Training Australian general practitioners in rural public health: Impact,desirability and adaptability of hybrid problem-based learning

Abstract

Context and Objective:

Australian rural general practitioners (GPs) require public health knowledge. This study explored the suitability of teaching complex public health issues related to Aboriginal health by way of a hybrid problem-based learning (PBL) model within an intensive training retreat for GP registrars, when numerous trainees have no PBL experience.

Methods:

A mixed method evaluation. Pre-training surveys on PBL experience and post-training semi-structured telephone interviews exploring the impact of the model and its desirability. Thematic and discourse analysis of interview statements, coded independently by two researchers.

Results:

Seventeen GP trainees and four tutors participated. Six main themes emerged: experience; PBL impact; learning modalities; educational needs; educational expectations; and educational planning.

Discussion:

No discernable differences were identified between Australian and international graduates, the knowledge impact of the hybrid model or desirability of the problem. While scabies offers a suitable scenario to explore rural public health complexities, a tension regarding the desire for intensive learning and PBL format needs to be addressed to increase trainees’ satisfaction. A reduction in the number of PBL sessions, PBL instruction and highly structured PBL groups will assist. Trainees value mixed modality education, including PBL, so a tailored hybrid PBL is worth consideration.

Keywords

General practitioner registrar training problem-based learning public health rural scabies

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

O’Shea

SPIKE

. Learning needs analysis: Developing a new tool for general practice training. Australian Family Practice, 2005: 34: 41–3.

Khoo

. Implementation of problem-based learning in Asian medical schools and student’s perceptions of their experience. Medical Education, 2003: 37: 401–9.

Dixon

Lam

CLK

Lam

. Can Hong Kong students cope with small-group, problem-based learning? In: Conway

Melville

Williams

(eds) Research and Development in Problem-based Learning, Volume 4: PBL: A Way Forward (pp. 119–126). Callaghan: Australian Problem Based Learning Network, 1998.

Remedios

. Experiences and Responses of Overseas-Educated Students to Problem-Based Learning and its Classroom Culture in an Australian Physiotherapy Context. Unpublished thesis, University of Melbourne, 2005. Online. Available Informit (accessed 13 July 2006).

Finucane

Johnson

Prideaux

. Problem-based learning: Its rationale and efficacy. Medical Journal of Australia, 1998: 168: 445–338.

Spinello

Fischback

. Problem-based learning in public health instruction: A pilot study of an online simulation as a problem-based learning approach. Education for Health, 2004: 17: 365–73.

Norman

Schmidt

. The psychological basis of problem based learning: A review of the evidence. Academic Medicine, 1992: 67: 557–65.

Albanese

Mitchell

. Problem-based learning: A review of literature on its outcomes and implementation issues. Academic Medicine, 1993: 68: 52–81.

Houlden

Collier

Frid

John

Pross

. Problems identified by tutors in a hybrid problem-based learning curriculum. Academic Medicine, 2001: 76: 81.

10.

GPET. General Practice Education and Training. Canberra: General Practice Education and Training Limited, 2006a.

11.

GPET. Australian General Practice Training 2007 Handbook. Canberra: General Practice Education and Training Limited, 2006b.

12.

Thomson

. A Framework for Vertical Integration in GP Education and Training. Canberra: General Practice Education and Training Limited, 2004.

13.

Pham

Blumberg

. Case design to emphasize population health concepts in problem-based learning. Education for Health, 2000: 13: 77–86.

14.

Dolmans

DHJM

De Grave

Wolfhagen

IHAP

Van Der Vleuten

. Problem-based learning: future challenges for educational practice and research. Medical Education, 2005: 39: 732–41.

15.

Barrows

. A taxonomy of problem-based learning methods. Medical Education, 1986: 20: 481–6.

16.

Mennin

Gordan

Majoor

Shazali

. (2003) Position paper on problem-based learning. Education for Health, 16, 98 – 113.

17.

Patton

. Qualitative Research and Evaluation Methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 2002.

18.

Fraser

. Population and public health in Australian general practice. Australian Family Practice, 2005: 34: 177–9.

19.

Hay

Katsikitis

. The ‘expert’ in problem-based and case-based learning: Necessary or not? Medical Education, 2001: 35: 22–6.

20.

Treloar

McCall

Rolfe

Person

Garvey

Heathcote

. Factors affecting progress of Australian and International students in a problem-based learning medical course. Medical Education, 2000: 34: 708–15.