Although many writers have bemoaned psychology’s indifference toward labor unions, there has been little critical analysis of why this indifference exists. In this article, several explanations that have been offered to explain this indifference are identified and evaluated. These explanations are: (i) limited access to relevant data; (ii) limited financial rewards;(iii) early psychologists’ attitudes toward unions; and (iv) the failure to appreciate power differences between workers and management. The history of psychology in the US is compared with the history of sociology and economics in order to investigate the viability of these hypotheses. It is concluded that the two crucial reasons for the neglect of labor union issues by applied psychologists are the psychologists’ reluctance to address the presence of conflict between employers and employees and the dearth of early, pro-union psychologists.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abbott, A. The sociology of work and occupations . Annual Review of Sociology, 1993, 19, 187-209 .
2.
AFL-CIO. AFL-CIO Research Agenda: Voice@Work - The freedom to choose a union. Unpublished manuscript, 2000.
3.
Baritz, L. Servants of power. Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press , 1960.
4.
Barkin, S. Implications of psychology in labor-management relations (A symposium): 4. Psychology as seen by a trade unionist . Personnel Psychology, 1961, 14, 259-270 .
5.
Barling, J., Fullagar, C. & Kelloway, E.K. The union and its members: A psychological approach. New York: Oxford University Press , 1992.
6.
Bell, D. Adjusting men to machines: Social scientists explore the world of the factory . Commentary, 1947, 3 (Jan.), 79-88 .
7.
Bourke, H. Industrial unrest as social pathology: The Australian writings of Elton Mayo . Historical Studies, 1982, 20, 217-233 .
8.
Boyer, G.R. & Smith, R.S. The development of the neoclassical tradition in labor economics . Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 2001, 54, 199-223 .
9.
Bramel, D. & Friend, R. Hawthorne, the myth of the docile worker, and class bias in psychology . American Psychologist, 1981, 36, 867-878 .
10.
Bramel, D. & Friend, R. Is industrial psychology none of Marxism’s business? American Psychologist, 1982, 37, 860-862 .
11.
Bramel, D. & McKnight, D. School superintendents’ antilabor bias in screening researchers’ access to classrooms . Sociology of Education, 1990, 63, 75-82 .
12.
Capshew, J.H. Psychologists on the march: Science, practice, and professional identity in America, 1929-1969. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press , 1999.
13.
Clark, P.F. Building more effective unions. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press , 2000.
14.
Commons, J.R. Myself: The autobiography of John R. Commons. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press , 1934/1964.
15.
Cornfield, D.B. Plant shutdowns and union decline: The United Furniture Workers of America, 1963-1981 . Work and Occupations, 1987, 14, 434-451 .
16.
Cravens, H. History of the social sciences . OSIRIS, 1985, 1, 183-207 .
17.
Eby, K. Research in labor unions . American Journal of Sociology, 1950, 56, 222-228 .
18.
Ely, R.T. The founding and early history of the American Economic Association . American Economic Review, 1936, 26, 141-150 .
19.
Ferguson, L.W. Industrial psychology and labor. In B. von Haller Gilmer (Ed.), Walter van dyke Bingham: Memorial program. Pittsburgh, PA: Carnegie Institute of Technology , 1962, pp. 7-22.
20.
Flacks, R. Marxism and sociology. In B. Ollman & E. Vernoff (Eds), The Left Academy: Marxist scholarship on American campuses. New York: McGraw-Hill , 1982, pp. 9-52.
21.
Freeman, R.B. & Medoff, J.L. What do unions do? New York: Basic Books , 1984.
22.
Ghorayshi, P. The sociology of work: A critical annotated bibliography. New York: Garland , 1990.
23.
Godard, J. New dawn or bad moon rising?: Large scale government administered workplace surveys and the future of Canadian IR Research . Relations Industrielles, 2001, 56, 3-33 .
24.
Gomberg, W. The use of psychology in industry: A trade union point of view . Management Science, 1957, 3, 348-370 .
25.
Gordon, M.E. & Burt, R.E. A history of industrial psychology’s relationship with American unions: Lessons from the past and directions for the future . International Review of Applied Psychology, 1981, 30, 137-156 .
26.
Gordon, M.E. & Nurick, A.J. Psychological approaches to the study of unions and union-management relations . Psychological Bulletin, 1981, 90, 293-306 .
27.
Hale, M. Human science and social order: Hugo Münsterberg and the origins of applied psychology. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press , 1980.
28.
Hartley, J. The psychology of industrial relations . International Review of Industrial and Organizational Psychology, 1992, 7, 201-243 .
29.
Hartley, J. & Kelly, J. Psychology and industrial relations: From conflict to cooperation? Journal of Occupational Psychology, 1986, 59, 161-176 .
30.
Hartley, J. & Stephenson, G.M. (Eds). Employment relations: The psychology of influence and control at work. Oxford: Blackwell , 1992.
31.
Hay, E.N. The attitude of the American Federation of Labor on job evaluation . Personnel Journal, 1947, 26, 163-169 .
32.
Highhouse, S. & Zickar, M.J. Where has all the psychology gone? The Industrial-Organizational Psychologist, 1997, 35, 82-85 .
33.
Hiller, E.T. The strike: A study in collective action. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press , 1928.
34.
Hills, S.M. Employment relations and the social sciences. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press , 1995.
35.
Hoxie, R.F. Scientific management and labor. New York: Appleton , 1915.
36.
Jacoby, S.M. Employee attitude testing at Sears, Roebuck and Company, 1938-1960 . Business History Review, 1986, 60, 602-632 .
37.
Kaufman, B.E. The origins and evolution of the field of industrial relations. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press , 1993.
38.
Kaufman, B.E. The theory and practice of strategic HRM and participative management: Antecedents in early industrial relations . Human Resource Management Review, 2001, 11, 505-533 .
39.
Kochan, T.A. What is distinctive about industrial relations research? In K. Whitfield & G. Strauss (Eds), Researching the world of work: Strategies and methods in studying industrial relations. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press , 1998, pp. 31-45.
40.
Kornhauser, A. Industrial psychology as management technique and as social science . American Psychologist, 1947, 11, 224-229 .
41.
Kornhauser, A. Mental health of the industrial worker. New York: Wiley , 1965.
42.
Landy, F.J. Hugo Münsterberg: Victim or visionary? Journal of Applied Psychology, 1992, 77, 787-802 .
43.
Lefkowitz, J. Ethics and values in industrial-organizational psychology. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum , 2003.
44.
Levenstein, A. Implications of psychology in labor-management relations (A symposium): 3. The psychologist joins the labor conflict . Personnel Psychology, 1961, 14, 250-259 .
45.
Lynch, E.C. Walter Dill Scott: Pioneer industrial psychologist . Business History Review, 1968, 42, 149-170 .
46.
McNulty, P. Labor problems and labor economics: The roots of an academic discipline . Labor History, 1968, 9, 239-261 .
47.
Metcalf, H.C. The attitude and the reaction of the business man to psychology . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1917, 1, 380-381 .
Myers, M.S. Managing without unions. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley , 1976.
50.
Nord, W.R. Continuity and change in industrial/organizational psychology: Learning from previous mistakes . Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 1982, 13, 942-953 .
51.
Nord, W.R., Brief, A.P., Atieh, J.M. & Doherty, E.M. Studying meanings of work: The case of work values. In A.P. Brief & W.R. Nord (Eds), Meanings of occupational work: A collection of essays. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books , 1990, pp. 21-64.
52.
Perlman, S. A theory of the labor movement. New York: Macmillan , 1928.
53.
Pfeffer, J. Power in organizations. Marshfield, MA: Pitman , 1981.
Simon, A. Backlash! Corporate front groups and the struggle for sustainable forestry in British Columbia . Capitalism, Nature, Socialism, 1998, 9, 3-38 .
59.
Slocombe, C.S.Meet C.I.O. on its own ground . Personnel Journal, 1937, 16, 1-8 .
60.
Society for Industrial-Organizational Psychology. A description of the Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology. Available from (accessed 1 May 2003): http://siop.org/gtp/gtp98/GTPDescription.htm
61.
Sokal, M. James McKeen Cattell and American psychology in the 1920s. In J. Brozek (Ed.), Explorations in the history of psychology in the United States. London: Associated University Press , 1984, pp. 273-323.
62.
Stagner, R. Psychology of industrial conflict. New York: Wiley , 1956.
63.
Stagner, R. The future of union psychology . International Review of Applied Psychology, 1981, 30, 321-328 .
64.
Stagner, R. The importance of historical context . American Psychologist, 1982, 37, 356 .
65.
Stagner, R. My life and growth in industrial-organizational psychology. The Industrial-Organizational Psychologist [on-line]. Available from (accessed 13 May 2003): http://www.siop.org/Presidents/Stagner.htm
66.
Strauss, G., Gallagher, D.G. & Fiorito, J. (Eds). The state of the unions. Madison, WI: Industrial Relations Research Association , 1991.
67.
Sverke, M. (Ed.). The future of trade unionism. Brookfield, VT: Ashgate , 1997.
68.
Taylor, F.W. What is scientific management? In H.G. Merrill (Ed.), Classics in management. New York: American Management Association , 1912/1970, pp. 67-71.
69.
Valciukas, J. The role of the psychologist in occupational neurotoxicology: Apropos of Huszczo et al.’s ‘Psychology and organized labor.’ American Psychologist, 1985, 40, 1053-1054 .
70.
Van de Water, T.J. Psychology’s entrepreneurs and the marketing of industrial psychology . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1997, 82, 486-499 .
71.
Ware, C.F. Labor education in universities: A study of university programs. New York: American Labor Education Service , 1946.
72.
Whyte, W.F. From human relations to organizational behavior: Reflections on the changing scene . Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 1987, 40, 487-500 .
73.
Woll, M. Labor will lead . American Federationalist, 1919, 513.
74.
Worthy, J.C. Shaping an American institution: Robert E. Wood and Sears, Roebuck. Urbana: University of Illinois Press , 1984.
75.
Yoakum, C.S. & Yerkes, R.M. Army mental tests. New York: H. Holt , 1920.
76.
Zickar, M.J. Using personality inventories to identify thugs and agitators: Applied psychology’s contribution to the war against labor . Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2001, 59, 149-164 .
77.
Zickar, M.J. Remembering Arthur Kornhauser: Industrial psychology’s advocate for worker well-being . Journal of Applied Psychology, 2003, 88, 363-369 .
78.
Zickar, M.J. & Highhouse, S. Measuring prestige of journals in industrial-organizational psychology . The Industrial-Organizational Psychologist, 2001, 38, 29-36 .
