Physiological measures of aircrew mental workload were divided into fourteen specific classes. Each class was then summarized in terms of background, applications, and implications for research and implementation. It is concluded that several physiological measures appear promising, but that more research is needed to provide convincing evidence of viability. Physiological techniques can, however, be combined with other workload assessment techniques to provide a more complete understanding of the workload associated with given aircrew tasks.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AuffretR.SerisH.BerthozA.FatrasB.Estimate of the perceptive load by variability of rate of heartbeat: Application to a piloting task. Le Travail Humain, 1967, 80, 309–310.
2.
BeattyJ.Pupillometric measurement of cognitive workload. Proceedings of the 12th annual NASA-university conference on manual control, University of Illinois, May, 1976, 135–143. (NASA TMX-73 70).
3.
BerlinerC.AngellD.ShearerD. J.Behaviors, measures, and instruments for performance evaluation in simulated environments. Paper presented at the symposium and workshop on the quantification of human performance, Alberquerque, New Mexico, August, 1964, (M-5. 7, Subcommittee on Human Factors, Electronic Industries Association).
4.
BoyceP. R.Sinus arrhythmia as a measure of mental load. Ergonomics, 1974, 17, 177–183.
5.
BradshawJ. L.Load and pupillary changes in continuous processing tasks. British Journal of Psychology, 1968, 59, 265–271.
6.
BrictsonC. A.Pilot landing performance under high workload conditions. Proceedings of the AGARD conference on simulation and study of high workload operations, AGARD-CP-146, April, 1974, A7-1–A7-10. (a).
7.
BrictsonC. A.Pilot landing performance under high workload conditions. La Jolla, California: Dunlap and Associates, Contract N00014-73-C-0053. April, 1974. (AD/A 001 802). (b).
8.
BurkeJ. E.In flight acquisition of task sequences and task times. Paper presented at the meeting of the Aerospace Medical Association, Las Vegas, Nevada, May, 1977.
9.
CanningsR.BorlandR. G.HillL. E.NicholsonA. N.Pitch and formant analysis of the voice in the investigation of pilot workload. Proceedings of the AGARD conference on methods to assess workload, AGARD-CPP-216, April, 1977, A5-1–A5-10.
10.
ChainovaL. D.KomarovaI. A.ZonabendF. I.Complex psychophysiological evaluation of the readability of symbolic information (Kompleksnaya Psikhofiziologicheskaya Ot senka Chitaemosti Znakovoy Informatsii). Voprosy Psikhologii, 1970, 16, 163–168. (Royal Aircraft Establishment Library Translation 1777).
11.
ClementW. F.Investigating the use of a moving map display and a horizontal situation indicator in simulated powered-lift short-haul operations. Proceedings of the 12th annual NASA-university conference on manual control, University of Illinois, May, 1976, 201–224. (NASA-TMX-73 70).
12.
CohenS. I.SilvermanA. J.Measurement of pilot mental effort. Paris, France: North Atlantic Treaty Organization, Advisory Group for Aeronautical Research and Development, Report 148, May, 1957.
13.
CorkindaleM. G. G.A flight simulator study of missile control performance as a function of concurrent workload. Proceedings of the AGARD conference on simulation and study of high workload operations, AGARD-CP-146, April, 1974, A5-1–A5-6.
14.
DahmA. E.Study of the field use of the psychological stress evaluator. Springfield, Virginia: Dektor Counterintelligence and Security, Unpublished manuscript, 1974.
15.
DefayolleM.DinandJ. P.GentilM. T.Averaged evoked potentials in relation to attitude, mental load, and intelligence. In SingletonW. T.FoxJ. G.WhitfieldD. (Eds.) Measurement of man at work. London: Taylor and Francis, 1973, 81–91.
16.
DickA. O.BaileyG.A comparison between oculometer data and pilot opinion on the usefulness of instruments during landing. Rochester, New York: University of Rochester, Center for Visual Science, Technical Report No. 3–76, 1976.
17.
DickA. O.BrownJ. L.BaileyG.Statistical evaluation of control inputs and eye movements in the use of instrument clusters during aircraft landing. Rochester, New York: University of Rochester, Center for Visual Science, Technical Report 4–76, 1976.
18.
DonchinE.Brain activity as an index of mental workload in man-machine systems. Proceedings of the symposium on man-system interface: Advances in workload study, Washington, D.C.: Airline Pilots Association, July 31-August 1, 1978, 35–46.
19.
EdsonR. K.The Dektor psychological stress evaluator (voice stress analyzer) as a research instrument. Unpublished master's thesis, National Graduate University, April, 1976.
20.
EttemaJ. H.Blood pressure changes during mental load experiments in man. Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 1969, 17, 191–195.
GardnerR. M.BeltramoJ. S.KrinskyR.Pupillary changes during encoding, storage, and retrieval of information. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 1975, 41, 951–955.
23.
GaumeJ. G.WhiteR. T.Mental workload assessment, II. Physiological correlates of mental workload: Report of three preliminary laboratory tests. St. Louis, Missouri: McDonnell Douglas Corporation, Report MDC J7023/01, December, 1975.
24.
GopherD.Eye movement patterns in selective listening tasks of focused attention. Perception and Psychophysics, 1973, 14, 259–264.
25.
GuttmannH. E.EasterlingR. G.WebsterR. G.The effects of flicker on performance as a function of task-loading. Albuquerque, New Mexico: Sandia Laboratories, SC-TM-72 0617, November, 1972.
26.
HaleH. B.AndersonC. A.WilliamsE. W.TanneE.Endocrine-metabolic effects of unusually long or frequent flying missions in C-130E or C-135B aircraft. Aerospace Medicine, 1968, 39, 561–570.
27.
HaleH. B.HartmanB. O.HarrisD. A.WilliamsE. W.MirandaR. E.HosenfeldJ. M.Time zone entrainment and flight stressors as interactants. Aerospace Medicine, 1972, 43, 1089–1094.
28.
HaleH. B.HartmanB. O.HarrisD. A.WilliamsE. W.MirandaR. E.HosenfeldJ. M.SmithB. N.Physiologic stress during 50-hour double-crew missions in C-141 aircraft. Brooks AFB, Texas: USAF School of Aerospace Medicine, SAM-TR-71-487, October, 1971.
29.
HaleH. B.McNeeR. C.EllisJ. P.Jr.BollingerR. R.HartmanB. O.Endocrine-metabolic indices of aircrew workload: An analysis across studies. Proceedings of the AGARD conference on simulation and study of high workload operations, AGARD-CP-146, April, 1974, A10-1–A10-6.
30.
HarrisD. A.PegramG. V.HartmanB. O.Performance and fatigue in experimental double-crew transport missions. Aerospace Medicine, 1971, 42, 980–986.
31.
HarrisS. D.NorthR. A.OwensJ. M.A system for the assessment of human performance in concurrent verbal and manual control tasks. Paper presented at the 7th annual meeting of the national conference on the use of on-line computers in psychology, Washington, D.C., November 9, 1977.
HelanderM. G.Physiological reactions of drivers as indicators of road traffic demand. In Driver performance studies. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Transportation Research Board, Technical Report TRB/TRR-530, 1975, 1–17.
34.
HickokJ. H.Grip pressure as a measure of task difficulty in compensatory tracking tasks. Master's thesis, Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, California, September, 1973.
35.
HicksT. G.WierwilleW. W., Comparison of five mental workload assessment procedures in a moving-base driving simulator. Human Factors, 1979, 21, 129–143.
36.
HollandM. K.TarlowG.Blinking and mental load. Psychological Reports, 1972, 31, 119–127.
37.
JenneyL. L.OlderH. J.CameronB. J.Measurement of operator workload in an information processing task. Washington, D.C.: National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Contractor's Report NASA CR-2150, December, 1972.
38.
JexH. R.AllenR. W.Research on a new human dynamic response test battery. Part II. Psychophysiological correlates. Proceedings of the 6th annual NASA-university conference on manual control, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, April, 1970.
39.
KahnemanD.BeattyJ.PollackI.Perceptual deficit during a mental task. Science, 1967, 157, 218–219.
40.
KalsbeekJ. W. H.Sinus arrhythmia and the dual task method in measuring mental load. In SingletonW. T.FoxJ. G.WhitfieldD. (Eds.) Measurement of man at work. London: Taylor and Francis, 1973, 101–113. (a).
41.
KalsbeekJ. W. H.Do you believe in sinus arrhythmia?Ergonomics, 1973, 16, 99–104. (b).
42.
KradzM. P.The psychological stress evaluator. Ellicott City, Maryland: Howard County Police Department, Unpublished manuscript, 1974.
43.
KrebsM. J.WingertJ. W.Use of the oculometer in pilot workload measurement. Washington, D.C.: National Aeronautics and Space Administration, NASA CR-144951, February, 1976.
44.
KrebsM. J.WingertJ. W.CunninghamT.Exploration of an oculometer-based model of pilot workload. Washington, D.C.: National Aeronautics and Space Administration, NASA CR-145153, March, 1977.
45.
LinnV. C.Jr.The parotid fluid technique for the evaluation of mental stress in a production situation. Texarkana, Texas: US Army Logistics Management Center, USAMC Intern Training Center, USAMC-ITC Report No. 2-72-05, July, 1972.
46.
LuczakH.LaurigW.An analysis of heart rate variability. Ergonomics, 1973, 16, 85–97.
47.
McFeelyT. E.Pupil diameter and the cross-adaptive critical tracking task; A method of workload measurement. Master's thesis, Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, California, June, 1972. (AD 749 075).
48.
McHughW. B.BrictsonC. A.NaitohP.Emotional and biochemical effects of high work-load. Proceedings of the AGARD conference on simulation and study of high workload operations, AGARD-CP-146, April, 1974, A12-1–A12-9.
49.
MobbsR. F.DavidG. C.ThomasJ. M.An evaluation of the use of heart rate irregularity as a measure of mental workload in the steel industry. London, England: British Steel Corporation, BISRA, OR/HF/25/71, August, 1971.
50.
MulderG.Sinus arrhythmia and mental workload. In MorayN. (Ed.) Mental workload, its theory and measurement. New York, Plenum Press, 1979, 327–343.
51.
MulderG.van der MeulenMulder-Hajonides W. R. E. H.Mental load and the measurement of heart rate variability. Ergonomics, 1973, 16, 69–83.
OlderH. J.JenneyL. L.Psychological stress measurement through voice output analysis. Alexandria, Virginia: The Planar Corporation, Contract NAS 9-14146, March, 1975.
54.
PettyjohnF. S.McNeilR. J.AkersL. A.FaberJ. M.Use of inspiratory minute volumes in evaluation of rotary and fixed-wing pilot workload. Fort Rucker, Alabama: US Army Aeromedical Research Laboratory, USAARL Report No. 77–9, April, 1977.
55.
SayersB. M.Analysis of heart rate variability. Ergonomics, 1973, 16, 17–32.
56.
ShannonI. L.KatzF. H.Identification and significance of parotid fluid corticosteroids. Brooks AFB, Texas: School of Aerospace Medicine, SAM-TDR-63-86, October, 1963.
57.
ShermanM. R.The relationship of eye behavior, cardiac activity and electromyographic responses to subjective reports of mental fatigue and performance on a doppler identification task. Master's thesis, Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, California, September, 1973. (AD 769 754).
58.
SimmonsR. R.KimballK. A.Methodological considerations of visual workloads of helicopter pilots. Proceedings of the AGARD conference on methods to assess workload, AGARD-CPP-216, April, 1977, A2–1.
59.
SimmonsR. R.KimballK. A.DiazJ. J.Measurement of aviator visual performance and workload during helicopter operations. Ft. Rucker, Alabama: U.S. Army Aeromedical Research Laboratory, Technical Report 77–4, December, 1976.
60.
SimonovP. V.FrolovM. V.Analysis of the human voice as a method of controlling emotional state: Achievements and goals. Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine, 1977, 48, 23–25.
61.
SmithW. S.Jr.Effects of neuromuscular tension in the use of an isometric hand controller. Monterey, California: U.S. Naval Postgraduate School, Master's thesis, December, 1972.
62.
SpicuzzaR. J.PinkusA. R.O'DonnellR. D.Development of performance assessment methodology for the digital avionics information system. Dayton, Ohio: Systems Research Laboratories, Final Report, 1 December 1973–30 June 1974, August, 1974.
63.
SpykerD. A.StackhouseS. P.KhalafallaA. S.McLaneR. C.Development of techniques for measuring pilot workload. Washington, D.C.: National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Contractors' Report NASA CR-1888, November, 1971.
StackhouseS. P.The measurement of pilot workload in manual control system. Minneapolis, Minnesota: Honeywell, Inc., F0398 FRI, January, 1976.
66.
StackhouseS. P.Measurement of aircrew information processing workload. Minneapolis, Minnesota: Honeywell, Unpublished manuscript, 1978.
67.
StormW. F.HartmanB. O.IntanoG. P.PetersG. L.Endocrine-metabolic effects in short-duration high-workload missions: Feasibility study. Brooks AFB, Texas: USAF School of Aerospace Medicine, SAM-TR-76-30, August, 1976.
68.
StreetR. L.SinghH.HaleP. N.Jr.The evaluation of mental stress through the analysis of parotid fluid. Human Factors, 1970, 12, 453–455.
69.
StrotherD. D.Aircrew performance in army aviation. Proceedings of conference 27–29, November 1973, U.S. Army Aviation Center, Fort Rucker, Alabama, November, 1973, 188–192.
70.
SunP. B.KeaneW. P.StackhouseS. P.The measurement of pilot workload in manual control systems. Proceedings of aviation electronics symposium. Fort Monmouth, New Jersey, April, 1976.
71.
UrsinH.UrsinR.Physiological indicators of mental load. In MorayN. (Ed.) Mental workload, its theory and measurement. New York, Plenum Press, 1979, 349–365.
72.
WallerM. C.An investigation of correlation between pilot scanning behavior and workload using stepwise regression analysis. Hampton, Virginia: NASA Langley Research Center, NASA TM X-3344, March, 1976.
73.
WeirD. H.KleinR. H.Measurement and analysis of pilot scanning behavior during simulated instrument approaches. Proceedings of the 6th annual NASA-university conference on manual control, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, April, 1970, 83–108.
74.
WestbrookC. B.AndersonR. O.PietrzakP. E.Handling qualities and pilot workload. Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio: AF Flight Dynamics Laboratory, AFFDL-FDCC-TM-66-5, September, 1966.
75.
WhiteR. T.GaumeJ. G.Mental workload assessment, III. Laboratory evaluation of one subjective and two physiological measures of mental workload. St. Louis, Missouri: McDonnell Douglas Corporation, Report MDC J7024/01, December, 1975.
76.
WickensC. D.IsrealJ.DonchinE.The event related cortical potential as an index of task workload. Proceedings of the 21st annual meeting of the Human Factors Society, San Francisco, California, 1977.
77.
WickensC. D.IsrealJ.McCarthyG.GopherD.DonchinE.The use of event-related potentials in the enhancement of system performance. Proceedings of the 12th annual NASA-university conference on manual control, University of Illinois, May, 1976, 124–134. (NASA TM X-73, 70).
78.
WilligesR. C.WierwilleW. W.Behavioral measures of aircrew mental workload. Human Factors, 1979, 21, 549–574.
79.
WisnerA.Electrophysiological measures for tasks of low energy expenditure. In SingletonW. T.FoxJ. G.WhitfieldD. (Eds.) Measurement of man at work. London: Taylor and Francis, 1973, 61–73.
80.
YoungL. R.SheenaD. A.Survey of eye movement recording methods. Behavior Research Methods and Instrumentation, 1975, 1, 397–429.
81.
ZwagaH. J. G.Psychophysiological reactions to mental tasks: Effort or stress?Ergonomics, 1973, 16, 61–67.
