Synthetic Flight Training Revisited

Abstract

Critical issues in the development and use of synthetic flight trainers are reviewed. Degree of simulation and fidelity of simulation are discussed as key design considerations. Problems in measurement of original learning, transfer, and retention are presented. Both transfer effectiveness and cost effectiveness are described as critical factors in the evaluation of flight trainers. Recent training innovations, such as automatically adaptive training, computer-assisted instruction, cross-adaptive measurement of residual attention, computer graphics, incremental transfer effectiveness measurement, and response surface methodology, are discussed as potential techniques for improving synthetic flight training. It is concluded that broader application of simulation is necessary to meet the new demands of pilot training, certification, and currency assurance in air transportation.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams

J. A.

Hufford

L. E

. Effects of programmed perceptual training on the learning of contact landing skills. (Tech. Rep. NAVTRADEVCEN 297-3) Port Washington, N. Y.: Office of Naval Research, Naval Training Device Center, April, 1961. (AD 264 377).

Adams

J. A.

Hufford

L. E.

Dunlop

J. M

. Partversus whole-task learning of a flight maneuver. (Tech. Rep. NAVTRADEVCEN 297-1) Port Washington, N. Y.: Office of Naval Research, Naval Training Device Center, June, 1960. (AD 242 580).

American Airlines, Inc. Optimized flight crew training: A step toward safer operations. Fort Worth, Tex.: American Airlines, Flight Training Academy, April, 1969.

Besco

R. V

. The effects of cockpit vertical accelerations on a simple piloted tracing task. (Rep. No. N.A. 61-47) Los Angeles: North American Aviation, April, 1961.

Bitzer

D. L.

Johnson

R. L.

PLATO: A computer-based system used in the engineering of education. Proceedings of the IEEE, 1971, 59, 960–968.

Blaiwes

A. S.

Regan

J. J

. An integrated approach to the study of learning, retention, and transfer—A key issue in training device research and development. (Final Rep. NAVTRADEVCEN-IH-178) Orlando, Fla.: Office of Naval Research, Naval Training Device Center, 1970.

Box

G. E. P.

Hunter

J. S

. Multifactor experimental designs for exploring response surfaces. Annals of Mathematical Statistics, 1957, 28, 195–241.

Box

G. E. P.

Wilson

K. B

. On the experimental attainment of optimum conditions. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series B (Methodological), 1951, 13, 1–45.

Briggs

G. E.

Wiener

E. L

. Fidelity of simulation: I. Time sharing requirements and control loading as factors in transfer of training. (Tech. Rep. NAVTRADEVCEN-TR-508-4) Port Washington, N. Y.: Office of Naval Research, Naval Training Device Center, 1959.

10.

Buckhout

Sherman

Goldsmith

C. T.

Vitale

D. A

. The effect of variations in motion fidelity during training on simulated low altitude flight. (Tech. Rep. AMRL-TR-63-108) Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio: Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory, December, 1963.

11.

Caro

P. W.

Jr.

Adaptive training—An application to flight simulation. Human Factors, 1969, 11, 569–576.

12.

Caro

P. W.

Jr. Isley

R. N

. Changes in flight trainee performance following synthetic helicopter flight training. (Professional Paper 1-66) Alexandria, Va.: Human Resources Research Office, April, 1966.

13.

Clark

Williges

R. C

. Response surface methodology central-composite design modifications for human performance research. Human Factors, 1973, 15, 295–310.

14.

Cochran

W. G.

Cox

G. M

. Some methods for the study of response surfaces. Experimental designs. New York: Wiley, 1957, 335–375.

15.

Cohen

. Is motion needed in flight simulators used for training? Human Factors, 1970, 12, 75–79.

16.

Conlon

E. W

. Preliminary report on contact flight instruction on a Link trainer. Washington, D. C.: National Research Council, Committee on Aviation Psychology, May, 1939.

17.

Crannell

C. W.

Greene

E. B.

Chamberlain

H. F

. The experimental study of the use of the Link trainer in visual contact flight instruction. Washington, D. C.: National Research Council, Committee on Aviation Psychology, 1941.

18.

Creelman

J. A

. Evaluation of approach training procedures. (Rep. 2, Proj. NM 001-109-107) Pensacola, Fla.: U. S. Naval School of Aviation Medicine, 1955.

19.

Crooks

W. H.

Roscoe

S. N

. Varied and fixed error limits in automated adaptive skill training. In: Ranc

M. P.

Jr. Malone

T. B.

(Eds.) Proceedings of the seventeenth annual meeting of the Human Factors Society. Santa Monica, Calif.: Human Factors Society, October 1973, 272–280.

20.

Damos

D. L.

Cross-adaptive measurement of residual attention in pilots. Unpublished master's thesis, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1972.

21.

Danneskiold

R. D

. Objective scoring procedure for operational flight trainer performance. (Tech. Rep. SPECDEVCEN-TR-999-2-4) Port Washington, N. Y.: Office of Naval Research, Special Devices Center, February, 1955. (AD 110 925).

22.

Dougherty

D. J.

Houston

R. C.

Nicklas

D. R

. Transfer of training in flight procedures from selected ground training devices to the aircraft. (Tech. Rep. NAVTRADEVCEN-TR-71-16-16) Port Washington, N. Y.: Office of Naval Research, Naval Training Device Center, September, 1957. (AD 149 547).

23.

Ekstrom

. Analysis of pilot work loads in flight control systems with different degrees of automation. Paper presented at the Institute of Radio Engineers, International Congress on Human Factors in Electronics, Long Beach, Calif., May, 1962.

24.

Ericksen

S. C

. A review of the literature on methods of measuring pilot proficiency. (Res. Bull. 52-25) Lackland Air Force Base, Tex.: Human Resources Research Center, 1952.

25.

Feddersen

W. E

. The effect of simulator motion upon system and operator performance. Paper presented at Seventh Annual Army Human Factors Engineering Conference, Ann Arbor, Michigan, October, 1961.

26.

Flexman

R. E

. Man in motion. The Connecting Link, 1966, 3, 12–18.

27.

Flexman

R. E.

Matheny

W. G.

Brown

E. L

. Evaluation of the School Link and special methods of instruction in a ten-hour private pilot flight-training program. University of Illinois Bulletin, 1950, 47 (80) (Aeronautics Bulletin 8).

28.

Flexman

R. E.

Roscoe

S. N.

Williams

A. C.

Jr. Williges

B. H

. Studies in pilot training: The anatomy of transfer. Aviation Research Monographs, 1972, 2(1).

29.

Flexman

R. E.

Townsend

J. C.

Ornstein

G. N

. Evaluation of a contact flight simulator when used in an Air Force primary pilot training program: Part I. Over-all effectiveness. (Tech. Rep. AFPTRC-TR-54-38) Lackland Air Force Base, Tex.: Air Force Personnel and Training Research Center, September, 1954. (AD 53730).

30.

Gabriel

R. F.

Burrows

A. A.

Abbott

P. E

. Using a generalized contact flight simulator to improve visual time-sharing. (Tech. Rep. NAVTRADEVCEN-TR-1428-1) Port Washington, N. Y.: Office of Naval Research, Naval Training Device Center, April, 1965. (AD 619 047).

31.

Gagne Simulators

R. M.

. In Glaser

(Ed.) Training research and education. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, 1962, 223–246.

32.

Gordon

T. A

. The airline pilot: A survey of the critical requirements of his job and of pilot evaluation and selection procedures. (Rep. No. 73) Washington, D. C.: Civil Aeronautics Administration, Division of Research, 1947.

33.

Gordon

T. A

. The development of a standard flight-check for the airline transport rating based on the critical requirements of the airline pilot's job. (Report 85) Washington, D. C.: Civil Aeronautics Administration, Division of Research, 1949.

34.

Greene

E. B.

The Link trainer in visual contact flying. Washington, D. C.: National Research Council, Committee on Aviation Psychology, 1941.

35.

Guercio

J. G.

Wall

R. L

. Congruent and spurious motion in the learning and performance of a compensatory tracking task. Human Factors, 1972, 14, 259–269.

36.

Gum

D. R.

Knoop

P. A.

Basinger

J. D.

Guterman

I. M.

Foley

W. L

. Development of an advanced training research simulation system. In: Tebbs

E. B.

(Ed.) Third annual symposium: Proceedings of psychology in the Air Force. Colorado Springs, Colo.: USAF Academy, Department of Life and Behavioral Sciences, April, 1972.

37.

Hudson

E. M

. Adaptive training and nonverbal behavior. (Tech. Rep. NAVTRADEVCENTR-1395-1) Port Washington, N. Y.: Office of Naval Research, Naval Training Device Center, July, 1964.

38.

Hufford

L. E.

Adams

J. A

. The contribution of part-task training to the relearning of a flight maneuver. (Tech. Rep. NAVTRADEVCENTR-297-2) Port Washington, N. Y.: Office of Naval Research, Naval Training Device Center, March, 1961. (AD 259 505).

39.

Jacobs

R. S.

Williges

R. C.

Roscoe

S. N

. Simulator motion as a factor in flight director display evaluation. Human Factors, 1973, 15, 569–582.

40.

Johnson

B. E.

Williams

A. C.

Jr.

Obedience to rotation-indicating visual displays as a function of confidence in the displays. Aviation Research Monographs, 1971, 1(3): 11–25.

41.

Kelley

C. R.

Self-adjusting vehicle simulators. In: Kelley

C. R.

(Ed.) Adaptive simulation. Arlington, Va.: Office of Naval Research, August, 1966. (AD 637 658).

42.

Knowles

W. B

. Operator loading tasks. Human Factors, 1963, 5, 155–161.

43.

Kraus

E. F.

Roscoe

S. N

. Reorganization of airplane manual flight control dynamics. In: Knowles

W. B.

Sanders

M. S.

(Eds.) Proceedings of the 16th annual meeting of the Human Factors Society. Los Angeles: Human Factors Society, October, 1972. [Also Tech. Rep. ARL-72-22/AF0SR-72-11. Savoy, Ill: University of Illinois at Urbaná-Champaign, Institute of Aviation, Aviation Research Laboratory, September, 1972.].

44.

Mahler

W. R.

Bennett

G. K

. Psychological studies of advanced Naval air training: Evaluation of operational flight trainers. (Tech. Rep. SPECDEVCEN-TR-999-1-1) Port Washington, N. Y.: Office of Naval Research, Special Devices Center, September, 1950. (AD 643 499).

45.

Matheny

W. G.

Dougherty

D. J.

Willis

J. M

. Relative motion of elements in instrument displays. Aerospace Medicine, 1963, 34, 1041–1046.

46.

McGrath

J. J.

Harris

D. H

. Adaptive training. Aviation Research Monographs, 1971, 1.

47.

Mengelkoch

R. F.

Adams

J. A.

Gainer

C. A

. The forgetting of instrument flying skills as a function of the level of initial proficiency. (Tech. Rep. NAVTRADEVCEN-71-16-18) Port Washington, N. Y.: Office of Naval Research, Naval Training Device Center, 1958.

48.

Meyer

D. L

. Response surface methodology in education and psychology. The Journal of Experimental Education, 1963, 31, 329–336.

49.

Michon

J. A

. Tapping regularity as a measure of perceptual motor load. Ergonomics, 1966, 9, 401–412.

50.

Miller

R. B

. Task and part-task trainers and training. (Tech. Rep. WADD-TR-60-469) Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio: Wright Air Development Division, Behavioral Sciences Laboratory, 1960.

51.

Muckler

F. A.

Nygaard

J. E.

O'Kelly

L. I.

Williams

A. C.

Jr.

Psychological variables in the design of flight simulators for training. (WADC Tech. Rep. 56-369) Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio: Wright Air Development Center, January, 1959. (AD 97130).

52.

Nygaard

J. E.

Roscoe

S. N

. Manual steering display studies: I. Display-control relationships and the configuration of the steering symbol. (Tech. Mem. 334) Culver City, Calif.: Hughes Aircraft Company, October, 1953.

53.

Ogden

The Evans and Sutherland LDS-1 display system. Proceedings of the Society for Information Display, 1970, 11, 52–60.

54.

Ornstein

G. N.

Nichols

I. A.

Flexman

R. E.

Evaluation of a contact flight simulator when used in an Air Force primary pilot training program. Part II. Effectiveness of training on component skills. (Tech. Rep. AFPTRC-TR-54-110) Lackland Air Force Base, Tex.: Air Force Personnel and Training Research Center, December, 1954. (AD 62373).

55.

Parker

J. F.

Jr. Downs

J. E

. Selection of training media. (Tech. Rep. ASD-TR-61-473) Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio: Aeronautical Systems Division, Aerospace Medical Laboratory, September, 1961. (AD 271 483).

56.

Payne

T. A.

Dougherty

D. J.

Hasler

S. G.

Skeen

J. R.

Brown

E. L.

Williams

A. C.

Jr.

Improving landing performance using a contact landing trainer. (Tech. Rep. SPECDEVCEN 71-16-11) Port Washington, N. Y.: Office of Naval Research, Special Devices Center, March, 1954. (AD 121 200).

57.

Pfeiffer

M. G.

Clark

W. C.

Danaher

J. W

. The pilot's visual task: A study of visual display requirements. (Tech. Rep. NAVTRADEVCENTR-783-1) Port Washington, N. Y.: Office of Naval Research, Naval Training Device Center, March, 1963. (AD 407 440).

58.

Pomarolli

R. S

. The effectiveness of the Naval air basic instrument trainer. (Special Rep. 65-7) Pensacola, Fla.: Naval Aviation Medical Center, November, 1965. (AD 627 218).

59.

Povenmire

H. K.

Alvares

K. M.

Damos

D. L.

Observer-observer flight check reliability. (Tech. Rep. LF-70-2) Savoy, Ill.: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Institute of Aviation, Aviation Research Laboratory, October, 1970.

60.

Povenmire

H. K.

Roscoe

S. N.

An evaluation of ground-based flight trainers in routine primary flight training. Human Factors, 1971, 13, 109–116.

61.

Povenmire

H. K.

Roscoe

S. N

. The incremental transfer effectiveness of a ground-based general aviation trainer. Human Factors, 1973, 15, 534–542.

62.

Prophet

W. W

. The importance of training requirements information in the design and use of aviation training devices. (Professional Paper 8-66) Alexandria, Va.: Human Resources Research Center, December, 1966.

63.

Rathert

G. A.

Jr. Creer

B. Y.

Douvillier

J. G.

Jr.

Use of flight simulators for pilot control problems. (NASA Memorandum 3-6-59A) Washington, D. C.: National Aeronautics and Space Administration, February, 1959. (AD 210 526).

64.

Rathert

G. A.

Jr. Creer

B. Y.

Sadoff

. The use of piloted flight simulators in general research. (AGARD Rep. 365) Paris, France: Advisory Group for Aeronautical Research and Development, North Atlantic Treaty Organization, April, 1961. (AD 404 196).

65.

Roscoe

S. N

. Incremental transfer effectiveness. Human Factors, 1971, 13, 561–567.

66.

Roscoe

S. N

. A little more on incremental transfer effectiveness. Human Factors, 1972, 14, 363–364.

67.

Roscoe

S. N.

Denney

D. C.

Johnson

S. L

. The frequency-separated display principle: Phase III. (Annual Summary Rep. ARL-71-15/ONR-71-1) Savoy, Ill.: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Institute of Aviation, Aviation Research Laboratory, December, 1971. (AD 735 915).

68.

Ruocco

J. N.

Vitale

P. A.

Benfari

R. C

. Kinetic cueing in simulated carrier approaches. (Tech. Rep. NAVTRADEVCEN-TR-1432-1) Port Washington, N. Y.: Office of Naval Research, Naval Training Device Center, April, 1965. (AD 617 689) (a).

69.

Ruocco

J. N.

Vitale

P. A.

Benfari

R. C

. Kinetic cueing in simulated carrier approaches. Supplement I. Study details. (Tech. Rept. NAVTRADEVCENTR-1432-1-S1) Port Washington, N. Y.: Office of Naval Research, Naval Training Device Center, April, 1965. (AD 618 756) (b).

70.

Seltzer

L. Z

. A study of the effect of time on the instrument skill of the private and commercial pilot. (Tech. Rep. FAA-DS-70-12) Washington, D. C.: Federal Aviation Administration, April, 1970.

71.

Selzer

Hulin

C. L.

Alvares

K. M.

Swartzendruber

L. E.

Roscoe

S. N

. Predictive validity of ground-based flight checks. In: Knowles

W. B.

Sanders

M. S.

Muckler

F. A.

(Eds.) Proceedings of the Sixteenth annual meeting of the Human Factors Society. Santa Monica, Calif.: Human Factors Society, October 1972, 318.

72.

Smith

J. F

. Applications of the advanced simulation in undergraduate pilot training (ASUPT) research facility to pilot training programs. In: Tebbs

E. B.

(Ed.) Third annual symposium: Proceedings of psychology in the Air Force. Colorado Springs, Colo.: USAF Academy, Department of Life and Behavioral Sciences, April, 1972.

73.

Smith

J. F.

Flexman

R. E.

Houston

R. C

. Development of an objective method of recording flight performance. (Tech. Rep. 52-15) Lackland Air Force Base, Tex.: Human Resources Research Office, December, 1952.

74.

Smode

A. F.

Hall

E. R.

Meyer

D. E

. An assessment of research relevant to pilot training. (Tech. Rep. AMRL-TR-66-196) Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio: Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory, November, 1966. (AD 804 600).

75.

Townsend

J. C

. Evaluation of the Link ME-1 basic instrument flight trainer. (Tech. Rep. AFPTRC-TR-56-84) Lackland Air Force Base, Tex.: Air Force Personnel and Training Research Center, June, 1956. (AD 113 519).

76.

Trans World Airlines. Flight simulator evaluation. Kansas City, Mo.: Trans World Airlines, Flight Operations Training Department, June, 1969.

77.

Valverde

H. H

. Flight simulators: A review of the research and development. (Tech. Rep. AMRL-TR-68-97) Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio: Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory, July, 1968. (AD 855 582).

78.

Wilcoxon

H. C.

Davy

Webster

J. C

. Evaluation of the SNJ operational flight trainer. (Tech. Rep. SPECDEVCEN-TR-999-2-1) Port Washington, N. Y.: Office of Naval Research, Special Devices Center, March, 1954. (AD 86988).

79.

Williams

A. C.

Jr. Adelson

. Some considerations in deciding about the complexity of flight simulators. (Tech. Rep. AFPTRC-TR-54-106) Lackland Air Force Base, Tex.: Air Force Personnel and Training Research Center, December, 1954. (AD 62986).

80.

Williams

A. C.

Jr. Flexman

R. E

. Evaluation of the School Link as an aid in primary flight instruction. University of Illinois Bulletin, 1949, 46 (71) (Aeronautics Bulletin 5).

81.

Williges

R. C.

Baron

M. L

. Transfer assessment using a between-subjects central-composite design. Human Factors, 1973, 15, 311–319.

82.

Williges

R. C.

Simon

C. W

. Applying response surface methodology to problems of target acquisition. Human Factors, 1971, 13, 511–519.