Role Perceptions among Occupational Groups in an Ambulatory Care Setting

Abstract

Effective multidisciplinary health care teams require a clear understanding of the roles and responsibilities of each group. This paper reports on a study of role perceptions among three occupational groups in a medical setting-physicians, nurses, and administrative personnel. Each group was asked to assess the extent to which their group and each of the others were involved in performing each of several activities. It was hypothesized that differences in perception are related to professional aspiration level, and that the greatest differences in perception would be related to the functions carried out by groups with the highest level of professional aspiration. The results confirmed this hypothesis. Nurses, highest in professional aspiration level among the three groups, showed consistently different perceptions in their role as compared with other groups' perceptions of their role. Implications for management and research are discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ARNOLD, M. P. Perception of professional role activities in the local health department . Public Health Reports, 1962, 77(1), 80-88 .

BANTA, D. , & FOX, R. Role strains of a health care team in a poverty community . Social Science and Medicine, 1972, 6, 697-722 .

BATES, B. Doctor and nurse: Changing roles and relations . New England Journal of Medicine, 1970, 283, 129-134 .

BATES, B. Physician and nurse practitioner: Conflict and reward . Annals of Internal Medicine, 1975, 82, 702-706 .

BEDEIAN, A. G. , & ARMENAKIS, A. A. A path-analytic study of the consequences of role conflict and ambiguity . Academy of Management Journal, 1981, 24, 417-424 .

CARR-SAUNDERS, A. M. Metropolitan conditions and traditional professional relationships. In R. M. Fisher (Ed.), The metropolis in modern life. Garden City, N.J.: Doubleday , 1955.

CAUDILL, W. A. The psychiatric hospital as a small society. Washington, D.C.: Howard University Press , 1958.

CORWIN, R. Patterns of organizational conflict . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1969, 14, 507-521 .

CROZIER, M. The bureaucratic phenomenon. Chicago: University of Chicago Press , 1964.

10.

FREIDSON, E. Profession of medicine. New York: Dodd, Mead , 1970.

11.

GEORGOPOULOS, B. S. , & MANN, F. C. The community general hospital. New York: Macmillan , 1962.

12.

GOODE, W. J. The theoretical limits of professionalization. In A. Etzioni , (Ed.), The semiprofessions and their organization. New York: Free Press , 1969.

13.

HININGS, C. R. , HICKSON, D. J. , PENNINGS, J. M. , & SCHNECK, R. E. Structural conditions for intraorganizational power . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1974, 19, 22-24 .

14.

JACKSON, S. E. Participation in decision making as a strategy for reducing job-related strain . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1983, 68, 3-19 .

15.

KANTER, R. M. Men and women of the corporation. New York: Basic Books , 1977.

16.

KEMERY, E. R. , BEDEIAN, A. G. , MOSSHOLDER, K. W. , & TOOULIATOS, J. Outcomes of role stress: A multisample constructive replication . Academy of Management Journal, 1985, 28, 363-375 .

17.

LEATT, P. , MICKEVICUIS, BARNSLEY, J. , VAYDA, E. , & WILLIAMS, J. I. Hospital medical staff organization: An annotated bibliography. Ottawa: Canadian Hospital Association , 1983.

18.

LEWIS, C. E. The physician as care team leader . Group Practice, 1968, 17, 20 .

19.

NEAL, H. Better communication for better health. New York: Columbia University Press , 1962.

20.

RAELIN, J. A. The basis for the professional's resistance to managerial control . Human Resource Management, 1985, 24(2), 147-175 .

21.

SIMPSON, R. L. , & SIMPSON, I. H. Women and bureaucracy in the semi-professions. In A. Etzioni , (Ed.), The semi-professions and their organization. New York: Free Press , 1969.

22.

SPITZER, W. O. , & ROBERTS, R. F. Twelve questions about teams in health services . Journal of Community Health, 1980, 6, 1-5 .

23.

STANTON, A. H. , & SCHWARTZ, M. S. The mental hospital. New York: Basic Books , 1954.

24.

TEMKIN-GREENER, H. Interprofessional perspectives on teamwork in health care: A case study . Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly/Health and Society, 1983, 61(4), 641-658 .

25.

THOMPSON, V. Hierarchy, specialization, and organizational conflict . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1969, 19.

26.

TOREN, N. Semi-professionalism and social work: A theoretical perspective. In A. Etzioni , (Ed.), The semi-professions and their organization. New York: Free Press , 1969.

27.

WAINER, H. Estimating coefficients in linear models: It don't make no nevermind . Psychological Bulletin, 1976, 83, 213-217 .

28.

WESSEN, A. F. Hospital ideology and communication between ward personnel. In G. Jaco , (Ed.), Patients, physicians, and illness. New York: Free Press , 1958.

29.

WILENSKY, H. L. Varieties of work experience. In H. Borow , (Ed.), Man in a world at work. Boston: Houghton Mifflin , 1964.

30.

WISE, H. , BECKHARD, R. , RUBIN, I. , & KYTE, A. Making health teams work. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Ballinger , 1974.

31.

ZALKIND, S. S. , & COSTELLO, T. W. Perception: Implications for administration . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1962, 7, 218-235 .