Particularistic considerations among professionals have been ascribed to social structural exigencies. A comparison of conventionally employed professionals with practitioners belonging to a communal framework (kibbutz) reveals two distinct forms of particularism: a generally approved Normative Particularism that caters to the legitimate demands of the professional's immediate social environment, and a less accepted Utilitarian Particularism that reflects a concern for clients who can provide greater concrete rewards. Regression analysis shows both forms of particularism to be generated out of direct interactions between practitioner and client, irrespective of social structure. Such dyadic ties may encourage practitioners to meet legitimate normative expectations, but they also provide opportunities for satisfying egoistic motives. In either case, particularistic service commitments are inherent to professional practice, and demonstrate the continuing significance of this work practice in contemporary society.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ALBRIGHT, R.Economics of doctor-patient relations. In E. G. Jaco (Ed.), Patients, physicians and illness: Sourcebook in behavioral science and medicine. Glencoe, Illinois: The Free Press , 1958.
2.
AMIT, T.Professionals in the kibbutz: Yesodot. Tel Aviv: Ichud Habonim , 1970.
3.
ANTONOVSKY, H. F. , & ANTONOVSKY, A.Commitment in an Israeli kibbutz . Human Relations, 1974, 27, 303-319 .
4.
BARBER, B.Some problems in the sociology of the professions . Daedalus, 1963, 92, 669-688 .
5.
BEN-DAVID, J.The professional role of the physician in bureaucratized medicine: A study in role conflict . Human Relations, 1958, 4, 255-274 .
6.
BEN-DAVID, J.The kibbutz and the moshav. In J. Ben-David (Ed.), Agricultural planning and village community in Israel. Paris: UNESCO , 1964.
7.
BEN-RAFAEL, E.Dynamics of social stratification in kibbutzim . International Journal of Comparative Sociology, 1980, 21, 88-99 .
8.
BERLANT, J. L.Profession and monopoly: A study of medicine in the United States and Great Britain. Berkeley: University of California Press , 1975.
9.
BILLIS, D.Differential administrative capacity and organizational development: A kibbutz case study . Human Relations, 1977, 30, 109-127 .
10.
BLAU, P. M.Orientations toward clients in a public welfare agency . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1960, 5, 341-361 .
11.
BLAU, P. M.Operationalizing a conceptual scheme: The universalism-particularism pattern variable . American Sociological Review, 1962, 27, 159-169 .
12.
CARLIN, J.Lawyers' ethics: A survey of the New York City Bar. New York: Russell Sage Foundation , 1966.
13.
CHILD, J. , & FULK, J.Maintenance of occupational control: The case of the professions . Work and Occupations, 1982, 9, 155-192 .
14.
DANET, B.Giving the underdog a break: Latent particularism among customs officials. In E. Katz & B. Danet (Eds.), Bureaucracy and the public: A Reader in official-client relations. New York: Basic Books , 1973.
15.
DARIN-DRABKIN, H.The other society. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World , 1962.
16.
EDEN, D.Intrinsic and extrinsic rewards and motives: Replication and extension with kibbutz workers . Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 1975, 5, 348-361 .
17.
FOX, R. C.Essays in medical sociology: Journeys into the field. New York: John Wiley & Sons , 1979.
18.
FRIEDSON, E.Client control and medical practice . American Journal of Sociology, 1960, 65, 374-382 .
19.
GARBER-TALMON, Y. , & STUP, Z.Secular asceticism: Patterns of ideological change. In S. N. Eisenstadt , R. Bar Yosef , & C. Adler (Eds.), Integration and development in Israel. Jerusalem: Israel Universities Press , 1970.
20.
GOLDBERG, A. I.The relevance of cosmopolitan/local orientations to professional values and behavior . Sociology of Work and Occupations, 1976, 3, 331-356 .
21.
GOLDBERG, A. I.Commune professionals: Reexamining the concept of professionalism . Paper delivered at the International Sociological Association Meetings, Mexico City, 1982.
22.
GOODE, W. J.Community within a community: The professions . American Sociological Review, 1957, 22, 194-200 .
23.
GOODE, W. J.Professions and non-professions. In H. M. Vollmer & D. L. Mills (Eds.), Professionalization. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall , 1966.
24.
GROSS, E.Change in technological and scientific developments and its impact upon the occupational structure. In R. Perrucci & J. E. Gerstl (Eds.), Engineers and the social structure. New York: John Wiley & Sons , 1969.
25.
HALL, O.The stages of a medical career . The American Journal of Sociology, 1948, LIII, 327-336 .
26.
HALL, R. H.Professionalization and bureaucratization . American Sociological Review, 1968, 33, 92-104 .
27.
HALMOS, P.Professionalization and social change. The sociological review monograph 20, The University of Keele, Keele, Staffordshire , 1973.
28.
HICKSON, D. J. , & THOMAS, M. W.Professionalization in Britain: A preliminary measurement . Sociology, 1969, 13, 219-233 .
29.
HUGHES, E. C.Professions . Daedalus, 1963, 92, 655-668 .
30.
KADUSHIN, C.The friends and supporters of psychotherapy: On social circles in urban life . American Sociological Review, 1966, 33, 499-517 .
31.
KANTER, R. M.Commitment and social organization: A study of commitment mechanisms in utopian communities . American Sociological Review, 1968, 33, 499-517 .
32.
KONRAD, G. , & SZELENYI, I.The intellectuals on the road to class power. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich , 1979.
33.
KRAUSE, E.Power and illness: The political sociology of health and medical care. New York: Elsevier , 1977.
34.
LARSON, M. S.The rise of professionalism: A sociological analysis. Berkeley: University of California Press , 1977.
35.
LEVIATAN, U.Organizational effects of managerial turnover in kibbutz production branches. Haifa: Center for Social Research on the Kibbutz , 1975.
36.
LITWAK, E.Models of bureaucracy which permit conflict . American Journal of Sociology, 1961, 67, 177-184 .
37.
LITWAK, E. , & MEYER, H. J.A balance theory of coordination between bureaucratic organizations and community primary groups . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1966, 11, 31-58 .
38.
MACAROV, D.Work patterns and satisfactions in an Israeli kibbutz: A test of the Herzberg hypothesis . Personnel Psychology, 1972, 25, 483-493 .
39.
MANNHEIM, B.A Comparative study of work centrality, job rewards, and satisfaction . Sociology of Work and Occupations, 1975, 2, 79-101 .
40.
MECHANIC, D.The growth of bureaucratic medicine: An inquiry into the dynamics of patient behavior and the organization of medical care. New York: John Wiley & Sons , 1976.
41.
MERTON, R. K.Social theory and social structure (Revised ed.). Glencoe, Illinois: The Free Press , 1957.
42.
MOORE, W. E.The professions: Roles and rules. New York: Russell Sage Foundation , 1970.
43.
NIR, U. The influence of the employment of salaried employees and kibbutz members on organizational effectiveness in a kibbutz service organization. Unpublished master's thesis, Faculty of Industrial Engineering and Management, Technion-Israel Institute of Technology, 1976.
44.
ORZACK, L. H.Work as a “central life interest” of professionals . Social Problems, 1959, 7, 125-132 .
45.
PARSONS, T.The social system. Glencoe, Illinois: The Free Press , 1951.
46.
PARSONS, T.The professions and social structure. In T. Parsons (Ed.), Essays in sociological theory (Revised ed.). Glencoe, Illinois: The Free Press , 1954.
47.
PARSONS, T. , & SHILS, E.Toward a general theory of action. Cambridge: Harvard University Press , 1951.
48.
QUINNEY, E. R.Occupational structure and criminal behavior: Prescription violation by retail pharmacists . Social Problems, 1963, 11, 179-185 .
49.
REED, J. P.The lawyer-client: A managed relationship? In C. D. Bryant (Ed.), The social dimensions of work. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall , 1972.
50.
RENEN, A.The status of the university graduate in the kibbutz. In Kibbutz: A new society. Tel Aviv: Ichud Habonim , 1971.
51.
RITZER, G.Working: Conflict and change (2nd ed.). Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall , 1977.
52.
ROSOW, I. Modern architecture and social change. Unpublished MA thesis, Department of Sociology, Wayne University, Detroit, 1948.
53.
ROTHSCHILD-WITT, J.The collectivist organization: An alternative to rational-bureaucratic models . American Sociological Review, 1979, 44, 509-527 .
54.
SCARR, H. A.Measures of particularism . Sociometry, 1964, 27, 413-432 .
55.
SCOTT, W. R.Reactions to supervision in a heteronomous professional organization . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1965, 10, 65-81 .
56.
SHEFER, Y.The professional on kibbutz: Binyah. Tel Aviv: Ichud Habonim , 1966.
57.
STOUFFER, S. A.An analysis of conflicting social norms . American Sociological Review, 1949, 14, 707-717 .
58.
STOUFFER, S. A. , & TOBY, J.Role conflict and personality . American Journal of Sociology, 1951, 56, 395-406 .
59.
SUTTON, F. X. , HARRIS, S. E. , KAYSEN, C. , & TOBIN, J.The American business creed. New York: Schocken , 1962.
60.
TALMON, Y.Family and community in the kibbutz. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press , 1972.
61.
TIGER, L. , & SHEPHER, J.Women in the kibbutz. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich , 1975.
62.
WEISS, R. S.Helping relationships: Relationships of clients with physicians, social workers, priests and others . Social Problems, 1973, 20, 319-328 .
63.
WILENSKY, H. L.The professionalization of everyone?The American Journal of Sociology, 1964, LXX, 137-158 .
64.
WOLFF, K. H. (Ed.). The sociology of Georg Simmel. Glencose, Illinois: The Free Press , 1950.
65.
YUCHTMAN, E.Reward distribution and work-role attractiveness in the kibbutz -reflections on equity theory . American Sociological Review, 1972, 37, 581-595 .
66.
ZBOROWSKI, M.Cultural components in responses to pain . Journal of Social Issues, 1952, 8, 16-30 .
