In the past decade, private sector involvement in punishment has been vigorously renewed and expanded. In documenting the growth of this trend, the literature has focused on normative issues related to privately operated prisons. Noticeably missing from the privatization debate is discussion of community corrections. This article seeks to fill this void by examining a rapidly growing trend in community corrections, namely the use of private treatment agencies to provide mandated counseling services to probationers. These services can include sex offense, substance abuse, domestic violence, life skills, impulse control, and anger management counseling. The ethical problems posed by the convergence of rehabilitation, discretion, and profit are raised through concrete examples of privatization's effects on both offenders and the control system. Policy recommendations also are provided to establish more principled treatment sanctioning in the community.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Allen, F. A.
1981. The Decline of the Rehabilitative Ideal. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
2.
American Probation and Parole Association
. 1994. Restructuring Intensive Supervision Programs: Applying What Works. Lexington, KY: American Probation and Parole Association.
3.
Beto, Dan Richard
. 1987. “Contracting for Services.”Texas Probation (July).
4.
Blomberg, Thomas
and Karol Lucken. 1994. “Stacking the Deck by Piling Up Sanctions.”Howard Journal33:62-80.
5.
Borna, Shaleen
. 1986. “Free Enterprise Goes to Prison.”British Journal of Criminology26:321-334.
6.
Bowditch, Christine
and Ronald S. Everett. 1987. “Private Prisons: Problems Within the Solution.”Justice Quarterly4:441-453.
7.
Bureau of Justice Assistance
. 1994. State and Local Programs: Focus on What Works. Vol. 1. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs.
8.
Chambers, Marcia
. 1993. “The Term Prison Industry Now Means Business.”National Law Journal25:17-19.
9.
Cikins, Warren I.1986. “Privatization of the American Prison System: An Idea Whose Time Has Come?”Journal of Law and Ethics and Policy2:445-464.
10.
Cody, W. J. Michael
and Andy Bennett. 1987. “The Privatization of Correctional Institutions: The Tennessee Experiment.”Vanderbilt Law Review40:829-849.
11.
Cohen, Stanley
. 1985. Visions of Social Control. Cambridge, England: Polity.
12.
Curran, Daniel J.1988. “Destructuring, Privatization and the Promise of Juvenile Diversion: Compromising Community-Based Corrections. Crime & Delinquency34:363-378.
13.
Duff, Antony
and David Garland. 1994. “Preface: E. Rotman's Beyond Punishment.” Pp. 281-283 in A Reader on Punishment, edited by A. Duff and D. Garland. New York: Oxford University Press.
14.
Dunham, Douglas W.1986. “Inmates' Rights and the Privatization of Prisons.”Columbia Law Review86:1475-1504.
15.
Durham, Alexis M.
1994. “The Future of Correctional Privatization: Lessons From the Past.” Pp. 33-49 in Privatizing Correctional Institutions, edited by G. W. Bowman, S. Hakim, and P. Seidenstat. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
16.
Ewick, Patricia
. 1993. “Corporate Cures: The Commodification of Social Control.”Studies in Law, Politics, and Society13:137-157.
17.
Feeley, Malcolm
. 1991. “The Privatization of Prisons in Historical Perspective.”Criminal Justice Research Bulletin6:1-10.
18.
Feeley, Malcolm
and Jonathan Simon. 1992. “The New Penology.”Criminology30:449-474.
19.
Field, Joseph
. 1987. “Making Prisons Private: An Improper Delegation of a Government Power.”Hofstra Law Review15:649-751.
20.
Florida Department of Corrections
. 1995a. 1994-1995 Annual Report. Tallahassee: Florida Department of Corrections.
21.
Florida Department of Corrections
. 1995b. Probation and Parole Services: Community-Based Treatment Programs. Tallahassee: Florida Department of Corrections.
22.
Gendreau, P.
and D. A. Andrews. 1990. “Tertiary Prevention: What the Meta-Analysis of the Offender Treatment Literature Tells Us About `What Works.'”Canadian Journal of Criminology32:173-184.
23.
Gentry, James T.1986. “The Panopticon Revisited: The Problem of Monitoring Private Prisons.”Yale Law Journal96:353-375.
24.
Givens, Eugene
. 1996. Fulton County Diversionary Drug Court: Treatment Network Development. Sudbury, MA: Advocates for Human Potential.
25.
Jensen, Christy
. 1987. Contracting for Community Corrections Services. Washington, DC: National Institute of Corrections.
26.
Johnson, Byron R.
and Paul P. Ross. 1990. “The Privatization of Correctional Management: A Review.”Journal of Criminal Justice18:351-358.
27.
Lerman, Paul
. 1984. “Child Welfare, the Private Sector, and Community-Based Corrections.”Crime & Delinquency30:5-38.
28.
Lilly, Robert J.1992. “Selling Justice: Electronic Monitoring and the Security Industry.”Justice Quarterly3:493-504.
29.
Lilly, Robert J.
and Richard A. Ball. 1993. “Selling Justice: Will Electronic Monitoring Last?”Northern Kentucky Law Review20:505-530.
30.
Lilly, Robert J.
and Matthieu Deflem. 1996. “Profit and Penality: An Analysis of the Corrections Commercial Complex.”Crime & Delinquency42:3-20.
31.
Lilly, Robert J.
and Paul Knepper. 1993. “The Corrections-Commercial Complex.”Crime & Delinquency39:150-166.
32.
Lindquist, Charles A.1980. “The Private Sector in Corrections: Contracting Probation Services From Community Organizations.”Federal Probation44:58-63.
33.
Little, Gregory
, Kenneth Robinson, and Katherine Burnette. 1994. Cognitive Behavioral Treatment Review and CCI News. Vol. 3, Nos. 2-3. Memphis, TN: Correctional Counseling, Inc.
34.
Logan, Charles H.
1990. Private Prisons: Cons and Pros. New York: Oxford University Press.
35.
Logan, Charles H.1992. “Well Kept Company: The Quality of Confinement in Private and Public Prisons.”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology83:577-613.
36.
Logan, Charles H.
and Gerald G. Gaes. 1993. “Meta-Analysis and the Rehabilitation of Punishment.”Justice Quarterly10:245-263.
37.
Logan, Charles
and Sharla P. Rausch. 1985. “Punish and Profit: The Emergence of Private Enterprise Prisons.”Justice Quarterly2:303-318.
38.
Lovell, David G.
1985. Sentencing Reform and the Treatment of Offenders. Olympia: Washington Council on Crime and Delinquency.
39.
Martinson, Robert
. 1974. “What Works? Questions and Answers About Prison Reform.”The Public Interest35:22-54.
40.
Mason, Todd
. 1994. “For Profit Jails: A Risky Business.” Pp. 163-174 in Privatizing Correctional Institutions, edited by G. W. Bowman, S. Hakim, and P. Seidenstat. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
41.
McDonald, D.1994. “Public Imprisonment by Private Means.”British Journal of Criminology34:29-48.
42.
Morris, Norval
and Michael Tonry. 1990. Between Prison and Probation. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
43.
Mullen, J.1985. “Corrections and the Private Sector.”The Prison Journal65:1-13.
44.
Porter, Robert G.1990. “The Privatization of Prisons in the U.S.: A Policy That Britain Should Not Emulate.”Howard Journal29:65-81.
45.
Robbins, Ira
. 1987. “Privatization of Corrections: Defining the Issues.”Vanderbilt Law Review40:813-828.
46.
Roberts, A. R.
and G. T. Powers. 1985. “The Privatization of Corrections: Methodological Issues and Dilemmas Involved in Evaluative Research.”The Prison Journal65:95-107.
47.
Rothman, David
. 1980. Conscience and Convenience. Boston: Little, Brown.
48.
Rotman, E.
1994. “Beyond Punishment.” Pp. 284-305 in A Reader on Punishment, edited by A. Duff and D. Garland. New York: Oxford University Press.
49.
Savas, Emmanuel S.1987. “Privatization and Prisons.”Vanderbilt Law Review40:88-89.
50.
Scull, Andrew
. 1977. Decarceration: Community Treatment and the Deviant. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
51.
Shichor, David
. 1993. “The Corporate Context of Private Prisons.”Crime, Law, and Social Change20:113-118.
52.
Simon, Jonathan
. 1993. Poor Discipline: Parole and the Social Control of the Underclass, 1890-1990. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
53.
Thomas, Charles
. 1991. “Prisoner's Rights and Corrections Privatization.”Business and Professional Ethics Journal10:3-45.
54.
Thomas, Charles
. 1996. Private Adult Correctional Facility Census. 9th ed.Gainesville: University of Florida, Center for Studies in Crime and Law.
55.
Tonry, Michael
. 1994. “Proportionality, Parsimony, and Interchangeability of Punishment.” Pp. 136-159 in A Reader on Punishment, edited by A. Duff and D. Garland. New York: Oxford University Press.
56.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
. 1992. Drug Abuse Research Series: Extent and Adequacy of Insurance Coverage for Substance Abuse Services—Institute of Medicine Report. Vol. 1. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
57.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
. 1995. Overview of the National Drug and Alcoholism Treatment Unit Survey (NDATUS): 1993 and 1980-1992. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
58.
von Hirsch, Andrew
. 1990. “The Ethics of Community-Based Corrections.”Crime & Delinquency36:162-173.
59.
von Hirsch, Andrew
, Martin Wasik, and Judith Greene. 1989. “Punishments in the Community and the Principles of Desert.”Rutgers Law Journal20:595-618.
60.
Woolley, Mary R.1985. “Prisons for Profit.”Dickinson Law Review90:307-331.
