Significant milestones in the development of maintainability assessment techniques are summarized. Maintainability models are critically reviewed in terms of general utility, ease of application, validity, and use of human engineering data. The capability of each model to be employed during various points in the system development cycle is evaluated with special consideration given to availability of model input data. Examples of potential model approaches are included. Survey results show continuing progress toward the potential development of efficient maintainability modeling techniques. However, increased effort is required to ensure the development of effective systems and to reduce maintenance costs. Emphasis is given to requirements for additional effort in (1) maintainability modeling early in the design process, (2) model validation, and (3) development of timely, valid input data.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AndersonV.Training, utilization and proficiency of Navy electronics technicians: III. Proficiency in the use of test equipment. Navy Technical Bulletin 62-14, U.S. Navy Personnel Research Activity, San Diego, California, 1962.
2.
AtchleyW. R.Ver HulstJ.LehrD. J.Specification of optimum fault isolation presentation. Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory TR TDR-64-57, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, June 1964.
3.
BalabanH. S.Maintainability prediction by unit function. RADC Technical Report RADC-TR-65-467, Griffiss AFB, New York, December 1965.
4.
BalabanH. S.CostelloD. L.System effectiveness: concepts and analytical techniques. ARINC Publication 267-01-7-419, Washington, D.C., January 1964.
5.
BellmanR.Dynamic programming.Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1957.
6.
BerkshireJ. R.Field evaluation of a troubleshooting aide. USAF Personnel and Training Research Center Report AFP TRC-TR-J4-2r, Lackland AFB, Texas, June 1954.
7.
BrindleyH. S.Role of design engineer in maintenance and reliability. Paper presented at FAA Fourth Annual Maintenance Symposium, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, December 1968.
8.
ChapanisA.The relevance of laboratory studies to practical situations. Ergonomics, 1967, 10, 557–577.
CoxC. D.Maintainability engineering guide. U. S. Army Missile Command Report RC-5-64-1, Redstone Arsenal, Alabama, May 1964.
11.
CrawfordB. M.Human engineering research and maintainability applications. Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory Report AMRL-TR-69-86, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, 1969.
12.
DrummondA.HarrisonG. T.LeubaH.Maintainability prediction: Theoretical basis and practical approach. ARINC Publication 207-1-275, Washington, D.C., February 1962.
13.
Electronics Industries Association.Data collection, analysis, corrective action. Proceedings of the Maintainability (M) Workshop, Anaheim, California, May 1968.
14.
Federal Electric Corporation.A maintainability study on shipboard electronic equipment. Paramus, New Jersey, July 1960(a).
15.
Federal Electric Corporation.A maintainability prediction procedure for designers of electronic equipment and systems. Paramus, New Jersey, July 1960(b).
16.
Federal Electric Corporation.A study on the bureau of ships maintainability index prediction procedure. Vol. I: Applicability and specification. Paramus, New Jersey, July 1962(a).
17.
Federal Electric Corporation.A study on the bureau of ships maintainability index prediction procedure. Vol. II: Supplementary prediction procedures. Paramus, New Jersey, July 1962(b).
18.
FinucaneJ. L.Measuring troubleshooting skills of maintenance personnel by paper and pencil tests. Paper presented at Eighth Annual Military Testing Association Conference, Waukegan, Illinois, September 1966.
19.
FirstmanS. I.GlussB.Search rules for automatic fault location. RAND Corporation Report RM 2514, Santa Monica, California, January 1960.
20.
FolleyJ. D.AltmanJ. W.Guide to design of electronic equipment for maintainability. WADC Technical Report 56-218, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, April 1956.
21.
FolleyJ. D.Jr.Factors to consider in developing new systems effectiveness measures. Paper presented at FAA Fourth Annual Maintenance Symposium, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, December 1968.
22.
FolleyJ. D.Jr.ElliottT. K.A field survey of electronic maintenance technical data problems. Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory Report AMRL-TR-67-159, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, 1967.
23.
FolleyJ. D.Jr.WoodsR. H.TrudoF. J.The design and application of a method for specifying an electronics maintenance entry course. Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory Report, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, 1968.
24.
FranksP. E.FurnishC. W.Automated maintenance: Theory, practice and implications for training. WADD Technical Report 60-412, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, August 1960.
25.
General Dynamics Corporation.Designer's checklist for improving maintainability. Aeronautical Systems Division Report ASD-TDR-62-45, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, February 1962.
26.
GriswoldG. H.Partitioning microelectronic equipment through the use of a symptom matrix: Final report. Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory Report, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, December 1967.
27.
HanifanD. T.SklarL. B.A generalized maintainability method. I. Rationale and procedure. Dunlap and Associates, Inc., Santa Monica, California, June 1968.
28.
HarkinsJ. A.The real world of system effectiveness. Annals of Assurance Sciences, 1969, Proceedings of Reliability and Maintainability Conference.New York: Gordon and Breach Science Publishers, 1969.
29.
HarrisonG.LeubaH.SchneiderE.Maintainability prediction: Theoretical basis and practical approach (revised). ARINC Publication 267-02-6-420, Washington, D.C., December 1963.
30.
HoehnA. J.WardellW. C.Development of an experimental troubleshooting guide for the F-86 electronic fuel control system. USAF Personnel and Training Center Report AFP, TRC-ML-TM-57-25, Lowry AFB, Colorado, December 1957.
31.
HorowitzM. W.WellsC. F.Human factors in maintenance. Part I: An investigation of maintenance problems of a representative training device. U.S. Naval Training Device Center Report NAVTRADEVCEN 20-05-23-1, Port Washington, New York, January 1958.
32.
JohnsonR. A.An information theory to diagnosis. Proceedings of the Sixth National Symposium on Reliability and Quality Control, Washington, D.C., January 1960.
33.
KamaW. N.Volumetric workspace study. I. Optimum workspace configuration for using various screwdrivers. Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory Report AMRL-63-68(I), Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, August 1963.
34.
KennedyJ.WinstonJ.StrongR.Maintainability design criteria. Report of the Martin Company, Denver, Colorado, May 1961.
35.
LeubaH. R.Compensating for errors in reported time: Methodology and rationale. ARINC Publication 267-02-2-388, Washington, D.C., April 1964.
36.
LeubaH. R.Van TijnD. Special report on accuracy of AFM-66-1 reporting. ARINC Publication 206-3-315, Washington, D.C., July 1962.
37.
LewisS. H.Customer requirements for maintainability (M) characteristics in Air Force systems and equipment. Proceedings of ESP Maintainability Conference, L. G. Hanscom Field, Bedford, Massachusetts, March 1963.
38.
LoseeJ. E.BuongiornoJ. A.Maintainability and supportability evaluation technique. WADD Technical Note 60-82, Part I, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, March 1960.
39.
LoseeJ. E.BuongiornoJ. A.FrahmW. F.Maintainability and supportability evaluation technique. WADD Technical Note 60-82, Part II, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, May 1960.
40.
LoseeJ. E.BuongiornoJ. A.FrahmW. F.KreugerR.Maintainability and supportability evaluation technique. WADD Technical Note 60-82, Part III, Vol. 1, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, June 1960(a).
41.
LoseeJ. E.BuongiornoJ. A.FrahmW. F.KreugerR.Maintainability and supportability evaluation technique. WADD Technical Note 60-82, Part III, Vol. 2, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, June 1960(b).
42.
McAbeeW. H.HallT. J.Human engineering/maintainability interface on the C-5A. Paper presented at the FAA Fourth Annual Maintenance Symposium, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, December 1968.
43.
McCabeA. T.SchmidtE. J.TommaneyR. F.Maintainability prediction by function. RADC Report RADC-TR-68-398, Griffiss AFB, New York, January 1969.
44.
McClellandW. A.Psychological research in electronics maintenance training. Paper presented at the Director of Electrical and Mechanical Engineer's Study Period, Arborfield, England, November 1965.
45.
McKendryJ. M.CorsoJ. F.GrantG.ScheihingF. A.An experimental investigation of equipment packaging for ease of maintenance. U.S. Naval Training Device Center Report NAVTRADEVCEN 330-1-1, Port Washington, New York, April 1960.
46.
MartinW. L.CrawfordB. M.KamaW. N.HermanJ.Quick release fasteners for space applications. Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory Report AMRL-68-117, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, August 1968.
47.
MeisterD.A pragmatic approach to the prediction of operational performance. Paper presented at the Human Factors Society, Los Angeles Chapter Symposium on Man-Machine Effectiveness Analysis, University of California, Los Angeles, California, June 1967.
48.
MeisterD.SullivanD. J.Human factors: Engineering blind spot. Electro-Technology, August 1968.
49.
Military standardization handbook: Maintainability prediction. MIL-HDBK-472, Department of Defense, Washington, D.C., May 1966.
50.
MitchellM. B.SmithR. L.BlanchardR. E.Development and test of a technique for establishing personnel performance standards (TEPPS): Phase IV final report. Dunlap and Associates, Inc., Santa Monica, California, August 1967.
51.
MossD. R. G. E.Advanced concepts for power plant maintenance. Paper presented at the FAA Fourth Annual Maintenance Symposium, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, December 1968.
52.
MungerS. J.SmithR. W.PayneD.An index of electronic equipment operability: Data store. American Institute for Research Report AIR-C43-1/62-RP(1), Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, January 1962.
53.
MungerM. R.WillisM. P.Development of an index of electronic maintainability. American Institute for Research Report AIR-275-59-FR-207, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, 1959.
54.
MyersL. B.CarterR. G.HostellerR. S.Guidebook for the collection of human factors data. HRB-Singer, Inc. Report PTB-66-3, State College, Pennsylvania, January 1966.
55.
PayneD.AltmanJ. W.An index of electronic equipment operability: Report of development. American Institute for Research Report AIR-C-43-1/62-RP(1), Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, January 1962.
56.
RCA Service Company.A research plan for developing methods of maintainability measurement and prediction (Phase I report). RADC Report RADC-TN-60-5, Griffiss AFB, New York, January 1960(a).
57.
RCA Service Company.Maintainability measurement and prediction methods for Air Force ground electronic equipment (Phase II report). RADC Report RADC-TN-60-221, Griffiss AFB, New York, September 1960(b).
58.
RCA Service Company.Maintainability measurement and prediction methods for Air Force ground electronic equipment (Phase III report). RADC Report RADC-TN-61-141, Griffiss AFB, New York, June 1961.
59.
RCA Service Company.Maintainability prediction technique (Phase IV report). RADC Report RADC-TDR-62-156, Griffiss AFB, New York, March 1962.
60.
RCA Service Company.Maintainability technique study final technical report (Phase V, Vol. I). RADC Report RADC-TDR-63-85, Vol. I, Griffiss AFB, New York, February 1963(a).
61.
RCA Service Company.Maintainability engineering. RADC Report RADC-TDR-63-85, Vol. II, Griffiss AFB, New York, February 1963(b).
62.
RettererB. L.GriswoldG. H.McLaughlinR. L.TopmillerD. A.The validation of a maintainability prediction technique for an airborne electronic system. Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory Report AMRL-TR-65-42, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, May 1965.
63.
RiehlC. M.Van BlarcomJ. P.SchneiderC. B.CeciR. J.Jr.Development of an abstract model for aerospace maintenance systems. Air Force Aero Propulsion Laboratory Report AFAPL-TR-64-150, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, March 1965.
64.
RigbyL. V.CooperJ. I.Problems and procedures in maintainability. Behavioral Sciences Laboratory ASD Note 61-126, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, October 1961.
65.
RunyonR. P.Human factors in maintenance. Part II: Maintenance problems anticipated as a result of subminiaturization. U.S. Naval Training Device Center Report NAVTRADEVCEN 20-05-23-2, Port Washington, New York, April 1958.
66.
SchaferT.BensonN.ClausenH.Development of criteria and quantitative predictions of maintainability of Air Force equipment. Aeronautical Systems Division Report ASD 61-502, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, September 1961.
67.
ShershinA. C.SorianoA.Mathematical optimization techniques for reliability and maintainability apportionments. Autonetics Report TM-31-024-43-ORA-014, North American-Rockwell Corporation, Anaheim, California, November 1963.
68.
SklarL. B.HanifanD. T.SmithR. P.A generalized maintainability method. III. Sample applications to mechanical and electronic systems. Dunlap and Associates, Inc., Santa Monica, California, November 1967.
69.
SmithR. L.LucacciniL. F.Vigilance research: Its application to industrial problems. Human Factors, 1969, 11, 149–156.
70.
SmithR. P.SklarL. B.HanifanD. T.A generalized maintainability method. II: Mathematical characterization and synthesis of time distributions. Dunlap and Associates, Inc., Santa Monica, California, November 1967.
71.
StandleeL. S.PohamW. J.FattuN. A.A Review of Troubleshooting Research.Indiana University, Report 3, Bloomington, Indiana, December 1956.
72.
StokesR. G.Mathematical models for maintainability evaluation. Vitro Laboratories, Division of Vitro Corporation of America, Technical Note 01749.01-1, Silver Spring, Maryland, April 1964.
73.
SwainA. D.Some problems in the measurement of human performance in man-machine systems. Human Factors, 1964, 6, 687–700.
74.
TopmillerD. A.A factor analytic approach to human engineering analysis and prediction of system maintainability. Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory Report AMRL-TR-64-115, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio, December 1964.
75.
VerdiA. P.SmithR. L.Personnel performance data store for Navy systems: Preliminary program concept. Dunlap and Associates, Inc., Santa Monica, California, July 1966.
76.
WinterB. B.Optimal diagnostic procedures. IRE Transactions on Reliability and Quality Control, December 1960.
