This paper seeks to critically discuss the current state of health promotion, arguing that ambiguity remains in its conceptual foundation, practice and education, which is contributing to its decline in several parts of the world. Drawing on relevant literature, the paper re-examines the status of health promotion as a specialist discipline in its own right and suggests that the reaffirmation of this status can move health promotion from the margins to the mainstream of public health policy and practice. The paper briefly rehearses some common conceptualisations of health promotion before suggesting four tensions which, if resolved, could offer greater conceptual clarity and galvanise the contribution of the discipline in addressing individual and community health across the globe.
BarryMMAllegranteJPLamarreM-C, et al. (2009) The Galway Consensus Conference: International collaboration on the development of core competencies for health promotion and health education. Global Health Promotion16: 5–11.
2.
BeattieA (1991) Knowledge and control in health promotion: A test case for social policy and social theory. In: GabeJCalnanMBuryM (eds) The Sociology of the Health Service. London: Routledge, pp. 162–202.
3.
BreslowL (1999) From disease prevention to health promotion. Journal of the American Medical Association281: 1030–1033.
4.
BrubakerBH (1983) Health promotion: a linguistic analysis. Advances in Nursing Science5: 1–14.
5.
BuntonRMacdonaldG (1992) Health Promotion. Disciplines and Diversity. London: Routledge.
6.
CaplanRHollandR (1990) Rethinking health education theory. Health Education Journal49: 10–12.
7.
CatfordJ (2008) Food security, climate change and health promotion: Opening up the streams not just helping out downstream. Health Promotion International23: 105–108.
8.
CohenJEMilioNRozierRG, et al. (2000) Political ideology and tobacco control. Tobacco Control9: 263–267.
9.
DaviesJK (2013) Health Promotion: A Unique Discipline?Auckland, New Zealand: Health promotion forum of New Zealand.
10.
DavisonCDavey SmithG (1995) The baby and the bath water: Examining socio-cultural and free-market critiques of health promotion. In: BuntonRNettletonSBurrowsR (eds) The Sociology of Health Promotion. London: Routledge, pp. 91–99.
11.
DixeyR (2013) After Nairobi: Can the international community help to develop health promotion in Africa?Health Promotion International29: 185–194.
12.
DixeyRCrossRFosterS, et al. (2013) The foundations of health promotion. In: DixeyR (ed.) Health Promotion: Global Principles and Practice. London: CABI, pp. 1–29.
13.
DoorisM (2007) Healthy settings: Past, present and future. Unpublished PhD Thesis, School of Health & Social Development, Deakin University, Melbourne, VIC, Australia.
14.
DoorisM (2009) Holistic and sustainable health improvement: The contribution of the settings-based approach to health promotion. Perspectives in Public Health129: 29–36.
15.
DoorisMDowdingGThompsonJ, et al. (1998) The settings-based approach to health promotion. In: TsourosADowdingGThompsonJ, et al. (eds) Health Promoting Universities: Concept, Experience and Framework for Action. Copenhagen: WHO, pp. 21–32.
16.
DownieRSTannahillCTannahillA (1996) Health Promotion. Models and Values. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
17.
DuncanP (2004) Dispute, dissent and the place of health promotion in a ‘disrupted tradition’ of health improvement. Public Understanding of Science13: 177–190.
18.
ErikssonMLindströmB (2008) A salutogenic interpretation of the Ottawa Charter. Health Promotion International23: 190–199.
19.
GoosC (1996) Perspectives on healthy prisons. In: SquiresNStroblJ (eds) Healthy Prisons – A Vision for the Future. Liverpool: The University of Liverpool, Department of Public Health, pp. 176–180.
20.
GreenJ (2008) Health education: the case for rehabilitation. Critical Public Health18: 447–456.
21.
GreenJCrossRWoodallJ, et al. (2019) Health Promotion. Planning and Strategies. London: SAGE.
22.
GreggJO’HaraL (2007) Values and principles evident in current health promotion practice. Health Promotion Journal of Australia18: 7–11.
23.
HancockT (1999) Creating health and health promoting hospitals: A worthy challenge for the twenty-first century. International Journal of Health Care Quality Assurance12: 8–19.
24.
JawitzJ (2009) Academic identities and communities of practice in a professional discipline. Teaching in Higher Education14: 241–251.
25.
JohanssonHWeinehallLEmmelinM (2009) ‘It depends on what you mean’: A qualitative study of Swedish health professionals’ views on health and health promotion. BMC Health Services Research9: 191.
26.
KellyMP (1989) Some problems in health promotion research. Health Promotion4: 317–330.
27.
KellyMPCharltonB (1995) The modern and postmodern in health promotion. In: BuntonRNettletonSBurrowsR (eds) The Sociology of Health Promotion. London: Routledge, pp. 78–90.
28.
KingPM (1994) Health promotion: The emerging frontier of nursing. Journal of Advanced Nursing20: 209–218.
29.
KrishnanA (2009) What are academic disciplines? Some observations on the disciplinarity vs. interdisciplinarity debate. NCRM Working Paper Series 03/09. Southampton: ESRC National Centre for Research Methods.
30.
LalondeM (1974) A New Perspective on the Health of Canadians: A Working Document. Ottawa, ON, Canada: Health and Welfare Canada.
31.
LaverackG (2017) Health Promotion in Disease Outbreaks and Health Emergencies. London: CRC Press.
32.
LaverackGManoncourtE (2016) Key experiences of community engagement and social mobilization in the Ebola response. Global Health Promotion23: 79–82.
33.
Le FanuJ (1994) Preventionitis: The Exaggerated Claims of Health Promotion. London: Social Affairs Unit.
34.
LindströmB (2018) Workshop salutogenesis and the future of health promotion and public health. Scandinavian Journal of Public Health46: 94–98.
35.
LossJLindacherVCurbachJ (2014) Online social networking sites – A novel setting for health promotion?Health & Place26: 161–170.
36.
LuptonD (1995) The Imperative of Health: Public Health and the Regulated Body. London: SAGE.
37.
LuptonD (2015) Health promotion in the digital era: A critical commentary. Health Promotion International30: 174–183.
38.
McPhail-BellKFredericksBBroughM (2013) Beyond the accolades: A postcolonial critique of the foundations of the Ottawa Charter. Global Health Promotion20: 22–29.
39.
MadsenW (2016) Early 20th century conceptualization of health promotion. Health Promotion International32: 1041–1047.
40.
MadsenW (2018) History in health: Health promotion’s underexplored tool for change. Public Health154: 118–122.
41.
MinklerM (1999) Personal responsibility for health? A review of the arguments and the evidence at century’s end. Health Education & Behavior26: 121–140.
42.
MoorheadSAHazlettDEHarrisonL, et al. (2013) A new dimension of health care: Systematic review of the uses, benefits, and limitations of social media for health communication. Journal of Medical Internet Research15: e85.
43.
NettletonSBuntonR (1995) Sociological critiques of health promotion. In: BuntonRNettletonSBurrowsR (eds) The Sociology of Health Promotion. London: Routledge, pp. 41–58.
44.
NewtonJDoorisMWillsJ (2016) Healthy universities: An example of a whole-system health-promoting setting. Global Health Promotion23: 57–65.
45.
NutbeamD (1986) Health promotion glossary. Health Promotion1: 113–126.
46.
NutbeamD (2008) What would the Ottawa Charter look like if it were written today?Critical Public Health18: 435–441.
47.
NutbeamD (2018) Health education and health promotion revisited. Health Education Journal78: 705–709.
48.
OberstUWegmannEStodtB, et al. (2017) Negative consequences from heavy social networking in adolescents: The mediating role of fear of missing out. Journal of Adolescence55: 51–60.
49.
PopayJWhiteheadMHunterDJ (2010) Injustice is killing people on a large scale – But what is to be done about it?Journal of Public Health32: 148–149.
50.
PotvinLJonesCM (2011) Twenty-five years after the Ottawa Charter: The critical role of health promotion for public health. Canadian Journal of Public Health102: 244–248.
51.
PotvinLMcQueenDV (2007) Modernity, public health, and health promotion. In: McQueenDVKickbuschIPotvinL, et al. (eds) Health and Modernity. The Role of Theory in Health Promotion. New York: Springer, pp. 12–20.
52.
RawsonD (1992) The growth of health promotion theory and its rational reconstruction. In: BuntonRMacDonaldG (eds) Health Promotion: Disciplines and Diversity. London: Routledge, pp. 202–224.
53.
SeedhouseD (1997) Health Promotion: Philosophy, Prejudice and Practice. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
54.
StokolsDGrzywaczJGMcMahanS, et al. (2003) Increasing the health promotive capacity of human environments. American Journal of Health Promotion18: 4–13.
55.
TannahillA (1985) What is health promotion?Health Education Journal44: 167–168.
56.
TenglandP-A (2010) Health promotion or disease prevention: A real difference for public health practice?Health Care Analysis18: 203–221.
57.
TilfordS (2018) Using a health promotion lens. International Journal of Health Promotion and Education56: 68–69.
58.
TilfordSGreenJTonesK (2003) Values, Health Promotion and Public Health. Leeds: Centre for Health Promotion Research, Leeds Metropolitan University.
59.
Van den BrouckeS (2017) Strengthening public health capacity through a health promotion lens. Health Promotion International32: 763–767.
60.
Warwick-BoothLCrossRWoodallJ, et al. (2018) Health promotion education in changing and challenging times: Reflections from England. Health Education Journal78: 692–704.
61.
WhiteJWillsJ (2011) What’s the future for health promotion in England? The views of practitioners. Perspectives in Public Health131: 44–47.
62.
WillsJEvansDSamuelAS (2008) Politics and prospects for health promotion in England: Mainstreamed or marginalised?Critical Public Health18: 521–531.
63.
WoodallJ (2016) A critical examination of the health promoting prison two decades on. Critical Public Health26: 615–621.
64.
WoodallJWarwick-BoothLSouthJ, et al. (2018) What makes health promotion distinct?Scandinavian Journal of Public Health46: 118–122.
