Human Operator Response Speed,Frequency,and Flexibility: A Review and Analysis 1

Abstract

The innate and state-of-the-art limitations on human operator manual control speed, frequency, and flexibility are reviewed and analyzed. Advanced manual control techniques for overcoming these limitations are suggested and research relating to these suggestions is reviewed. It is concluded that a considerable increase in human operator response speed, frequency, and flexibility could accrue from use of the suggested manual control techniques.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams

J. L.

An investigation of the effects of the time lag due to long transmission distances upon remote control, Phase I. NASA TN D-1211, December 1961

Adams

J. L.

An investigation of the effects of time lag due to long transmission distances upon remote control, Phases II & III. NASA TN D-1351, April 1962

Barlow

J. S.

Evoked responses in relation to visual perception and occulamotor reaction times in man.

Annals N. Y. Acad. Sci., 1964, 112 (1), 432–467

Bartley

S. H.

Relation of intensity and duration of brief retinal stimulation by light to the electrical responses of the optic cortex of the rabbit.

Amer. J. Physiol., 1934, 108, 397–408

Bartley

S. H.

Bishop

G. H.

Optic nerve response to retinal stimulation in the rabbit.

Proc. Soc. Exp. Biol., 1940, 44, 39–41

Bartz

A. E.

Eye movement latency, duration, and response time as a function of angular displacement.

J. exp. psychol., 1962, 64, 318–324

Basmajian

J. V.

Conscious control of single nerve cells.

New Scientist, 1963, 12, 662–664

Bennett

R. L.

Principles of therapeutic exercise. In Licht

(Ed.) Therapeutic exercises. New Haven, Connecticut: Elizabeth Licht, Publisher, 1958

Bernotat

Widlok

Prediction display. Paper presented at the MIT-NASA Working Conference on Manual Control, Cambridge, Mass., February 28-March 2, 1966

10.

Bescoe

R. O.

Manual attitude control systems: Volume II. Display format considerations. Culver City, California: Hughes Aircraft Co., NASA Technical Report, March 1964

11.

Bishop

G. H.

O'Leary

J. S.

Electrical activity of the lateral geniculate of cats following optic nerve stimulation.

J. Neurophysiol., 1940, 3, 308–22

12.

Bliss

C. B.

Investigations in reaction time and attention.

Stud. Yale psychol. Lab., 1893, 1, 1–55

13.

Bliss

J. C.

Crane

H. D.

Experiments in tactual perception. Washington, D. C.: NASA Report No. CR-322, November 1965

14.

Bliss

J.C

Townsend

J. T.

Crane

H. D.

Link

S. W.

Tactual perception: experiments and models. Menlo Park, California: NASA Report No. NAS2-2751, Stanford Research Institute, December 1965

15.

Bontrager

E. L.

The application of muscle education techniques in the investigation of electromyographic control. Unpublished Masters Thesis, Case Institute of Technology, November 1965

16.

Bottomley

Wilson

A. B. K.

Nightingale

Muscle substitutes and myoelectric control.

J. Brit. I. R. E., 1963, 26 (6), 439–448

17.

Brebner

Gordon

Ensemble size and selective response times with a constant signal rate.

Quart. J. exp. Psychol., 1962, 14, 113–116

18.

Bricker

P. D.

The identification of redundant stimulus patterns.

J. exp. psychol., 1955, 49, 73–81

19.

Brown

J. S.

Slater-Hammel

A. T.

The effect of speed-up instructions upon the performance of discrete movements in the horizontal plane. State University of Iowa, Department of Psychology, Project Report No. 3, Contract N5ori-57, January 1948

20.

Buckner

D. N.

McGrath

J. J.

Vigilance: a symposium. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1963

21.

Burke

Gibbs

C. B.

A Comparison of free-moving and pressure levers in a positional control system.

Ergonomics, 1965, 8, 23–29

22.

Canfield

A. A.

Comrey

A. L.

Wilson

R. C.

A study of reaction time to light and sound as related to increased positive radial acceleration.

Aviat. Med., 1949, 20, 350–355

23.

Chang

H-T.

Kaada

B. R.

An analysis of primary response of visual cortex to optic nerve stimulation in cats.

J. Neurophysiol., 1950, 13, 305–18

24.

Conklin

J. E.

Effect of control lag on performance in a tracking task.

J. exp. psychol., 1957, 53, 261–268

25.

Conklin

J. E.

Linearity of the tracking performance function.

Percept, mot. skills, 1959, 9, 387–391

26.

Craik

K. J. W.

Theory of the human operator in control systems. I. The operator as an engineering system.

Brit. J. Psychol., 1947, 38, 56–61

27.

Davis

D. R.

Pilot error: some laboratory experiments. Cambridge, England: Applied Psychol. Research Unit, Medical Research Council, 1948

28.

deFlorez

True blind flight.

J. of Aeronautical Sciences, 1936, 3, 168–170

29.

Dodge

C. H.

Bioelectrically controlled upper extremity prostheses. ATD Report No. 66-46, Aerospace Technology Division, Library of Congress, April 1966

30.

Durr

L. B.

The effect of error amplitude information. M. A. Thesis, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, 1961

31.

Elliot

F. R.

Louttit

C. M.

Auto braking reaction times to visual vs. auditory warning signals.

Proc. Ind. Acad. Sci., 1948, 47, 220–225

32.

Ely

J. H.

Bowen

Orlansky

Man-machine dynamics. In Morgan

C. T.

Cook

J. S.

Chapanis

Lund

M. W.

(Eds.), Human engineering guide to equipment design. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1963, 217–245

33.

Eppler

W. G.

Study of human tracking performance based on the use of various output variables. Lockheed Missiles and Space Co., October 1965

34.

Fargel

L. C.

Ulbrich

E. A.

Aerospace simulators prove predictor displays extend manual operation.

Control Engineering, 1963, 8, 57–60

35.

Forbes

The effect of certain variables on visual and auditory reaction times.

J. exp. Psychol., 1945, 35, 153–162

36.

Forbes

T. W.

Garner

W. R.

Howard

J. G.

Flying by auditory reference (FLYBAR). OSRD Report No. 5123, Psycho-Acoustic Lab., Harvard University, June 1945

37.

Ford

White

C. T.

The effectiveness of the eye as a servo-control system. San Diego, California: U. S. Navy Electronics Lab. Report No. 934, October 1959

38.

Froeberg

The relation between the magnitude of stimulus and the time of reaction.

Arch. Psychol., 1907, 16, 1–38

39.

Garvey

W. D.

, Sweeney, J. S. & Birmingham, H. P. Differential effects of “display lags” and “control lags” on the performance of manual control tracking systems. J. exp. psychol., 1958, 56, 8–10

40.

Gasser

H. S.

Pain-producing impulses in peripheral nerves.

Res. Publ. Asso. Nerv. Ment. Dis., 1943, 23, 44–62

41.

Geldard

F. A.

Cutaneous channels of communication. In Rosenblith

W. A.

(Ed.) Sensory communications, New York: Wiley, 1961, pp. 73–87

42.

Gibbs

C. B.

The continuous regulation of skilled response by kinesthetic feedback.

Brit. J. Psychol., 1954, 45, 24–39

43.

Goldman

Technical Report 789-11-1, Naval Training Device Center, Port Washington, N. Y., 1959

44.

Granit

Receptors and sensory perception. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1955

45.

Harris

J. D.

Pikler

A. G.

Murphy

J. E.

Compensatory and pursuit tracking of pitch.

J. Acoustical Soc. Amer., 1963, 35 (4), 581–587

46.

Hathaway

S. R.

An action potential study of neuromuscular relations.

J. exp. Psychol., 1935, 11, 285–298

47.

Henmon

V. A. C.

The time of perception as a measure of differences in sensations.

Arch. Philos. Psychol. sci. Meth., N. Y., 1906, 8

48.

Hirsh

Kadushin

Experiments in tactile control of flying vehicles. In 6th Ann. Conf. on Aviation and Astronautics, Israel, February 1964

49.

Hodgson

D. A.

Preliminary studies of auditory flight control displays. Renton, Washington: Boeing Co., Code Ident. No. 81205(D6-57104), June 1966

50.

Howell

W. C.

Briggs

G. E.

An initial evaluation of a vibrotactile display in complex control tasks. Columbus, Ohio: Ohio State University, Technical Report (813)-5, October 1959

51.

Humphrey

C. E.

Thompson

J. E.

Auditory displays. II. Comparison of auditory and visual tracking in one dimension. A. Discontinuous signals, simple course. Johns Hopkins University, Appl. Physics Lab., Report TG-146, September 1952a

52.

Humphrey

C. E.

Thompson

J. E.

Auditory displays. II. Comparison of auditory tracking with visual tracking in one dimension. B. Discontinuous signals, complex course. Johns Hopkins University, Applied Physics Lab., Report TG-147, September 1952b

53.

Humphrey

C. E.

Thompson

J. E.

Auditory displays. II. Comparison of auditory tracking with visual tracking in one dimension. C. Continuous signals, simple, intermediate and complex courses. Johns Hopkins University, Appl. Physics Lab., Report TG-194, April 1953

54.

Kelley

C. R.

A predictor instrument for manual control. Paper read at the 8th Office of Naval Research Human Engineering Conference, Ann Arbor, Michigan, September 1958

55.

Kelley

C. R.

Developing and testing the effectiveness of the predictor instrument. Dunlap and Associates, Inc. Technical Report 252-60-1 to the Office of Naval Research, March 1960a

56.

Kelley

C. R.

Further research on the predictor instrument. Dunlap and Associates, Inc. Technical Report 252-60-2 to the Office of Naval Research, December 1960b

57.

Kelley

C. R.

Predictor instruments look into the future.

Control Engineering, 1962, 9 (3), 86–90

58.

Kemp

E. H.

Copp&eAe

G. E.

Robinson

E. H.

Electrical responses of the brain stem to unilateral auditory stimulation.

Amer. J. Physiol., 1937, 120, 304–322

59.

Kristofferson

A. B.

Attention in time discrimination and reaction time. Washington, D. C.: NASA Contract No. NAS 2-1790, April 1965a

60.

Kristofferson

A. B.

A time constant involved in attention on neural information processing. California: NASA Ames Research Center. Moffcit Field, Contract No. NAS 2-2486, July 1965b

61.

Leslie

J. M.

Thompson

D. A.

Human frequency response as a function of visual feedback delay. Paper delivered at 10th Annual Meeting of Human Factors Society, November 1966

62.

Lockard

R. S.

Fozard

J. L.

The eye as a control mechanism. China Lake, California: Naval Ordnance Test Station, Technical Report NOTS 1546, 1956

63.

Loeb

Hawkes

Rise and decay time in vigilance for weak auditory and cutaneous stimuli.

Percept. mot. skills, 1961, 13, 235–242

64.

Loveless

Holding

Reaction time and tracking ability.

Percept. mot. skills, 1959, 9, 134

65.

Lyman

Weltman

Groth

Studies in skilled myoelectric control. USAF: AFAL-TR-66-83. April 1966

66.

Mackworth

N. H.

Research on the measurement of human performance. Cambridge, England: Applied Psychology Research Unit, Report APU-263, Medical Research Council, 1950

67.

Marshall

W. H.

Talbot

S. A.

Ades

H. W.

Cortical response of the anesthetized cat to gross photic and electrical afferent stimulation.

J. Neuraphysiol., 1943, 6, 1–15

68.

McCoy

W. K.

Jr. Frost

G. G.

A predictor display for orbital rendezvous. USAF: AMRL Memorandum P-79, July 1964

69.

McRuer

D. T.

Magdaleno

R. E.

Human pilot dynamics with various manipulators. USAF: AFFDL-TR-66-138, December 1966

70.

Miller

Glickstein

Reaction time to cortical stimulation.

Science, 1964, 146, 1594–1595

71.

Muckler

F. A.

Obermayer

R. W.

Control system ags and man-machine system performance. NASA CR-83, July 1964

72.

North

J. D.

Lomnicki

Z. A.

Further experiments on human operators in compensatory tracking tasks.

Ergonomics, 1961, 4, 339–353

73.

Parker

J. F.

Fleishman

E. A.

Ability factors and component performance measures as predictors of complex tracking behavior.

Psychol. Monographs, 1960, 74 (16)

74.

Patton

H. D.

Special properties of nerve trunks and tracks. In Ruch

T. C.

Fulton

J. F.

(Eds.) Medical physiology and biophysics. Philadelphia: Saunders, 1961a

75.

Patton

H. D.

Reflex regulation of movement and posture. In Ruch

T. C.

Fulton

J. F.

(Eds.) Medical physiology and biophysics. Philadelphia: Saunders, 1961b

76.

Pikler

A. G.

Harris

J. D.

Compensatory and pursuit tracking of loudness.

Acoustical Soc. Amer., 1960, 32 (9), 1129–1133

77.

Poffenberger

A. T.

Reaction time to retinal stimulation, with special reference to the time lost in conduction through nerve centers.

Arch. Psychol., 1912, 23, 1–73

78.

Pollack

Fick

The information of elementary auditory displays.

J. Acoustical Soc. Amer., 1954, 26, 155–158

79.

Poulton

E. C.

Tracking behavior. In Bilodeau

E. A.

(Ed.) Acquisition of Skill. New York: Academic Press, 1966

80.

Robinson

E. S.

Work of the integrated organism. In Murchison

J. C.

(Ed.) Handbook of general experimental psychology. Worcester, Mass.: Clark University Press, 1934

81.

Ruch

T. C.

Fulton

J. F.

Medical physiology and biophysics. Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders, 1960

82.

Sampson

P. B.

Coleman

P. B.

Elkin

E. H.

The possibility of using the eye as a source of control signals in tracking. Medford, Mass.: Tufts University, Technical Report to ONR, 1959

83.

Segarle

L. V.

Taylor

F. V.

Studies of trackin behavior. I. Rate and time characteristics of simple corrective movements.

J. exp. psychol., 1948, 38, 615–631

84.

Seashore

S. H.

Seashore

R. H.

Individual differences in simple auditory reaction times of hands, feet, and jaws.

J. exp. psychol., 1941, 29, 342–345

85.

Seeley

H. F.

Bliss

J. C.

Compensatory tracking with visual and tactile displays.

IEEE Transactions on Human Factors in Electronics, 1966, HFE-7 (2), 84–90

86.

Smith

W. M.

Sensitivity to apparent movement in depth as a function of stimulus dimensionality.

J. exp. psychol., 1952, 43, 149–155

87.

Spector

W. S.

(Ed.) Handbook of biological data. Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders, 1956

88.

Stark

Vossius

Young

L. R.

Predictive control of eye tracking movements.

IRE Transactions on Human Factors in Electronics, 1962, HFE-3 (2), 52–57

89.

Swink

J. R.

Intersensory comparisons of reaction times using an electro-pulse tactile stimulus.

Human Factors, 1966, 8, 143–145

90.

Taylor

F. V.

, personal communication to J. D. Harris contents in: J. Acoustical Soc. Amer., 1963, 35 (4), 581–587

91.

Teichner

W. H.

Recent studies of simple reaction time.

Psychol. Bull., 1954, 51, 128–149

92.

Todd

J. W.

Reaction to multiple stimuli.

Arch. Psychol., 1912, 25, 1–65

93.

Vince

M. A.

Corrective movements in a pursuit task.

Quart. J. exp. Psychol., 1948, 1, 85–103

94.

Vodovnik

Ing. Dr.

An electromagnetic brake activated by eyebrow muscles.

Elect. Eng., 1964, 36 (440), 694–5

95.

Vörckel

Reaktionszeit bei willkurlicher kontraktion und erschlaffung der beuger und strecker des vorder-arms.

Z. Biol., 1922, 75, 79–90

96.

Wargo

M. J.

, The effect of delay in motion-produced visual or auditory feedback on manual control behavior. Paper presented at the Western Psychological Assoc. Meeting, April 1966. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Medford, Mass.: Tufts University, December 1965

97.

Wargo

M. J.

Delayed sensory feedback in visual and auditory tracking.

Percept. mot. skills, 1967, 24, 55–62

98.

Wargo

M. J.

Kelley

C. R.

Mitchell

M. B.

Prosin

D. J.

Human operator response speed, frequency, and flexibility: A review, analysis and device demonstration. Santa Monica, California: Dunlap and Associates, Inc., NASA Technical Report, Contract NAS 12-103, March 1967 in press

99.

Wargo

M. J.

Kelley

C. R.

Prosin

D. J.

Mitchell

M. B.

Muscle action potential and hand switch disjunctive reaction time to visual, auditory, and combined visual-auditory displays. Paper read at Eastern Psych. Assoc. Meeting, Boston, April 1967. (IEEE Transactions on Human Factors in Electronics, in press.)

100.

Warrick

M. J.

Effect of transmission-type control lags on tracking accuracy. USAF Air Material Command Technical Report No. 5916, September 1949

101.

Wasserman

W. L.

Human amplifiers.

Science and Technology, October 1964

102.

Weddell

The anatomy of cutaneous sensibility.

Brit. Med. Bull., 1945, 3, 167–172

103.

Weissenberger

Sheridan

T. B.

Dynamics of human operator control systems using tactile feedback.

J. Basic Eng., 1962, 84, 297–301

104.

Wiggins

J. S.

Two determinants of reaction time.

J. exp. Psychol., 1957, 54, 144–147

105.

Woodbury

W. F.

Ruch

T. C. Muscle

In Ruch

T. C.

Fulton

J. F.

(Eds.) Medical physiology and biophysics. Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders, 1961

106.

Woodworth

R. S.

Schlosberg

Experimental psychology. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winton, 1965

107.

Wright

G. W.

The latency of sensations of warmth due to radiation.

J. Physiol., 1951, 112, 344–358

108.

Young

L. R.

A sampled data model for eye tracking movements. Unpublished Sc.D. Dissertation, MIT, Cambridge, 1962