The Effects of Extended Practice on the Evaluation of Visual Display Codes

Abstract

A series of nine experiments are reported in which highly practiced subjects were used to investigate the use of letters, digits, familiar geometric shapes, and colored dots as coding dimensions in visual displays. These experiments used single-code and dual-code displays in three isolated tasks (choice reaction, search and locate, and identification-memory) and in a multiple task that combined the three tasks in an irregularly alternating sequence. The results of these experiments provided no basis for concluding that any particular code has a general advantage or disadvantage over any other. Furthermore, when there were differences in performance with different codes, there was a tendency for practice to attenuate those differences. It is concluded that the relative effectiveness of different visual codes varies as a function of practice, other display conditions, the tasks, and the dependent measure used to make the comparison.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Christ, R. E. Predicting human performance VI: The accuracy of identifying simple targets. Las Cruces, NM: Department of Psychology, New Mexico State University, Report NMSU-ONR-TR-74–1, March, 1974.

Christ, R. E. Review and analysis of color coding research for visual displays. Human Factors, 1975, 17, 542–570.

Christ, R. E. Research for evaluating visual display codes: An emphasis on colour coding. In R. Easterby and H. Zwaga (Eds.). Visual presentation of infonnalion, Sussex, England: Wiley, in press.

Christ, R. E. , and Corso, G. M. Color research for visual displays. Las Cruces, NM: Department of Psychology, New Mexico State University, ONR Report CR213102–3, July, 1975.

Christ, R. E. , Stevens, A. L. , and Stevens, D. Color research for visual displays. Las Cruces, NM: Department of Psychology, New Mexico State University, NMSUFR-74–1, JANAIR Report 741103, July, 1974.

Mackworth, J. F. The relation between the visual image and post-perceptual immediate memory. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 1963, 2, 75–85.

National Research Council , Division of Behavioral Sciences, Committee on Vision. Visual Search: Symposium at Spring Meeting, 1970. Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences, 1974.

Teichner, W. H. , Christ, R. E. , and Corso, G. M. Color research for visual displays. Las Cruces, NM: Department of Psychology, New Mexico State University, ONR Report CR 213–102-4F, June, 1977.

Teiehner, W. H. , and Krebs, M. J. Visual search for simple targets. Psychological Bulletin, 1973, 81, 15–28.