The purpose of this meta-analytic review is to examine the role of three work environment support variables (i.e., peer, supervisor, and organizational support) in training transfer and sustainment or long-term use of learned knowledge, skills, and attitudes (KSAs).
Background:
Estimates demonstrate that little training is transferred to the job, wasting billions in organizational spending each year and resulting in significant loss to safety and individual and team performance. Prior research shows the importance of a supportive work environment to facilitating transfer; however, we know little of the relative importance of specific support variables. This study seeks to examine the unique roles of distinct support variables in training transfer.
Method:
A meta-analysis was conducted with multiple regressions to answer three primary research questions.
Results:
All work environment support variables demonstrate moderate and positive correlations with transfer of training. Furthermore, multiple regressions demonstrate that each factor of the work environment explains unique variance as a predictor, with the model accounting for 32% of transfer and peer support accounting for most of R2. Motivation to transfer mediates the relationship between all three work environment support variables and transfer. Furthermore, three support variables are positively related to sustainment, with peer and supervisor support showing the strongest relationships.
Conclusion:
Findings illuminate the relative contribution of peer, supervisor, and organizational support to transfer and sustainment of training. As transfer continues to be an important yet understudied measure of the effectiveness of workplace training, these findings hold implications for both research and practice.
*Al-AmmarS. A. (1995). The influence of individual and organizational characteristics on training motivation and effectiveness (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). State University of New York, Albany.
2.
*Al-EisaA. S.FurayyanM. A.AlhemoudA. M. (2009). An empirical examination of the effects of self-efficacy, supervisor support and motivation to learn on transfer intention. Management Decision, 47, 1221–1244.
3.
ArthurW.BennettJ. B.StanushP. L.McNellyT. L. (1997). Factors that influence skill decay and retention: A quantitative review and meta-analysis. Human Performance, 11, 57–101.
4.
Association of Training and Development. (2015). 2015 State of the industry report. Alexandria, VA: Author.
5.
*AxtellC. M.MaitlisS.YeartaS. K. (1997). Predicting immediate and longer-term transfer of training. Personnel Review, 26, 201–213. doi:10.1108/00483489710161413
6.
BaldwinT. T.FordJ. K. (1988). Transfer of training: A review and directions for future research. Personnel Psychology, 41, 63–105.
7.
*BaronL.MorinL. (2009). The coach-coachee relationship in executive coaching: A field study. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 20, 85–106.
8.
*BatesR. A.HoltonI. I. I.BurnettM. F. (1999). Assessing the impact of influential observations on multiple regression analysis on human resource research. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 10, 343–363.
9.
BauerK. N. (2013). The impact of trainee characteristics on transfer of training over time (Doctoral dissertation, Old Dominion University). Retrieved from https://digitalcommons.odu.edu/psychology_etds/145
10.
BeckerB. J.SchramC. M. (1994). Examining explanatory models through research synthesis. In CooperH. M.HedgesL. (Eds.), The handbook of research synthesis and meta-analysis (pp. 357–381). New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
11.
BeierM. E.KanferR. (2010). Motivation in training and development: A phase perspective. In KozlowskiS. W. J.SalasE. (Eds.), Learning, training and development in organizations (pp. 65–98). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
12.
*BellB. S.FordJ. K. (2007). Reactions to skill assessment: The forgotten factor in explaining motivation to learn. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 18, 33–62.
13.
BlumeB. D.FordJ. K.BaldwinT. T.HuangJ. L. (2010). Transfer of training: A meta-analytic review. Journal of Management, 36, 1065–1105.
14.
*BrinkerhoffR. O.MontesinoM. U. (1995). Partnerships for training transfer: Lessons from a corporate study. Human Resources Development Quarterly, 6, 263–274.
15.
BroadM. L.NewstromJ. W. (1992). Transfer of training: Action-packed strategies to ensure high payoff from training investments. New York, NY: Addison-Wesley.
16.
BryantS. E. (2005). The impact of peer mentoring on organizational knowledge creation and sharing: An empirical study in a software firm. Group & Organization Management, 30, 319–338.
17.
*BurkeL. A. (1997). Improving positive transfer: A test of relapse prevention training on transfer outcomes. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 8, 115–128.
18.
BurkeL. A.HutchinsH. M. (2007). Training transfer: An integrative literature review. Human Resource Development Review, 6, 263–296.
19.
BurkeL. A.HutchinsH. M. (2008). A study of best practices in training transfer and proposed model of transfer. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 19, 107–128.
20.
BurkeL. A.HutchinsH. M.SaksA. M. (2013). Best practices in training transfer. In PaulidiM. A. (Ed.), Psychology for business success (Vol. 3, pp. 115–132). Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger.
21.
*CasperB. (2005). The positive transfer of learned skills from training to changed behaviors at the job (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Pepperdine University, Malibu, CA.
22.
ChambersD. A.GlasgowR. E.StangeK. C. (2013). The dynamic sustainability framework: Addressing the paradox of sustainment amid ongoing change. Implementation Science, 8, 117–125.
23.
*ChengE. W. L. (2000). Test of the MBA knowledge and skill transfer. International Journal of Human Resource Management, 11, 837–852.
24.
ChiaburuD. S.LindsayD. R. (2008). Can do or will do? The importance of self-efficacy and instrumentality for training transfer. Human Resource Development International, 11, 199–206.
25.
*ChiaburuD. S.TekleabA. G. (2005). Individual and contextual influences on multiple dimensions of training effectiveness. Journal of European Industrial Training, 29, 604–626.
26.
*ChiaburuD. S.van DamK.HutchinsH. M. (2010). Social support in the workplace and training transfer: A longitudinal analysis. International Journal of Selection and Assessment, 18, 187–200.
27.
ClarkeN. (2002). Job/work environment factors influencing training transfer within a human service agency: Some indicative support for Baldwin and Ford’s transfer climate construct. International Journal of Training and Development, 6, 146–162.
28.
ColquittJ. A.LePineJ. A.NoeR. A. (2000). Toward an integrative theory of training motivation: A meta-analytic path analysis of 20 years of research. Journal of Applied Psychology, 85, 678–707.
29.
*CromwellS. E.KolbJ. A. (2004). An examination of work-environment support factors affecting transfer of supervisory skills training to the workplace. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 15, 449–471.
30.
*CummingsJ. L. (2002). Knowledge transfer across R&D units: An empirical investigation of the factors affecting successful knowledge transfer across intra- and inter-organizational units (Doctoral dissertation). George Washington University, Washington, DC. (3034605)
31.
*DevosC.DumayX.BonamiM.BatesR.HoltonE. (2007). The Learning Transfer System Inventory (LTSI) translated into French: Internal structure and predictive validity. International Journal of Training and Development, 11, 181–199.
32.
DuvalS.TweedieR. (2000). Trim and fill: A simple funnel-plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis. Biometrics, 56, 455–463.
33.
EganT. M.YangB.BartlettK. R. (2004). The effects of organizational learning culture and job satisfaction on motivation to transfer learning and turnover intention. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 15, 279–301.
34.
EggerM.Davey SmithG.SchneiderM.MinderC. (1997). Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. British Medical Journal, 315, 629–634. doi:10.1136/bmj.315.7109.629
35.
*EnosM. D.KehrhahnM. T.BellA. (2003). Informal learning and the transfer of learning: How managers develop proficiency. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 14, 369–387.
36.
*FacteauJ.DobbinsG. H.RussellJ. E. A.LaddR. T.KudischJ. D. (1995). The influence of general perceptions of the training environment on retraining motivation and perceived training transfer. Journal of Management, 21, 1–25.
37.
*FitzgeraldC. G. (2002). Transfer of training and transfer climate: The relationship to the use of transfer maintenance strategies in an autonomous job context (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). The University of Connecticut, Mansfield.
38.
FordJ. K.BaldwinT. T.PrasadJ. (2018). Transfer of training: The known and the unknown. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 5, 201–225.
39.
*FrashR. E.Jr. (2004). Modeling the context and transfer relationship for blended e-learning instructional design and delivery in hospitality (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN.
40.
*FreemanE. W. (2009). Training effectiveness: The influence of personal achievement goals on post-training self-efficacy (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). North Carolina State University, Raleigh.
41.
*FutrisT. G.SchrammD. G.RichardsonE. W.LeeT. K. (2015). The impact of organizational support on the transfer of learning to practice. Children and Youth Services Review, 51, 36–43.
42.
*GegenfurtnerA. (2013). Dimensions of motivation to transfer: A longitudinal analysis of their influence on retention, transfer, and attitude change. Vocations and Learning, 6, 187–205.
43.
GeyskensI.KrishnanR.SteenkampJ. B. E. M.CunhaP. V. (2009). A review and evaluation of meta-analysis practices in management research. Journal of Management, 35, 393–419. doi:10.1177/0149206308328501
44.
*Gilpin-JacksonY.BusheG. R. (2007). Leadership development training transfer: A case study of post-training determinants. Journal of Management Development, 26, 980–1004.
45.
GoldhaberD. D.BrewerD. J. (1999). Teacher licensing and student achievement. In KanstoroomM.FinnC. F. J. (Eds.), Better teachers, better schools (pp. 83–102). Washington, DC: Thomas B. Fordham Foundation.
46.
*GreenE. C. (2002). The influence of individual and work environment characteristics on trainee motivation and training effectiveness measures. Dissertation Abstracts International Section A: Humanities and Social Sciences, 62(12), 4025.
47.
*GrohmannA.BellerJ.KauffeldS. (2014). Exploring the critical role of motivation to transfer in the training transfer process. International Journal of Training and Development, 18(2), 84–103.
48.
GrossmanR.Burke-SmalleyL. A. (2018). Context-dependent accountability strategies to improve the transfer of training: A proposed theoretical model and research propositions. Human Resource Management Review, 28, 234–247.
49.
GrossmanR.SalasE. (2011). The transfer of training: What really matters. International Journal of Training & Development, 15, 103–120.
*HicksE. T. (2006). Individual and situational factors affecting transfer of training in a call center environment (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Louisville, KY.
52.
*HinrichsA. (2014). Predictors of collateral learning transfer in continuing vocational training. International Journal for Research in Vocational Education and Training, 1, 35–56.
53.
*HixJ. W. (2013). Measuring the effectiveness of transfer of learning constructs and intent to transfer in a simulation-based leadership training program (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of North Texas, Denton.
54.
HoltonE. F. (1996). The flawed four-level evaluation model. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 7, 5–21.
55.
*HomklinT.TakahashiY.TechakanontK. (2014). The influence of social and organizational support on transfer of training: Evidence from Thailand. International Journal of Training & Development, 18, 116–131.
56.
HuangJ. L.BlumeB. D.FordJ. K.BaldwinT. T. (2015). A tale of two transfers: Disentangling maximum and typical transfer and their respective predictors. Journal of Business and Psychology, 30, 709–732.
57.
HughesA. M.GregoryM. E.JosephD. L.SoneshS. C.MarlowS. L.LacerenzaC. N.SalasE. (2016). Saving lives: A meta-analysis of team training in healthcare. Journal of Applied Psychology, 101, 1266–1304.
58.
HunterJ. E.SchmidtF. L. (2004). Methods of meta-analysis: Correcting error and bias in research findings. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
59.
*HutchinsH. M.NimonK.BatesR.HoltonE. (2013). Can the LTSI predict transfer performance? Testing intent to transfer as a proximal transfer of training outcome. International Journal of Selection and Assessment, 21, 251–263.
60.
*JodlbauerS.SelenkoE.BatinicB.StiglbauerB. (2012). The relationship between job dissatisfaction and training transfer. International Journal of Training and Development, 16, 39–53.
61.
*KazbourR. R.McGheeH. M.MooneyT.MasicaL.BrinkerhoffR. O. (2013). Evaluating the impact of a performance-based methodology on transfer of training. Performance Improvement Quarterly, 26, 5–33.
62.
KeithN.FreseM. (2008). Effectiveness of error management training: A meta-analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology, 93, 59–69.
63.
*KhalfaniS. D. N. (2014). Training transfer: Post-training influences (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Capella University, Minneapolis, MN.
64.
KingH. B.HardenS. W. (2013). Sustainment of teamwork. In SalasE.FrushK.BakerD. P.BattlesJ. B.KingH. B.WearsR. L. (Eds.), Improving patient safety through teamwork and team training (pp. 188–200). New York, NY: Oxford Press.
65.
*KirwanC.BirchallD. (2006). Transfer of learning from management development programmes: Testing the Holton model. International Journal of Training and Development, 10, 252–268.
66.
*KorunkaC.DudakE.MolnarM.HoonakkerP. (2007). Organizational predictors of a successful implementation of an ergonomic training program. Proceedings of the Human Factors & Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 51, 967–971.
67.
KotterJ. P. (1995). Leading change: Why transformation efforts fail. Harvard Business Review, 73(2), 59–67.
68.
KozlowskiS. W. J.SalasE. (1997). An organizational systems approach to implementation and transfer of training. In FordJ. K.KozlowskiS. W. J.KraigerK.SalasE.TeachoutM. (Eds.), Improving training effectiveness in work organizations (pp. 3–90). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
69.
KurtessisJ. N.EisenbergerR.FordM. T.BuffardiL. C.StewartK. A.AdisC. S. (2017). Perceived organizational support: A meta-analytic evaluation of organizational support theory. Journal of Management, 43, 1854–1884.
70.
*LeeC.LeeH.LeeJ.ParkJ. (2014). A multiple group analysis of the training transfer model: Exploring the differences between high and low performers in a Korean insurance company. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 25, 2837–2857.
71.
*LeeJ. G. (2010). An investigation of the relationship between transfer of learning factors and perceived organizational knowledge performance in selected Korean organizations (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). The Pennsylvania State University, University Park.
72.
LionettiP. (2012). Transfer of training: 1988-2011 with the practitioner in mind. Available from ProQuest. (3547780)
73.
*LiuJ.SmithB. D. (2011). Transferring training to child welfare practice: Individual and collective efforts. Children and Youth Services Review, 33, 149–156.
74.
*MartinH. J. (2010). Workplace climate and peer support as determinants of training transfer. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 21, 87–104.
75.
*MartineauJ. W. (1995). A contextual examination of the effectiveness of a supervisory skills training program (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Pennsylvania State University, University Park.
76.
*MassenbergA.SpurkD.KauffeldS. (2015). Social support at the workplace, motivation to transfer and training transfer: A multilevel indirect effects model. International Journal of Training and Development, 19, 161–178.
77.
*MohamedM. A. K. (1994). An investigation of the contextual factors affecting transfer of training, and the role of management values in contextual change: The case of the United Arab Emirates public sector (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Southern California, Los Angeles.
78.
MoherD.LiberatiA.TetzlaffJ.AltmanD. G.& The PRISMA Group. (2009). Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. PLoS Med6(7): e1000097. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed1000097
79.
MorgesonF. P.DeRueD. S.KaramE. P. (2010). Leadership in teams: A functional approach to understanding leadership structures and processes. Journal of Management, 36, 5–39.
80.
*MyersS. D. (1998). The role of person, outcome, environmental, and learning variables in training effectiveness (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Tennessee, Knoxville.
81.
*NairP. K. (2007). A path analysis of relationships among job stress, job satisfaction, motivation to transfer, and transfer of learning: Perceptions of occupational safety and health administration outreach trainers. Dissertation Abstracts International Section A: Humanities and Social Sciences, 68(6–A), 2546.
82.
*NaowaruttanavanitM. (2002). Relationships of collective efficacy, cynicism, and motivation to transfer on transfer of training in Thailand (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Minnesota, St. Paul.
83.
*NgK. H. (2015). Supervisory practices and training transfer: Lessons from Malaysia. Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources, 53, 221–240.
84.
NunnallyJ. C. (1978). Psychometric theory. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
85.
*PhamN. T. P.SegersM. S. R.GijselaersW. H. (2013). Effects of work environment on transfer of training: Empirical evidence from Master of Business Administration programs in Vietnam. International Journal of Training and Development, 17(1), 1–19.
86.
*PoteetM. L. (1996). The training transfer process: An examination of the role of individual, motivational and work environmental factors (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Tennessee, Knoxville.
87.
*PowellJ. L. (2009). Transfer initiation and maintenance of training: Employees’ perception of the relative influences of transfer intentions, general self-efficacy (GSE) and supervisor support (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, VA.
88.
PreacherK. J.SeligJ. P. (2012). Advantages of Monte Carlo confidence intervals for indirect effects. Communication Methods & Measures, 6(2), 77–98.
89.
RabinB. A.BrownsonR. C.Haire-JoshuD.KreuterM. W.WeaverN. L. (2008). A glossary for dissemination and implementation research in health. Journal of Public Health Management and Practice, 14, 117–123.
90.
*RichmanW. L. (1998). Examining the effects of post-training interventions on transfer of training (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Illinois at Urbana–Champaign, IL.
91.
*RonenE. (2010). Transfer of e-learning in the workplace: The effects of trainee characteristics and contextual factors. Dissertation Abstracts International, 70, 5218.
92.
RouillerJ. Z.GoldsteinI. L. (1993). The relationship between organizational transfer climate and positive transfer of training. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 4, 377–390.
93.
SaksA. M. (2002). So what is a good transfer of training estimate? A reply to Fitzpatrick. The Industrial-Organizational Psychologist, 39, 29–30.
94.
SalasE.TannenbaumS. I.KraigerK.Smith-JentschK. A. (2012). The science of training and development in organizations: What matters in practice. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 13(2), 74–101.
95.
ScadutoA.LindsayD. R.ChiaburuD. S. (2008). Leader influences on training effectiveness: Motivation and outcome expectation processes. International Journal of Training and Development, 12, 158–170.
96.
SchlenkerB. R.BrittT. W.PenningtonJ.MurphyR.DohertyK. (1994). The triangle of responsibility. Psychological Review, 101, 632–652.
97.
SchulzeR. (2004). Meta-analysis: A comparison of approaches. Ashland, OH: Hogrefe & Huber Publishers.
98.
*SekowskiG. J. (2003). Evaluating training outcomes: Testing an expanded model of training outcome criteria. Dissertation Abstracts International, 63, 6130.
99.
SeylerD. L.HoltonE. F.IIIBatesR. A.BurnettM. F.CarvalhoM. A. (1998). Factors affecting motivation to transfer training. International Journal of Training and Development, 2(1), 2–16.
100.
*ShortM. A. (1997). Transfer of training: Examining the relationship of supervisor, peer, and subordinate support on the transfer of leadership behaviors to the work place (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). The Ohio State University, Columbus.
101.
SkinnerB. F. (1953). Science and human behavior. Cambridge, MA: Simon & Schuster.
102.
*Smith-JentschK. A.Cannon-BowersJ. A.TannenbaumS. I.SalasE. (2008). Guided team self-correction: Impacts on team mental models, processes, and effectiveness. Small Group Research, 39, 303–327.
103.
*SwitzerK. C.NagyM. S.MullinsM. E. (2005). The influence of training reputation, managerial support, and self-efficacy on pre-training motivation and perceived training transfer. Applied Human Resource Management Research, 10, 21–34.
104.
TharenouP.SaksA. M.MooreC. (2007). A review and critique of research on training and organizational-level outcomes. Human Resource Management Review, 17, 251–273.
105.
TraceyJ. B.TannenbaumS. I.KavanaghM. J. (1995). Applying trained skills on the job: The importance of the work environment. Journal of Applied Psychology, 80, 239–252.
106.
*Van den BosscheP.SegersM.JansenN. (2010). Transfer of training: The role of feedback in supportive social networks. International Journal of Training & Development, 14, 81–94.
107.
*Van der LochtM.van DamK.ChiaburuD. S. (2013). Getting the most of management training: The role of identical elements for training transfer. Personnel Review, 42, 422–439.
108.
*VeladaR.CaetanoA.MichelJ. W.LyonsB. D.KavanaghM. J. (2007). The effects of training design, individual characteristics and work environment on transfer of training. International Journal of Training and Development, 11, 282–294.
109.
ViswesvaranC.OnesD. S. (1995). Theory testing: Combining psychometric meta-analysis and structural equations modeling. Personnel Psychology, 48, 865–885.
110.
*WarrP.AllanC.BirdiK. (1999). Predicting three levels of training outcome. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 72, 351–375.
111.
*WenzelR. (2014). Pathways to training transfer: Proactive transfer behaviour and hope at work. Academy of Management Proceedings, 2014, 17546.
112.
WexleyK. N.NemeroffW. F. (1975). Effectiveness of positive reinforcement and goal setting as methods of management development. Journal of Applied Psychology, 60, 446–450.
113.
YamnillS.McLeanG. N. (2001). Theories supporting transfer of training. Human Resource Development Quarterly, 12, 195–208.
114.
*ZumrahA. R.BoyleS. (2015). The effects of perceived organizational support and job satisfaction on transfer of training. Personnel Review, 44, 236–254.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
