The article discusses and exemplifies three models of health care rationing observed in affluent, economically advanced countries. Its underlying premise is that no welfare system in the world can be exempted from any rationing whatsoever. This raises the question as to how the problem ought best to be resolved. But before thinking about normatively appealing answers it might be helpful to study how the problem is actually dealt with in the real world. For such a study brings to light several advantages and drawbacks of various rationing schemes which it would be hard to consider (even conceive) in the abstract alone, but whose knowledge may be highly relevant, perhaps indispensable, for the designation of adequate solutions.
AARON, Henry J. and SCHWARTZ, William B. (1984) The Painful Prescription: Rationing Hospital Care. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution .
2.
AGNELL, Marcia (1985) ‘Cost Containment and the Physician’ , Journal of the American Medical Association254: 1203-1207 .
3.
ALBER, Jens (1992) Das Gesundheitswesen in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Entwicklung, Struktur und Funktionsweise. Frankfurt: Campus.
4.
ANHEIER, Herbert (1996) ‘Betriebsführung im Krankenhaus: Arzt oder (und) Manager?’, Deutsches Ärzteblatt 93: A-2758.
5.
AW, Tar Choon and LOW, Linda (1997) ‘Health Care Provision in Singapore’, in Tan Teck Meng and Chew Soon Beng (eds) Affordable Health Care: Issues and Prospects, pp. 50-71. Singapore: Prentice-Hall .
6.
BREYER, Friedrich and KLIEMT, Hartmut (1994) ‘Lebensverlängernde medizinische Leistungen als Clubgüter? Ein Beitrag zum Thema Rationierung im Gesundheitswesen’, in Karl Homann (ed.) Wirtschaftsethische Perspektiven I. Ordnungsfragen, internationale Institutionen, pp. 131-58. Berlin: Duncker und Humblot.
7.
BREYER, Friedrich , KLIEMT, Hartmut and THIELE, Felix (eds) (2002) Rationing in Medicine: Ethical, Legal and Practical Aspects. Berlin: Springer .
8.
CALABRESI, Guido and BOBBITT, Philip (1978) Tragic Choices: The Conflicts Society Confronts in the Allocation of Tragically Scarce Resources. New York: Norton .
9.
CENTRAL PROVIDENT FUND BOARD (2000) A People’s Wealth, a Nation’s Health: The CPF Story. Singapore: CPF .
10.
CLADE, Harald (1997) ‘Medizinischer Fortschritt und knappe Ressourcen: Das Dilemma der Prioritätensetzung’, Deutsches Ärzteblatt 94: A-80.
11.
COAST, Joanna (1997) ‘Rationing within the NHS Should be Explicit: The Case Against’ , British Medical Journal314: 1118-1122 .
12.
COHEN, Michael D. , MARCH, James J. and OLSEN, Johan P. (1972) ‘A Garbage Can Model of Organizational Change’ , Administrative Science Quarterly17: 1-25 .
13.
COULTER, Angela and HAM, Chris (eds) (2000) The Global Challenge of Health Care Rationing. Buckingham: Open University Press .
14.
DANIELS, Norman (1996) Justice and Justification: Reflective Equilibrium in Theory and Practice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
15.
DAY, Valerie (2002) ‘Practitioners as Gate Keepers in an Advanced Country: UK NHS - The Manager’s Perspective’, in Frank Dietrich , Hartmut Kliemt and Michael Imhoff (eds) Microallocations of Medical Resources. Economics and Ethics, pp. 105-112. Munich: Accedo .
16.
DIETRICH, Frank , KLIEMT, Hartmut and IMHOFF, Michael (eds) (2002) Microallocations of Medical Resources: Economics and Ethics. Munich: Accedo .
17.
DOYAL, Len (1997) ‘Rationing within the NHS Should be Explicit: The Case For’ , British Medical Journal314: 1114-1118 .
18.
DUFF, John (2001) ‘Financing to Foster Community Health Care: A Comparative Analysis of Singapore, Europe, North America and Australia’ , Current Sociology49: 135-154 .
19.
FEICHT, Günther (2002) ‘Daily Dermatology: A Dermatologist’s Description of his “German” Experience’, in Frank Dietrich , Hartmut Kliemt and Michael Imhoff (eds) Microallocations of Medical Resources: Economics and Ethics, pp. 11-23. Munich: Accedo .
20.
GÄFGEN, Gérard (1985) ‘Die ethische Problematik von Allokationsentscheidungen - am Beispiel des Ressourceneinsatzes im Gesundheitswesen’, in Georges Enderle (ed.) Ethik und Wirtschaftswissenschaft, pp. 249-74. Berlin: Duncker und Humblot.
21.
GOODIN, Robert E. and LE GRAND, Julian (1987) Not Only the Poor: The Middle Classes and the Welfare State. London: Allen and Unwin .
22.
GRIFFITHS, Lesley and HUGHES, David (1998) ‘Purchasing in the British NHS: Does Contracting Mean Explicit Rationing?’ , Health: An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Social Study of Health, Illness and Medicine2: 349-371 .
23.
GUTMANN, Thomas and LAND, Walter (1997) ‘The Ethics of Organ Allocation’ , Transplantation Reviews11: 191-207 .
24.
HADORN, David (1991) ‘Setting Health Care Priorities in Oregon: Cost-Effectiveness Meets the Rule of Rescue’ , Journal of the American Medical Association265: 2218-2225 .
25.
HALL, Mark A. (1997) Making Medical Spending Decisions: The Law, Ethics, and Economics of Rationing Mechanisms. New York: Oxford University Press .
26.
HALPER, Thomas (1989) The Misfortunes of Others: End Stage Renal Disease in the United Kingdom. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
27.
HUNTER, David J. (2002) ‘The Practice of Rationing Health Care in the United Kingdom’, in Friedrich Breyer , Hartmut Kliemt and Felix Thiele (eds) Rationing in Medicine: Ethical, Legal and Practical Aspects, pp. 39-52. Berlin: Springer .
28.
KLEIN, Rudolf (1997) ‘Rationing within the NHS Should be Explicit: The Case Against’ , British Medical Journal314: 506-509 .
29.
KLEIN, Rudolf , DAY, Patricia and REDMAYNE, Sharon (1996) Managing Scarcity: Priority Setting and Rationing in the NHS. Buckingham: Open University Press .
30.
KRACHT, Monika and TAPP, Burkhard (1997) ‘Allokationsprobleme aus der Sicht der Patienten’, in Rolf Lachmann and Norbert Meuter (eds) Zur Gerechtigkeit der Organverteilung. Ein Problem der Transplantationsmedizin aus interdisziplinärer Sicht, pp. 39-47. Stuttgart: G. Fischer.
31.
KRIMMEL, Lothar (1997) ‘Ambulante Versorgung unter Budgetzwang: Was ist “medizinisch notwendig”?’, Deutsches Ärzteblatt 94: A-20.
32.
KUHLMANN, Ellen (1998) ‘Zwischen zwei Mahlsteinen. Ergebnisse einer empirischen Studie zur Verteilung knapper medizinscher Ressourcen in ausgewählten klinischen Settings’, in Günter Feuerstein and Ellen Kuhlmann (eds) Rationierung im Gesundheitswesen, pp. 11-80. Wiesbaden: Ullstein Medical.
33.
LIGHT, Donald W. and HUGHES, David (2001) ‘Introduction: A Sociological Perspective on Rationing: Power, Rhetoric and Situated Practices’ , Sociology of Health and Illness23: 551-569 .
34.
LIM, Judy (1997) ‘Health Care Reform in Singapore: The Medisave Scheme’, in Tan Teck Meng and Chew Soon Beng (eds) Affordable Health Care: Issues and Prospects, pp. 277-285. Singapore: Prentice-Hall .
35.
LIM, Linda Y. C. (1989) ‘Social Welfare’, in Kernial Singh Sandh and Paul Wheatley (eds) Management of Success: The Moulding of Modern Singapore, pp. 171-197. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies .
36.
LINDBLOM, Charles E. (1959) ‘The Science of Muddling Through’ , Public Administration Review19: 79-88 .
37.
LUHMANN, Niklas (1989) ‘Politische Steuerung’, Politische Vierteljahresschrift 30: 4-9.
38.
MECHANIC, David (1995) ‘Dilemmas in Rationing Health Care Services: The Case for Implicit Rationing’ , British Medical Journal310: 1655-1659 .
39.
MÖLLER, Johannes and LAASER, Ulrich (2002) ‘Der WHO Weltgesundheitsbericht 2000 - Anspruch und kritische Würdigung’, Zeitschrift für Gesundheitswissenschaften 10: 276-88.
40.
PAULY, Mark and GOODMAN, John (1995) ‘Tax Credits for Health Insurance and Medical Savings Accounts’ , Health Affairs14: 126-139 .
41.
POWELL, John W. (2002) ‘Practitioners as Gate Keepers in an Advanced Country: American HMO II - The Manager’s Perspective’, in Frank Dietrich , Hartmut Kliemt and Michael Imhoff (eds) Microallocations of Medical Resources: Economics and Ethics, pp. 86-96. Munich: Accedo .
42.
ROTHGANG, Heinz (1999) ‘Rationierung im Gesundheitswesen: Fakt oder Fiktion - notwendig oder ethisch verwerflich?’, Journal für Anästhesie und Intensivbehandlung 6: 134-6.
43.
‘SCARCE MEDICAL RESOURCES’ (1969) Columbia Law Review9: 620-692 .
44.
SCHMIDT, Volker H. (1996) ‘Veralltäglichung der Triage’, Zeitschrift für Soziologie 25: 419-37.
45.
SCHMIDT, Volker H. (1998) ‘Selection of Recipients for Donor Organs in Transplant Medicine’ , Journal of Medicine and Philosophy23: 50-74 .
46.
SCHMIDT, Volker H. and GUTMANN, Thomas (2002) ‘Einleitung’, in Thomas Gutmann and Volker H. Schmidt (eds) Rationierung und Allokation im Gesundheitswesen, pp. 7-40. Weilerswist: Velbrück Wissenschaft.
47.
STROSBERG, Martin A. , WIENER, Joshua M. and BAKER, Robert (eds) (1992) Rationing America’s Medical Care: The Oregon Plan and Beyond. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution .
48.
TAN, Teck Meng and CHEW, Soon Beng (eds) (1997) Affordable Health Care: Issues and Prospects. Singapore: Prentice-Hall .
49.
UBEL, Peter A. (2000) Pricing Life: Why it’s Time for Health Care Rationing. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press .
50.
VASSY, Carine (2001) ‘Categorisation and Micro-Rationing: Access to Care in a French Emergency Department’ , Sociology of Health and Illness23: 615-632 .
51.
VEATCH, Robert (1991) ‘Who Empowers Medical Doctors to Make Allocative Decisions for Dialysis and Transplantation?’, in Walter Land and John B. Dossetor (eds) Organ Replacement Therapy: Ethics, Justice, Commerce, pp. 331-336. Berlin: Springer .
52.
WIESENTHAL, Helmut (2003) ‘Soziologie als Optionenheuristik?’, in Jutta Allmendinger (ed.) Entstaatlichung und soziale Sicherheit, pp. 94-109. Opladen: Leske und Budrich.
53.
WILLIAMSON, Paul K. (2002) ‘Practitioners as Gate Keepers in an Advanced Country: American HMO I - The Physician’s Perspective’, in Frank Dietrich , Hartmut Kliemt and Michael Imhoff (eds) Microallocations of Medical Resources. Economics and Ethics, pp. 71-78. Munich: Accedo .
54.
WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION (2000) World Health Report 2000. Health Systems: Improving Performance. Geneva: World Health Organization .
