Student Experience Outcomes in Racially Integrated Schools: Looking Beyond Test Scores in Six Districts

Abstract

In this study, we examine eight social and emotional outcomes (e.g., student engagement, sense of belonging) analyzing differences for students who attend racially diverse schools. Drawing on survey responses from roughly 26,000 students, we find that racially diverse schools are associated with more positive social and emotional outcomes for all students. Strikingly, we find that these outcomes are most uniformly positive among white students, whose families have long represented the strongest opposition to systematic racial desegregation. In light of these results, this study has implications for educators, advocates, researchers, and policy makers during a time of renewed attention to school integration.

Keywords

desegregation integration race student outcomes

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Civil Liberties Union [ACLU]. (2019). Cops and no counselors. https://www.aclu.org/report/cops-and-no-counselors

Asycue

Frankenberg

Siegel-Hawley

(2017). The complementary benefits of racial and socioeconomic diversity in schools. National Coalition on School Diversity. https://school-diversity.org/pdf/DiversityResearchBriefNo10.pdf

Baltimore Sun. (2019, September 6). In Howard County, a ‘courageous’ plan to redraw school boundaries tests community’s commitment to diversity. https://www.baltimoresun.com/education/bs-md-howard-school-redistricting-20190906-xhzkmkf2zvgcxdkbd3vqdanblm-story.html

Bernal

D. D.

(2002). Critical race theory, Latino critical theory, and critical raced-gendered epistemologies: Recognizing students of color as holders and creators of knowledge. Qualitative Inquiry, 8(1), 105–126.

Billingham

C. M.

Hunt

M. O.

(2016). School racial composition and parental choice: New evidence on the preferences of white parents in the United States. Sociology of Education, 89(2), 99–113.

Boger

J. C.

Orfield

(Eds.). (2005). School resegregation: Must the South turn back? University of North Carolina Press.

Boston Indicators. (2019). The changing faces of Greater Boston. The Boston Foundation. https://www.bostonindicators.org/-/media/indicators/boston-indicators-reports/report-files/changing-faces-2019/indicators-changing-facesf2web.pdf

Brown v. Board of Education, 347 U.S. 483 (1954).

Charles

C. Z.

(2003). The dynamics of racial residential segregation. Annual Review of Sociology 29(1), 167–207. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.soc.29.010202.100002

10.

City of New York Department of Education. (2019, June 10). Mayor de Blasio, Schools Chancellor Carranza announce adoption of School Diversity Advisory Group Recommendations. https://www1.nyc.gov/office-of-the-mayor/news/292-19/mayor-de-blasio-schools-chancellor-carranza-adoption-school-diversity-advisory-group

11.

Coleman

J. S.

Campbell

Hobson

McPartland

Mood

A. M.

Weinfeld

F. D.

York

R. L.

(1966). Equality of educational opportunity. National Center for Educational Statistics. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED012275.pdf

12.

Crain

R. L.

Mahard

R. E.

(1983). The effect of research methodology on desegregation-achievement studies: A meta-analysis. American Journal of Sociology, 88(5), 839–854.

13.

Crain

T. P.

(2019). Jefferson County to offer school choice under desegregation plan. https://www.al.com/news/2019/05/jefferson-county-to-offer-school-choice-under-desegregation-plan.html

14.

Cummings

(2014). The new statistics: Why and how. Psychological Science, 25(1), 7–29.

15.

Delmont

M. F.

(2016). Why busing failed: Race, media, and the national resistance to school desegregation. University of California Press.

16.

Eaton

S. E.

(2001). The Other Boston busing story: What’s won and lost across the boundary line. Yale University Press.

17.

Erickson

A. T.

(2016). Making the unequal metropolis: School desegregation and its limits. University of Chicago Press.

18.

Frankenberg

(2010). Exploring the difference in diverse schools’ destinies: A research note. Teachers College Record. http://www.tcrecord.org/Content.asp?ContentID=15929

19.

Frankenberg

Ayscue

Orfield

(2019, May 10). Harming our common future: America’s segregated schools 65 years after Brown. UCLA Civil Rights Project-Proyecto Derechos Civiles. https://escholarship.org/uc/item/23j1b9nv

20.

Frankenberg

Lee

C. Q.

(2008). The post-Parents Involved challenge: Confronting extralegal obstacles to integration. Ohio State Law Journal, 69(5), 1015–1071.

21.

García

S. B.

Guerra

P. L.

(2004). Deconstructing deficit thinking: Working with educators to create more equitable learning environments. Education and Urban Society, 36(2), 150–168. https://doi.org/10.1177/0013124503261322

22.

Garda

R. A.

(2011). The white interest in school integration. Florida Law Review, 63, 600–652.

23.

Gagnon

Schneider

(2019). Holistic school quality measurement and the future of accountability: Pilot-test results. Educational Policy, 33(5), 734–760.

24.

Gurin

Dey

Hurtado

Gurin

(2002). Diversity and higher education: Theory and impact on educational outcomes. Harvard Educational Review, 72(3), 330–367.

25.

Hallinan

M. T.

(1998). Diversity effects on student outcomes: Social science evidence. Ohio State Law Journal, 59, 733–754.

26.

Hannah-Jones

(2016). Choosing a school for my daughter in a segregated city. New York Times, June 12. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/12/magazine/choosing-a-school-for-my-daughter-in-a-segregated-city.html

27.

Holme

J. J.

(2002). Buying homes, buying schools: School choice and the social construction of school quality. Harvard Educational Review, 72(2), 177–206.

28.

IntegrateNYC. (n.d.) Real integration – IntegrateNYC. https://www.integratenyc.org/realintegration

29.

Johnson

R. C.

(2011). Long-run impacts of school desegregation and school quality on adult attainments (No. w16664). National Bureau of Economic Research.

30.

Johnson

R. C.

(2019). Children of the dream: Why school integration works. Hachette Book Group.

31.

Kennedy

M. M.

Jung

R. K.

Orland

M. E.

(1986). Poverty, achievement and the distribution of compensatory education services. Office of Educational Research and Improvement, U.S. Department of Education.

32.

Koretz

D. M.

(2008). Measuring up: What educational testing really tells us. Harvard University Press.

33.

Kurlaender

Yun

J. T.

(2005). Fifty years after Brown: New evidence of the impact of school racial composition on student outcomes. International Journal of Educational Policy, Research, and Practice: Reconceptualizing Childhood Studies, 6(1), 51–78.

34.

Kurlaender

Yun

J. T.

(2007). Measuring school racial composition and student outcomes in a multiracial society. American Journal of Education, 113(2), 213–242.

35.

Lewis

A. E.

Diamond

J. B.

(2015). Despite the best intentions: How racial inequality thrives in good schools. Oxford University Press.

36.

Loeb

Christian

M. S.

Hough

Meyer

R. H.

Rice

A. B.

West

M. R.

(2018). School effects on social-emotional learning: Findings from the firts large-scale panel survey of students. PACE, Stanford Graduate School of Education.

37.

Mayer

S. E.

(2002). The influence of parental income on children’s outcomes. Knowledge Management Group, Ministry of Social Development.

38.

Y. S.

Kurlaender

(2005). The future of race-conscious policies in K–12 public schools: Support from recent legal opinions and social science research. In Boger

J. C.

Orfield

(Eds.), School resegregation: Must the South turn back? University of North Carolina Press.

39.

McInerny

(2019, August 14). Austin failed at desegregation before. That history influences today’s school closure decisions. KUT Austin. https://www.kut.org/post/austin-failed-desegregation-history-influences-todays-school-closure-decisions

40.

McRae

E. G.

(2018). Mothers of massive resistance: White women and the politics of white supremacy. Oxford University Press.

41.

Mickelson

R. A.

(2008). Twenty-first century social science on school racial diversity and educational outcomes. Ohio State Law Journal, 69, 1173.

42.

Mickelson

R. A.

Nkomo

(2012). Integrated schooling, life course outcomes, and social cohesion in multiethnic democratic societies. Review of Research in Education, 36(1), 197–238.

43.

Milner

H. R.

(2006). The promise of Black Teachers’ success with Black Students. Educational Foundations, 20, 89–104.

44.

National Academy of Education. (2007). Race conscious policies for assigning students to schools. https://nepc.colorado.edu/sites/default/files/Brief-NAE.pdf

45.

Nunnaly

(1978). Psychometric theory. McGraw-Hill.

46.

Orfield

(2001a). Diversity challenged: Evidence on the impact of affirmative action. Harvard Education Press.

47.

Orfield

(2001b). Schools more separate: Consequences of a decade of resegregation. Harvard Civil Rights Project. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED459217.pdf

48.

Orfield

Lee

(2004). Brown at 50: King’s dream or Plessy’s nightmare? The Civil Rights Project, Harvard University.

49.

Orfield

Lee

(2006). Racial transformation and the changing nature of racial segregation. The Civil Rights Project, Harvard University.

50.

Orfield

Yun

J. T.

(1999). Resegregation in American schools. UCLA: The civil rights project/proyecto derechos civiles. https://escholarship.org/uc/item/6d01084d

51.

Page

S. E.

(2008). The difference: How the power of diversity creates better groups, firms, schools, and societies. Princeton University Press.

52.

Petek

Pope

(2016). The multidimensional impact of teachers on students. University of Chicago Working Paper.

53.

Pettigrew

T. F.

Tropp

L. R.

(2006). A meta-analytic test of intergroup contact theory. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 90(5), 751–783. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.90.5.751

54.

Reardon

S. F.

Firebaugh

(2002). Measures of multigroup segregation. Sociological Methodology, 32(1), 33–67.

55.

Roda

Stuart Wells

A. S.

(2013). School choice policies and racial segregation: Where White Parents’ good intentions, anxiety, and privilege collide. American Journal of Education, 119(2), 261–293.

56.

Rothstein

Jacobsen

(2006). The goals of education. Phi Delta Kappan, 88(4), 264–272. https://doi.org/10.1177/003172170608800405

57.

Rucinski

C. L.

(2015). Teacher-child relationships, classroom emotional climate, and elementary students’ social-emotional and academic development. ETD collection for Fordham University. AAI1601580. https://fordham.bepress.com/dissertations/AAI1601580

58.

Schneider

(2017). Beyond test scores: A better way to measure school quality. Harvard University Press.

59.

Sheff v. O’Neill. (1996). 238 Conn. 1, 678 A.2d 126.

60.

Sheff v. O’Neill Stipulation and Proposed Order. (2013, December 13). Judicial district of Hartford, Docket No. HHD-X07-CV89-4026240-S. http://ctschoolfinance.org/resources/sheff-v-oneill

61.

Siegel-Hawley

(2012). How non-minority students also benefit from racially diverse schools. National Coalition on School Diversity. https://www.school-diversity.org/pdf/DiversityResearchBriefNo8.pdf

62.

Stuart Wells

. (2009). Both sides now: The story of school desegregation’s graduates. University of California Press.

63.

Stuart Wells

Baldridge

B. J.

Duran

Grzesikowsky

Lofton

Roda

Warner

White

. (2009). Boundary crossing for diversity, equity and achievement: Inter-district school desegregation and educational opportunity. Charles Hamilton Houston Institute for Race and Justice, Harvard Law School.

64.

The Century Foundation. (2016). How racially diverse schools and classrooms can benefit all students. https://tcf.org/content/report/how-racially-diverse-schools-and-classrooms-can-benefit-all-students/

65.

The Century Foundation. (2018). Diverse-by-design charter schools. https://tcf.org/content/report/diverse-design-charter-schools/

66.

Tung

Carlo

V. D.

Colón

Del Razo

J. L.

Diamond

J. B.

Frazier Raynor

Graves

Kuttner

P. J.

Miranda

Rose

(2015). Promising practices and unfinished business: Fostering equity and excellence for Black and Latino males. Center for Collaborative Education and Annenberg Institute for School Reform, Brown University.

67.

U.S. Department of Education and U.S. Department of Justice. (2011). Guidance on the voluntary use of race to achieve diversity and avoid racial isolation in elementary and secondary schools. http://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ocr/docs/guidance-ese-201111.pdf

68.

Vigdor

Ludwig

(2007). Segregation and the black-white test score gap (No. w12988). National Bureau of Economic Research.

69.

Welner

K. G.

(2006). K–12 race-conscious student assignment policies: Law, social science, and diversity. Review of Educational Research, 76(3), 349–382.

70.

West

Pier

Fricke

Hough

Loeb

Meyer

R. H.

Rice

A. B.

(2018). Trends in student social emotional learning: Evidence from the CORE distrcits. PACE, Stanford Graduate School of Education.