In an attempt to apply the concept of group dynamics to family dynamics, entire families performed a quality solution type task. The process utilized by these families was evaluated by a jury trained in group dynamics on the criteria used to evaluate nonfamily group functioning. A panel of family experts ranked the family solutions on the task. This ranking was correlated with group process ranking on 11 group dynamics characteristics derived from the literature. Analysis indicated four summary characteristics are unimportant or unobservable, two influenced families and groups oppositely, and the remaining characteristics were detrimental to both. The characteristics are examined by virtue of the literature supporting them in both family and group functioning. Explanations compatible with current family thought are offered for the results. Suggestions for future research are included.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ALEXANDER, J. P.Defensive and supportive communications in the normal and deviant families . Journal of Counseling Psychology, 1973, 40, 223-231 .
2.
ALKINE, A. A.Social power and communications within families of disturbed children and non-disturbed preadolescents . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1969, 13, 335-349 .
3.
BALDWIN, A. L.Socialization and the parent-child relationship . Child Development, 1948, 19, 127-136 .
4.
BASS, B. M.An analysis of leaderless group discussion . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1949, 33, 527-533 .
5.
BATESON, G. , JACKSON, D. D. , HALEY, J. , & WEAKLAND, J.Toward a theory of schizophrenia . Behavioral Science, 1959, 1, 251-264 .
6.
BEELS, C. , & FERBER, A.What family therapists do? In A. Ferber , A. Mendolsohn : & A. Naiper (Eds.), The book of family therapy. Boston: Houghton Mifflin , 1973.
7.
BOWEN, M. , DYSINGER, R. H. , & BASAMINIA . The role of the father in families with a schizophrenic patient . Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Psychiatric Association, May, 1958.
8.
BRILHART, J. K. , & JOCHEM, L. M.Effects of different patterns on outcome of problem-solving discussions . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1964, 48, 175-179 .
9.
CALLAROS, F. A. , & ANDERSON, L. R.Effect of perceived expertness upon creativity of members of brainstorming groups . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1969, 53, 159-163 .
10.
CAMMALLERI, J. A. , HENDRICK, H. W. , PITMAN, W. C. , BLOUT, H. D. , & PRATHER, D. C.Effects of different leadership styles on group accuracy . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1973, 57, 32-37 .
11.
CARTWRIGHT, D. , & ZANDER, A.Group dynamics: Research and theory. New York: Harper & Row , 1968.
12.
CROSS, J. J.The relation of parental training conditions to the conceptual level in adolescent boys . Journal of Personality, 1966, 34, 348-365 .
13.
DELBECQ, A. L. , & VAN DE VEN, A. H.A group process model for problem identification and program planning . Journal of Applied Science, 1971, 7, 466-492 .
14.
DUNNETTE, M. D.Are meetings any good for solving problems?Personal Administration, March-April 1964, 12-16; 29 .
15.
DUNNETTE, M. D. , CAMPBELL, J. , & JAASTAD, K.The effect of group participation on brainstorming effectiveness for two individual samples . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1963, 47, 30-37 .
16.
ELDER, G. H.Structural variations in the child rearing relationship . Sociometry, 1962, 25, 241-242 .
17.
ELDER, G. H.Parental power legitimation and its effect on the adolescent . Sociometry, 1963, 26, 50-65 .
18.
FERREIRA, A. J. , & WINTER, W. C.Information exchange and silence in normal and abnormal families . Family Process, 1968, 7, 251-256 .
19.
FOUREIZOS, N. T. , HUTT, M. L. , AND GUETZKOW, H.Measurement of self-oriented needs in discussion groups . Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1950, 45, 682-690 .
20.
FRENCH, J. R. , MORRISON, H. W. , & LEVINGER, G.Coercive power and forces affecting conformity . Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1969, 61, 93-101 .
21.
GERARD, E. L. , & SIEGAL, F.The family background of schizophrenia . Psychiatric Quarterly, 1950, 24, 47-73 .
22.
GINTER, G. , & LINDSKOLD, S.Rate of participating and expertise as factors influencing leader choice . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1975, 32, 1085-1089 .
23.
GOLDMAN, M. , BOLEN, M. , & MARTIN, R.Some conditions under which groups operate and how this affects their performance . Journal of Social Psychology, 1961, 54, 47-56 .
24.
GUETZKOW, H. , & GYR, J.An experimental analysis of conflict in decision-making groups . Human Relations, 1954, 7, 367-382 .
25.
HALEY, J.An interactional explanation of hypnosis . American Journal of Clinical Hypnosis, 1958, 1, 41-57 .
HALEY, J.The family of the schizophrenic: A model system . Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 1959b, 129, 357-374 .
28.
HALL, E. J. , MOUTON, J. S. , & BLAKE, R. R.Group problem solving effectiveness under conditions of pooling versus interaction . Journal of Social Psychology, 1963, 59, 147-157 .
29.
HEILBRUN, A. B. , & ORR, H. K.Perceived maternal childrearing history and subsequent motivational effects of failure . Journal of Genetic Psychology, 1956, 109, 75-89 .
30.
HEILBRUN, A. B. , ORR, K. K. , & HARRELL, S. N.patterns of parental childrearing and subsequent vulnerability to cognitive disturbance . Journal of Consulting Psychology, 1966, 30, 51-59 .
31.
HOFFMAN, M. L.Power assertion by the parent and its impact upon the child . Child Development, 1960, 31, 129-143 .
32.
JACKSON, D. D.The question of family homeostatis . Psychoanalytic Quarterly, 1957, 31, supplement, 79-90 .
33.
LAING, R. D.The politics of the family and other essays. New York: Pantheon , 1971.
34.
LEIK, R. K.Instrumentality and emotionality in family interaction . Sociometry, 1963, 26,, 131-145 .
35.
LIDZ, T. , CORNELISON, A. R. , FLECK, S. , & TERRY, D.The intrafamilial environment of schizophrenic patients, II. Marital schism and marital skew . American Journal of Psychiatry, 1957, 114, 241-248 .
36.
LIDZ, R. W. , & LIDZ, T.The family environment of schizophrenic patients . American Journal of Psychiatry, 1949, 106, 126-132 .
37.
LUCAS, R. L. , & JAFFEE, C. L.Effects of high-rate talkers on group voting behavior in the leaderless-group problem-solving situation . Psychological Reports, 1969, 25, 471-477 .
38.
MAIER, N. R. F. , & HOFFMAN, L. R.Quality of first and second solutions in group problem-solving . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1960, 44, 278-283 .
39.
MATER, N. R. F.Maximizing personal creativity through better problem solving . Personnel Administration, 1964, 27, 14-18 .
40.
MAIER, N. R. F. , & MAIER, A. R. A.An experimental test of the effects of `Development' versus `Free' discussions on the quality of group decisions . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1957, 41, 320-323 .
41.
MAIER, N. R. F. , & SOLEM, A. R.The contribution of the discussion leader to the quality of group thinking . Human Relations, 1952, 5, 277-288 .
42.
MEADOW, A. , & PARNES, S. J.Evaluation of training in creative problem solving . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1959, 43, 189-194 .
43.
MEADOW, A. , PARNES, S. J. , & RESSE, H.Influence of brainstorming instructions and problem sequence on a creative problem solving test . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1959, 43, 413-416 .
44.
MORRIS, C. G. , & HACKMAN, J. R.Behavioral correlates of perceived leadership . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1969, 13, 350-361 .
45.
MURREL, S. A. , & STACHOWIAK, J. G.Consistency, rigidity, and power in the interaction patterns of clinic and nonclinic families . Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 1967, 72, 265-272 .
46.
NAPIER, A. Y.Beginning struggles with families . Journal of Marriage and Family Counseling, 1976, 2, 3-11 .
47.
PARNES, J. S.Effects of extended effort in creative problem-solving . Journal of Educational Psychology, 1961, 52, 117-122 .
48.
PARNES, J. S. , & MEADOW, A.Effects of brain-storming instruction on creative problem-solving by trained and untrained subjects . Journal of Educational Psychology, 1959, 50, 171-176 .
49.
PECK, B. B. , & STACKHOUSE, T.Reading problems and family dynamics . Journal of Learning Disabilities, 1973, 6, 506-511 .
50.
PELZ, D. C.Some social factors related to performance in a research organization . Administrative Science Quarterly, 1956, 1, 310-325 .
51.
PIKAS, A.Children's attitude toward rational versus inhibiting parental authority . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1961, 62, 315-321 .
52.
REDDY, W. B.Diagnosing team problem-solving effectiveness: A comparison of four populations . Small Group Behavior, 1975, 6, 174-186 .
53.
REICHARD, S. , & TILLMAN, G.Patterns of parent-child relationships in schizophrenia . Psychiatry, 1950, 13, 247-257 .
54.
RIECKER, H. W.The effect of talkativeness on ability to influence group solutions of problems . Sociometry, 1958, 21, 309-321 .
55.
SASHKIN, M. , & MAIER, N. R. F.Sex effects in delegation . Personnel Psychology, 1971, 24, 471-476 .
56.
SATIR, V.Conjoint Family Therapy. Palo Alto, Calif.: Science and Behavior Books , 1967.
57.
SHAW, M. E.Some effects of problem solution efficiency in different communication nets . Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1954, 48, 211-217 .
58.
SORRENTINO, R. M. , & BOUTILLIER, R. G.The effect of quality of verbal interaction on ratings of leadership ability . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1974, 11, 403-411 .
59.
STRAUS, M. A.Conjugal power structure and adolescent personality . Marriage and Family Living, 1962, 24, 17-25 .
60.
STRAUS, M. A.Communication, creativity, and problem solving ability of middle and working families in three societies . American Journal of Sociology, 1968, 73, 417-430 .
61.
TORRANCE, E. P.Group decision making and disagreement . Social Forces, 1957, 35, 314-318 .
62.
VAN DE VEN, A. H. , & DELBECQ, A. L.Nominal versus interacting group processes for committee decision-making processes . Academy of Management Journal, 1974, 17, 605-621 .
63.
VROOM, V. H. , GRANT, L. D. , & COTTON, T. S.The consequences of social interaction in group problem-solving . Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1969, 4, 77-95 .
64.
WALSH, R. P.Parental rejecting attitudes and control in children . Journal of Clinical Psychology, 1968, 24, 185-186 .
65.
WATZLAWICK, P. , WEAKLAND, J. H. , & FISCH, R.Change: Principles of problem formation and problem resolution. New York: Norton , 1974.
66.
WILLIAMSON, D.Seminar in advanced strategies of family therapy. Paper presented at Texas Woman's University, 1977.
67.
WRIGHT, S. S. The effects of assigned family roles on small group interactions. Unpublished Master's Thesis, Texas Woman's University, 1976.
68.
WYNNE, I. D. , RYCHOFF, I. M. , DAY, J. , & HIRSCH, S. E.Pseudomutuality in the family relations of schizophrenics . Psychiatry, 1958, 21, 205-220 .
