Lay Theories of Psychotherapy III: Comparing the Ratings of Lay Persons and Clinical Psychologists

Abstract

This study set out to compare the beliefs of lay, nonspecialist adults and trained practicing clinical psychologists on the topic of psychotherapy. Approximately 200 lay people (working adults and students) and over 50 practicing psychologists completed a four-part questionnaire that examined attitudes to psychotherapy, beliefs concerning what patients report during psychotherapy, the efficacy of quite different types of psychological treatment, and finally the prognosis for a wide range of psychological problems. The ratings of the two groups, lay vs. professional, were compared on an item-by-item basis, as well as by interpretable factors that were found in previous studies (Furnham & Wardley, 1990, 1991). The results showed a predicted pattern of similarities and differences with most differences occurring on the questionnaires concerned with beliefs about what happens in psychotherapy and the efficacy of therapy, and least differences in the part concerned with the anticipated attitudes of psychotherapy clients. Overall, psychotherapists seemed less optimistic and more skeptical concerning the efficacy of therapies and the prognosis of personal problems. These results arc discussed in terms of available literature on lay expectations of psychotherapy.

Keywords

lay theories psychotherapy health

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ABFELBAUM, D. Dimensions of transference in psychotherapy). Berkeley: University of California Press, 1958.

BISHOP, G. Lay conceptions of physical symptoms. Journal of Appl/ied Social Psychology, 1987, 17, 127-146.

BORDIN, E. The implications of client expectations for the counselling process. Journal of Counselling Psychology, 1955, 2, 17-21.

BOYLE, G. Does item homogeneity indicate internal consistency or item redundancy in psychometric scales. Personality and Individual Differences, 1991, 12, 291-294.

BREWIN, C. , & FURNHAM, A. Attributional versus pre-attributional variables in self-esteem and depression. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1986, 50, 1013-1020.

CALNAN, M. Health and illness: The lay perspective. London: Tavistock, 1987.

FISCHER, E. , & TURNER, J. Orientation to seeking professional help: Development and research utility of attitude scale. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 1970, 35, 79-90.

FRANK, J. The dynamics of the psychotherapy relationship. Psychiatry, 1959, 22, 17-39.

FRANKEL, P. , & PERLMAN, S. Student perceptions of the student counselling service function. Journal of College Student Personnel, 1969, 10, 232-235.

10.

FURNHAM, A. Lay conceptions of neuroticism. Personality and Individual Differences, 1984, 5, 95-103.

11.

FURNHAM, A. Lay theories: Everyday understanding of problems in the social sciences. Oxford: Pergamon, 1988.

12.

FURNHAM, A. , & BOWER, P. A comparison of academic and lay theories of schizophrenia. British Journal of Psychiatry. In press.

13.

FURNHAM, A. , & HENLEY, S. Lay beliefs about overcoming psychological problems. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, 1988, 26, 423-438.

14.

FURNHAM, A. , & LOWICK, V. Lay theories of the causes of alcoholism. British Journal of Medical Psychology, 1984, 57, 319-322.

15.

FURNHAM, A. , & REES, J. Lay theories of schizophrenia. International Journal of Social Psychiatry, 1988, 34, 212-220.

16.

FURNHAM, A. , & SMITH, C. Choosing alternative medicine: A comparison of the beliefs of patients visiting a general practitioner and a homeopath. Social Science and Medicine, 1988, 26, 685-689.

17.

FURNHAM, A. , & WARDLEY, Z. Lay theories of psychotherapy 1: Attitudes to, and beliefs about, psychotherapy and psychotherapists. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 1990, 46, 878-890.

18.

FURNHAM, A. , & WARDLEY, Z. Lay theories of psychotherapy II: Attitudes to, and beliefs about, psychotherapy and psychotherapists. Human Relations, 1991, 44, 1197-2010.

19.

GOLDSTEIN, A. Therapist-patient expectancies in psychotherapy. New York: MacMillan, 1962.

20.

HALL, L. , & TUCKER, C. Relationships between ethnicity, conceptions of mental illness and attitudes associated with seeking psychological help. Psychological Reports, 1985, 57, 907-916.

21.

HEILBRUN, A. Towards a resolution of the dependency -premature termination paradox for females in psychotherapy. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psycholog, 1970, 34, 382-386.

22.

HENLEY, S. , & FURNHAM, A. The attribution of cure. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 1988, 27, 384-386.

23.

JEMMOTT, J. , CROYLE, R. , & DITTO, P. Commonsense epidemiology: Self-based judgments from lay persons and physicians. Health Psychology, 1988, 7, 55-73.

24.

KNAPP, J. , & KARABENICK, S. Overcoming problems. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 1985, 9, 343-354.

25.

KRAUS, M. , FITZSIMMONS, M. , & WOLF, N. Focusing on the clients expectation of treatment. Psychological Reports, 1969, 24, 973-974.

26.

LLEWELYN, S. Psychological therapy as viewed by clients and therapists. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 1988, 27, 223-237.

27.

MILLSTEIN, S. , & IRWIN, C. Concepts of health and illness: Different constructs and variations on a theme. Healtlh Psychology, 1987, 6, 515-524.

28.

NUNNALLY, J. Popular conceptions of menial healtih. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston, 1961.

29.

PARHAM, W. , & TINSLEY, H. What are friends for: Students expectations of the friendships encounter. Journal of Counselling Psychology, 1980, 27, 524-527.

30.

PATTERSON, C. Client expectations and social conditioning. Personnel and Guidance Journal, 1958, 37, 136-138.

31.

PRINS, H. Attitudes towards the mentally disordered. Medicine, Science and Law, 1984, 24, 181-191.

32.

RIPPERE, V. How depressing: Another cognitive dimension of commonsense knowledge. Behavior Research and Therapy, 1981, 19, 169-181.

33.

SANDLER, W. Patient-therapist dissimarily of role expectations related to premature termination of psychotherapy with student therapists. Dissertation Abstracts International, 1975, 35, 6111-6112.

34.

SNYDER, J. , HILL, C. , & DERKSEN, T. Why some students do not use University Counselling Psychology facilities. Journal of Counselling Psychology, 1972, 19, 263-268.

35.

TINSLEY, H. , & HARRIS, S. Client expectation for counselling. Journal of Counselling Psychology, 1976, 2-3, 173-177.

36.

TINSLEY, H. , BOWMAN, S. , & RAY, S. Manipulation of expectancies about counselling and psychotherapy. Journal of Counselling Psycholog, 1988, 35, 99-108.