Recent developments in the organization and practice of healthcare, driven by the introduction of (quasi-) markets and privatization, are altering traditional forms of professionalism found in high- and middle-income countries. Yet there remains debate about whether these neoliberal trends are universal or country specific, and whether they have any effect (positive or negative) on health service delivery. This article develops a comparative analysis that focuses on changes in maternity service systems in four countries in Northern Europe and the Americas with primarily publicly financed healthcare systems: the UK, Finland, Chile and Canada. The article begins with a discussion of the continuum of professional forms found in the post-Second World War period and their relationship to different kinds of welfare states. It then focuses on the impact of recent neoliberal reforms on the ideological projects of the medical and allied health professions in the four case examples. The results show that variation across time and place is mainly the result of structural/economic factors and that various forms of professional discourses are the result of the public/private ways that healthcare systems are organized. The article concludes with suggestions for further comparative sociological research.
Armstrong, P. and Armstrong, H. (2003) Wasting Away: The Undermining of Canadian Healthcare . Toronto: Oxford University Press .
2.
Askham, J. and Chisholm, A. (2006) Patient-Centred Medical Professionalism: Towards an Agenda for Research and Action. Oxford: Picker Institute.
3.
Benoit, C. and Carroll, D. (2005) `Canadian Midwifery: Themes from Past to Present' , in C. Bates, D. Dodd and N. Rousseau (eds) On All Frontiers: Four Centuries of Canadian Nursing, pp. 27-41. Ottawa : University of Ottawa Press and Canadian Museum of Civilization.
4.
Benoit, C., Wrede, S., Bourgeault, I., Sandall, J., De Vries, R. and van Teijlingen, E.R. (2005) `Understanding the Social Organisation of Maternity Care Systems: Midwifery as a Touchstone', Sociology of Health and Illness27(6): 722-37.
5.
Bourgeault, I., Benoit, C. and Davis-Floyd, R. (eds) ( 2004) Reconceiving Midwifery. Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queen's University Press.
6.
Brint, S. (1994) In an Age of Experts: The Changing Role of Professionals in Politics and Public Life. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
7.
Brint, S. (2001) `Professionals and the "Knowledge Economy": Rethinking the Theory of Postindustrial Society', Current Sociology49(4): 101-32.
8.
Bury, M. (2004) `Researching Patient-Professional Interactions' , Journal of Health Services Research and Policy9 (Suppl. 1): 48-54.
9.
CHSRF (Canadian Health Services Research Foundation) (2006) Evidence Boost: Allow Midwives to Participate as Full Members of the Healthcare Team. Ottawa: CHSRF.
10.
CIHI (Canadian Institute for Health Information) (2006) The Status of Alternative Payment Programs for Physicians in Canada, 2003-2004 and Preliminary Information for 2004-2005 . Ottawa: CIHI.
11.
Davies, C. (1995) Gender and the Professional Predicament in Nursing . Buckingham: Open University Press .
12.
Davies, C. (2004) `Regulating the Healthcare Workforce: Next Steps for Research', Journal of Health Services Research and Policy9 (Suppl. 1): 55-61.
13.
Department of Health (2004a) Patient and Public Involvement in Health: The Evidence for Policy Implementation . London: Department of Health .
14.
Department of Health (2004b) National Service Framework for Children, Young People and Maternity Services . London: Department of Health .
15.
Department of Health (2007) Maternity Matters, Choice, Access and Continuity of Care in a Safe Service . London: Department of Health .
16.
Department of Health (2008) `NHS Next Stage Review: A Quality Workforce'; at: www.ournhs.nhs.uk/2008/06/30/nhs-next-stage-review-a-quality-workforce/ (accessed 9 March 2009).
17.
Evetts, J. (2003) `The Sociological Analysis of Professionalism: Occupational Change in the Modern World', International Sociology18(2): 395-415.
18.
Freidson, E. (1994) Professionalism Reborn: Theory, Prophecy and Policy . Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
19.
Hakulinen-Viitanen, T., Pelkonen, M. and Haapakorva, A. (2005) Äitiys- ja lastenneuvolatyö Suomessa [Maternity and Child Healthcare in Finland]. Helsinki. Finnish Ministry of Social Affairs and Health
20.
Hanlon, G. (1998) `Professionalism as Enterprise: Service Class Politics and the Redefinition of Professionalism', Sociology32(1): 43-63.
21.
Hanzich, J. (2005) `A Man on a Mission: Chilean President Ricardo Lagos' Health Reform Plan', Harvard International Review 27(2; `Defining Power'); at: hir.harvard.edu/articples/print.php?article=1342 (accessed 7 March 2007).
22.
Haug, M.R. (1973) `Deprofessionalisation: An Alternative Hypothesis for the Future', Sociological Review Monograph 195-212.
23.
Healthcare Commission (2006) Investigation into 10 Maternal Deaths at, or Following Delivery at, Northwick Park Hospital, North West London Hospitals NHS Trust, between April 2002 and April 2005. London: Healthcare Commission .
24.
Hemminki, E.Malin, M. and Kojo-Austin H. (1990) `Prenatal Care in Finland: From Primary to Tertiary Healthcare', International Journal of Health Services20: 221-32.
25.
Henriksson, L., Wrede, S. and Bureau, V. ( 2006) `Understanding Professional Projects in Welfare Service Work: Revival of Old Professionalism?', Gender Work and Organisation13(2): 174-92.
26.
Home Secretary/Secretary of State for Health ( 2007) Learning from Tragedy Keeping Patients Safe: Overview of the Government's Action Programme, Cmnd 7014. London : The Stationery Office.
27.
House of Commons Health Committee (2003a) Provision of Maternity Services, Fourth Report of Session 2002-3, Vol. 1. London: The Stationery Office.
28.
House of Commons Health Committee (2003b) Inequalities in access to Maternity Services, Eighth Report of Session 2002-03, Vol. 1. London, The Stationery Office .
29.
House of Commons Health Committee (2003c) Choice in Maternity Services, Ninth Report of Session 2002-03, Vol. 1. London: The Stationery Office .
30.
Hugman, R. (1991) Power in the Caring Professions. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
31.
Irvine, D. (2003) The Doctor's Tale: Professionalism and Public Trust . Oxford: Radcliffe Medical Press .
32.
Jiménez de la Jara, J. and Heyermann, G. (1993) `Re-establishing Healthcare in Chile', British Medical Journal307: 729-30.
33.
Johnson, T.J. (1972) Professions and Power. London : Macmillan.
34.
Jones, L. and Green, J. (2006) `Shifting Discourses of Professionalism: A Case Study of General Practitioners in the United Kingdom', Sociology of Health and Illness28(7): 927-50.
35.
King's Fund (2007) Inquiry into the Safety of Maternity Services; at: www.kingsfund.org.uk/health_topics/inquiry_into_the.html (accessed 5 March 2007).
36.
Kornelsen, J., Dahinten, V.S. and Carty, E. (2003) `On the Road to Collaboration: Nurses and Newly Regulated Midwives inBritish Columbia, Canada', Journal of Midwifery and Women's Health48: 126-32.
37.
Kojo-Austin, H., Malin, M. and Hemminki, E. (1993) `Women's Satisfaction with Maternity Healthcare Services in Finland', Social Science and Medicine37(5): 633-8.
38.
Larkin, G. (1983) Occupational Monopoly and Modern Medicine. London: Tavistock.
39.
Law on the Changes of the Public Health Act, 928 [Laki kansanterveyslain muuttamisesta] (2005) Finnish Parliament, Helsinki.
40.
Letelier, L. and Bedregal, P. (2006) `Health Reform in Chile', The Lancet368 (23-30 December): 2197-8.
41.
Liljeroth, P. (2007) `Förlossningsrädda kvinnor - ett medicinskt problem?' [Women with a Fear of Childbirth: A Medical Dilemma?], in J. Ahlbeck-Rehn and E. Oinas (eds) Kvinnor, kropp och hälsa. Lund: Studentlitteratur.
42.
Lindström, E. (2003) Terveydenhuollon eri ammattiryhmien välisen työnjaon kehittäminen Suomessa ja muissa Pohjoismaissa [The Development of the Division of Labour between Different Professional Groups in Healthcare in Finland and other Nordic Countries], Monisteita (Working papers) 12. Helsinki: Finnish Ministry of Social Affairs and Health .
43.
Marshall, T.M. (1939) `The Recent History of Professionalism in Relation to Social Structure and Social Policy', The Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science5(3): 325-40.
44.
Miranda, E., Scarpaci, J.L. and Irarrázaval, I. (1995) `A Decade of HMOs in Chile: Market Behaviour, Consumer Choice and the State', Health and Place1: 51-9.
45.
Murray, S. (2002) `Caesarean Birth in the Private Insurance Sector in Chile', thesis, Philosophy Department of Social and Political Science, Royal Holloway College University of London.
46.
Murray, S.F. and Elston, M.A. (2005) `The Promotion of Private Health Insurance and its Implications for the Social Organisation of Healthcare: A Case Study of Private Sector Obstetric Practice in Chile', Sociology of Health and Illness27(6): 701-21.
47.
Murray, S.F. and Serani Pradenas, F. (1997) `Caesarean Birth Trends in Chile, 1986 to 1994', Birth25(3): 207-8.
48.
National Statistics (2006) NHS Maternity Statistics, England: 2004-05. London: The Information Centre, Community Health Statistics.
49.
O'Cathain, A., Goode, J., Strangleman, T. et al. (2005) `Does NHS Direct Empower Patients?', Social Science and Medicine61: 1761&-71.
50.
Okma, K.G.H. (2002) `What is the Best Public-Private Model for Canadian Healthcare?', Policy Matters3(6): 1-35
51.
O'Neill, O. (2002) A Question of Trust. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
52.
Parsons, T. (1978) `The Sick Role and the Role of the Physician Reconsidered', Action Theory and the Human Condition. New York and London: The Free Press.
53.
Quesney, L.F. (1996) `El séctor privado en salud', in G. Giaconi (ed.) La salud en el siglo XX: cambios necessarios. Santiago: Centro de Estudios Públicos.
54.
Royal College of Midwives (2007) `Position Paper on Normal Birth', Campaign for Normal Birth ; at: www.rcmnormalbirth.org.uk/ (accessed 5 March 2007).
55.
RCOG (Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists) (2006a) A Career in Obstetrics and Gynaecology Recruitment and Retention in the Specialty. London: RCOG.
56.
RCOG (Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists) (2006b) Safer Childbirth: Minimum Standards for Service Provision and Care in Labour. London: RCOG.
57.
Royal College of Physicians (2005) Doctors in Society, Medical Professionalism in a Changing World: Report of a Working Party. London: Royal College of Physicians.
58.
Saks, M. (1995) Professions and the Public Interest: Medical Power, Altruism and Alternative Medicine. London: Routledge.
59.
Sandall, J., Manthorpe, J., Mansfield, A. and Spencer, L. (2007) Support Workers in Maternity Services: A National Scoping Study of NHS Trusts Providing Maternity Care in England in 2006, Report to Department of Health. London: King's College London.
60.
Scarpaci, J.L. (1987) `HMO Promotion and the Privatization of Healthcare in Chile', Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law12(3): 551-67.
61.
Secretary of State for Health (2006) Our Health, Our Care, Our Say: A New Direction for Community Services, Cmnd 6737. London: The Stationery Office .
62.
Secretary of State for Health (2007a) Safeguarding Patients, The Government's Response to the Recommendations of the Shipman Inquiry's Fifth Report and to the Recommendations of the Ayling, Neale and Kerr/Haslam Inquiries, Cmnd 7015. London: The Stationery Office.
63.
Secretary of State for Health (2007b) Trust, Assurance and Safety: The Regulation of Health Professionals in the 21st Century. London: The Stationery Office.
64.
Speed, S. and Luker, K. (2006) `Getting a Visit: How District Nurses and General Practitioners "Organise" Each Other in Primary Care', Sociology Health and Illness28(7): 883-902.
65.
Stakes (2006) `Parturients, Deliveries and Births - Preliminary Data for 2005', Statistical Summary 13/2006, Official Statistics of Finland, Health, National Research and Development Centre for Welfare and Health, Helsinki .
66.
Starr, P. (1982) The Social Transformation of American Medicine: The Rise of a Sovereign Profession and the Making of a Vast Industry. Philadelphia, PA: Basic Books.
67.
Witz, A. (1992) Professions and Patriarchy. London: Routledge.
68.
Wrede, S. (2001) Decentering Care for Mothers: The Politics of Midwifery and the Design of Finnish Maternity Services. Turku: Åbo Akademi University Press.
69.
Wrede, S., Benoit, C., Bourgeault, I., van Teijlingen, E., Sandall, J. and De Vries, R. (2006) `Decentered Comparative Research: Context Sensitive Analysis of Maternal Healthcare', Social Science and Medicine63: 2986-97.
