Tangible Line Graphs: An Experimental Investigation of Three Formats Using Capsule Paper

Abstract

This study explores three formats for the presentation of tangible line graphs to visually handicapped people, using the capsule-paper production process. The formats are L/no-grid (standard x and y axes/data curves on smooth background), box/no-grid (duplicated axes enclose graph space on all four sides/smooth background), and box/grid (duplicated axes/data curves superimposed on grid). Subjects answered questions concerning the coordinate value of points, the difference in coordinate value between two points, and configurational aspects of the data. Questions that involved determining coordinate values were answered most accurately from the box/grid format, followed by the box/no-grid, and, lastly, the L/no-grid. Response times did not differ. A different pattern emerged with questions concerning configurational aspects of the graph. With these there was no difference in accuracy between the formats, but the L/no-grid format led to faster responding than the box/no-grid, which in turn was faster than the box/grid. The practical implications of these data are considered.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aids and Appliances Review. (1984, Fall issue). Tactual graphics: Research and resources. Vol. 14.

Aldrich, F. K., and Parkin, A. J. (1987). Verbal descriptions or tangible graphics? An experimental evaluation of two methods used to communicate line graphs to the blind. Unpublished manuscript.

Andrews, S. K. (1985). The use of capsule paper in producing tactual maps. Journal of Visual Impairment and Blindness, 79, 396-399.

Barth, J. L. (1983). Factors affecting line tracing in tactile graphs. Journal of Special Education, 17, 215-226.

Barth, J. L. (1984). Incised grids: Enhancing the readability of tangible graphs for the blind. Human Factors. 26, 61-70.

Berla', E. P. , and Butterfield, L. H. (1977). Tactile political maps: Two experimental designs. Journal of Visual Impairment and Blindness, 71, 262-264.

Kirchner, C. (1979). Non-text reading matter: How should it be presented? Journal of Visual Impairment and Blindness, 73, 329.

Lederman, S. J. , and Campbell, J. I. (1982). Tangible graphs for the blind. Human Factors, 24, 85-100.

Matsumoto, Yushi Seiyaki KK. (1981). Stereo copying system. Matsumoto Oil and Fat Pharmaceutical Company, Japan.

10.

Nolan, C. Y. (1971). Relative legibility of raised and incised tactual figures. Education of the Visually Handicapped, 3, 33-36.

11.

Parkin, A. J. , and Aldrich, F. K. (1987). Facilitating the use of tape recorded texts by visually handicapped students (Final report). London: Royal National Institute for the Blind.