The Effects of the Findings of the U.S. National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders: An Experimental Study of Attitude Change

Abstract

One hundred and nineteen white student Ss responded to semantic differential, behavioral differential, Likert scales and other measures tapping attitudes, perceptions and factual information relevant to the race riots of the mid to late 1960's. Items were factor analyzed and composite scores on the resulting factors were used in later analyses. Thirty-seven experimental Ss were given reading material containing a summary of the salient points made in the Kerner Commission Report. Twenty-nine controls received dummy reading material. The questionnaire was re-administered three weeks later to both groups. A number of significant shifts in attitudes were obtained; these were typically in a direction more consistent with the findings of the Kerner Commission Report, which advocated social change. Significant shifts occurred in Ss' evaluation of changing social policy as well as in their expression of behavioral intentions toward stimulus persons of both races who strongly favored civil rights action. Attitude shifts were accompanied by increases in factual information. Negative relationships between measures of racial prejudice and semantic differential evaluations of busing children to promote school integration (r =-.39; p<.001) and federal enforcement of open housing (r =-.47; p<.OOl) were obtained, suggesting that attitudes toward such issues are significantly related to racial prejudice. It was suggested that, as potential instruments of attitude change, reports of this and similar Commissions set up to study social problems and make recommendations for social policy should be studied to determine the extent of their impact on attitudes.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ADORNO, T. W. , FRENKEL-BRUNSWIK, E. , LEVINSON, D. and SANFORD, R. N. (1950). The authoritarian personality. New York: Harper .

ALLPORT, G. W. and KRAMER, B. M. (1946). Some roots of prejudice . Journal of psychology, 22, 9-39 .

BLAUNER, R. (1966). Whitewash over Watts . Trans/action, 3, 8-8 .

CAMPBELL, A. and SCHUMAN, H. (1968). Racial attitudes in fifteen American cities. Supplemental studies for the national advisory commission on civil disorders. Washington, D. C.: U.S. Government Printing Office .

DAVIS, E. E. (1966). A methodological study of behavioral and semantic differential scales relevant to intercultural negotiations. (Tech. Rep. 32, ONR Contract 177-472, Nonr-1834 (36)) Urbana: University of Illinois .

DAVIS, E. E. and TRIANDIS, H. C. (1971). An experimental study of black-white negotiations . Journal of applied social psychology, 1, 240-262 .

ERSKINE, H. (1968). The polls: Recent opinion on racial problems . Public opinion quarterly, 32, 696-703 .

FEAGIN, J. R. and SHEATSLEY, P. B. (1968). Ghetto resident appraisals of a riot . Public opinion quarterly, 32, 352-362 .

GOLDSTEIN, M. and DAVIS, E. E. (1972). Race and belief: A further analysis of the social determinants of behavioral intentions . Journal of personality and social psychology, 22, 346-355 .

10.

HARRIS, L. (1967). After the riots: A survey-How the flare-ups affected U.S. racial attitudes. Newsweek, 21st August, p. 19-19.

11.

HEIDER, F. (1944). Social perception and phenomenal causality . Psychological review, 51, 358-374 .

12.

ROSSI, P. H. , BERK, R. A. , BOESEL, D. P. , EIDSON, B. K. and GROVES, W. E. (1968). Between white and black-The faces of American institutions in the ghetto. Supplemental studies for the national advisory commission on civil disorders. Washington, D. C.: U.S. Government Printing Office .

13.

SEARS, D. O. and TOMLINSON, T. M. (1968). Riot ideology in Los Angeles: A study of Negro attitudes . Social science quarterly,49, 485-505 .

14.

SHEATSLEY, P. B. (1966). White attitudes toward the Negro. In T. Parsons and K. Clark (eds), The Negro American. Boston: Houghton Mifflin .

15.

SMITH, G. and STOCKMAN, N. (1972). Some suggestions for a sociological approach to the study of government reports . The sociological review, 20, 59-77 .

16.

TRIANDIS, H. C. and DAVIS, E. E. (1965). Race and belief as determinants of behavioral intentions . Journal of personality and social psychology, 2, 715-725 .