The ethical issues of biotechnology: Religious culture and the value of life

Abstract

Advances in biotechnology and medical science, especially breakthroughs in cloning and stem cell research, have raised great expectations for curing diseases, repairing damaged body tissue and organs, enabling conception at advanced age and selecting embryos based on genetic diagnosis. However, the question arises whether these advances will improve the happiness of humankind or whether human bodies are being assaulted as development resources in order to procure greater profits. This article investigates how the value of life is conceptualized by religious cultures vis-a-vis the emerging threats. With regard to the early embryonic stage of human life, the Catholic Church, for example, has raised a loud voice against the artificial termination of pregnancy. As a matter of fact, various religious cultures have showed and underpinned to a considerable extent the value of life and the direction that science and technology should take in this respect. It is argued that the globalized competition in science and technology makes it necessary to transcend the views concerning the value of life propagated by particular religious cultures.

Keywords

biotechnology ethics eugenics religion reproductive medicine value of life

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Cass L. ( 2003) Beyond Therapy: Biotechnology and the Pursuit of Happiness, A Report by the President’s Council on Bioethics. New York: HarperPerennial.

Chiba T. and Otsu T. ( 1983) Mabiki to mizuko: kosodate no Folklore [Infanticide and Aborted Fetuses: Childcare Folklore]. Tokyo: Nosangyoson Bunka Kyokai.

Fuchigami K. ( 2003) Jinko Seishoku Jidai no Chosen Jukyo [Confucianism in Korea in an age of artificial reproduction]. In: International Institute for the Study of Religions (ed.) Gendai Shukyo 2003 [Contemporary Religions 2003]. Tokyo : Tokyo-do Shuppan.

Fujime Y. ( 1999) Sei-no rekishigaku: kosho seido to dataizai taisei kara baishun boshiho to yuseihogo-ho taisei e [History of Sexual Practices: From State-Regulated Prostitution and Abortion Crime System to the Prostitution Prohibition Act and Eugenic Protection Act System]. Tokyo : Fuji Shuppan.

Fujino Y. ( 1998) Nippon fascism to yusei shiso [Japanese Fascism and Eugenic Thought]. Kyoto: Kamogawa Shuppan .

Fukuyama F. ( 2002) Our Posthuman Future: Consequences of the Biotechnology Revolution. New York: Farrar, Strauss and Giroux (Japanese translation by Suzuki Y, Diamondo-sha).

Kevles DJ ( 1985) In the Name of Eugenics: Genetics and the Uses of Human Heredity. New York: Alfred A Knopf (Japanese translation by Nishimata S, Asahi Shimbun-sha, 1993).

Morioka M. ( 2001) Seimeigaku ni nani ga dekiru ka - noshi, feminism, yusei shiso [What is Possible with Life Science? Brain Death, Feminism and Eugenic Thought]. Tokyo: Keiso Shobo.

Namihira E. ( 1996) Inochi no bunka jinruigaku [Cultural Anthropology of Life] . Tokyo: Shincho-sha.

10.

Ogino M. ( 2001) Chuzetsu ronso to America shakai: Karada o meguru senso [Abortion Debate and American Society: War Concerning the Body]. Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten.

11.

Sakai R. ( 1999) Reportage: shussei-mae shindan [Reportage: Foetal Genetic Diagnosis]. Tokyo: NHK Press.

12.

Sato T. ( 1999) Shussei-zen shindan [Prenatal Genetic Diagnosis]. Tokyo: Yuhikaku.

13.

Sawayama M. ( 1998) Shussan to Karada no Kinsei [Births and the Body in the Premodern Age]. Tokyo: Keiso Shobo .

14.

Shimazono S. ( 2003) Ko toshite no inochi, majiwari no naka no inochi. [Life conceived as individual, and life in human interaction]. Shiseigaku 2.

15.

Shimazono S. ( 2005) Life as an individual, life in the process of interaction . Bulletin of Death and Life Studies 1.

16.

Shimazono S. ( 2009) Reasons against the selection of life: From Japan’s experience of prenatal genetic diagnosis. In: Savulescu J and Bostrum N (eds) Human Enhancements. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

17.

Shimazono S. , Komatsu Y. and Doi K. ( 2004) Teidan: Clone hai riyo to ningen no shuen [Tripartite talk: The use of the cloned human embryos and the end of humanity]. Fukuin to Sekai December.

18.

Shinmura T. ( 1996) Shussan to seishoku kan no rekishi [History of Childbirths and Views on Reproduction]. Tokyo: Hosei University Press.

19.

Silver LM ( 1998) Remaking Eden: How Genetic Engineering and Cloning Will Transform the American Family. New York: Avon Books (Japanese translation by Higashie K et al., Tarumi, Tokyo: Shoei-sha).

20.

Stock G. ( 2002) Redesigning Humans: Choosing Our Children’s Genes . New York: Houghton Mifflin (Japanese translation by Tarumi Y, Hayakawa Shobo).

21.

Tamai M. ( 1999a) Shussei-zen shindan to Sentakuteki chuzetsu o meguru Double Standard to Taiji joho eno access [Double standards in prenatal genetic diagnosis and selective abortion and the access to information on foetuses] . In: Matsutomo R (ed.) Chiteki shogaisha no jinken [Human Rights of the Mentally Disabled]. Tokyo: Akashi Shoten.

22.

Tamai M. ( 1999b) Shogai to shussei-zen shindan [Disability and prenatal genetic diagnosis]. In: Ishikawa J and Nagase O (eds) Shogaigaku e no shotai: Shakai, bunka, disability [Invitation to Disability Studies: Society, Culture and Disability]. Tokyo: Akashi Shoten .

23.

Tateiwa S. ( 2000) Yowaku-aru jiyu e: Jiko kettei, kaigo, seishi no gijutsu [Freedom to be Weak: Self-Determination, Care, Technology for Life and Death] . Tokyo: Seido-sha.

24.

Trombley S. ( 1988) The Right to Reproduce. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson (Japanese translation by Fujita M, Akashi Shoten, 2000).

25.

Yonemoto S. , Matsubara Y. , Nudeshima J. and Ichinokawa Y. ( 2000) Yuseigaku to ningen shakai: seimei kagaku no seiki wa doko e mukau no ka? [Eugenics and Human Society: Where is the Century of Bioscience Heading for?]. Tokyo: Kodansha.