The discussion in New Testament scholarship regarding early low or early high Christology has a long history, but recent studies have traced developments only for the latter. This can be seen in a specific debate over how best to interpret Paul’s Christ Hymn: is Jesus therein described as divine or an angel? After reviewing the rise of objective approaches to history, and tracing the construction of two competing paradigms, one can better assess the arguments, along with the often unstated prior commitments that lead to either conclusion. The aim of this article is not to side with either view, but to demonstrate how each paradigm was constructed under the demands of certain theological commitments. In this light, the case of the Christ Hymn in Philippians looks very different, since the differences between the two sides is much less than either acknowledges.
AallAnathon. Der Logos, 2 vols. Leipzig: O.R. Reisland, 1896, 1899.
2.
AlkierStefan.‘Belief in Miracles as the Gateway to Atheism: Theological–Historical Remarks about Ferdinand Christian Baur’s Critique of Miracles.’ Pages 261–286 in Ferdinand Christian Baur and the History of Early Christianity. Edited by MartinBauspiess, et al. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2017.
3.
AlzogJohann Baptist.Handbuch der Universal-Kirchengeschichte. 4 vols. Mainz: Kupferberg, 1841.
4.
AndersonPaul N. Felix JustTomThatcher, eds. John, Jesus, and History, 3 vols. Atlanta: SBL Press, 2007, 2009, 2016.
5.
AyresLewis.Nicaea and Its Legacy An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004.
6.
BairdWilliam. History of New Testament Research. Vol. 1: From Deism to Tübingen. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 1992.
7.
BairdWilliam. History of New Testament Research. Vol. 2: From Jonathan Edwards to Rudolf Bultmann. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2003.
8.
BairdWilliam. History of New Testament Research. Vol. 3: From C.H. Dodd to Hans Dieter Betz. Minneapolis: Fortress, 2013.
9.
BarkerMargaret.The Great Angel: A Study of Israel’s Second God. London: SPCK, 1992.
10.
BauckhamRichard. Jesus and the God of Israel. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008.
11.
BaurFerdinand Christian. Das Christenthum und die christliche Kirche der drei ersten Jahrhunderte. Tübingen: L. Fr. Fues, 1853.
12.
BaurFerdinand Christian. Das manichäische Religionssystem. Tübingen: Osiander, 1831.
13.
BaurFerdinand Christian. De Ebionitarum origine et doctrina ab Essenis repetenda. Tübingen: Hopferi de L’Orme, 1831.
14.
BaurFerdinand Christian. Die christliche Gnosis. Tübingen: Osiander, 1835.
15.
BellarminoRoberto. De scriptoribus ecclesiasticis. Rome: B. Zanetti, 1613.
16.
BirdMichael. Jesus Among the Gods: Early Christology in the Greco-Roman World. Waco, TX: Baylor University Press, 2022.
17.
BockDarrell L.CharlesworthJames H., eds. Parables of Enoch: A Paradigm Shift. JCTCRS 11. London: T&T Clark/Bloomsbury, 2013.
18.
BrownRaymond E.The Virginal Conception and Bodily Resurrection of Jesus. New York: Paulist, 1973.
19.
BrownRaymond E.CollinsThomas Aquinas. ‘Church Pronouncements.’ Pages 1166–1174 in The New Jerome Biblical Commentary. Edited by BrownRaymond EFitzmeyerJoseph A.MurphyRoland E.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1990.
20.
BoussetWilhelm.Kurios Christos: A History of Belief in Christ from the Beginnings of Christianity to Irenaeus. Nashville: Abingdon, 1970.
21.
BühnerRuben A.Messianic High Christology: New Testament Variants of Second Temple Judaism. Waco, TX: Baylor University Press, 2021.
BultmannRudolph. Jesus. Berlin: Deutsche Bibliothek, 1926.
24.
BultmannRudolph. ‘Das christologische Bekenntnis des Ökumenischen Rates.’ EvT11 (1951): 1–13.
25.
BultmannRudolph. Das Verhältnis der uchristlichen Christusbotschaft zum historischen Jesus. Sitzungsberichte der Heidelberger Akademie der Wissenschaften 1960. Heidelberg: Winter, 1962.
26.
BuryR. G.The Fourth Gospel and the Logos-Doctrine. Cambridge: Heffer and Sons, 1940.
27.
ChapmanMark. Ernst Troeltsch and Liberal Theology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001.
28.
ChesterAndrew. ‘High Christology – Whence, When and Why?’ Early Christology2 (2011): 22–50.
29.
ClarkElizabeth A. ‘From Patristics to Early Christian Studies.’ Pages 7–41 in The Oxford Handbook of Early Christian Studies. Edited by SusanAshbrook HarveyHunterDavid G.Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008.
CoakleySarah.Christ Without Absolutes: A Study of the Christology of Ernst Troeltsch. Oxford: Clarendon, 1995.
32.
CollinsJohn J. ‘Historical Criticism and the State of Biblical Theology.’ Christian Century (July28–August4, 1993): 743–747.
33.
CollinsJohn J. ‘Is Critical Biblical Theology Possible?’ Pages 1–18 in The Hebrew Bible and its Interpreters. William Henry Propp, Baruch Halpern, and David Freedman. BJSUCSD 1. Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 1990.
34.
CongdonDavid W. The Mission of Demythologizing Rudolf Bultmann’s Dialectical Theology. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2015.
35.
DibeliusMartin. Jesus. Translated by HedrickCharles B.GrantFrederick C.Philadelphia: Westminster, 1949.
36.
DoddC. H.Interpretation of the Fourth Gospel. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1953.
37.
DunnJames D. G. Christology in the Making: A New Testament Inquiry into the Origins of the Doctrine of the Incarnation. 2nd ed. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1989.
38.
DunnJames D. G. ‘Why “Incarnation”? A Review of Recent New Testament Scholarship.’ Pages 235–256 in Crossing The Boundaries: Essays in Biblical Interpretation in Honour of Michael D. Goulder. Edited by Stanley E. Porter, Paul Joyce, and David E. Orton. Leiden: Brill, 1994.
39.
DupontJacques.Essais sur la christologie de S. Jean. Le Christ, parole, lumière et vie, la gloire du Christ. Brugge: Editions de l’Abbaye de Saint-André, 1951.
40.
ElliotMark. ‘Christology in the Seventeenth Century.’ Pages 297–314 in The Oxford Handbook of Christology. Edited by MurphyFrancesca Aran. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015.
41.
FechtJohann.Theses ex universa theologia patristica selectae. Rostock: J. Wepplingius, 1695.
FredriksenPaula. ‘How High Can Early High Christology Be?’ Pages 293–320 in Monotheism and Christology in Greco-Roman Antiquity, ed. NovensonMatthew V. NovTSup 180. Leiden: Brill, 2020.
44.
FredriksenPaula. ‘Mandatory Retirement: Ideas in the Study of Christian Origins Whose Time Has Come to Go.” In SR35 (2006): 231–246.
45.
FreyJörg. ‘Ferdinand Christian Baur and the Interpretation of John.’ Pages 206–235 in Ferdinand Christian Baur and the History of Early Christianity. Edited by MartinBauspiess, et al. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2017.
46.
GiambroneAnthony.A Quest for the Historical Christ: Scientia Christi and the Modern Study of Jesus. Washington, D.C.: Catholic University of America Press, 2022.
47.
GieselerJohann Karl Ludwig. Dogmengeschichte. Bonn: Adolph Marcus, 1855.
48.
GieselerJohann Karl Ludwig. Lehrbuch der Kirchengeschichte. 3rd ed. 6 vols. Bonn: Adolph Marcus, 1824-57.
49.
GieselerJohann Karl Ludwig. Historisch-kritischer Versuch über die Entstehung u. die frühesten Schicksale der schriftlichen Evangelien. Leipzig: Wilhelm Engelmann, 1818.
50.
GieschenCharles A.Angelomorphic Christology: Antecedents and Early Evidence. Leiden: Brill, 1998.
51.
HannahDarrell D.Michael and Christ: Michael Traditions and Angel Christology in Early Christianity. WUNT 2/109. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 1999.
52.
HansonR. P. C.The Search for the Christian Doctrine of God: The Arian Controversy 318–381. London: T&T Clark, 1988.
53.
HarrisCharles.Creeds or No Creeds? A Critical Examination of the Basis of Modernism. New York: Dutton and Company, 1922.
54.
Von HarnackAdolf. History of Dogma. 7 vols. Translated by MillarJames. London: Williams and Norgate, 1897-99.
55.
Von HarnackAdolf. Lehrbuch der Dogmengeschichte. Freiburg: Mohr Siebeck, 1894.
56.
HarveyVan. The Historian and the Believer: The Morality of Historical Knowledge and Christian Belief. New York: Macmillan, 1966.
57.
HesierMichael S. ‘Monotheism, Polytheism, Monolatry, or Henotheism? Toward and Assessment of Divine Plurality in the Hebrew Bible.’ BBR18 (2008): 1–30.
58.
HengelMartin.Judentum und Hellenismus: Studien zu ihrer Begegnung unter Berücksichtigung Palästinas bis zur Mitte des 2 Jh.s v.Chr. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 1973.
59.
HengelMartin.Son of God: The Origin of Christology and the History of Jewish-Hellenistic Religion. Minneapolis: Fortress, 1976.
60.
HollowayPaul. ‘Ideology and Exegesis: A Response to Gerald O’Collins.’ ExpTim133 (2022): 275–283.
HurtadoLarry. ‘“Ancient Jewish Monotheism” in Hellenistic and Roman Periods.’ JAJ4 (2013): 370–400.
63.
JohnsonLuke Timothy. The Real Jesus: The Misguided Quest for the Historical Jesus and the Truth of the Traditional Gospels. San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 1996.
64.
KrebsEngelbert.Der Logos als Heiland im ersten Jahrundert. Freiberger Theologische Studien 2. Freiberg: Herdersche Verlagshandlung, 1910.
65.
KuhnThomas S.The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1969.
66.
KümmelW. G.The New Testament: The History of the Investigation of its Problems. London: SCM, 2012.
67.
MachMichael. ‘The Concepts of Jewish Monotheism During the Hellenistic Period.’ Pages 21–42 in Jewish Roots of Christological Monotheism: Papers from the St. Andrews Conference on Historical Origins of the Worship of Jesus. Edited by NewmanCarey C.DavilaJames R.LewisGladys S. Journal for the Study of Judaism Supplement 63. Leiden: Brill1999.
68.
McDonaldNathan.Deuteronomy and the Meaning of ‘Monotheism.’ FAT 2/1. Tübingen, Mohr Siebeck, 2003.
69.
McFarlandIan A. The Word Made Flesh: A Theology of the Incarnation. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox Press, 2019.
70.
MeierFriedrich Karl.Lehrbuch der Dogmengeschichte für akademische Vorlesungen. Geissen: J. Ricker, 1840.
71.
MeierJohn P.A Marginal Jew: Rethinking the Historical Jesus. Vol. 1: The Roots of the Problem and the Person. New York, NY: Doubleday, 1991.
72.
MorganRobert. ‘Bultmann in Retrospect.’ Journal for the Study of the New Testament42 (2020): 303–324.
73.
von MosheimJ. L. Einleitung die Wahrheit und Göttlichkeit der christlichen Religion. Gründlich zu beweisen und gegen die Ungläubigen und Deisten zu vertheidigen. Erlangen: Wolfgang Walther, 1772.
74.
NeanderAugust. Allgemeine Geschichte der christlichen Religion und Kirche. 6 vols. Hamberg: Friedrich Perthes, 1825–1852.
75.
NeanderAugust. General History of the Christian Religion and Church. 2nd ed. Vol. 2. Translated by JosephTorrey. Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1847.
76.
NeanderAugust. Das Leben Jesu Christi, in seinem geschichilichen Zusammenhang und seiner geschichtlichen Entwickelung. Hamburg: Friedrich Perthes, 1837.
77.
NeanderAugust. The Life of Christ in its Historical Connexion and Historical Development. 4th ed. Translated by McClintockJohnBlumenthalCharles E.New York: Barper and Brothers, 1948.
78.
NewmanCarey C.DavilaJames R.LewisGladys S., eds. The Jewish Roots of Christological Monotheism: Papers from the St. Andrews Conference on the Historical Origins of the Worship of Jesus. Leiden: Brill, 1999.
79.
NixEcholJr.. Ernst Troeltsch and Comparative Theology. New York: Peter Lang, 2010.
80.
NortonRobert E.The Crucible of German Democracy: Ernst Troeltsch and the First World War. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2021.
81.
O’CollinsGerald. ‘Does Philippians 2:6–11 Present Christ as a Superior Angel?’ ExpTim133 (2022): 269–274.
82.
OrlovAndrei A.The Glory of the Invisible God: Two Powers in Heaven Traditions and Early Christology. JCTCRSS 31. London: T&T Clark/Continuum, 2019.
83.
OwenHenry.Observations on the Four Gospels. London: T. Payne, 1764.
84.
PagetJames CarletonMichael J.Thate. Albert Schweitzer in Thought and Action: A Life in Parts. Syracuse: Syracuse University Press, 2016.
85.
PauckWilhelm.Harnack and Troeltsch: Two Historical Theologians. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1968.
86.
PlantingaAlvin. ‘Two (or More) Kinds Of Scripture Scholarship.’ Modern Theology14 (1998): 243–278.
87.
PrangerGary K.Philip Schaff (1819–1893): Portrait of an Immigrant Theologian. Peter Lang, 1997.
88.
RitschlAlbrecht. ‘Euber geschichtliche Methode in der Erforschung des Urchristenthums.’ JDT6 (1861): 433–459.
89.
RobinsonJames M.The New Quest for the Historical Jesus and Other Essays. London: SCM, 1959. Repr. Philadelphia: Fortress, 1983.
90.
RowlandsJonathan.The Metaphysics of Historical Jesus Research. London: Routledge, 2022.
91.
SabarAriel. Veritas: A Harvard Professor, a Con Man and the Gospel of Jesus’s Wife. New York: Doubleday, 2020.
92.
SabarAriel. ‘A Scholarly Screw-Up of Biblical Proportions: ‘Harvard Theological Review” Offers an Exemplary Guide on How Not to do Peer Review.’ Chronicle of Higher Education. June29, 2021.
SchaffPhilip.The Person of Christ. New York: Scribner & Co., 1865.
95.
SchaffDavid S.The Life of Philip Schaff: In Part Autobiographical. New York: Scribner’s and Sons, 1897.
96.
SchäferPeter. Die Geburt des Judentums aus dem Geist des Christentums: Fünf Vorlesungen zur Entstehung des rabbinischen Judentums. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2010.
97.
SchäferPeter. Two Gods in Heaven: Jewish Concepts of God in Antiquity. Translated by AllisonBrown. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2020.
98.
SchröterJens. ‘Trinitarian Belief, Binitarian Monotheism, and the One God: Reflections on the Origin of Christian Faith in Affiliation to Larry Hurtado’s Christological Approach.’ Pages 171–194 in Reflections on the Early Christian History of Religion – Erwägungen zur frühchristlichen Religionsgeschichte. Edited by BreytenbachCilliersFreyJörg; AJEC 81; Leiden: Brill, 2013.
99.
SchleiermacherFriedrich. Das Leben Jesu: Vorlesungen an der Universität Berlin im Jahr 1832. Edited by RutenikK.A.Berlin: Reimer, 1864.
100.
SchleiermacherFriedrich. Hermeneutik und Kritik mit besonderer Beziehung auf das Neue Testament. Berlin: Reimer, 1838. Repr. Heidelberg: Heidelberger Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1959.
101.
SchnackenburgRudolf. The Gospel According to St John, Volume 1: Introduction and Commentary on Chapters 1-4. Translated by SmithKevin. New York: Crossroad1982.
102.
SchweitzerAlbert.The Quest for the Historical Jesus: A Critical Study of its Progress From Reimarus to Wrede. Translated by MontgomeryW.London: Charles and Black, 1910.
103.
ScottHugh McDonald. Origin and Development of the Nicene Theology. Chicago: Chicago Theological Seminary Press, 1896.
104.
SemischCarl. Justin der Märtyrer: Eine kirchen- und dogmengeschichtliche Monographie. 2 vols. Breslau: Austust Schultz, 1840–1842.
105.
ShriverGeorge H.Philip Schaff: Christian Scholar and Ecumenical Prophet. Macon, GA: Mercer University Press, 1987.
106.
SimonRichard. Nouveau Testament de Notre-Seigneur Jesus-Christ (Trévoux: Ganeau1702).
107.
SmithBrandon D. ‘What Christ Does, God Does: Surveying Recent Scholarship on Christological Monotheism.’ CurBR17 (2019):184–208.
108.
Spinoza, Tractatus Theologico-Politicus. 2nd ed. Leiden: Isaac Hercules, 1673.
109.
StendahlKrister. ‘Biblical Theology, Contemporary.’ Pages 418–432 in vol. 1 of The Interpreter’s Dictionary of the Bible. Edited by ButtrickGeorge A.Nashville: Abingdon, 1962.
110.
StraussDavid F.Life of Jesus, Critically Examined. 3 vols. from the 4th German ed., trans. EvansMarian (London 1846).
111.
StraussDavid F.Das Leben Jesu kritisch berarbeited. Tübingen: Osiander, 1835–1836.
112.
StuckenbruckLoren T.Angel Veneration and Christology: A Study in Early Judaism and in the Christology of the Apocalypse of John. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 1995.
113.
StumpEleonore. ‘Revelation and Biblical Exegesis: Augustine, Aquinas, and Swinburne.’ Pages 161–197 in Reason and the Christian Religion: Essays in Honour of Richard Swinburne. Edited by A.Padgett.Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1994.
114.
SvenssonLeif.A Theology for the Bildungsbürgertum: Albrecht Ritschl in Context. Berlin: de Gruyter, 2020.
115.
TalbertCharles H., ed. Reimarus: Fragments. Translated by FraserRalph S. Lives of Jesus Series. Edited by KeckLeander E.Philadelphia: Fortress, 1970.
116.
TroeltschErnst. ‘Historiography.’ Pages 716–723 in Encyclopedia of Religion and Ethics. Vol. 6. Edited by HastingsJames. Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1914.
117.
TroeltschErnst. Zur religiösen Lage, Religionsphilosophie und Ethik. Vol. 2 of Gesammelte Schriften. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 1913.
118.
VollenweiderSamuel. ‘Christozentrisch oder theozentrisch? Christologie im Neuen Testament.’ Pages 19–40 in Christologie. Edited by Gräb-SchmidtE.PreulR.Leipzig, 2011.
119.
WellhausenJulius.Das Evangelium Marci: Übersetzt und Erklärt. Berlin: Reimer, 1903.
120.
WilburEarl Morse. A History of Unitarianism. Boston: Beacon Press, 1945.
121.
WilburEarl Morse. The Two Treatises of Servetus on the Trinity. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1932.
122.
WilhiteDavid E. ‘The History of Ancient Christian History.’ Pages 3–31 in The Cambridge History of Ancient Christianity. Edited by LongeneckerBruce W.WilhiteDavid E.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2023.
123.
WilhiteDavid E.WinnAdam, Israel’s LORD: YHWH as Two Powers in Second Temple Literature (Minneapolis: Fortress Academic, 2024).
124.
WilliamsRowan. Arius: Heresy and Tradition. Rev. ed. Grand Rapids: Darton, Longman & Todd, 1987.
125.
WolfAbraham. ‘Professor Harnack’s “What Is Christianity?”’ JQR16 (1904): 668–689.
126.
YasukataToshimasa. Ernst Troeltsch: Systematic Theologian of Radical Historicality. Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1986.
