This study was aimed at examining team communication during postoperative handover and its relationship to clinicians’ self-ratings of handover quality.
Background:
Adverse events can often be traced back to inadequate communication during patient handover. Research and improvement efforts have mostly focused on the information transfer function of patient handover. However, the specific mechanisms between handover communication processes among teams of transferring and receiving clinicians and handover quality are poorly understood.
Method:
We conducted a prospective, cross-sectional observation study using a taxonomy for handover behaviors developed on the basis of established approaches for analyzing teamwork in health care. Immediately after the observation, transferring and receiving clinicians rated the quality of the handover using a structured tool for handover quality assessment. Handover communication during 117 handovers in three postoperative settings and its relationship to clinicians’ self-ratings of handover quality were analyzed with the use of correlation analyses and analyses of variance.
Results:
We identified significantly different patterns of handover communication between clinical settings and across handover roles. Assessments provided during handover were related to higher ratings of handover quality overall and to all four dimensions of handover quality identified in this study. If assessment was lacking, we observed compensatory information seeking by the receiving team.
Conclusion:
Handover quality is more than the correct, complete transmission of patient information. Assessments, including predictions or anticipated problems, are critical to the quality of postoperative handover.
Application:
The identification of communication behaviors related to high-quality handovers is necessary to effectively support the design and evaluation of handover improvement efforts.
AnwariJ. S. (2002). Quality of handover to the postanaesthesia care unit nurse. Anaesthesia, 57, 484–500.
2.
ApkerJ.MallakL. A.ApplegateE. B.IIIGibsonS. C.HamJ. J.JohnsonN. A.StreetR. L.Jr. (2010). Exploring emergency physician-hospitalist handoff interactions: Development of the Handoff Communication Assessment. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 55, 161–170.
BenderR.LangeS. (2001). Adjusting for multiple testing: When and how?Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 54, 343–349.
5.
BlickensderferE. L.StoutR. J.Cannon-BowersJ. A.SalasE. (1993, October). Deriving theoretically-driven principles for cross-training teams. Paper presented at the 37th annual meeting of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, Seattle, WA.
6.
BogenstätterY.TschanF.SemmerN. K.SpychigerM.BreuerM.MarschS. (2009). How accurate is information transmitted to medical professionals joining a medical emergency? A simulator study. Human Factors, 51, 115–125.
7.
BorowitzS. M.Waggoner-FountainL. A.BassE. J.SleddR. M. (2008). Adequacy of information transferred at resident sign-out (in-hospital handover of care): A prospective survey. Quality and Safety in Health Care, 17, 6–10.
BurtscherM. J.KolbeM.WackerJ.ManserT. (2011). Interactions of team mental models and monitoring behaviors to predict team-performance in anesthesia. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 17, 257–269.
10.
BurtscherM. J.WackerJ.GroteG.ManserT. (2010). Managing nonroutine events in anesthesia: The role of adaptive coordination. Human Factors, 52, 282–294.
11.
Cannon-BowersJ. A.SalasE. (2001). Reflections on shared cognition. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 22, 195–202.
12.
CarrollJ. S.WilliamsM.GallivanT. M. (in press). The ins and outs of change of shift handoffs between nurses: A communication contest?BMJ Quality and Safety.
13.
CatchpoleK. R.De LevalM. R.McEwanA.PigottN.ElliottM. J.McQuillanA.. . . GoldmanA. J. (2007). Patient handover from surgery to intensive care: Using Formula 1 pit-stop and aviation models to improve safety and quality. Pediatric Anesthesia, 17, 470–478.
14.
CatchpoleK. R.GiddingsA. E.WilkinsonM.HirstG.DaleT.de LevalM. R. (2007). Improving patient safety by identifying latent failures in successful operations. Surgery, 142, 102–110.
15.
ClancyC. M. (2006). Care transitions: A threat and an opportunity for patient safety. American Journal of Medical Quality, 21, 415–417.
16.
Committee on Quality of Health Care in America. (2001). Crossing the quality chasm: A new health system for the 21st century. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
17.
CookeN. J.GormanJ. C.DuranJ. L.TaylorA. R. (2007). Team cognition in experienced command-and-control teams. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 13, 146–157.
18.
CookeN. J.KiekelP. A.SalasE.StoutR.BowersC.Cannon-BowersJ. (2003). Measuring team knowledge: A window to the cognitive underpinnings of team performance. Group Dynamics: Theory, Research, and Practice, 7, 179–199.
19.
DavisD. A.MazmanianP. E.FordisM.Van HarrisonR.ThorpeK. E.PerrierL. (2006). Accuracy of physician self-assessment compared with observed measures of competence. JAMA: The Journal of the American Medical Association, 296, 1094–1102.
20.
FieldA. (2005). Discovering statistics using SPSS. London, UK: Sage.
21.
FosterS.ManserT. (2012). Receiving care providers’ role during patient handover. Trends in Anaesthesia and Critical Care. Advance online publication. doi:10.1016/j.tacc.2012.03.003
22.
FosterS.ManserT. (in press). The effects of patient handoff characteristics on subsequent care: A systematic review and areas for future research. Academic Medicine.
23.
FousheeH. C. (1984). Dyads and triads at 35,000 feet: Factors affecting group process and aircrew performance. American Psychologist, 39, 885–893.
24.
GormanJ. C.CookeN. J.WinnerJ. L. (2006). Measuring team situation awareness in decentralized command and control environments. Ergonomics, 49, 1312–1325.
25.
GreenbergC. C.RegenbogenS. E.StuddertD. M.LipsitzS. R.RogersS. O.ZinnerM. J.GawandeA. A. (2007). Patterns of communication breakdowns resulting in injury to surgical patients. Journal of the American College of Surgeons, 204, 533–540.
26.
HaggertyJ. L.ReidR. J.FreemanG. K.StarfieldB. H.AdairC. E.McKendryR. (2003). Continuity of care: A multidisciplinary review. British Medical Journal, 327, 1219–1221.
27.
HaigK. M.SuttonS.WhittingtonJ. (2006). SBAR: A shared mental model for improving communication between clinicians. Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety/Joint Commission Resources, 32, 167–175.
28.
HarveyC. M.SchusterR. J.DursoF. T.MatthewsA. L.SurabattulaD. (2007). Human factors of transition of care. In CarayonP. (Ed.), Handbook of human factors and ergonomics in health care and patient safety (pp. 233–248). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
29.
HeldJ.ManserT. (2005). A PDA-based system for online recording and analysis of concurrent events in complex behavioral processes. Behavior Research Methods, Instruments, & Computers, 37, 155–164.
30.
LandisJ. R.KochG. G. (1977). The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics, 33, 159–174.
31.
LawrenceR. H.TomoloA. M.GarlisiA. P.AronD. C. (2008). Conceptualizing handover strategies at change of shift in the emergency department: A grounded theory study. BMC Health Services Research, 8, 256.
32.
LingardL.EspinS.WhyteS.RegehrG.BakerG. R.ReznickR.. . . GroberE. (2004). Communication failures in the operating room: An observational classification of recurrent types and effects. Quality & Safety in Health Care, 13, 330–334.
33.
LingardL.ReznickR.EspinS.RegehrG.DeVitoI. (2002). Team communications in the operating room: Talk patterns, sites of tension, and implications for novices. Academic Medicine, 77, 232–237.
34.
ManserT. (2009). Teamwork and patient safety in dynamic domains of healthcare: A review of literature. Acta Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica, 53, 143–151.
35.
ManserT.FosterS. (2011). Effective handover communication: An overview of research and improvement efforts. Best Practice & Research Clinical Anaesthesiology, 25, 181–191.
36.
ManserT.FosterS.GisinS.JaeckelD.UmmenhoferW. (2010). Assessing the quality of patient handoffs at care transitions. Quality & Safety in Health Care, 19(6), 1–5.
37.
ManserT.HarrisonT. K.GabaD. M.HowardS. K. (2009). Coordination patterns related to high clinical performance in a simulated anesthetic crisis. Anesthesia and Analgesia, 108, 1606–1615.
38.
ManserT.HowardS. K.GabaD. M. (2008). Adaptive coordination in cardiac anaesthesia: A study of situational changes in coordination patterns using a new observation system. Ergonomics, 51, 1153–1178.
39.
MarksM. A.SabellaM. J.BurkeC. S.ZaccaroS. J. (2002). The impact of cross-training on team effectiveness. Journal of Applied Psychology, 87, 3–13.
40.
MillerA.ScheinkestelC.LimpusA.JosephM.KarnikA.VenkateshB. (2009). Uni- and interdisciplinary effects on round and handover content in intensive care units. Human Factors, 51, 339–353.
41.
NagpalK.AroraS.AbboudiM.VatsA.WongH. W.ManchandaC.. . . MoorthyK. (2010). Postoperative handover: Problems, pitfalls, and prevention of error. Annals of Surgery, 252, 171–176.
42.
NagpalK.VatsA.AhmedK.VincentC.MoorthyK. (2010). An evaluation of information transfer through the continuum of surgical care: A feasibility study. Annals of Surgery, 252, 402–407.
43.
PattersonE.RothE. M.WoodsD. D.ChowR.GomesJ. O. (2004). Handoff strategies in settings with high consequences for failure: Lessons for health care operations. International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 16, 125–132.
44.
PattersonE.WearsR. L. (2010). Patient handoffs: Standardized and reliable measurement tools remain elusive. Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety, 36(2), 52–61.
45.
PattersonE.WoodsD. D. (2001). Shift changes, updates, and the on-call architecture in space shuttle mission control. Computer Supported Cooperative Work, 10, 317–346.
PerryS. (2004). Transitions in care: Studying safety in emergency department signovers. Focus on Patient Safety, 7(2), 1–3.
48.
Raduma-TomasM. A.FlinR.YuleS.WilliamsD. (2011). Doctors’ handovers in hospitals: A literature review. BMJ Quality and Safety, 20, 128–133.
49.
RiesenbergL. A.LeitzschJ.LittleB. W. (2009). Systematic review of handoff mnemonics literature. American Journal of Medical Quality, 24, 196–204.
50.
RiesenbergL. A.LeitzschJ.MassucciJ. L.JaegerJ.RosenfeldJ. C.PatowC.. . . KarpovichK. P. (2009). Residents’ and attending physicians’ handoffs: A systematic review of the literature. Academic Medicine, 84, 1775–1787.
51.
SalasE.DickinsonT.ConverseS.TannenbaumS. (1992). Toward an understanding of team performance and training. In SwezeyR.SalasE. (Eds.), Teams: Their training and performance (pp. 3–29). Norwood, NJ: Ablex.
52.
SalasE.PrinceC.BakerD. P. (1995). Situation awareness in team performance: Implications for measurement and training. Human Factors, 37, 123–136.
53.
SchwilkB.GravensteinN.BlessingS.FriesdorfW. (1994). Postoperative information transfer: A study comparing two university hospitals. International Journal of Clinical Monitoring and Computing, 11, 145–149.
54.
SextonB. (1999). Content analysis of cockpit communication (Tech. Rep. 99-8). Austin: University of Texas.
55.
SmithA. F.MishraK. (2010). Interaction between anaesthetists, their patients, and the anaesthesia team. British Journal of Anaesthesia, 105, 60–68.
56.
SmithA. F.PopeC.GoodwinD.MortM. (2008). Interprofessional handover and patient safety in anaesthesia: Observational study of handovers in the recovery room. British Journal of Anaesthesia, 101, 332–337.
57.
StoutR. J.SalasE.CarsonR. (1994). Individual task proficiency and team process behavior: What is important for team functioning. Military Psychology, 6, 177–192.
58.
VolpeC. E.Cannon-BowersJ. A.SalasE.SpectorP. E. (1996). The impact of cross-training on team functioning: An empirical investigation. Human Factors, 38, 87–100.
59.
WearsR. L.PerryS. J. (2010). Discourse and process analyses of shift change handoffs in emergency departments. In Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 54th Annual Meeting (pp. 953–956). Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors and Ergonomics Society.
60.
WearsR. L.PerryS. J.ShapiroM.BeachC.BeharaR. (2003). Shift changes among emergency physicians: Best of times, worst of times. In Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 47th Annual Meeting (pp. 1420–1423). Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors and Ergonomics Society.
61.
WeingerM. B.SlagleJ. M.KuntzA.BanerjeeA.SchildcroutJ. S.MercaldoN. D.. . . WallsonK. (2010). Improving actual handover behavior with a simulation-based training intervention. In Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 54th Annual Meeting (pp. 957–961). Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors and Ergonomics Society.
