Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 1999-3
A systematic search of the literature on effectiveness of alliances for health promotion: some methodological issues and their implications for research
A systematic literature search was undertaken and an annotated bibliography compiled on the effectiveness of alliances for health promotion. Nineteen databases were systematically searched according to a pre-specified search strategy using parts 1 and 2 of the Cochrane Search Strategy for controlled studies which generated 185 discrete references. Of the 110 published empirical studies that were identified, 19 involved macro-alliances and 91 micro-alliances. Studies involved lifestyle behav iours (n=47), reproductive health and parenting (n=20) or focused on disease ( n=34). The methods used for the literature search and their considerations are presented in this paper along with a preliminary description of the studies retrieved. The method ological issues are discussed along with their implications and suggestions for further research and health policy.
The New NHS.Modern-Dependable. London: The Stationery Office, 1998 (p27).
3.
World Health Organization.ConstitutionGeneva: WHO, 1946.
4.
World Health Organization.Health Promotion: a Discussion Document on the Concepts and Principles. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe, 1984.
5.
World Health Organization.Targets for Health for All. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe, 1985.
6.
World Health Organization.Report of the International Conference on Primary Health Care. Report of Alma Ata Conference. Geneva: WHO, 1978.
7.
World Health Organization.Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion, An International Conference on Health Promotion. Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe, 1986.
8.
Health promotion1986: 1(4). Complete issue.
9.
Dean K.Nutrition education in health promotion. Journal of the Canadian Dietetic Association1990: 51(4): 481-4.
10.
Ashton J.Seymour H.The New Public Health. Milton Keynes: Open University Press, 1998.
11.
Roe B.Guinness L., Rafferty AM, the Health Promotion Information Centre. Evidence on the Effectiveness of Alliances for Health Promotion: a Systematic Literature Search and Qualitative Annotated Bibliography. Unpublished Report submitted to the Health Education Authority. London: Centre for Policy in Nursing Research, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine , 1997.
12.
Gillies PAEffectiveness of alliances and partnerships for health promotion. Health Promotion International1998: 13: 99-120.
13.
NHS Centre for Reviews and Dissemination.Undertaking Systematic Reviews of Research on Effectiveness. Report No. 4 . York NHS Centre for Reviews and Dissemination, University of York, 1996.
14.
The Cochrane Handbook. ftp.cochrane.co.uk for the UK, 1997.
15.
The Cochrane Library. London: British Medical Journal Publishing Group. 1997.
16.
Cochrane ALEffectiveness and Efficiency. Random Reflections on Health Services. London: British Medical Journal and The Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust. 1971
17.
Chalmers I., Altman DGSystematic Reviews. London: British Medical Journal Publishing Group, 1995.
18.
Speller V.Learmouth A., Harrison D.The search for evidence of effective health promotion. British Medical Journal1997: 315: 361-3.
19.
NHS Centre for Reviews and Dissemination. Undertaking Svstematic Reviews of Research on Effectiveness. Report No. 4. York NHS Centre for Reviews and Dissemination, University of York, 1996, Appendix I, page 73.
20.
Roe B., Guinness L., Rafferty AM, the Health Promotion Information Centre. Evidence on the Effectiveness of Alliances for Health Promotion: a Systematic Literature Search and Qualitative Annotated Bibliography. Unpublished Report submitted to the Health Education Authority. London: Centre for Policy in Nursing Research, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, 1997, Appendix I.
21.
Staessen J. , Bulpitt CJFargard R., Joosens JV, Lynen P., Amery A.Salt intake and blood pressure in the general population: a controlled intervention trial in two towns. Journal of Hypertension1988:6: 965-73.
22.
Perry CL, Williams CL, Forster JL, et al. Background, conceptualization and design of a community-wide research program on adolescent alcohol abuse. Prokect Northland. Health Education Research1993: 8(1): 125-36.
23.
Simons-Morton BGBrink S.Bates D.Effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of persuasive communications and incentives in increasing safety belt use. Health Education Quarterly1987: 14(2): 167-79.
24.
Harkey Pruitt R.Effectiveness and cost-efficiency of interventions in health promotion. Journal of Advanced Nursing1992: 17: 926-32.
25.
Leigh JP, Richardson N., Beck R., et al. Randomized controlled Study of a retiree health program. Archives of Internal Medicine1992: 152: 1201-6.
26.
Fries JF, Bloch DA, Harrington H.Richardson N., Beck R.Two year results of a randomized controlled trial of a health promotion program in a retired population: The Bank of America Study. The American Journal of Medicine1993: 94: 455-62.
27.
The COMMIT Group.Community intervention trial for smoking cessation (COMMIT): I Cohort results from a four year community intervention. American Journal of Public Health1995: 85: 183-92.
28.
Van Assema P., Steenbakkers M., Kok G.Eriksen M., De Vries H.Short Report. Results of the Dutch community project 'Healthy Bergeyk'. Preventive Medicine1994: 23: 394-401.
29.
Windsor RA, Lowe JBBartlett EEThe effectiveness of a worksite self help smoking cessation program: a randomized trial. Journal of Behavioural Medicine1988 : 11(4): 407-21.
30.
Haug K., Fugelli P., Aaro LE, Foss OPIs smoking intervention in general practice more Successful among pregnant than non-pregnant women? Family Practice1994 : 11(2): 111-16.
31.
Jeffery RW, Foster JL, French SA, et al. The healthy worker project: a worksite intervention: weight control and smoking cessation. American Journal of Public Health1994: 83(3): 395-401.
32.
Barber JG, Crisp BRThe 'pressure change' approach to working with the partners of heavy drinkers . Addiction1995: 90: 269-76.
33.
Sciacca JPPhipps BL, Dube DA, Ratliff MIInfluences on breast feeding by lower-income women: an incentive-based. partner-supported educational program. Journal of the American Dietetics Association1995: 95: 323-8.
34.
Sciacca JP, Dube DA, Phipps BL, Ratliff MIA breast feeding education and promotion program: effects on knowledge, attitudes and support for breast feeding. Journal of Community Health1995: 2(6): 473-90.
35.
Rickert VI, Gottlieb A., Jay MSA comparison of three clinic-based AIDS education programs on femafe adolescents' knowledge, attitudes and behavior. Journal of Adolescent Health Care1990: 11: 298-303.
36.
Gomel M., Oldenberg B.Simpson JM, Owen N.Worksite cardiovascular risk reduction: a randomized trial of health risk assessment education, counseling and incentives. American Journal of Public Health1993: 83(9): 1231-8.
37.
Cupples ME, McKnight A.Randomised controlled trial of health promotion in general practice for patients at high cardiovascular risk. British Medical Journal1994: 309: 993-6.
38.
Kviz FK, Crittenden KS, Madura KJWarnecke RBUse and effectiveness of buddy support in a self help smoking cessation program . American Journal of Health Promotion1993 : 8(3): 191-201.
39.
Johnson Z., Howell F., Molly B.To test the effectiveness of a child development programme delivered by non-professional volunteer community mothers for disadvantaged first-time mothers for children up to one year. British Medical Journal1993 : 306: 1449-52.
40.
Schou L., Wright C.Clemson N., Douglas S.Clark C.Oral health promotion for institutionalised elderly. Community Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology1989: 17: 2-6.
41.
Ewart CKHarris WL, Iwata MMCoates TJ, Bullock R., Simon B.Feasibility and effectiveness of school based relaxation in lowering blood pressure. Health Psychology1987: 6(5): 399-416.
42.
Chalmers I. , Dickerson K., Chalmers TCGetting to grips with Archie Cochrane's agenda . British Medical Journal1992: 305: 386-8.
43.
Mulrow CDRationale for systematic reviews. In: Chalmers I, Altman DG (eds) Systematic Reviews. London: British Medical Journal Publishing Group, 1995.
44.
Sindhu F.Meta-analyses and systematic reviews in the literature. In: Roe B, Webb C (eds), Research and Development in Clinical Nursing Practice. London: Whurr Publishing, 1998: 84-111.
45.
Mickey RM, Goodwin GDThe magnitude and variability of design effects for community intervention studies. American Journal of Epidemiology1993: 137(1): 9-18.
46.
Donner A., Klar N.Methods for comparing event rates in intervention studies when the unit of allocation is a cluster. American Journal of Epidemiology1994a: 140(3): 279-89.
47.
Donner A., Klar N.Cluster randomization trials in epidemiology: theory and application. Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference1994b: 42: 37-56.
48.
Feldman HA, McKinlay SM. Cohort versus cross sectional design in large field trials: precision, sample and unifying model. Statistics in Medicine1994: 13: 61-78.
49.
Klar N.Gyorkos T., Donner A.Cluster randomization trials in tropical medicine: a case study. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene1995: 89: 454-9.
50.
De Leeuw E.Concepts in health promotion: the notion of relativism. Social Science Medicine1989: 29(1): 1281-8.
51.
Stern R.Healthy communities: reflections on building alliances in Canada: a view from the middle. Health Promotion International1990: 5(3): 225-31.
52.
Baum F., Cooke R.Healthy cities Australia; the evaluation of the pilot project in Noarlunga, South Australia. Health Promotion International1992: 7(3): 181-93.
53.
Ouellet F., Durand D., Forget G.Preliminary results of an evaluation of three healthy city initiatives in the Montreal area. Health Promotion International1994: 9(3): 153-9.
54.
Fraser E.Guest editorial. How effective are effectiveness reviews? Health Education Journal1996: 55: 359-62.
55.
Wagner EH, Keopsell TD, Anderman C., et al. The evaluation of the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation's community health promotion grant program: design. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology1991: 44(7): 685-99.
56.
Rogers A., Popay J., Williams G., Latham M.Inequalities in Health Promotion: Insights from the Qualitative Research. London: Health Education Authority, 1997.
57.
Popay J.Rogers A., Williams G.Rationale and standards for the systematic review of qualitative literature in health services research. Qualitative Health Research1998: 8: 341-51.
