A Splash and a Crowd: Do Water Fountains and Storefronts Improve Plaza’s Visitability?

Abstract

Whyte made recommendations based on observational studies on making public plazas more livable. The present paper describes two experiments that looked at whether two design attributes he identified—water features and active streets—increase livability measured through visitability, a concept that replaced livability. The studies manipulated four scenarios for fountains (accessible, inaccessible, floor, nothing) and two for storefronts (present, absent) using slides of three plazas each manipulated to present one of the eight scenarios. Study 1 had 66 college students (34 women, 32 men). Study 2 had 93 participants (53 women, 39 men, 1 other) rate the slides on the Perceived Visitability Scale. Fountains and storefronts increased visitability. Accessible water improved visitability for people between the ages 25 and 44. Participants between 18 and 24 and those 45 and older judged plazas with floor fountains as less visitable, suggesting varying effects of certain design elements across age groups.

Keywords

livable spaces public plazas storefronts water fountain visitability scale

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abdulkarim

Nasar

J. L.

(2014). Do seats, food vendors, and sculptures improve plaza visitability? Environment and Behavior, 46, 805–825.

Abrams

(2011). Columbia Heights: DC’s Most Diverse Neighborhood, But For How Long? https://dc.urbanturf.com/articles/blog/columbia_heights_dcs_most_diverse_neighborhood_but_for_how_long/3235

Adkins

Dill

Luhr

Neal

(2012). Unpacking walkability: Testing the influence of urban design features on perceptions of walking environment attractiveness. Journal of Urban Design, 17(4), 499–510.

Appleyard

(1981). Livable streets. University of California Press.

Biddulph

(2012). Radical streets? The impact of innovative street designs on liveability and activity in residential areas. Urban Design International, 17(3), 178–205.

Boarnet

M. G.

Forsyth

Day

Oakes

J. M.

(2011). The street level built environment and physical activity and walking: Results of a predictive validity study for the Irvine Minnesota Inventory. Environment and Behavior, 43(6), 735–775.

Borst

H. C.

Miedema

H. M. E.

de Vries

S. I.

Graham

J. M. A.

van Dongen

J. E. F.

(2008). Relationships between street characteristics and perceived attractiveness for walking reported by elderly people. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 28(4), 353–361.

Bosselmann

Macdonald

Kronemeyer

(1999). Livable streets revisited. Journal of the American Planning Association, 65(2), 168–180.

Carr

Francis

Rivlin

L. G.

Stone

A. M.

(1992). Public space. Cambridge University Press.

10.

Cerin

Macfarlane

D. J.

H. H.

Chan

K. C. A.

(2007). Measuring perceived neighbourhood walkability in Hong Kong. Cities, 24(3), 209–217.

11.

Cerin

Saelens

B. E.

Sallis

J. F.

Frank

L. D.

(2006). Neighborhood environment walkability scale: Validity and development of a short form. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 38(9), 1682–1691.

12.

Deehr

R. C.

Shumann

(2009). Active Seattle achieving walkability in diverse neighborhoods. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 37(6 Suppl. 2), S403–S411.

13.

Downtown Denver Partnership (DDP). (2018). Wynkoop Plaza at Denver Union Station. https://www.downtowndenver.com/about-us/special-districts/wynkoop-plaza/

14.

Dumbaugh

Gattis

J. L.

(2005). Safe streets, livable streets. Journal of the American Planning Association, 71(3), 283–300.

15.

Engwicht

(1999). Street reclaiming: Creating livable streets and vibrant communities. New Society Publishers.

16.

Ewing

Clemente

(2013). Measuring urban design: Metrics for livable places. Island.

17.

Ewing

Clemente

Handy

Brownson

Winston

(2005). Identifying and measuring urban design qualities related to Walkability—Final report. Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. https://activelivingresearch.org/sites/activelivingresearch.org/files/FinalReport_071605.pdf

18.

Ewing

Hajrasouliha

Neckerman

K. M.

Purciel-Hill

Greene

(2016). Streetscape features related to pedestrian activity. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 36(1), 5–15.

19.

Ewing

Handy

(2009). Measuring the unmeasurable: Urban design qualities related to walkability. Journal of Urban Design, 14(1), 65–84.

20.

Ewing

Handy

Brownson

R. C.

Clemente

Winston

(2006). Identifying and measuring urban design qualities related to walkability. Journal of Physical Activity and Health, 3(S1), S223–S240.

21.

Faggi

Breuste

Madanes

Gropper

Perelman

(2013). Water as an appreciated feature in the landscape: A comparison of residents’ and visitors’ preferences in Buenos Aires. Journal of Cleaner Production, 60, 182–187.

22.

Faulkner

Fearn

Sensenig

Stokle

(2016). Creating livable infrastructure: The ConnectOAKLAND vision to reconnect neighborhoods and connect cities through freeway removal. Journal of Green Building, 11(2), 1–21.

23.

Gallimore

J. M.

Brown

B. B.

Werner

C. M.

(2011). Walking routes to school in new urban and suburban neighborhoods: An environmental walkability analysis of blocks and routes. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 31(2), 184–191.

24.

Gehl

(1987). Life between buildings: Using public space. Van Nostrand Reinhold.

25.

Gehl

Gemzøe

Kirknæs

Søndergaard

B. S.

(2006). New City Life, The Danish Architectural Press, Denmark.

26.

Giles-Corti

Broomhall

M. H.

Knuiman

Collins

Douglas

Lange

Donovan

R. J.

(2005). Increasing walking: How important is distance to, attractiveness, and size of public open space? American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 28(2 Suppl. 2), 169–176.

27.

Harvey

Aultman-Hall

(2016). Measuring urban streetscapes for livability: A review of approaches, the Professional Geographer, 68(1), 149–158.

28.

Heffernan

Pan

(2014). The relationship between the quality of active frontages and public perceptions of public spaces. Urban Design International, 19(1), 92–102.

29.

Hosler

A. S.

Gallant

M. P.

Riley-Jacome

Rajulu

D. T.

(2014). Relationship between objectively measured walkability and exercise walking among adults with diabetes. Journal of Environmental and Public Health, 2014, 542123.

30.

Jensen

W. A.

Stump

T. K.

Brown

B. B.

Werner

C. M.

Smith

K. R.

(2017). Walkability, complete streets, and gender: Who benefits most? Health & Place, 48, 80–89.

31.

Khder

H. M.

Mousavi

S. M.

Khan

T. H.

(2016). Impact of street’s physical elements on walkability: A case of Mawlawi street in Sulaymaniyah, Iraq. International Journal of Built Environment and Sustainability, 3(1), 18–26.

32.

Kickert

Vom Hofe

(2018). Critical mass matters: The long-term benefits of retail agglomeration for establishment survival in downtown Detroit and the Hague. Urban Studies, 55(5), 1033–1055.

33.

Killingsworth

R. E.

(2009). Active living–past, present, and future: Implications for the field. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 37(6 Suppl. 2), S445–S447.

34.

Kitzes

(2010, December 16). Placemaking 101. https://www.pps.org/article/placemaking-101

35.

Kwon

Lee

Xiao

(2017). Exploring the role of neighborhood walkability on community currency activities: A case study of the crooked river alliance of TimeBanks. Landscape and Urban Planning, 167, 302–314.

36.

Lang

Chen

Chan

E. H. W.

Yung

E. H. K.

Lee

T. C. F.

(2019). Understanding livable dense urban form for shaping the landscape of community facilities in Hong Kong using fine-scale measurements. Cities, 84, 34–45.

37.

López

T. G.

(2003). Influence of the public–private border configuration on pedestrian behaviour. The case of the city of Madrid. La Escuela Te ́cnica Superior de Arquitectura de Madrid.

38.

Sarkar

Xiao

(2018). The effect of street-level greenery on walking behavior: Evidence from Hong Kong. Social Science & Medicine, 208, 41–49.

39.

Macdonald

(2005). Street-facing dwelling units and livability: The impacts of emerging building types in Vancouver’s new high-density residential neighbourhoods. Journal of Urban Design, 10(1), 13–38.

40.

Macridis

Garcia Bengoechea

McComber

A. M.

Jacobs

Macaulay

A. C.

(2016). Active transportation to support diabetes prevention: Expanding school health promotion programming in an Indigenous community. Evaluation and Program Planning, 56, 99–108.

41.

Mahmoudi

Ahmad

(2015). Determinants of livable streets in Malaysia: A study of physical attributes of two streets in Kuala Lumpur. Urban Design International, 20(2), 158–174.

42.

Mahmoudi

Ahmad

Abbasi

(2015). Livable streets: The effects of physical problems on the quality and livability of Kuala Lumpur streets. Cities, 43, 104–114.

43.

McAndrews

Marshall

(2018). Livable streets, livable arterials? Characteristics of commercial arterial roads associated with neighborhood livability. Journal of the American Planning Association, 84(1), 33–44.

44.

Mehta

(2014). Evaluating public space. Journal of Urban Design, 19(1), 53–88.

45.

Miller

H. J.

Witlox

Tribby

C. P.

(2013). Developing context-sensitive livability indicators for transportation planning: A measurement framework. Journal of Transport Geography, 26, 51–64.

46.

Moore

(2010, December 26). Child’s play: Robin Moore, DiplArch, MCP, investigates parks as active recreation sites for kids. http://www.rwjf.org/pr/product.jsp?id=71626

47.

Nasar

J. L.

Holloman

Abdulkarim

(2015). Street characteristics to encourage children to walk. Transportation Research Part A, 72, 62–70.

48.

Nasar

J. L.

(2004). Landscape mirror: The attractiveness of reflecting water. Landscape and Urban Planning, 66, 233–238. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0169-2046(03)00113-0

49.

Pasini

Berto

Scopelliti

Carrus

(2009). Measuring the restorative value of the environment: Contribution to the validation of the Italian version of the perceived restorativeness scale. Bollettino Di Psicologia Applicata, 257, 3–11.

50.

Project for Public Spaces (PPS). (2011). About PPS: Placemaking for communities. http://www.pps.org/about/approach/

51.

Project for Public Spaces (PPS). (2017, December 21). The placemaking process. https://www.pps.org/article/5-steps-to-making-places

52.

Rempusheski

V. F.

Laster

Getman

S. R.

Thornton

(2010). Healthy aging in livable communities. Nursing Outlook, 58(2), e26–e26.

53.

Riggs

Gilderbloom

(2016). Two-way street conversion: Evidence of increased livability in Louisville. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 36(1), 105–118.

54.

Rosales

(2007). Road diet handbook: Setting trends For livable streets. Parsons Brinckerhoff.

55.

Sallis

J. F.

Saelens

B. E.

Frank

L. D.

Conway

T. L.

Slymen

D. J.

Cain

K. L.

Chapman

J. E.

Kerr

(2009). Neighborhood built environment and income: Examining multiple health outcomes. Social Science & Medicine, 68(7), 1285–1293.

56.

Säumel

Weber

Kowarik

(2016). Toward livable and healthy urban streets: Roadside vegetation provides ecosystem services where people live and move. Environmental Science & Policy, 62, 24–33.

57.

Soltani

Hosseinpour

Zare

(2018). The development and assessment of environmental features associated with walkability of urban streets. Theoretical and Empirical Researches in Urban Management, 13(1), 22–36.

58.

Stamps

A. E.

III . (2010). Use of static and dynamic media to simulate environments: A meta-analysis. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 111, 355–364.

59.

Sundquist

Eriksson

Kawakami

Skog

Ohlsson

Arvidsson

(2011). Neighborhood walkability, physical activity, and walking behavior: The Swedish Neighborhood and Physical Activity (SNAP) study. Social Science & Medicine, 72(8), 1266–1273.

60.

Tribby

C. P.

Miller

H. J.

Brown

B. B.

Werner

C. M.

Smith

K. R.

(2016). Assessing built environment walkability using activity-space summary measures. Journal of Transport and Land Use, 9(1), 187–207.

61.

Weinstein Agrawal

Schlossberg

Irvin

. (2008). How far, by which route and why? A spatial analysis of pedestrian preference. Journal of Urban Design, 13(1), 81–98.

62.

Wellborn

(2009, April 14). Columbia Heights Civic Plaza open by the end of summer. https://dc.urbanturf.com/articles/blog/columbia_heights_civic_plaza_open_by_the_end_of_summer/798

63.

Werner

C. M.

Brown

B. B.

Stump

Tribby

C. P.

Jensen

Miller

H. J.

Strebel

Messina

(2018). Street use and design: Daily rhythms on four streets that differ in rated walkability. Journal of Urban Design, 23(4), 603–619.

64.

Whyte

W. H.

(1980). The social life of small urban spaces. The Conservation Foundation.

65.

Whyte

W. H.

(1988). City: Rediscovering the center. Doubleday.

66.

Yavuz

Welch

E. W.

(2010). Addressing fear of crime in public space: Gender differences in reaction to safety measures in train transit. Urban Studies, 47(12), 2491–2515.

67.

Zieff

S. G.

Chaudhuri

Musselman

(2016). Creating neighborhood recreational space for youth and children in the urban environment: Play(ing in the) streets in San Francisco. Children and Youth Services Review, 70, 95–101.