Doing the Same Work with Hard Copy and with Cathode-Ray Tube (CRT) Computer Terminals

Abstract

Much public concern has centered on possible fatiguing effects of using CRT terminals in one's work. Previous experiments have not carefully distinguished the effects of using a CRT display per se from the effects of the work itself This experiment studies this problem by having people do the same task with a CRT display and with hard copy. Twenty-four participants proofread from a CRT on one day and from hard copy on another day. No change throughout the day in participants' proofreading performance (speed and accuracy), feelings (about the comfort of their eyes, body, mind, and work), or vision (acuity, contrast, and flicker sensitivity, phoria) could be attributed to using CRT terminals. Participants did proofread from hard copy about 20 to 30% faster than from a CRT, however.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Brown, B. S. , Dismukes, K. , and Rinalducci, E. J. (1982), Video display terminals and vision of workers: Summary and overview of a symposium. Behaviour and Information Technology, 1, 121–140.

Dainoff, M. J. , Happ, A. , and Crane, P. (1981). Visual fatigue and occupational stress in VDT operators. Human Factors, 23, 421–438.

De Groot, J. P. (1981, September). Eye strain in video terminal users. Paper presented at the European Conference of Postal and Telecommunications Administrations, Symposium on Ergonomics in PTT-Administrations, The Hague.

Gould, J. D. , and Grischkowsky, N. (1982). Doing the same work with a CRT terminal and with hardcopy. In Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 26th Annual Meeting (pp. 165–166). Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society.

Grandjean, E. , and Vigliani, E. (Eds.). (1980). Ergonomic aspects of visual display terminals. London: Taylor & Francis.

Haider, M. , Kundi, M. , and Weibenbock, M. (1980). Worker strain related to VDUs with differently coloured characters. In E. Grandjean and E. Vigliani (Eds.), Ergonomic aspects of visual display terminals (pp. 53–64). London: Taylor & Francis.

Kak, A. V. (1981). Relationships between readability of printed and CRT-displayed text. In Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 25th Annual Meeting (pp. 137–140). Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors Society.

Kucera, H. , and Francis, W. W. (1967). Computational analysis of present-day American English. Providence, RI: Brown University Press.

Matula, R. A. (1981). Effects of visual display units on the eyes; A bibliography (1972-1980). Human Factors, 23, 581–586.

10.

Mourant, R. , Lakshmanan, R. , and Chantadisai, R. (1981). Visual fatigue and cathode ray tube terminals. Human Factors, 23, 529–540.

11.

Muter, P. , Latémouille, S. A. , Treurniet, W. C. , and Beam, P. (1982). Extended readings of continuous text on television screens. Human Factors, 24, 501–508.

12.

Östberg, O. (1980). Accommodation and visual fatigue in display work. In E. Grandjean and E. Vigliani (Eds.). Ergonomic aspects of visual display terminals (pp. 41–52). London: Taylor & Francis.

13.

Sauter, S. L. , Gottlieb, M. S. , Jones, K. C. , Dodson, V. N. , and Rohrer, K. M. (1983). Job and health implications of VDT use: Initial results of the Wisconsin-NIOSH study. Communications of ACM, 26, 284–294.

14.

Smith, W. J. , Cohen, B. G. , and Stammerjohn, J. W. (1981). An investigation of health complaints and job stress in video display operations. Human Factors, 23, 387–400.

15.

Starr, S.J. , Thompson, C.R. , and Shute, S.J. (1982). Effects of video display terminals on telephone operators. Human Factors, 24, 699–713.

16.

Wright, P. , and Lickorish, A. (1983). Proof-reading texts on screen and paper. Behaviour and Information Technology, 2, 227–235.