: The Maharajas of India, London , 1986.
40.
Mukhopadhyay, A.Behind the Mask: The Cultural Definition of the Legal Subject in Colonial Bengal, 1775–1911, New Delhi , 2006.
41.
Nair, J.Women and Law in Colonial India: A Social History, New Delhi , 1996.
42.
O'Hanlon, R.A Comparison between Women and Men: Tarabai Shinde and the Critique of Gender Relations in Colonial India, Madras , 1994.
43.
Peirce, L.The Imperial Harem, Oxford , 1993.
44.
Price, P.Kingship and Political Practice in Colonial India, Cambridge , 1996.
45.
Ramusack, B.The Indian Princes and their States, Cambridge , 2004.
46.
Spivak, G. ‘Can the Subaltern Speak?’ in C. Nelson and L. Grossberg , eds, Marxism and the Inter-pretation of Culture, Illinois , 1988, pp. 271–313.
47.
Younger, C.Wicked Women of the Raj: European Women Who Broke Society's Rules and Married Indian Princes, New Delhi , 2003.
