Attitudes Toward Punishment in Relation to Beliefs in Free Will and Determinism

Abstract

An experiment was conducted to investigate attitudes toward punishment in relation to beliefs in free will and determinism. College students responded to two questionnaires; one designed to assess attitudes toward punishment and one designed to assess strength of belief in free will or determinism. It was found that subjects who scored higher in belief in determinism recommended more punitive measures for behavioral deviations than those who scored higher in belief in free will. A possible explanation for these results emphasized the burdensome moral responsibility which punishment may represent to those who believe in free will. Such responsibility would demand that punishment be administered with scrupulous attention to fairness and justice.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

BUDD, W. C.

Is free will really necessary?

American Psychologist, 1960, 15, 217-218.

GRUNBAUM, A. Free will and the laws of human behavior. American Philosophical Quarterly, 1971, 8, 299-317.

HARTMANN, W. The free will controversy. American Psychologist, 1961, 16, 37-38.

NELSON, T. H.

On "Cruelty, dignity, and determinism."

American Sociological Review, 1959, 24, 692-693.

NETTLER, G. Cruelty, dignity, and determinism. American Sociological Review, 1959, 24, 375-384.

NETTLER, G. Free will and cruelty. American Psychologist, 1961, 16, 529-529.

ROBERTS, L. D. Libertarianism and statistical laws. Nous, 1974, 8, 195-199.

VINEY, D. W. Freedom and responsibility: A Whiteheadian view. Unpublished Master's Thesis, The University of Oklahoma, 1979.