Ideologies in the news: On the measurement of ideological characteristics of news reports

Abstract

Abstract. In this article, we discuss recent developments within the field of text-analysis from a socio-cultural point of view. In the first part attention is paid to the relation between dominant research traditions in communication studies such as the tradition of content analysis and new approaches which are often labeled as discourse analysis. The main methodological and theoretical problems within the tradition of content analysis are exposed. Perspectives of discourse analysis to overcome these problems are evaluated. Common problem of different approaches seems to be the question whether adequate research tools can be designed to produce not only reliable and valid results but also theoretical relevant analyses of media-discourses.

In the second part of this article we consider by way of example a new method of measuring ideological characteristics of news. This method is comparable to jurisdiction in several important respects: Like judges, the task of coders does not simply consist of applying rules of coding in a purely technical way. The coding of news articles, using general rules, is coupled to a further elaboration of the rules themselves. To test the validity of this procedure, we use a method of scaling derived from a theoretical model generally known as "the law of categorical judgement". We also analyze the reliability of the coding process. Finally, the value of the research tool is demonstrated by presenting some results of a content analysis of the news coverage of a renowned Dutch industrial dispute in the seventies.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barthes, R. (1967), Elements of Semiology, London .

Berelson, B. (1952), Content Analysis in Communication Research, Glencoe.

Bock, R.D. and L.V. Jones (1968), The Measurement and Prediction of Judgment and Choice. San Francisco.

Boesjes-Hommes, R.W. (1970), De geldige operationalisering van begrippen (The valid operationalization of concepts). Meppel.

Comstock, G. , and E. Rubinstein (1972), Television and Social Behaviour, Vol. I: Media Content and Control. Washington.

Connell, I. (1980), "Television News and the Social Contract", in: S. Hall et al. (eds.), Culture, Media and Language. London.

Connell, I. and A. Miles (1985), "Text Discourse and Mass Communication", in: T.A. Van Dijk et al. (eds.), Discourse and Communication. New York: 26-44.

Galtung, J. (1970), Theory and Methods of Social Research. London.

Hall, S. (1980), "Encoding and Decoding", in: S. Hall et al. (eds.), Culture, Media and Language. London.

10.

Hall, S. , D. Hobson , A. Lowe , and P. Willis (eds.) (1980), Culture, Media and Language, London.

11.

Hirst, P. (1979), On Law and Ideology. London .

12.

Holsti, O.R. (1969), Content Analysis for the Social Sciences and the Humanities, Reading.

13.

Kracauer, S. (1959), "The Challenge of Qualitative Content Analysis ", Public Opinion Quarterly 16(4):631-641.

14.

Krippendorff, K. (1980), Content Analysis: An Introduction to its methodology . London.

15.

Laclau, E. , and C. Mouffe (1985), Hegemony and Socialist Strategy. London.

16.

Lasswell, H.R. , and Z. Namenwirth (1968), The Lasswell Value Dictionary. New Haven.

17.

Propp, V. (1958), Morphology of the Folktale, Bloomington.

18.

Scott, W.A. (1955), "Reliability of Content Analysis: the Case of Nominal Scale Coding", Public Opinion Quarterly 19: 321-325.

19.

Stone, P.J. , D.C. Dumphy , M.S. Smith , and D.N. Ogilvie (1966), The General Inquirer; a computer approach to content analysis. Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA.

20.

Sumner, C. (1979), Reading Ideologies. London .

21.

Torgerson, W.F. (1967), Theory and Methods of Scaling. New York.

22.

Van den Berg, H. , F. Glastra and C.G. van der Veer (1984), "Television Images of an Industrial Dispute: the structure and function of news coverage". Gazette 33: 37-50.

23.

Van den Berg, H. , and C.G. van der Veer (1985), "Measuring Ideological Frames of Reference", Quality and Quantity 19:105-118.

24.

Van den Berg, H. , and C.G. van der Veer (1986), Ideologie en Massamedia (Ideology and Mass Media). Amsterdam.

25.

Van den Berg, H. , and C.G. van der Veer (1988), "Geldigheidsproblemen bij Inhoudsanalyse", Sociale Wetenschappen, 31e jaargang, no. 1: 37-61.

26.

Van Dijk, T.A. (ed.) (1985), Handbook of Discourse Analysis, 4 vols. London.

27.

Weber, R.P. (1985), Basic Content Analysis. Beverly Hills.