A Dialectical Approach to Formulating and Testing Social Science Theories: Assumptional Analysis

Abstract

It is argued that the necessary step in the formulation of “good” theories and their subsequent testing and refinement is uncovering the relevant underlying assumptions that different scientists make concerning the nature of human behavior, social environments, and the interactions between these. Since assumptions are, by definition, implicit, unconscious, or even obscure, an explicit process is needed to examine this hidden domain. This paper presents such a process and illustrates how this dialectical approach can be utilized to facilitate advances in social science research.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ARMSTRONG, J. S. Advocacy as a scientific strategy: The Mitroff myth . Academy of Management Review, 1980, 5, 509-511 .

CAMPBELL, D. T. , & STANLEY, J. C. Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for research. Chicago: Rand McNally , 1963.

CHURCHMAN, C. W. The design of inquiring systems. New York: Basic Books , 1971.

GALBRAITH, J. Designing complex organizations. Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley , 1973.

GILBRETH, F. B. Primer of scientific management. New York: Van Nostrand , 1914.

HUSE, E. H. Organization change and development (2nd ed.). St. Paul, Minn.: West , 1980.

KATZ, D. , & KAHN, R. L. Some recent findings in human relations research in industry. In G. W. Swanson , T. M. Newcomb , & E. E. Hartley (eds.), Reading in social psychology (2nd ed.). New York: Holt , 1952.

KILMANN, R. H. Problem management: A behavioral science approach. In G. Zaltman (Ed.), Management principles for nonprofit agencies and organizations. New York: AMACOM , 1979.

KILMANN, R. H. , & MITROFF, I. I. Qualitative versus quantitative analysis for management science: Different forms for different psychological types . Interfaces, 1976, 6(2), 17-28 .

10.

MARCH, J. G. & SIMON, H. A. Organizations. New York: Wiley , 1958.

11.

MASON, R. O. A dialectical approach to strategic planning . Management Science, 1969, 15, B403-B413 .

12.

MASON, R. O. , & MITROEF, I. I. A program for research on management information systems . Management Science, 1973, 19, 475-487 .

13.

MITROFF, I. I. The subject side of science: A philosophical inquiry into the psychology of apollo moon scientists. Amsterdam: Elsevier , 1974.

14.

MITROFF, I. I. Reality as a scientific strategy: Revising our concepts of science . Academy of Management Review, 1980, 5, 513-515 .

15.

MITROFF, I. I. , & EMSHOFF. J. On strategic assumption-making: A dialectical approach to policy and planning . Academy of Management Review, 1979, 4, 1-12 .

16.

MITROFF, I. I. , EMSHOFF, J. , & KILMANN, R. H. Assumptional analysis: A methodology for strategic problem solving . Management Science, 1979, 25, 583-593 .

17.

MITROFF, I. I. , & KILMANN, R. H. Methodological approaches to social science: Integrating divergent concepts and theories. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass , 1978.

18.

ROETHLISBERGER, F. J. , & DICKSON, J. Management and the worker, Boston: Harvard University , 1938.

19.

SAATY, T. L. The analytic hierarchy process: Planning, priority setting, resource allocation. New York: McGraw-Hill , 1980.

20.

SHAW, M. E. Group dynamics, New York: McGraw-Hill , 1971.

21.

TAYLOR, F. W. Scientific management, New York: Harper , 1911.

22.

THOMPSON J. D. Organizations in action, New York: McGraw-Hill , 1967.

23.

TRIST, E. L. , & BAMFORTH, K. W. Some social and psychological consequences of the long-wall method of coal-getting . Human Relations, 1951, 4, 3-38 .

24.

WEBER, M. The theory of social and economic organization A. M. Handerson and Talcott Parsons. (Trans.). New York: Free Press , 1947.

25.

WEICK, K. E. Social psychology of organizing, Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley , 1969. Assumptional. Analysis