An extensive meta-analysis, including 52 studies, was undertaken on the relationship between character education and student achievement and behavioral outcomes. Additional analyses were done to determine whether the effects of character education differed by student grade level, locale, race, and so on. The results indicated that character education is associated with higher levels of educational outcomes, no matter what type of standardized or nonstandardized measure was employed. Character education was also related to higher levels of expressions of love, integrity, compassion, and self-discipline. Overall, character education had somewhat greater effects for children in high school rather than those who were in elementary school. The effects of character education did not differ by the race of the children. The significance of these results is discussed.
*AberJ. L.JonesS. M.BrownJ. L.ChaudryN.SamplesF. (1998). Resolving conflict creativity: Evaluating the developmental effects of a school-based violence prevention program in neighborhood and classroom context. Development and Psychopathology, 10, 187-213.
2.
ArthurJ. (2014). Traditional approaches to character education in Britain and America. In NucciL. P.KrettenauerT.NarvaezD. (Eds.), Handbook of moral and character education (pp. 43-60). New York, NY: Routledge.
3.
*BattistichV. (2003). Effects of a school-based program to enhance prosocial development on children’s peer relations and social adjustment. Journal of Research in Character Education, 1, 1-17.
4.
*BattistichV.SolomonD.WatsonM. (1989). Effects of an elementary school program to enhance prosocial behavior on children’s cognitive-social problem-solving skills and strategies. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 10, 147-169.
5.
*BavarianN.LewisK. M.DuBoisD. L.AcockA.VuchinichS.SilverthornN.. . . FlayB. R. (2013). Using social-emotional and character development to improve academic outcomes: A matched-pair, cluster-randomized controlled trial in low-income, urban schools. Journal of School Health, 83, 771-774.
6.
*BeetsM. W.FlayB. R.VuchinichS.SnyderF. J.AcockA.LiK. (2009). Using a social and character development program to prevent substance abuse, violent behaviors, and sexual activity among elementary school students in Hawaii. American Journal of Public Health, 99, 1438-1445.
7.
BennettW. J. (1996). The book of virtues. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster.
8.
BennettW. J. (2011). The book of man: Readings on the path to manhood. Nashville, TN: Thomas Nelson.
9.
*BenningaJ. S.BerkowitzM. W.KuehnP.SmithK. (2003). The relationship of character education implementation and academic achievement in elementary schools. Journal of Research in Character Education, 1, 19-32.
10.
BerkowitzM. W. (1998). A primer for evaluating: A character education initiative. Washington, DC: Character Education Partnership.
11.
BerkowitzM. W.BierM. (2005). The interpersonal roots of character education. In LapsleyD. K.PowerF. C. (Eds.), Character psychology and character education (pp. 268-285). Notre Dame, IN: Notre Dame University Press.
12.
*BotvinG. J.GriffinK. W.DazT.Ifill-WilliamM. (2001). Drug abuse prevention among minority adolescents: Postest and one-year follow-up of a school-based prevention intervention. Prevention Science, 2, 1-13.
13.
*BotvinG. J.GriffinK. W.PaulE.MacaulayA. P. (2003). Preventing tobacco and alcohol use among elementary school students through life skills training. Journal of Child & Adolescent Substance Abuse, 12(4), 1-18.
14.
BrooksD. (2011). The social animal: The hidden sources of love, character, and achievement. New York, NY: Random House.
15.
BrunnP. (2014). Pedagogy for the whole child. In NucciL. P.KrettenauerT.NarvaezD. (Eds.), Handbook of moral and character education (pp. 263-271). New York, NY: Routledge.
16.
CarlinD. R. (2000). Schools cannot teach moral values. In WillimsMary E. (Ed.), Education: Opposing viewpoints (pp. 144-147). San Diego, CA: Greenhaven Press.
17.
CarlstonL. (2004). Surviving Columbine: How faith helps us find peace when tragedy strikes. Salt Lake City, UK: Deseret.
18.
CiceroM. T. (2001). On moral ends. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
19.
CohenJ. (1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences (2nd ed.). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
20.
*ColemanJ.HofferT.KilgoreS. (1982). High school achievement: Public, catholic, and private schools compared. New York, NY: Basic Books.
21.
*CorriganM. W.GroveD.VincentP. F.ChapmanP.WallsR. T. (2007). The importance of multidimensional baseline measurements to assessment of integrated character education models. Journal of Research in Character Education, 5, 103-129.
22.
*DiBiaseA. (2010). The impact of a psych-educational prevention program for behaviorally at-risk students, equip for educators. Journal of Character Education, 8, 21-59.
23.
*EliasM. J.GaraM. A.SchuylerT. F.Branden-MullerL. R.SayetteM. A. (1991). The promotion of social competence: Longitudinal study of a preventive school-based program. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 61, 409-417.
24.
*FlayB. R.AllredC. G. (2003). Long-term effects of the Positive Action Program. American Journal of Health Behavior, 27(Suppl. 1), S6-S21.
25.
*FlayB. R.AllredC. G.OrdwayN. (2001). Effects of the Positive Action Program on achievement and discipline: Two matched-control comparisons. Prevention Science, 2, 71-89.
26.
*FoaC.BrugmanB.ManciniT. (2012). School moral atmosphere and normative orientation to explain aggressive and transgressive behaviors at secondary school. Journal of Moral Education, 41, 1-22.
27.
GattoJ. T. (2001). The underground history of American schooling. New York, NY: Oxford Village Press.
28.
GlassG. V.McGawB.SmithM. L. (1981). Meta-analysis in social research. Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE.
29.
*GradyF. A. (1999). Cluster school: A study of the impact in adulthood of a moral education intervention project. Dissertation Abstracts International, Section A: Humanities and Social Sciences, 55(7A), 1808.
30.
*GrayE. K.WatsonD. (2002). General and specific traits of personality, and their relation to sleep and academic performance. Journal of Personality, 70, 177-206.
31.
GreenhouseJ. B.IyengarS. (1994). Sensitivity analysis and diagnosis. In CooperH.IyengarS. (Eds.), Handbook of research synthesis (pp. 383-398). New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
32.
*HarringtonN. G.GilesM.HoyleR. H.FeeneyG. J.YungbluthS. C. (2001). Evaluation of the all stars character education and Problem Behavior Prevention Program: Effects on mediator and outcome variable for middle school students. Health Education & Behavior, 29, 533-546.
33.
HedgesL. V.VeveaJ. L. (1998). Fixed and random effects models in meta-analysis. Psychological Method, 3, 486-504.
34.
HenningfeldD. A. (2008). Standardized testing. Detroit, MI: Greenhaven Press.
35.
*HofferT.GreeleyA. M.ColemanJ. S. (1985). Achievement growth in public and Catholic schools. Sociology of Education, 58, 74-97.
36.
*Hofmann-TowfighN. (2007). Do students’ values change in different types of schools?Journal of Moral Education, 36, 453-473.
37.
*HoltzappleC. K.GriswoldJ. S.CirilloK.RosebrockJ.NouzaN.BerryC. (2011). Implementation of a school-wide adolescent character education and prevention program: Evaluating the relationships between principal support, faculty implementation, and student outcomes. Journal of Character Education, 9, 71-90.
38.
JeynesW. (2002a). A meta-analysis of the effects of attending religious schools and religiosity on Black and Hispanic academic achievement. Education and Urban Society, 35(1), 27-49.
39.
JeynesW. (2002b). Educational policy and the effects of attending a religious school on the academic achieveement of children. Educational Policy,16(3), 406-424.
40.
JeynesW. (2003). A meta-analysis: The effects of parental involvement on minority children’s academic achievement. Education and Urban Society, 35(2), 202-218.
41.
JeynesW. (2006). Standardized tests and Froebel’s original kindergarten model. Teachers College Record, 108(1), 1937-1959.
42.
JeynesW. (2007). American educational history: School, society, and the common good. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
43.
JeynesW. (2009a). The relationship between Bible literacy and academic achievement and school behavior. Education and Urban Society, 41(4), 419-436.
44.
JeynesW. (2009b). The relationship between biblical literacy, academic achievement, and school behavior among Christian- and public- school students. Journal of Research on Christian Education, 18(1), 36-55.
45.
JeynesW. (2011). Help families by fostering parental involvement. Phi Delta Kappan, 93(3), 38-39.
46.
JeynesW. (2012). A meta-analysis on the effects and contributions of public, public charter, and religious schools on student outcomes. Peabody Journal of Education, 87(3), 305-335.
47.
*JohnsonD. W.JohnsonR. T.DudleyB.MagnusonD. (1995). The impact of conflict resolution training on middle school students. Journal of Social Psychology, 135, 673-686.
48.
*JohnsonD. W.JohnsonR. T.DudleyB.MitchellJ.FredricksonJ. (1997). The impact of conflict resolution training on middle school students. Journal of Social Psychology, 137, 11-21.
49.
*JohnsonK. A. (1999). Comparing math scores of black students in D.C.’s public and Catholic schools. Washington, DC: Heritage Foundation.
50.
*JohnsonS. K.HershbergR. M.ArbeitM. R.DeSouzaL. M.CallinaK. S.GutierrezA. S.. . . RubinR. O. (2014). Exploring characteristics of young adult men: Initial findings from mixed methods evaluation of an all-male, character focused trade school. Journal of Character Education, 10, 129-154.
51.
JonesM. L.LewisP. A.ReffittK. E. (2013). Toward human flourishing: Character, practical wisdom, and professional formation. Macon, GA: Mercer University Press.
52.
KhanY. (1997). Japanese moral education: Past and present. Madison, WI: Farleigh Dickinson University Press.
53.
KrisjanssonK. (2015). Aristolelian character education. New York, NY: Abington.
LapsleyD. K.NarvaezD. (2006). Character education. In RenningerK. A.SigelI. E. (Eds.), Handbook of child psychology, Vol. 4: Child psychology in practice (pp. 248-296). Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley.
56.
LapsleyD. K.PowerF. C. (2005). Moral psychology and the crossroads. In LapsleyD. K.PowerF. C. (Eds.), Character psychology & character education (pp. 18-35). Notre Dame, IN: Notre Dame University Press.
57.
*LewisK. M. (2012). Evaluation of a socio-emotional and character development program: Methods and outcomes. Dissertation Abstracts, 74(3-B), E.
58.
LickonaT. (1991). Educating for character. New York, NY: Bantam Books.
59.
LickonaT. (1993). The return of character education. Educational Leadership, 51(3), 6-11.
60.
LickonaT. (2004). Character matters. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster.
61.
*LuoR.ShiY.ZhangL.LiuC.LiH.RozelleS.SharbonoB. (2011). Community service, educational performance and social responsibility in Northwest China. Journal of Moral Education, 40, 181-202.
62.
MarrouH. I. (1956). A history of education in antiquity. New York, NY: Sheed & Ward.
63.
*MarshallJ. C.CaldwellS. D.FosterJ. (2011). Moral education the CHARACTERplus way. Journal of Moral Education, 40, 51-72.
64.
MateraD. (2001). A cry for character. Paramus, NJ: Prentice Hall.
65.
McClellanB. E. (1999). Moral education in America. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
66.
*McClowryS.SnowD. L.Tamis-LeMondaC. S. (2005). An evaluation of the effects of “insights” on the behavior of inner city primary school children. Journal of Primary Prevention, 26, 567-584.
67.
MiddletonR. (2004). Religion and education. In RyanM. C. (Ed.), Living in colonial America (pp. 65-74). San Diego, CA: Greenhaven Press.
68.
*MillerT. W.KrausR. F.VeltkampL. J. (2005). Character education as a prevention strategy in school-related violence. Journal of Primary Prevention, 26, 455-466.
69.
MooreJ. P. (2005). One nation under God: The history of prayer in America. New York, NY: Doubleday.
70.
*MucherahW.LapsleyD. K.MielsJ.HortonM. (2004). An intervention to improve sociomoral climate in elementary school classrooms: An evaluation of Don’t Laugh at Me. Journal of Research in Character Education, 2, 45-58.
71.
*MunozM. A.VanderharrJ. E. (2006). Literacy-embedded character education in a large urban district: Effects of the child development project on elementary school students and teachers. Journal of Research in Character Education, 4, 47-64.
72.
*MuscottH. S.MannE. L.LeBrunM. R. (2008). Positive behavioral interventions and supports in New Hampshire: Effects of large-scale implementation of schoolwide positive behavior support on student discipline and academic achievement. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 10, 190-205.
73.
NeuhausR. J. (2001). The best of the “public square”: Book 2. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.
74.
OliverT. S. (1996, March25). Neutral and free: Religion, values, and the public schools. Sojourners, pp. 12-13.
75.
PalmerJ. A. (2001). Fifty major thinkers on education. London: Routledge.
76.
*ParkerD. C.NelsonJ. S.BurnsM. K. (2010). Comparison of correlates of classroom behavior problems in schools with and without a school-wide character education program. Psychology in the Schools, 47, 817-827.
77.
PaulR.ElderL. (2002). Critical thinking: Tools for taking charge of your professional and personal life. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Financial Times.
78.
*PrinceC. K.HoE. A.HansonS. B. (2010). Effects of a school based program to improve adaptive school behavior and social competencies among elementary school youth: The Living Skills Program. Journal of Character Education, 8(2), 39-59.
79.
PurpelD. E. (2005). Moral outrage in education. New York, NY: Peter Lang.
80.
RaeT.MacConvilleR. (2015). Using positive psychology to enhance student achievement: A school-based programme for character education. Abingdon, UK: Routledge.
81.
*RaudenbushS.BrykA. S. (1986). A hierarchical model for studying school effects. Sociology of Education, 59, 1-17.
82.
*RenfroJ.HuebnerR.RitcheyB. (2003). The effects of a university and high school partnership. Journal of School Violence, 2, 81-99.
83.
RyanK.BohlinK. E. (1999). Building character in schools: Practical ways to bring moral instruction to life. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
84.
SalkindN. J.RasmussenK. (2007). Encyclopedia of measurement and statistics. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
85.
SangerM. N.OsguthorpeR. D.FenstermacherG. D. (2013). The moral work of teaching in teacher education. In SangerM. N.OsguthorpeR. D. (Eds.), The moral work of teaching and teacher education (pp. 3-13). New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
86.
*SeiderS.GilbertJ. K.NorickS. (2013). The role of moral and performance character strengths in predicting achievement and conduct among urban middle school students. Teachers College Record, 115(8), 1-34.
87.
*SherblomS. A.MarshallJ. C.SherblomJ. C. (2006). The relationship between school climate and math and reading achievement. Journal of Research in Character Education, 4, 19-31.
88.
SiegalH. (2009). The Oxford handbook of the philosophy of education. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
89.
SikorskiR. (1993). Controversies in constitutional law. New York, NY: Garland.
90.
*SkaggsG.BodenhornN. (2006). Relationships between implementing character education, student behavior, and student achievement. Journal of Advanced Academics, 18, 82-114.
91.
*SnyderF.FlayB.VuchinichS.AcockA.WashburnI.BeetsM.LiK.-K. (2010). Impact of a social-emotional and character development program on school-level indicators of academic achievement, absenteeism, and disciplinary outcomes: A matched-pair, cluster randomized, controlled trial. Journal of Research of Educational Effectiveness, 3, 28-55.
92.
*SorianoE.FrancoC.SleeterC. (2011). The impact of a values education program for adolescent Romanies in Spain on their feelings of self-realization. Journal of Moral Education, 40, 217-235.
93.
StengelB. S. (2013). Teaching moral responsibility: Practical reasoning in a pedagogical “wonderland.” In SangerM. N.OsguthorpeR. D. (Eds.), The moral work of teaching and teacher education (pp. 44-59). New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
94.
StengelB. S.TomA. R. (2006). Moral matters: Five ways to develop the moral life of Schools. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
95.
*StephensJ. M. (2004). Motivation, morality, and academic (mis)conduct among adolescents. Stanford, CA: Stanford University.
96.
*TwemlowS. W.FonagyP.SaccoF. C.GiesM. L.EvansR.EwbankR. (2001). Creating a peaceful school learning environment: A controlled study of an elementary school intervention to reduce violence. American Journal of Psychiatry, 158, 808-810.
97.
*van der VeldenF.BrugmanD.BoomJ.KoopsW. (2010). Effects of EQUIP for educators on students’ self-serving cognitive distortions, moral judgement, and antisocial behavior. Journal of Character Education, 8, 77-95.
98.
*WilliamsD. D.YancharS. C.JensenL. C.LewisC. (2003). Character education in a public high school: A multi-year inquiry into unified studies. Journal of Moral Education, 32, 3-33.
99.
WirtzW. (1977). On further examination. New York, NY: College Entrance Examination Board.
100.
*YurkewiczC. (2009). Happiness in adolescence: Contributions of self-control, hope, and personal strivings. New York, NY: Saint John’s University.
101.
*ZsolnaiA. (2002). Relationship between children’s social competence, learning, and school achievement. Educational Psychology, 22, 317-320.
