Many sociologists have hypothesized that persons who possess inconsistent or conflicting attributes will tend to experience stress and manifest certain psychological characteristics which are markedly different from those who possess ordinary combinations of attributes. This problem has been regarded from three theoretical perspectives, the "theories" of the marginal man, role conflict, and status inconsistency. After examining the ways in which each perspective has been employed, this paper discusses several points of convergence and specifies implicit assumptions each makes about the nature of the interaction involved. Some conclusions are offered which indicate the usefulness of a reductionist approach in the formulation of sociological theory and in the conduct of research.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ALEXANDER, C. N., JR. , & SIMPSON, R. L.Balance theory and distributive justice . Sociological Inquiry, 1964, 34, 182-192 .
2.
BAUMAN, K. E.Status consistency, satisfying social interaction and community satisfaction in an area of rapid growth . Social Forces, 1968, 47, 45-52 .
3.
BENOIT-SMULLYAN, E.Status, status types, and status interrelations . American Sociological Review, 1944, 9, 151-161 .
4.
BERRY, J. W.Marginality, stress and ethnic identification in an acculturated Aboriginal community . Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 1970, 1, 239-252 .
5.
BIDDLE, B. J. , & THOMAS, E. J. (eds.). Role theory: Concepts and research. New York: Wiley , 1966.
6.
BROOM, L. , & JONES, F. L.Status consistency and political preference: The Australian case . American Sociological Review, 1970, 35, 989-1009 .
7.
BURCHARD, W.Role conflicts of military chaplains . American Sociological Review, 1954, 19, 528-535 .
8.
CAMPBELL, E. Q. , & PETTIGREW, T. F.Racial and moral crises: The role of the Little Rock ministers . American Journal of Sociology, 1959, 64, 509-516 .
9.
CHILD, I.Italian or American?New Haven: Yale University Press , 1943.
10.
CICOUREL, A. V.Cognitive sociology. Harmondsworth: Penguin , 1974.
11.
DUNHAM, H. W. , PHILLIPS, P. , & SRINIVASAN, B.A research note on diagnosed mental illness and social class . American Sociological Review, 1966, 31, 223-227 .
12.
FENCHEL, G. H. , MORDERER, J. H. , & HARTLEY, E. H.Subjective status and the equilibration hypothesis . Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1951, 46, 476-479 .
13.
GARFINKEL, H.Studies in ethnomethodology. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: PrenticeHall , 1967.
14.
GESCHWENDER, J. A.Continuities in theories of status consistency and cognitive dissonance . Social Forces, 1967, 46, 160-171 .
15.
GESCHWENDER, J. A.Status inconsistency, social isolation and social unrest . Social Forces, 1968, 46, 477-483 .
16.
GIBBS, J. , & MARTIN, W.Status integration and suicide. Eugene: University of Oregon Press , 1965.
17.
GOFFMAN, I. W.Status consistency and preference for change in power distribution . American Sociological Review, 1957, 22, 275-281 .
18.
GOLDBERG, M. M.A qualification of the marginal man theory . American Sociological Review, 1941, 4, 52-58 .
19.
GREEN, A. W.A reexamination of the marginal man concept . Social Forces, 1947, 26, 167-171 .
20.
GROSS, N. , MASON, W. S. , & McEACHERN, A.Explorations in role analysis. New York: Wiley , 1958.
21.
HOMANS, G. C.Sentiments and activities. Glencoe, Ill.: The Free Press , 1962.
22.
HOMANS, G. C.Bringing men back in. American Sociological Review, 1964, 29, 809-818 .
23.
HUGHES, E. C.Social change and status protest; An essay on the marginal man . Phylon, 1949,10, 58-65 .
24.
JACKSON, E. F.Status consistency and symptoms of stress . American Sociological Review, 1962, 27, 469-480 .
25.
JACKSON, E. F. , & BURKE, P. J.Status consistency and symptoms of stress: Additive and interaction effects . American Sociological Review, 1965, 30, 556-564 .
26.
JACKSON, E. F. , & CURTIS, R. F.Effects of vertical mobility and status inconsistency: A body of negative evidence . American Sociological Review, 1972, 37, 701-713 .
27.
KAHN, R. L. , WOLFE, D. M. , QUINN, R. P. , SNOECK, J. D. , & ROSENTHAL, R. A.Organizational stress: Studies in role conflict and ambiguity. New York: Wiley , 1964.
28.
KELLY, K. D. , & CHAMBLISS, W. J.Status consistency and political attitudes . American Sociological Review, 1966, 31, 375-381 .
29.
KENKEL, W. F.The relationship between status consistency and political-economic attitudes . American Sociological Review, 1956, 21, 365-380 .
30.
KERCKHOFF, A. C. , & McCORMICK, T. C.Marginal status and marginal personality . Social Forces, 1955, 34, 48-55 .
31.
KNOKE, D.Consistency and community . Social Forces, 1972, 51, 23-33 .
32.
KOMAROVSKY, M.Functional analysis of sex roles . American Sociological Review, 1950, 15, 508-516 .
33.
LAUMANN, E. O. , & SEGAL, D. R.Status inconsistency and ethnoreligious group membership as determinants of social participation and political attitudes . American Journal of Sociology, 1971, 77, 36-61 .
34.
LENSKI, G. E.Status crystallisation: A non-vertical dimension of social status . American Sociological Review, 1954, 19, 405-413 .
35.
LENSKI, G. E.Social participation and status crystallisation . American Sociological Review, 1956, 21, 288-301 .
36.
LENSKI, G. E.Status inconsistency and the vote: A four nation test . American Sociological Review, 1967, 32, 288-301 .
37.
MANN, J. W.Group relations and the marginal personality . Human Relations, 1958, 11, 77-92 .
38.
MERTON, R. K.Social theory and social structure. Glencoe, Ill.: The Free Press , 1957.
39.
OLSEN, M. E. , & TULLY, J. C.Socioeconomic-ethnic status inconsistency and preference for political change . American Sociological Review, 1972, 37, 560-574 .
40.
PARK, R. E.Race and culture. Glencoe, Ill.: The Free Press , 1950.
41.
PARSONS, T.The social system. New York: The Free Press , 1951.
42.
RINGER, B. B. , & SILLS, D. L.Political extremists in Iran . Public Opinion Quarterly, 1953, 16, 689-702 .
43.
RUSH, G. B.Status consistency and right-wing extremism . American Sociological Review, 1967, 32, 86-92 .
44.
SAMPSON, E. E.Status congruence and cognitive consistency . Sociometry, 1963, 26, 146-162 .
45.
SEGAL, D. R.Status inconsistency, cross pressures and American political behavior . American Sociological Review, 1969, 34, 352-358 .
46.
SHIBUTANI, T.Society and personality. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall , 1964.
47.
STONEQUIST, E. V.The marginal man. New York: Scribner's , 1937.
48.
TREIMAN, D. J.Status discrepancy and prejudice . American Journal of Sociology, 1966, 71, 651-664 .
49.
VANDER ZANDEN, J. W.Race relations in transition. New York:Random House , 1965.
50.
WILSON, B. R.The Pentecostal minister: Role conflicts and status contradictions . American Journal of Sociology, 1959, 64, 494-504 .
51.
WRAY, D. E.The marginal men of industry: The foreman . American Journal of Sociology, 1949, 14, 298-301 .
