Another Look at the Conformity Explanation of Group-Induced Shifts in Choice

Abstract

A conformity explanation of group-induced shifts in individual choice has never received careful examination. For conformity to account for groupinduced shifts, it must be shown that (a) movement toward the group produces shifts in predictable directions on given decision problems, and (b) the motive force behind individual changes is group pressure. This article reviews the evidence bearing upon these two propositions and compares conformity with other currently popular explanations of the choice shift. The conclusion drawn is that conformity cannot account for the full choice shift effect, but that it does explain a significant portion of the variance in individual shifts.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ALLEN, V. L. Situational factors in conformity. In L. Berkowitz (Ed.), Advances in experimental social psychology (Vol. 2). New York: Academic , 1965, pp. 133-175.

BARON, R. S. , DION, K. L. , BARON, P. H. , & MILLER, N. Group consensus and cultural values as determinants of risk taking . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1971, 20, 446-455 .

BARON, R. S. , MONSON, T. C. , & BARON, P. H. Conformity pressure as a determinant of risk taking: Replication and extension . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1973, 28, 406-413 .

BISHOP, G. D. , & MYERS, D. G. Informational influence in group discussion . Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1974, 12, 92-104 .

BLASCOVICH, J. , & GINSBURG, G. P. Emergent norms and choice shifts involving risk . Sociometry, 1974, 37, 205-218 .

BLASCOVICH, J. , GINSBURG, G. P. , & VEACH, T. L. A pluralistic explanation of choice shifts on the risk dimension . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1975, 31, 422-429 .

BROWN, R. Socialpsychology. New York: Free Press , 1965.

BURNSTEIN, E. , & VINOKUR, A. Testing two classes of theories about group induced shifts in individual choice . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1973, 9, 123-137 .

BURNSTEIN, E. , VINOKUR, A. , & PICHEVIN, M. F.

What do differences between own, admired, and attributed choices have to do with group induced shifts in choice?

Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1974, 10, 428-443 .

10.

BURNSTEIN, E. , VINOKUR, A. , & TROPE, Y. Interpersonal comparison versus persuasive argumentation: A more direct test of alternative explanations for group-induced shifts in individual choice . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1973, 9, 236-245 .

11.

CARTWRIGHT, D. Risk taking by individuals and groups: An assessment of research employing choice dilemmas . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1971, 20, 361-378 .

12.

CARTWRIGHT, D. Determinants of scientific progress: The case of research on the risky shift . American Psychologist, 1973, 28, 222-231 .

13.

CASTORE, C. H. , PETERSON, K. , & GOODRICH, T. A. Risky shift: Social value or social choice? An alternative model . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1971, 20, 487-494 .

14.

CECIL, E. A. , CHERTKOFF, J. M. , & CUMMINGS, L. L. Risk taking in groups as a function of group pressure . Journal of Social Psychology, 1970, 81, 273-274 .

15.

CLARK, R. D., III , & CROCKETT, W. H. Subjects' initial positions, exposure to varying opinions, and the risky shift . Psychonomic Science, 1971, 23, 277-279 .

16.

CLARK, R. D., III , CROCKETT, W. H. , & ARCHER, R. L. Risk-as-value hypothesis: The relationship between perception of self, others, and the risky shift . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1971, 20, 425-429 .

17.

CLARK, R. D., III , & WILLEMS, E. P. Where is the risky shift? Dependence on instructions . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1969, 13, 215-221 .

18.

DEUTSCH, M. , & GERARD, H. B. A study of normative and informational social influences upon individual judgment . Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1955, 51, 629-636 .

19.

EBBESEN, E. B. , & BOWERS, R. J. Proportion of risky to conservative arguments in a group discussion and choice shift . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1974, 29, 316-327 .

20.

ELLIS, H. D. , SPENCER, C. P. , & OLDFIELD-BOX, H. Matched groups and the risky shift phenomenon: A defense of the extreme member hypothesis . British Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, 1969, 8, 333-339 .

21.

FESTINGER, L. Informal social communication . Psychological Review, 1950, 57, 271-282 .

22.

FESTINGER, L. A theory of social comparison processes . Human Relations, 1954, 7, 117-140 .

23.

FRASER, C. Group risk-taking and group polarization . European Journal of Social Psychology, 1971, 1, 493-510 .

24.

FRASER, C. , GOUGE, C. , & BILLIG, M. Risky shifts, cautious shifts, and group polarization . European Journal of Social Psychology, 1971, 1, 1-29 .

25.

GORDON, M. , FLANDERS, J. P. , & CRANNY, C. J. Inside the black box: A content analysis of group discussions involving risk . Proceedings of the 81st Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association, 1973, 8, 283-284 (Summary).

26.

JELLISON, J. M. , & RISKIND, J. A social comparison of abilities interpretation of risktaking behavior . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1970, 15, 375-390 .

27.

JELLISON, J. M. , & RISKIND, J. Attribution of risk to others as a function of their ability . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1971, 20, 413-415 .

28.

KERR, N. L. , DAVIS, J. H. , MEEK, D. , & RISSMAN, A. K. Group position as a function of member attitudes: Choice shift effects from the perspective of social decision scheme theory . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1975, 31, 574-593 .

29.

KIESLER, C. A. , & KIESLER, S. B. Conformity. Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley , 1969.

30.

LAMM, H. , SCHAUDE, E. , & TROMMSDORFF, G. Risky shift as a function of group members' value of risk and need for approval . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1971, 20, 430-435 .

31.

LAMM, H. , TROMMSDORFF, G. , & ROST-SCHAUDE, E. Self-image, perception of peers' risk acceptance and risky shift . European Journal of Social Psychology, 1972, 2, 255-272 .

32.

LEVINGER, G. , & SCHNEIDER, D. J. Test of the "risk is a value" hypothesis . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1969, 11, 165-169 .

33.

MADARAS, G. R. , & BEM, D. J. Risk and conservatism in group decision-making . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1968, 4, 350-365 .

34.

MARQUIS, D. G. Individual responsibility and group decisions involving risk . Industrial Management Review, 1962, 3, 8-23 .

35.

MCCAULEY, C. R. Extremity shifts, risk shifts and attitude shifts after group discussion . European Journal of Social Psychology, 1972, 2, 417-436 .

36.

MORGAN, C. P. , & ARAM, J. D. The preponderance of arguments in the risky shift phenomenon . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1975, 11, 25-34 .

37.

MOSCOVICI, S. , DOISE, W. , & DULONG, R. Studies in group decision II: Differences of positions, differences of opinion and group polarization . European Journal of Social Psychology, 1972, 2, 385-399 .

38.

MOSCOVICI, S. , & ZAVALLONI, M. The group as a polarizer of attitudes . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1969, 12, 125-135 .

39.

MURDOCH, P. , MYERS, D. G. , & SMITH, G. F. Information effects on cautious and riskyshift items . Psychonomic Science, 1970, 20, 97-98 .

40.

MYERS, D. G. , & ARENSON, S. Enhancement of dominant risk tendencies in group discussion . Psychological Reports, 1972, 30, 615-623 .

41.

MYERS, D. G. , BACH, P. J. , & SCHREIBER, F. B. Normative and informational effects of group interaction . Sociometry, 1974, 37, 275-286 .

42.

MYERS, D. G. , & BISHOP, G. D. Enhancement of dominant attitudes in group discussion . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1971, 20, 386-391 .

43.

MYERS, D. G. , & LAMM, H. The group polarization phenomenon . Psychological Bulletin, 1976, 83, 602-627 .

44.

MYERS, D. G. , WONG, D. W. , & MURDOCH, P. Discussion arguments, information about others' responses, and risky shift . Psychonomic Science, 1971, 24, 81-83 .

45.

PRUITT, D. G. Choice shifts in group discussion: An introductory review . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1971, 20, 339-358 .

46.

PRUITT, D. G. , & COSENTINO, C. The role of values in the choice shift . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1975, 11, 301-316 .

47.

PRUITT, D. G. , & TEGER, A. I. Is there a shift toward risk in group discussion? If so, is it a group phenomenon? If so, what causes it? Paper presented at the meeting of the American Psychological Association, Washington, D.C., September 1967.

48.

ROBERTS, J. C. , & CASTORE, C. H. The effects of conformity, information, and confidence upon subjects' willingness to take risk following a group discussion . Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1972, 8, 384-394 .

49.

SCHACHTER, S. Deviation, rejection, and communication . Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1951, 46, 190-207 .

50.

SILVERTHORNE, C. P. Information input and the group shift phenomenon in risk taking . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1971, 20, 456-461 .

51.

SINGLETON, R. A., JR. Group discussion, others' decisions, others' arguments, and the choice shift phenomenon. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Indiana University, 1973.

52.

ST. JEAN, R. Reformulation of the value hypothesis in group risk taking . Proceedings of the 78th Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association, 1970, 5, 339-340 .

53.

STOKES, J. P. Effects of familiarization and knowledge of others' odds choices and shifts to risk and caution . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1971, 20, 407-412 .

54.

STONER, J. A. F. A comparison of individual and group decisions involving risk. Unpublished master's thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1961.

55.

STONER, J. A. F. Risky and cautious shifts in group decisions: The influence of widely held values . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1968, 4, 442-459 .

56.

TEGER, A. I. , & PRUITT, D. G. Components of group risk taking . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1967, 3, 189-205 .

57.

VIDMAR, N. Group composition and the risky shift . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1970, 6, 153-166 .

58.

VINOKUR, A. Distributions of initial risk levels and group decisions involving risk . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1969, 13, 207-214 .

59.

VINOKUR, A. , TROPE, Y. , & BURNSTEIN, E. A decision-making analysis of persuasive argumentation and the choice-shift effect . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1975, 11, 127-148 .

60.

WALLACH, M. A. , & KOGAN, N. The roles of information, discussion, and consensus in group risk taking . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1965, 1, 1-19 .

61.

WALLACH, M. A. , KOGAN, N. , & BEM, D. J. Group influence on individual risk taking . Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1962, 65, 75-86 .

62.

WALLACH, M. A. , KOGAN, N. , & BEM, D. J. Diffusion of responsibility and level of risk taking in groups . Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1964, 68, 263-274 .

63.

WALLACH, M. A. , & MABLI, J. Information versus conformity in the effects of group discussion on risk taking . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1970, 14, 149-156 .

64.

WALLACH, M. A. , & WING, C. W., JR.

Is risk a value?

Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1968, 9, 101-106 .

65.

WILLEMS, E. P. , & CLARK, R. D., III. Shift toward risk and heterogeneity of groups . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1971, 7, 304-312 .