In their best-selling book, The Bell Curve, Herrnstein and Murray argue that IQ is a powerful predictor of a range of social ills including crime. They use this “scientific reality” to oppose social welfare policies and, in particular, to justify the punishment of offenders. By reanalyzing the data used in The Bell Curve and by reviewing existing meta-analyses assessing the relative importance of criminogenic risk factors, the present authors show empirically that Herrnstein and Murray's claims regarding IQ and crime are misleading. The authors conclude that Herrnstein and Murray's crime control agenda is based on ideology, not on intelligent criminology.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Andrews, D. A.
and James Bonta. 1994. The Psychology of Criminal Conduct. Cincinnati, OH: Anderson.
2.
Andrews, D. A.
and James Bonta. 1995. LSI-R: The Level of Service Inventory-Revised. Toronto: Multi-Health Systems.
3.
Andrews, D. A.
, Ivan Zinger, Robert D. Hoge, James Bonta, Paul Gendreau, and Francis T. Cullen. 1990. “Does Correctional Treatment Work? A Clinically-Relevant and Psychologically-Informed Meta-Analysis.”Criminology28:369-404.
4.
Block, Jack
. 1995. “On the Relation Between IQ, Impulsivity, and Delinquency: Remarks on the Lynam, Moffit, and Stouthamer-Loeber (1993) Interpretation.”Journal of Abnormal Psychology104:395-398.
5.
Bonta, James
, Moira Law, and Karl Hanson. Forthcoming. “The Prediction of Criminal and Violent Recidivism Among Mentally Disordered Offenders: A Meta-Analysis.”Psychological Bulletin.
6.
Caspi, Avshalom
, Terrie E. Moffitt, Phil A. Silva, Magda Stouthamer-Loeber, Robert F. Krueger, and Pamela S. Schmutte. 1994. “Are Some People Crime-Prone? Replications of the Personality-Crime Relationship Across Countries, Genders, Races, and Methods.”Criminology32:163-194.
7.
Chomsky, Noam
. 1972. “The Fallacy of Richard Herrnstein's IQ.”Social Policy3:19-25.
8.
Clear, Todd R.
1994. Harm in American Penology: Offenders, Victims, and Their Communities. Albany: State University of New York Press.
9.
Coontz, Stephanie
. 1992. The Way We Never Were: American Families and the Nostalgia Trap. New York: Basic Books.
10.
Coulson, Grant
, Giorgia Ilacqua, Verna Nutbrown, Diana Giulekas, and Francis Cudjoe. 1996. “Predictive Utility of the LSI for Incarcerated Female Offenders.”Criminal Justice and Behavior23:427-439.
11.
Currie, Elliott
. 1985. Confronting Crime: An American Challenge. New York: Pantheon.
12.
DeParle, Jason
. 1994. “Daring Research or `Social Science Pornography'?”New York Times Magazine, October 9: 48-53, 62, 70-71, 74, 78, 80.
13.
Dershowitz, Alan M.
1994. The Abuse Excuse: And Other Cop-Outs, Sob Stories, and Evasions of Responsibility. Boston: Little, Brown.
14.
Dorfman, Donald D.1995. “Soft Science With a Neoconservative Agenda.”Contemporary Psychology40:418-421.
15.
Farrington, David P.
1994. “Human Development and Criminal Careers.” Pp. 511-584 in The Oxford Handbook of Criminology, edited by M. Maguire, R. Morgan, and R. Reinder. New York: Oxford University Press.
16.
Farrington, David P.1995. “The Development of Offending and Antisocial Behaviour From Childhood: Key Findings From the Cambridge Study in Delinquent Development.”Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry360:929-964.
17.
Gardner, Howard
. 1983. Frames of Mind: The Theory of Multiple Intelligence. New York: Basic Books.
18.
Gardner, Howard
. 1994. “Cracking Open the IQ Box.”The American Prospect20:71-80.
19.
Gendreau, Paul
. 1996. “The Principles of Effective Intervention With Offenders.” Pp. 117-130 in Correctional Options That Work: Defining the Demand and Evaluating the Supply, edited by A. T. Harland. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
20.
Gendreau, Paul
and D. A. Andrews. 1990. “Tertiary Prevention: What the Meta-Analyses of the Offender Treatment Literature Tell Us About `What Works'.”Canadian Journal of Criminology32:173-184.
21.
Gendreau, Paul
and Claire E. Goggin. 1996. “Principles of Effective Correctional Programming.”Forum on Corrections Research8:38-41.
22.
Gendreau, Paul
, Claire E. Goggin, Francis T. Cullen, D. A. Andrews, and James Bonta. 1997. “The Effectiveness of `Get Tough' Strategies on Offender Recidivism.” Unpublished manuscript, Centre for Criminal Justice Studies, University of New Brunswick, Saint John.
23.
Gendreau, Paul
, Claire E. Goggin, and Moira A. Law. Forthcoming. “Predicting Prison Misconducts.”Criminal Justice and Behavior.
24.
Gendreau, Paul
, Claire Goggin, and Mario Paparozzi. 1996. “Principles of Effective Assessments for Community Corrections.”Federal Probation60 (September): 64-70.
25.
Gendreau, Paul
, Tracy Little, and Claire Goggin. 1996. “A Meta-Analysis of the Predictors of Adult Offender Recidivism: What Works!”Criminology34:575-607.
26.
Gendreau, Paul
and Milton D. Suboski. 1971. “Age and IQ Discrimination Conditioning of the Eyelid Response.”Journal of Experimental Psychology89:379-382.
27.
Gibbons, Don C.
1994. Talking About Crime and Criminals. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
28.
Gibbs, John J.
, Charles M. Puzzanchera, and Dennis Giever. 1997. “Emotional Intelligence and Criminal Behavior: A Conceptual Framework and Empirical Test.” Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Academy of Criminal Justice Sciences, Louisville, KY, March.
29.
Glass, Gene V.1976. “Primary, Secondary, and Meta-Analysis of Research.”Educational Researcher5:3-8.
30.
Glass, Gene V.
, Barry McGaw, and Mary Lee Smith. 1981. Meta-Analysis in Social Research. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
31.
Goldberger, Arthur S.
and Charles F. Manski. 1995. “Review Article: The Bell Curve by Herrnstein and Murray.”Journal of Economic Literature33:762-776.
32.
Goleman, Daniel
. 1995. Emotional Intelligence. New York: Bantam.
33.
Gould, Stephen Jay
. 1981. The Mismeasure of Man. New York: Norton.
34.
Gould, Stephen Jay
. 1994. “Curveball.”The New Yorker, November 28: 139-149.
35.
Hanson, R. Karl
and Monique T. Bussiere. 1996. Predictors of Sexual Offender Recidivism: A Meta-Analysis. Ottawa: Solicitor General of Canada.
36.
Harland, Alan T.
, ed. 1996. Choosing Correctional Options That Work: Defining the Demand and Evaluating the Supply. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
37.
Hauser, Robert M.1995. “Symposium: The Bell Curve.”Contemporary Sociology24: 149-153.
38.
Henning, Chris R.
and B. Christopher Frueh. 1996. “Cognitive-Behavioral Treatment of Offenders: An Evaluation of the Vermont Department of Corrections Cognitive Self-Change Program.”Criminal Justice and Behavior23:523-541.
39.
Herrnstein, Richard J.
1995. “Criminogenic Traits.” Pp. 39-63 in Crime, edited by J. Q. Wilson and J. Petersilia. San Francisco: ICS Press.
40.
Herrnstein, Richard J.
and Charles Murray. 1994. The Bell Curve: Intelligence and Class Structure in American Life. New York: Free Press.
41.
Hirschi, Travis
and Michael J. Hindelang. 1977. “Intelligence and Delinquency: A Revisionist Review.”American Sociological Review42:571-587.
42.
Hoge, Robert D.
and D. A. Andrews. 1996. Assessing the Youthful Offender: Issues and Techniques. New York: Plenum.
43.
Howell, James C.
, Barry Krisberg, J. David Hawkins, and John J. Wilson, eds. 1995. Serious, Violent, and Chronic Juvenile Offenders: A Sourcebook. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
44.
Hunt, Morton
. 1997. How Science Takes Stock: The Story of Meta-Analysis. New York: Russell Sage.
45.
Jacoby, Russell
and Naomi Glauberman, eds. 1995. The Bell Curve Debate: History, Documents, Opinions. New York: Times Books.
46.
Kamin, Leon
. 1995. “Lies, Damned Lies, and Statistics.” Pp. 81-105 in The Bell Curve Debate: History, Documents, Opinions, edited by R. Jacoby and N. Glauberman. New York: Times Books.
47.
Lipsey, Mark S.
1992. “Juvenile Delinquency Treatment: A Meta-Analytic Inquiry Into the Variability of Effects.” Pp. 83-117 in Meta-Analysis for Explanation: A Casebook, edited by T. D. Cook, H. Cooper, D. S. Cordray, H. Hartmann, L. V. Hedges, R. J. Light, T. A. Louis, and F. Mosteller. New York: Russell Sage.
48.
Lipsey, Mark S.
and James H. Derzon. 1997. “Predictors of Violent or Serious Delinquency in Adolescence and Early Adulthood: A Synthesis of Longitudinal Research.” Paper prepared for the OJJDP Study Group on Serious and Violent Juvenile Offenders, March.
49.
Lipsey, Mark S.
and David B. Wilson. 1997. “Effective Intervention for Serious Juvenile Offenders: A Synthesis of Research.” Paper prepared for the OJJDP Study Group on Serious and Violent Juvenile Offenders, January.
50.
Loeber, Rolf
and T. Dishion. 1983. “Early Predictors of Male Delinquency: A Review.”Psychological Bulletin94:68-99.
51.
Lubinski, David
and Camilla P. Benbow. 1995. “An Opportunity for Empiricism: A Review of Multiple Intelligence: The Theory in Practice.”Contemporary Psychology40:935-937.
52.
Lynam, Donald
, Terrie Moffitt, and Magda Stouthamer-Loeber. 1993. “Explaining the Relation Between IQ and Delinquency: Class, Race, Test Motivation, School Failure, or Self-Control?”Journal of Abnormal Psychology102:187-196.
53.
Massey, Douglas S.1995. “Review Essay: The Bell Curve.”American Journal of Sociology3:747-753.
54.
Masters, John C.
, Thomas G. Burish, Steven D. Hollon, and David C. Rimm. 1989. Behavior Therapy: Techniques and Empirical Findings. San Diego: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
55.
Matson, Johnny L.
and Thomas M. DiLorenzo. 1984. Punishment and Its Alternatives: A New Perspective for Behavior Modification. New York: Springer.
56.
Menard, Scott
and Barbara Morse. 1984. “A Structuralist Critique of the IQ-Delinquency Hypothesis: Theory and Evidence.”American Journal of Sociology89:1347-1378.
57.
Moffitt, Terrie E.
, Donald R. Lynam, and Phil A. Silva. 1994. “Neuropsychological Tests Predicting Persistent Male Delinquency.”Criminology32:277-300.
58.
Moffitt, Terrie E.
and Phil A. Silva. 1988. “IQ and Delinquency: A Direct Test of the Differential Detection Hypothesis.”Journal of Abnormal Psychology97:330-333.
59.
Morin, Richard
. 1995. “An Army From Academe Tries to Straighten Out `The Bell Curve'.”Washington Post, January 16: A3.
60.
Murray, Charles
. 1984. Losing Ground: American Social Policy, 1950-1980. New York: Basic Books.
61.
Murray, Charles A.
and Louis A. Cox, Jr. 1979. Beyond Probation: Juvenile Corrections and the Chronic Delinquent. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
62.
Murray, Charles A.
and Richard J. Herrnstein. 1994. “Race, Genes and IQ: An Apologia.”The New Republic, October 31: 27-37.
63.
Neisser, Ulric
. 1976. “General, Academic, and Artificial Intelligence.” Pp. 179-189 in Human Intelligence: Perspectives on Its Theory and Measurement, edited by L. Resnick. Norwood, NJ: Ablex.
64.
Neisser, Ulric
, Gwyneth Boodoo, Thomas J. Bouchard, Jr., A. Wade Boykin, Nathan Brody, Stephen J. Ceci, Diane F. Halpern, John C. Loehlin, Robert Perloff, Robert J. Sternberg, and Susana Urbina. 1996. “Intelligence: Knowns and Unknowns.”American Psychologist51:77-101.
65.
Race
. 1994. The New Republic, October 31. (Issue devoted to The Bell Curve)
66.
Raine, Adrian
. 1993. The Psychopathology of Crime: Criminal Behavior as a Clinical Disorder. San Diego: Academic Press.
67.
Rice, Marnie E.
and Grant T. Harris. 1995. Cross-Validation of Actuarial Predictions. Research report, Vol. 12, No. 2. Penetanguishene, Ontario: Mental Health Centre.
68.
Rosnow, Robert L.
and Robert Rosenthal. 1993. Beginning Behavioral Research: A Conceptual Primer. New York: Macmillan.
69.
Schmidt, Frank L.
and John E. Hunter. 1981. “Employment Testing: Old Theories and New Research Findings.”American Psychologist36: 1128-1137.
70.
Simourd, David J.1997. “The Criminal Sentiments Scale-Modified and Pride in Delinquency Scale: Psychometric Properties and Construct Validity of Two Measures of Criminal Attitudes.”Criminal Justice and Behavior24:52-70.
71.
Simourd, Linda
and D. A. Andrews. 1994. “Correlates of Delinquency: A Look at Gender Differences.”Forum on Corrections Research6:26-31.
72.
Snedecor, George W.
1946. Statistical Methods. 4th ed.Ames. Iowa State College Press.
73.
Sternberg, Robert J.
1985. Beyond IQ: A Triarchic Theory. New York: Cambridge University Press.
74.
Sternberg, Robert J.1995a. “For Whom the Bell Curve Tolls: A Review of The Bell Curve.”Psychological Science6:257-261.
75.
Sternberg, Robert J.
1995b. In Search of the Human Mind. Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt Brace.
76.
Sternberg, Robert J.
, Richard K. Wagner, Wendy M. Williams, and Joseph A. Horvath. 1995. “Testing Common Sense.”American Psychologist50:912-927.
77.
Sykes, Gresham M.
and Francis T. Cullen. 1992. Criminology. Fort Worth, TX: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
78.
Taylor, Howard F.1995. “Symposium: The Bell Curve.”Contemporary Sociology24:153-158.
79.
Tittle, Charles R.
and Robert F. Meier. 1990. “Specifying the SES/Delinquency Relationship.”Criminology28:271-299.
80.
Tittle, Charles R.
, Wayne J. Villemez, and Douglas A. Smith. 1978. “The Myth of Social Class and Criminality.”American Sociological Review43:643-656.
81.
Walters, Gary
and Joan Grusec. 1977. Punishment. San Francisco: Freeman.
82.
Ward, David A.
and Charles R. Tittle. 1994. “IQ and Delinquency: A Test of Two Competing Explanations.”Journal of Quantitative Criminology10:189-212.
83.
Wechsler, David
. 1974. The Measurement and Appraisal of Adult Intelligence. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins.
84.
Wilson, James Q.
and Richard J. Herrnstein. 1985. Crime and Human Nature. New York: Simon & Schuster.
85.
Wilson, James Q.
and Joan Petersilia, eds. 1995. Crime. San Francisco: ICS Press.
