Mastering political time: China’s graduates in the quest for temporal sovereignty through civil service exam battles

Abstract

Spanish

French

This article investigates how China’s graduates navigate the civil service exam as a means to reclaim temporal sovereignty amid the structural shift of ‘state advances, private sector retreats’. The exam transcends its role as a career gateway, becoming a symbolic site where individuals resist the temporal volatility of the private sector – marked by age-based layoffs and fragmented rhythms – by aligning with the state’s stable temporal structures. Yet this pursuit unveils a paradox of ironic compliance: in rejecting market-driven temporal chaos, individuals surrender to the regimented rhythms of state governance, exchanging one form of uncertainty for another. This tension influences career paths, personal relationships, and social identities, as civil servants are valorized for mastering political time. The article conceptualizes political time as a governance tool that, akin to economic extraction, mines individuals’ temporal resources – attention, energy, and life plans – and redirects them toward state-defined objectives. By illuminating this dynamic, the article reveals how temporal governance simultaneously constrains and enables the construction of temporal sovereignties in modern China.

Keywords

China governance political time state advances and private sector retreats temporal sovereignty

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adam

(2013) Time and Social Theory. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.

Awâsis

(2020) Anishinaabe time: Temporalities and impact assessment in pipeline reviews. Journal of Political Ecology 27(1): 830–852.

Braun

Clarke

(2012) Thematic Analysis. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

Burns

Wang

(2010) Civil service reform in China: Impacts on civil servants’ behaviour. The China Quarterly 201: 58–78.

Chen

Hong

(2024) Business of involution: Self-study rooms and work culture in China. Journal of Cultural Economy 17(3): 396–412.

Chen

(2021) No, I cannot just walk away’: Government career entrenchment in China. International Review of Administrative Sciences 87(4): 944–961.

Chen

Hsieh

Chen

, et al. (2022) Like father, like son: Explicating parental influence on adult children’s public sector preference. International Public Management Journal 25(2): 261–279.

China News (2024) Dr. Stanford is proposed to serve as a township civil servant: Is it a pity? Available at: https://www.chinanews.com.cn/m/sh/2024/06-20/10237490.shtml (accessed 25 June 2024).

Chinese Civil Service Law (2018) Chapter IV Recruitment of Civil Servants (Public Examination). Available at: https://www.gov.cn/guowuyuan/2018-12/30/content_5353490.htm (accessed 5 September 2022).

10.

Claassen

(2012) Temporal autonomy in a laboring society. Inquiry 55(5): 543–562.

11.

Clancy

(2014) The politics of temporality: Autonomy, temporal spaces and resoluteness. Time & Society 23(1): 28–48.

12.

Dong

(2023) The dilemma of Foxconn moms: Social reproduction and the rise of ‘gig manufacturing’ in China. Critical Sociology 49(7–8): 1231–1249.

13.

Feng

(2022) Domesticating political resistance: Rhetoric, time, and (the limits of) settler sovereignty in Thomas Hobbes’ Leviathan. Theory & Event 25(1): 4–24.

14.

Foucault

(2023) Discipline and punish. In: Longhofer

Winchester

(eds) Social Theory Re-wired. London: Routledge, pp. 291–299.

15.

Gao

Kong

(2019) Who secures job opportunities in the Chinese government? Evidence based on the first jobs of graduates from a Chinese college. Pacific Economic Review 24(3): 447–463.

16.

Gore

(2019) The Communist Party-dominated governance model of China: Legitimacy, accountability, and meritocracy. Polity 51(1): 161–194.

17.

Hildebrandt

(2006) Balance between work and life: New corporate impositions through flexible working time or opportunity for time sovereignty? European Societies 8(2): 251–271.

18.

Hjärpe

(2022) Measurable time is governable time: Exploring temporality and time governance in childcare social work. Time & Society 31(2): 291–314.

19.

Hoffman

(2006) Autonomous choices and patriotic professionalism: On governmentality in late-socialist China. Economy and Society 35(4): 550–570.

20.

Huang

Chen

(2016) Revolving out of the Party-State: The Xiahai entrepreneurs and circumscribing government power in China. Journal of Contemporary China 25(97): 41–58.

21.

Jiang

(2022) Understanding bureaucratic involution through Weber’s bureaucracy: China’s central inspection teams in practice. Modern China 48(6): 1179–1207.

22.

Johansson

Feng

(2016) The state advances, the private sector retreats? Firm effects of China’s great stimulus programme. Cambridge Journal of Economics 40(6): 1635–1668.

23.

Kahn

(2006) Political time: Sovereignty and the transtemporal community. Cardozo Law Review 28: 259.

24.

Kunzl

Messner

(2023) Temporal structuring as self-discipline: Managing time in the budgeting process. Organization Studies 44(9): 1439–1464.

25.

Lai

Song

Wong

, et al. (2016) Transition to higher education in contemporary China: A study of high school graduates in urban Nanjing. Journal of Sociology 52(1): 83–102.

26.

Gore

(2018) Merit-based patronage: Career incentives of local leading cadres in China. Journal of Contemporary China 27(109): 85–102.

27.

(2023) Managerial technique and worker subjectivity in dialogue: Understanding overwork in China’s internet industry. Work, Employment and Society 37(6): 1699–1716.

28.

Lin

Gullotta

(2021) Disarticulating Gingnian: Chinese youth beyond ‘rising tides’ and ‘lying flat’. Made in China Journal 6(3): 20–30.

29.

Liu

(2023) The role of the state in influencing work conditions in China’s internet industry: Policy, evidence, and implications for industrial relations. Journal of Industrial Relations 65(1): 3–21.

30.

(2021) Educating the elites: School counselors as education nannies in Urban China. Comparative Education Review 65(3): 493–512.

31.

McSweeney

(2011) Contracts, Consent, and Fate: Framing the Chinese Civil Service Examinations as Mechanisms of Social Conditioning and Political Domination. Tuscaloosa, AL: University of Alabama Press.

32.

Miyazaki

(1981) China’s Examination Hell: The Civil Service Examinations of Imperial China. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

33.

National Civil Service Administration (2020) Civil servant recruitment regulations. Available at: http://www.scs.gov.cn/zcfg/202001/t20200108_16198.html (accessed 1 January 2023).

34.

Paulsen

(2017) Slipping into functional stupidity: The bifocality of organizational compliance. Human Relations 70(2): 185–210.

35.

Pieke

(2018) Party spirit: Producing a communist civil religion in contemporary China. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 24(4): 709–729.

36.

Ramsay

(2017) Incommensurable futures and displaced lives: Sovereignty as control over time. Public Culture 29(3): 515–538.

37.

Ren

Liu

(2019) Domesticating ‘transnational cultural capital’: The Chinese state and diasporic technopreneur returnees. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 45(13): 2308–2327.

38.

Rifkin

(2017) Beyond Settler Time: Temporal Sovereignty and Indigenous Self-Determination. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

39.

Shirk

(2020) Competitive Comrades: Career Incentives and Student Strategies in China. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

40.

Song

(2023) Empowered in business or penalised in marriage: Experiences of single female entrepreneurs in China. Work, Employment and Society 37(1): 3–19.

41.

(2023) Lie flat’: Chinese youth subculture in the context of the pandemic and national rejuvenation. Continuum 37(1): 127–139.

42.

Suen

(2006) Chronic consequences of high-stakes testing? Lessons from the Chinese civil service exam. Comparative Education Review 50(1): 46–65.

43.

Tan

(2022) Tech workers lie flat. Dissent 69(2): 32–41.

44.

Thrasher

(2019) Self-ownership as personal sovereignty. Social Philosophy and Policy 36(2): 116–133.

45.

Wang

Zhang

(2023) The making of ‘exam ronins’: Young people’s desire for public service jobs in China. Journal of Youth Studies 28: 1–16.

46.

Wang

Deng

(2017) Precarity among highly educated migrants: College graduates in Beijing, China. Urban Geography 38(10): 1497–1516.

47.

Xin

Jian

(2024) Lying flat’: Chinese youths’ resistance to overwork and the practice of stratification. Youth and Globalization 5(2): 231–251.

48.

(2021) Time, class and privilege in career imagination: Exploring study-to-work transition of Chinese international students in UK universities through a Bourdieusian lens. Time & Society 30(1): 5–29.

49.

Yang

(2024) Why current Chinese youth are enthusiastic about taking the civil service exam. Journal of Education, Humanities and Social Sciences 35: 77–82.

50.

Yee

SKL

(2024) Embedding the Party in state and society: From integrated to embedded domination during China’s COVID-19 crisis. Journal of Contemporary China 34: 271–294.

51.

Yin

Zhang

Tan

(2024) Doctoral students from Chinese prestigious universities who wish to work in the government sector: Perceptions and mechanisms. Higher Education Quarterly 78(2): 436–457.

52.

Zhai

Moskal

Read

(2021) Compelled to compete: Chinese graduates on employment and social mobility after international and domestic study. International Journal of Educational Development 84: 102432.

53.

Zhang

(2015) Crowding out meritocracy? Cultural constraints in Chinese public human resource management. Australian Journal of Public Administration 74(3): 270–282.

54.

Zhang

Spicer

(2014) Leader, you first’: The everyday production of hierarchical space in a Chinese bureaucracy. Human Relations 67(6): 739–762.