Punishing femicide: Criminal justice responses to the killing of women over four decades

Abstract

Spanish

French

The way in which nation states respond to femicide has become the focus of much attention in the past decade. The establishment of specialized police and prosecution units has been recommended and some countries have implemented specific legislation or criminal offences specific to femicide. Part of the challenge in moving beyond these legislative and policy initiatives is the dearth of reliable data that show how states are actually punishing crimes of femicide on the ground. Using data that document punishment outcomes in cases of femicide over four decades in Canada’s most populous province, this article examines how punishments compare for female and male homicide victims, across femicide subtypes and over time. Results show that cases involving female victims attract more punitive court responses overall than cases with male victims. Second, intimate and familial femicides are treated more leniently at several stages than other femicides. Finally, there have been positive changes in the punishment of femicide over time, paralleling legislative and policy responses to violence against women in Canada. Priorities for future research that address the role played by dominant stereotypes in punishment related to particular types of femicide as well as some women’s increased risk are highlighted.

Keywords

Femicide gender intimacy punishment violence

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alvazzi del Frate

Nowak

(2013) Femicide in global perspective. In: ACUNS, Femicide: A Global Issue that Demands Action. Vienna: Academic Council on the United Nations System (ACUNS).

Baldus

Woodworth

Pulaski

(1990) Equal Justice and the Death Penalty: A Legal and Empirical Analysis. Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press.

Baumer

Messner

Felson

(2000) The role of victim characteristics in the disposition of murder cases. Justice Quarterly 17(2): 281–307.

Beaulieu

Messner

(1999) Race, gender, and outcomes in first degree murder cases. Journal of Poverty 3(1): 47–68.

Belknap

(2001) The Invisible Woman: Gender, Crime and Justice, 3rd edn. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth/Thompson.

Berk

(1983) An introduction to sample selection bias in sociological data. American Sociological Review 48: 386–398.

Black

(1976) The Behavior of Law. New York: Academic Press.

Bond

Jeffries

(2014) Similar punishment? Comparing sentencing outcomes in domestic and non-domestic violence cases. British Journal of Criminology 54(5): 849–872.

Boyce

(2013) Adult criminal court statistics in Canada, 2011/2012. Juristat Catalogue No. 85-002-X. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.

10.

Campbell

Runyan

(1998) Femicide. Guest editors’ introduction. Homicide Studies 2(4): 347–352.

11.

Cohen

(1975) Applied Multiple Regression/Correlation Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

12.

Cotter

(2014) Homicide in Canada, 2013. Juristat Catalogue No. 85-002-X. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.

13.

Crenshaw

(1991) Mapping the margins: Intersectionality, identity politics, and violence against women of color. Stanford Law Review 43(6): 1241–1299.

14.

Curry

(2010) The conditional effects of victim and offender ethnicity and victim gender for sentences for non-capital cases. Punishment and Society 12(4): 438–462.

15.

Curry

Lee

Fernando Rodriguez

(2004) Does victim gender increase sentence severity? Further explorations of gender dynamics and sentencing outcomes. Crime and Delinquency 50(3): 319–343.

16.

Daly

Tonry

(1997) Gender, race and sentencing. Crime and Justice 22: 201–252.

17.

Dawson

(2006) Intimacy, violence and the law: Exploring stereotypes about victim–defendant relationship and violent crime. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 96(4): 1417–1450.

18.

Dawson

(2012) Intimacy, homicide, and punishment: Examining court outcomes over three decades. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology 45(3): 400–422.

19.

Dawson

Gartner

(1998) Differences in the characteristics of intimate femicide: The role of relationship state and relationship status. Homicide Studies 2(4): 378–399.

20.

Demaris

(1992) Logit Modeling: Practical Applications. London: Sage.

21.

Doob

(2011) The unfinished work of the Canadian Sentencing Commission. Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice 53(3): 279–297.

22.

Doob

Webster

(2006) Countering punitiveness: Understanding stability in Canada’s imprisonment rate. Law and Society Review 40(2): 325–367.

23.

Farrell

Swigert

(1986) Adjudication in homicide: An interpretative analysis of the effects of defendant and victim social characteristics. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 23(4): 349–369.

24.

Fox

(1997) Applied Regression Analysis, Linear Models and Related Methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

25.

Franklin

(2008) Women offenders, disparate treatment, and criminal justice: A theoretical, historical, and contemporary overview. Criminal Justice Studies 21(4): 341–360.

26.

Franklin

Fearn

(2008) Gender, race and formal court decision-making outcomes: Chivalry/paternalism, conflict theory or gender conflict? Journal of Criminal Justice 36(3): 279–290.

27.

Gartner

Dawson

Crawford

(1999) Woman killing: Intimate femicide in Ontario, 1974–1994. Resources for Feminist Research 26(3/4): 151–173.

28.

Gillespie

Loughran

Smith

. (2013) Exploring the role of victim sex, victim conduct, and victim–defendant relationship in capital punishment sentencing. Homicide Studies 18(2): 175–195.

29.

Glaeser

Sacerdote

(2000) The Determinants of Punishment: Deterrence, Incapacitation and Vengeance (Discussion Paper 1894). Harvard Institute of Economic Research. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.

30.

Grant

(2010) Intimate femicide: A study of sentencing trends for men who kill their intimate partners. Alberta Law Review 47: 779–822.

31.

Grant

Chunn

Boyle

(1998) The Law of Homicide. Scarborough, Ont.: Carswell.

32.

Hindson

Potter

Radelet

(2006) Race, gender, region and death sentencing in Colorado, 1980–1999. University of Colorado Law Review 77: 549–594.

33.

Holcomb

Williams

Demuth

(2004) White female victims and death penalty disparity research. Justice Quarterly 21(4): 877–902.

34.

Hotton Mahony

(2010) Women and the Criminal Justice System. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.

35.

Hotton Mahony

Turner

(2012) Police-reported clearance rates in Canada, 2010. Juristat Catalogue No. 85-002-XPE. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.

36.

IACHR (Inter-American Commission on Human Rights) (2014) Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women in British Columbia, Canada. Washington, DC: IACHR.

37.

Johnson

Dawson

(2011) Violence Against Women in Canada: Research and Policy Perspectives. Toronto: Oxford University Press.

38.

Johnson

Van Windgerden

Nieuwbeerta

(2010) Sentencing homicide offenders in the Netherlands: Offender, victim and situational influences in criminal punishment. Criminology 48(4): 981–1018.

39.

Klepper

Nagin

Tierney

(1983) Discrimination in the criminal justice system: A critical appraisal of the literature. In: Blumstein

Cohen

Martin

Tonry

(eds) Research on Sentencing: The Search for Reform, Vol. II. Washington, DC: National Academy Press, pp. 55–128.

40.

Laurent

Platzer

Idomir

(2013) Femicide: A Global Issue that Demands Action. Vienna: Academic Council on the United Nations (ACUNS) Vienna Liaison Office.

41.

Mahoney

(1991–1992) Legal images of battered women: Redefining the issue of separation. Michigan Law Review 90(1): 1–94.

42.

Manson

(2001) The Law of Sentencing. Toronto: Irwin Law.

43.

Miller

(2005) Victims as Offenders: The Paradox of Women’s Violence in Relationships. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.

44.

Mujica

Tuesta

(2014) Femicide penal response in the Americas: Indicators and the misuses of crime statistics, evidence from Peru. International Journal of Criminology and Sociological Theory 7(1): 1–21.

45.

Nowak

(2012) Femicide: A Global Problem. Small Arms Survey. Vienna: Academic Council on the United Nations System (ACUNS).

46.

NWAC (Native Women’s Association of Canada) (2010) What Their Stories Tell Us: Research Findings from the Sisters in Spirit Initiative. Ottawa: NWAC.

47.

Orme

Reis

(1991) Multiple regression with missing data. Journal of Social Service Research 15(1–2): 61–91.

48.

Pearce

(2013) An awkward silence: Missing and murdered vulnerable women and the Canadian justice system. Dissertation, University of Ottawa.

49.

Phillips

Haas

Coverdill

(2012) Disentangling victim gender and capital punishment: The role of the media. Feminist Criminology 7(2): 130–145.

50.

Pierce

Radelet

(2002) Race, region, and death sentencing in Illinois, 1988–1997. Oregon Law Review 81: 39–96.

51.

Rapaport

(1994) The death penalty and the domestic discount. In: Fineman

Mykitiuk

(eds) The Public Nature of Private Violence: The Discovery of Domestic Abuse. New York: Routledge, pp. 224–254.

52.

RCMP (Royal Canadian Mounted Police) (2014) Missing and Murdered Aboriginal Women: A National Operational Overview. Ottawa: RCMP.

53.

Richards

Jennings

Smith

. (2014) ‘Female victim effect’ in capital punishment: An examination of victim sex-specific models of juror sentence decision-making. Crime and Delinquency (Online) 18(2): 1–24.

54.

Royer

Hritz

Hans

. (2014) Victim gender and the death penalty. Cornell Law School, Legal Studies Research Paper Series.

55.

Russell

DEH

Harmes

(2001) Femicide in Global Perspective. London: Teacher’s College Press.

56.

Silverman

Kennedy

(1993) Deadly Deeds: Murder in Canada. Scarborough: Nelson.

57.

Songer

Unah

(2006) The effect of race, gender, and location on prosecutorial decisions to seek the death penalty in South Carolina. South Carolina Law Review 58: 161–205.

58.

Statistics Canada (2006) Victimization and Offending among the Aboriginal Population in Canada. Ottawa: Minister of Industry.

59.

Statistics Canada (2014) Canada’s population estimates: Age and sex, 2014. The Daily, 26 September.

60.

Stauffer

Smith

Cochran

. (2006) The interaction between victim race and gender on sentencing outcomes in capital murder trial: A further exploration. Homicide Studies 10(2): 98–117.

61.

Steffensmeier

Ulmer

Kramer

(1998) The interaction of race, gender and age in criminal sentencing: The punishment cost of being young, black, and male. Criminology 36(1): 763–798.

62.

Ulmer

(2012) Recent developments and new directions in sentencing research. Justice Quarterly 29(1): 1–40.

63.

United Nations (2011) Report of the Special Rapporteur on Violence against Women, its Causes and Consequences, Rashida Manjoo. New York: United Nations.

64.

UNODC (2011) Homicide statistics. Available at: www.unodc.org/unodc/en/data-andanalysis/homicide.html.

65.

WHO (World Health Organization) (2005) WHO Multi-Country Study on Women’s Health and Domestic Violence Against Women: Initial Results on Prevalence, Health Outcomes and Women’s Responses. Geneva: WHO.

66.

Widyono

(2008) Conceptualizing femicide. In: Strengthening Understanding of Femicide: Using Research to Galvanize Action and Accountability. Seattle, WA: PATH, pp. 7–25.

67.

Williams

Holcomb

(2004) The interactive effects of victim race and gender on death sentence disparity findings. Homicide Studies 8(4): 350–376.

68.

Williams

Demuth

Holcomb

(2007) Understanding the influence of victim gender in death penalty cases: The importance of victim race, sex-related victimization, and jury decision-making. Criminology 45(4): 865–891.