This article provides a critical comparative review of Ulrich Beck's and Mary Douglas's social theories of risk. The author is particularly concerned to highlight the partiality of their favoured renditions of the social reality of risk perception in relation to the accumulated evidence of empirical research. Their contrasting (and opposing) conceptions of the social processes through which people may negotiate the meaning of `hazard' in terms of `risk' are presented as ideal-types which are both indispensable and insufficient for explaining the cultural complexity of this phenomenon. Moreover, insofar as the lived experience of complexity may be made the object of sociological concern, it is suggested that we might be in a better position to evaluate the cultural significance of risk as a product of this experience.
ADAMS, J. (1995) Risk. London: University College London Press.
2.
BECK, U. (1992a) Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity. London: Sage.
3.
BECK, U. (1992b) `From Industrial Society to the Risk Society: Questions of Survival, Social Structure and Ecological Enlightenment', Theory, Culture & Society9: 97-123.
4.
BECK, U. (1994) `The Reinvention of Politics: Towards a Theory of Reflexive Modernization', in U. Beck, A. Giddens, and S. Lash (eds) Reflexive Modernization: Politics, Tradition and Aesthetics in the Modern Social Order, pp. 1-55. Cambridge: Polity Press.
5.
BECK, U. (1995a) Ecological Politics in an Age of Risk. Cambridge: Polity Press.
6.
BECK, U. (1995b) Ecological Enlightenment: Essays on the Politics of the Risk Society, trans. Mark A. Ritter. Atlantic Highlands, NJ: Humanities Press International.
7.
BECK, U. (1997) The Reinvention of Politics: Rethinking Modernity in the Global Social Order. Cambridge: Polity Press.
8.
BECK, U. (1998) Democracy Without Enemies. Cambridge: Polity Press.
9.
BECK, U. (1999) World Risk Society. Cambridge: Polity Press.
10.
BELLABY, P. (1990) `To Risk or Not to Risk? Uses and Limitations of Mary Douglas on Risk Acceptability for Understanding Health and Safety at Work and Road Accidents', Sociological Review38(3): 465-483.
11.
BERNSTEIN, P. L. (1998) Against the Gods: The Remarkable Story of Risk. New York: John Wiley.
12.
BOHOLM, A. (1996) `Risk Perception and Social Anthropology: Critique of Cultural Theory', Ethnos61(1-2): 64-84.
13.
BRENOT, J. , BONNEFOUS, S. and MARRIS, C. (1998) `Testing the Cultural Theory of Risk in France', Risk Analysis18(6): 729-739.
14.
BRUNSDON, C. , and MORLEY, D. (1978) Everyday Television: Nationwide. London: British Film Institute.
15.
CLARKE, L. and SHORT, J. F. (1993) `Social Organization and Risk: Some Current Controversies', Annual Review of Sociology19: 375-399.
16.
COLEMAN, C. L. (1993) `The Influence of the Mass Media and Interpersonal Communication on Societal and Personal Risk Judgements', Communication Research20(4): 611-628.
17.
CORNER, J. , RICHARDSON, K. and FENTON, N. (1990) `Textualising Risk: TV Discourse and the Issue of Nuclear Energy', Media, Culture & Society12: 105-124.
18.
CULBERTSON, H. M. and STEMPEL, G. H. (1985) `Media Malaise: Explaining Personal Optimism and Societal Pessimism About Health Care', Journal of Communication35: 180-190.
19.
CUMBERBATCH, G. and HOWITT, D. (1989) A Measure of Uncertainty: The Effects of the Mass Media, British Standards Council Research Monograph Series: 1. London: John Libby.
20.
CUTTER, S. L. (1993) Living With Risk: The Geography of Technological Hazards. London: Edward Arnold.
21.
CUTTER, S. L. , TIEFENBACHER, J. and SOLECKI, W. D. (1992) `Engendered Fears: Femininity and Technological Risk Perception', Industrial Crisis Quarterly6: 5-22.
22.
DAHLGREN, P. (1988) `What's the Meaning of This? Viewers' Plural Sense-Making of TV News', Media, Culture & Society10: 235-301.
23.
DAKE, K. (1991) `Orienting Dispositions in the Perception of Risk: An Analysis of Contemporary Worldviews and Cultural Biases', Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology22(1): 61-82.
24.
DAKE, K. (1992) `Myths of Nature: Culture and the Social Construction of Risk', Journal of Social Issues48(4): 21-37.
25.
DELANTY, G. (1999) `Biopolitics in the Risk Society: The Possibility of a Global Ethic of Societal Responsibility', in P. O'Mahony (ed.) Nature, Risk and Responsibility, pp. 37-51. London: Macmillan.
26.
DICKENS, P. (1992) `Who Would Know? Science, Environmental Risk and the Construction of Theory', Working Paper 86, Centre for Urban and Regional Research, University of Sussex.
27.
DOUGLAS, M. (1978a) Implicit Meanings: Essays in Anthropology. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
28.
DOUGLAS, M. (1978b) Cultural Bias, Occasional Papers 35. London: Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland.
29.
DOUGLAS, M. (1986) Risk Acceptability According to the Social Sciences. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
30.
DOUGLAS, M. (1990) `Risk as a Forensic Resource', Daedalus119(4): 1-16.
31.
DOUGLAS, M. (1992) Risk and Blame: Essays in Cultural Theory. London: Routledge.
32.
DOUGLAS, M. (1996) Thought Styles: Critical Essays in Good Taste. London: Sage.
33.
DOUGLAS, M. and WILDAVSKY, A. (1982) Risk and Culture: An Essay in the Selection and Interpretation of Technological and Environmental Dangers. Berkeley: University of California Press.
34.
DUNLAP, R. E. and SCARCE, R. (1992) `The Polls - Poll Trends: Environmental Problems and Protection', Public Opinion Quarterly55: 651-672.
35.
ELDRIDGE, J. (1999) `Risk, Society and the Media: Now You See It, Now You Don't', in G. Philo (ed.) Message Received. Harlow: Longman.
36.
ELLIS, R. J. (1993) American Political Cultures. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
37.
FIFE-SCHAW, C. and ROWE, G. (1996) `Public Perceptions of Everyday Food Hazards: A Psychometric Study', Risk Analysis16(4): 487-500.
38.
FISCHOFF, B. , SLOVIC, P., LICHTENSTEIN, S., READ, S. and COMBS, B. (1978) `How Safe is Safe Enough? A Psychometric Study of Attitudes Towards Technological Risks and Benefits', Policy Sciences9: 127-152.
39.
FISCHOFF, B. , LICHTENSTEIN, S., SLOVIC, P., DERBY, S. L. and KEENY, R. L. (1981) Acceptable Risk. New York: Cambridge University Press.
40.
FISCHOFF, B. , WATSON, S. R. and HOPE, C. (1984) `Defining Risk', Policy Sciences17: 123-139.
41.
FRANKLIN, J. (ed.) (1998) The Politics of Risk Society. Cambridge: Polity Press.
42.
FREUDENBERG, W. R. and PASTOR, S. K. (1992) `Public Responses to Technological Risks: Toward a Sociological Perspective', Sociological Quarterly31(3): 389-412.
43.
FREUDENBERG, W. R. , COLEMAN, C. L., GONZALES, J. and HELGELAND, C. (1996) `Media Coverage of Hazard Events: Analyzing the Assumptions', Risk Analysis16(1): 31-42.
44.
GARDNER, G. T. and GOULD, L. C. (1989) `Public Perceptions of the Risks and Benefits of Technology', Risk Analysis9: 225-242.
45.
GOLDBLATT, D. (1996) Social Theory and the Environment. Cambridge: Polity Press.
46.
GUSTAFSON, P. E. (1998) `Gender Differences in Risk Perception: Theoretical and Methodological Perspectives', Risk Analysis18(6): 805-811.
47.
HANSEN, A. (1991) `The Media and the Social Construction of the Environment', Media, Culture & Society13: 443-458.
48.
HEYMAN, B. (1998) `Introduction', in B. Heyman (ed.) Risk, Health and Health Care, pp. 1-23. London: Arnold.
49.
HEYMAN, B. and HENRIKSEN, M. (1998) `Probability and Health Risks', in B. Heyman (ed.) Risk, Health and Health Care, pp. 27-64. London: Arnold.
50.
HOOD, C. and JONES, D. (1996) Accident and Design: Contemporary Debates in Risk Management. London: University College London Press.
51.
IRWIN, A. , SIMMONS, P. and WALKER, G. (1999) `Faulty Environments and Risk Reasoning: The Local Understanding of Industrial Hazards', Environment and Planning A31: 1311-1326.
52.
JENSEN, K. B. (1990) `The Politics of Polysemy: Television News, Everyday Consciousness and Political Action', Media, Culture & Society12: 57-77.
53.
JOFFE, H. (1999) Risk and `The Other'. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
54.
KASPERSON, J. X. and KASPERSON, R. E. (1996) `The Social Amplification and Attenuation of Risk', The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science545: 95-105.
55.
KASPERSON, R. E. , GOLDING, D. and TULER, S. (1992) `Siting Hazardous Facilities and Communicating Risks under Conditions of High Social Distrust', Journal of Social Issues48(4): 161-187.
56.
LASH, S. , SZERSZYNSKI, B. and WYNNE B. (eds) (1996) Risk Environment and Modernity: Towards a New Ecology. London: Sage.
57.
LUPTON, D. (1999) Risk. London: Routledge.
58.
McLEOD, J. M. , KOSICKI, G. M. and PAN, Z. (1991) `On Understanding and Misunderstanding Media Effects', in J. Curran and M. Gurevitch (eds) Mass Media and Society, pp. 235-266. London: Edward Arnold.
59.
MAZUR, A. (1981) `Media Coverage and Public Opinion on Scientific Controversies', Journal of Communication31: 106-115.
60.
MILLER, D. and REILLY, J. (1994) Food Scares in the Media. Glasgow: Glasgow University Media Group.
61.
MORLEY, D. (1986) Family Television. London: Comedia/Routledge.
62.
MORLEY, D. (1992) Television Audiences and Cultural Studies. London: Routledge.
63.
MORLEY, D. and SILVERSTONE, R. (1990) `Domestic Communication - Technologies and Meanings', Media, Culture & Society12(1): 31-56.
64.
OFFICE FOR NATIONAL STATISTICS (1997) Social Trends 27. London: The Stationery Office.
65.
POWELL, D. and LEISS, W. (1997) Mad Cows and Mother's Milk: The Perils of Poor Risk Communication. Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press.
66.
RAYNER, S. (1992) `Cultural Theory and Risk Analysis', in S. Krimsky, and D. Golding (eds) Social Theories of Risk, pp. 27-64. Westport, CT: Praeger.
67.
RENN, O. , BURNS, W. J., KASPERSON, J. X., KASPERSON, R. E. and SLOVIC, P. (1992) `The Social Amplification of Risk: Theoretical Foundations and Empirical Applications', Journal of Social Issues48(4): 137-160.
68.
ROGERS, G. O. (1997) `The Dynamics of Risk Perception: How Does Perceived Risk Respond to Risk Events?', Risk Analysis17(6): 745-757.
69.
ROYAL SOCIETY (1992) Risk: Analysis, Perception and Management. London: Royal Society.
SADRI, A. (1992) Max Weber's Sociology of Intellectuals. New York: Oxford University Press.
72.
SCHWARZ, S. and THOMPSON, M. (1990) Divided We Stand: Rethinking Politics, Technology and Social Choice. Hemel Hempstead: Harvest Wheatsheaf.
73.
SILVERSTONE, R. (1994) Television and Everyday Life. London: Routledge.
74.
SINGER, E. and ENDRENY, P. (1987) `Reporting Hazards: Their Benefits and Costs', Journal of Communication37(3): 10-26.
75.
SJOBERG, L. (1997) `Explaining Risk Perception: An Empirical Evaluation of Cultural Theory', Risk Decision and Policy2(2): 113-130.
76.
SJOBERG, L. (1998) `Worry and Risk Perception', Risk Analysis18(1): 85-93.
77.
SLOVIC, P. (1987) `Perception of Risk', Science236: 280-285.
78.
SPENCER, W. J. and TRICHE, E. (1994) `Media Constructions of Risk and Safety: Differential Framings of Hazard Events', Sociological Inquiry64(2): 199-213.
79.
STALLINGS, R. A. (1990) `Media Discourse and the Social Construction of Risk', Social Problems37(1): 80-95.
80.
STARR, C. (1969) `Social Benefit vs Technological Risk', Science165: 1232-1238.
81.
THOMPSON, J. B. (1995) The Media and Modernity: A Social Theory of the Media. Cambridge: Polity Press.
82.
THOMPSON, M. , ELLIS, R. and WILDAVSKY, A. (1990) Cultural Theory. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
83.
TYLER, T. T. and COOK, F. L. (1984) `The Mass Media and Judgements of Risk: Distinguishing Impact on Personal and Societal Level Judgements', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology47(4): 693-708.
84.
WEBER, M. (1949) ` “Objectivity” in Social Science and Social Policy', in E. A. Shils and H. A. Finch (eds) The Methodology of the Social Sciences, pp. 49-111. New York: The Free Press.
85.
WILDAVSKY, A. and DAKE, K. (1990) `Theories of Risk Perception: Who Fears What and Why?', Daedalus119(4): 41-59.
86.
WILKINS, L. and PATTERSON, P. (1987) `Risk Analysis and the Construction of News', Journal of Communication37(3): 80-92.
87.
WILKINSON, I. (1999a) `Where is the Novelty in our Current “Age of Anxiety”?', European Journal of Social Theory2(4): 445-467.
88.
WILKINSON, I. (199b) `News Media Discourse and the State of Public Opinion on Risk', Risk Management: An International Journal1(4): 21-31.
89.
YOUNG, K. (1990) `Living Under Threat', in R. Jowell, S. Witherspoon and L. Brook (eds) British Social Attitudes - 7th Report, pp. 77-108. Aldershot: Gower.
