This study examines the hypotheses that (a) subordinates' perceptions of participation in decision-making (PDM) is positively related to their perceived and desired power equalization (PE), in terms of hierarchical power differentials (HPD) between subordinates and superiors; (b) low-level participants' perceptions of the distribution of power within the organizational hierarchy reflect a zero-sum notion of power; and (c) subordinates' desire for participation and ability (in terms of education) moderate the relationship between PE and PDM. A sample of three hierarchical groups was selected from 40 stores of a large, retail drug company in the midwest: 40 store managers, 59 assistant managers, and 153 nonmanagerial employees. The results provide support for all three hypotheses. Implications of the findings for the exercise of power and effective management styles are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ABDEL-HALIM, A. A.Interaction effects of power equalization and subordinate personality on job satisfaction and performance . Human Relations, 1979, 32, 489-502 .
2.
ABDEL-HALIM, A. A.Power equalization and work effectiveness: An empirical investigation . Journal of Occupational Behaviour, 1980, 1, 223-237 .
3.
ABDEL-HALIM, A. A.A reexamination of ability as a moderator of role perceptions-satisfaction relationship . Personnel Psychology, 1981, 34, 549-561 .
4.
ABDEL-HALIM, A. A. , & ROWLAND, K. M.Power equalization: A convergence of organizational control and participative leadership theories . Midwest Academy of Management Proceedings, St. Louis, Missouri, 1976. (a)
5.
ABDEL-HALIM, A. A. , & ROWLAND, K. M.Some personality determinants of the effects of participation: A further investigation . Personnel Psychology, 1976, 29, 41-55 . (b)
6.
AIKEN, M. , & HAGE, J.Organizational alienation: A comparative analysis . American Sociological Review, 1966, 31, 497-507 .
7.
ALLUTO, J. A. , & BELASCO, J.Atypology for participation in organizational decision making . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1972, 17, 117-125 .
8.
ARGYRIS, C.Personality and organization: The conflict between system and individual. New York: Harper , 1957.
BAUM, B. H. , & SORENSEN, P. F., Jr.Contemporary student attitudes and the future of management . Academy of Management Proceedings, San Diego, California, 1970.
11.
BLAKE, R. R. , & MOUTON, J. S.The managerial grid. Houston, Texas: Gulf Publishing Co. , 1964.
12.
BLANKENSHIP, L. V. , & MILES, R. E.Organizational structure and managerial decision behavior . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1968, 13, 106-120 .
13.
DALTON, G. S. , BARNES, L. B. , & ZALEZNIK, A.The distribution of authority in formal organizations. Boston, Mass.: Division of Research, Graduate School of Business Administration, Harvard University , 1968.
14.
DeVRIES, D. L. , & SNYDER, J. P.Faculty participation in departmental decision-making . Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1974, 11, 195-221 .
15.
FRENCH, J. R., Jr. , ISRAEL, J. , & AS, D.An experiment on participation in a Norwegian factory: Interpersonal dimension of decision-making . Human Relations, 1960, 13, 3-19 .
16.
FRENCH, J. R., Jr. , & RAVEN, B.The bases of power. In D. Cartwright and A. Zander (Eds.), Group dynamics: Research and theory (2nd ed.). Evanston, Ill.: Row, Peterson , 1960.
17.
GARDELL, B.Autonomy and participation at work . Human Relations, 1977, 30, 515-533 .
18.
HAGE, J. , & AIKEN, M.Program change and organizational properties: A comparative analysis . American Journal of Sociology, 1967, 72, 503-519 .
19.
HESPE, G. , & WALL, T.The demand for participation among employees . Human Relations, 1976, 29, 411-428 .
20.
HREBINIAK, L. G.Effects of job level and participation on employee attitudes and perceptions of influence . Academy of Management Journal, 1974, 17, 649-662 .
21.
HULIN, C. L. , & SMITH, P. C.A linear model of job satisfaction . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1964, 49, 209-216 .
22.
HUNT, J. G. , OSBORN, R. M. , & LARSON, L. L.Upper level technical orientation of first level leadership within a noncontingency and a contingency framework . Academy of Management Journal, 1975, 18, 475-488 .
23.
JAGO, A. G.An assessment of the deemed appropriateness of participative decision-making for high and low hierarchical levels . Human Relations, 1981, 34, 379-396 .
24.
LABOVITZ, S.Criteria for selecting a significance level: A note on the sacredness of .05 . The American Sociologist, 1968, 3, 220-222 .
25.
LIKERT, R.New patterns of management. New York: McGraw-Hill , 1961.
26.
LIKERT, R.The human organization: Its management and value. New York: McGraw-Hill , 1967.
27.
LOWIN, A.Participative decision making: A model, literature critique, and prescriptions for research . Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1968, 3, 68-106 .
28.
MAIER, N. R. F.Psychology in industrial organizations (4th ed.) Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company , 1973.
29.
McMAHON, J. T.Participative and power-equalized organizational systems: An empirical investigation and theoretical integration . Human Relations, 1976, 29, 203-214 .
30.
McMAHON, J. T. , & IVANCEVICH, J. M.A study of control in a manufacturing organization: Managers and non-managers . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1976, 21, 67-83 .
31.
MECHANIC, D.Sources of power of lower participants in complex organizations . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1962, 7, 349-364 .
32.
MILES, R. E.Conflicting elements in managerial ideologies . Industrial Relations, 1964, 4, 77-91 .
33.
MILES, R. E.Human relations or human resources?Harvard Business Review, 1965, 43, 148-163 .
MULDER, M. , & WILKE, H.Participation and power-equalization . Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1970, 5, 430-448 .
36.
PALUMBO, D. J.Power and role specificity in organizational theory . Public Administration Review, 1969, 29, 237-248 .
37.
PEARLIN, L. I.Alienation from work: A study of nursing personnel . American Sociological Review, 1962, 27, 314-326 .
38.
PORTER, L. W. , & LAWLER, E. E.Properties of organizational structure in relation to job attitudes and job behavior . Psychological Bulletin, 1965, 64, 23-51 .
39.
RITCHIE, J. B. , & MILES, R. E.An analysis of quantity and quality of participation as mediating variables in the participative decision making process . Personnel Psychology, 1970, 23, 347-359 .
40.
SAUNDERS, D. R.Moderator variables in prediction . Educational and Psychological Measurement, 1956, 16, 209-222 .
41.
SCHULER, R. S.The effects of role perceptions on employee satisfaction and performance moderated by employee ability . Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1977, 18, 98-107 .
42.
SKIPPER, J. K., Jr. , GUNETHER, A. L. , & NASS, G.The sacredness of .05: A note concerning the uses of statistical levels of significance in social science . The American Sociologist, 1967, 2, 16-18 .
43.
STRAUSS, G.Some notes on power-equalization. In H. J. Leavitt (Ed.), The social science of organization. Englewood Cliffs, N. J.: Prentice-Hall , 1963.
44.
TANNENBAUM, A. S. (Ed.). Control in organizations. New York: McGraw-Hill , 1968.
45.
TANNENBAUM, R. , WESHLER, I. , & MASSARIK, F.Leadership and organization: A behavioral science approach. New York: McGraw-Hill , 1961.
46.
TODD, J.Management control: A zero-sum game?Management International Review, 1978, 4, 73-78 .
47.
TOSI, H.A reexamination of personality as a determinant of the effects of participation . Personnel Psychology, 1970, 23, 91-99 .
48.
VEEN, P.Effects of participative decision-making in field hockey training: A field experiment . Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1972, 7, 288-307 .
49.
VROOM, V. H.Some personality determinants of the effects of participation. Englewood Cliffs, N. J.: Prentice-Hall , 1960.
50.
WEBER, M.Bureaucracy. In H. H. Gerth and C. W. Mills (eds.), From Max Weber: Essays in sociology. New York: Oxford University Press , 1960.
51.
WOOD, M. T.Effects of decision processes and task situations on influence perceptions . Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1972, 7, 417-427 .
52.
WOOD, M. T.Power relationships and group decision making in organizations . Psychological Bulletin, 1973, 79, 280-293 .
53.
ZEDECK, S.Problems with the use of “moderator” variables . Psychological Bulletin, 1971, 76, 295-310 .
