The primary purpose of judicial waiver is to impose more severe sanctions on offenders than are available in juvenile court. This article explores two dimensions of sanction severity, sentence length and actual time served, to determine if juveniles waived to adult court do receive more severe sanctions. Data were collected on all youth waived to adult court from 1981-1993 and sentenced to prison (n = 946). Juveniles in this population consistently received longer sentences than are available in juvenile court. When actual time served was taken into consideration, however, these youth rarely served more lengthy sentences than are available in juvenile court, serving an average of only 27% of their original sentence.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Allen, Francis A.
1981. The Decline of the Rehabilitative Ideal. New Haven: Yale University Press.
2.
August, Robin
. 1981. A Study of Juveniles Transferred for Prosecution to the Adult System. Miami: Office of the Dade-Miami Criminal Justice Council.
3.
Barnes, Carole
and Randal Franz. 1989. “Questionably Adult: Determinants and Effects of the Juvenile Waiver Decision.”Justice Quarterly6:117-135.
4.
Bishop, Donna M.
, Charles E. Frazier, and John C. Henretta. 1989. “Prosecutorial Waiver: Case Study of a Questionable Reform.”Crime & Delinquency35:179-201.
5.
Boland, Barbara
and James Q. Wilson. 1978. “Age, Crime, and Punishment.”The Public Interest51:22-34.
6.
Bortner, M. A.
1982. Inside a Juvenile Court. New York: New York University Press.
7.
Bortner, M. A.1986. “Traditional Rhetoric, Organizational Realities: Remand of Juveniles to Adult Court.”Crime & Delinquency32:53-73.
8.
Bowker, Marjorie
. 1987. “Waiver of Juveniles to Adult Court under the Juvenile Delinquents Act: Applicability of Principles to Young Offenders Act.”Criminal Law Quarterly29:368-400.
9.
Champion, Dean J.1989. “Teenage Felons and Waiver Hearings: Some Recent Trends, 1980-1988.”Crime & Delinquency35:577-585.
10.
Champion, Dean J.
and G. Larry Mays. 1991. Transferring Juveniles to Criminal Courts. New York: Praeger.
11.
Cullen, Francis T.
, Kathryn M. Golden, and John B. Cullen. 1983. “Is Child Saving Dead? Attitudes Toward Juvenile Rehabilitation in Illinois.”Journal of Criminal Justice11:1-13.
12.
Dawson, Robert O.1992. “An Empirical Study of Kent Style Juvenile Transfers to Criminal Court.”St. Mary's Law Journal23:975-1054.
13.
Eigen, Joel P.1981. “Punishing Youth Homicide Offenders in Philadelphia.”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology72:1072-1093.
14.
Emerson, Robert
. 1981. “On Last Resorts.”American Journal of Sociology87:1-22.
15.
Fagan, Jeffrey
. 1990. “Social and Legal Policy Dimensions of Violent Juvenile Crime.”Criminal Justice and Behavior17:93-133.
16.
Fagan, Jeffrey
and Elizabeth P. Deschenes. 1990. “Determinants of Judicial Waiver Decisions for Violent Juvenile Offenders.”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology81:314-347.
17.
Fagan, Jeffrey
, Martin Forst, and T. Scott Vivona. 1987. Separating the Men from the Boys. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.
18.
Feld, Barry C.1980. “Juvenile Court Legislative Reform and the Serious Young Offender: Dismantling the Rehabilitative Ideal.”Minnesota Law Review65:167-242.
19.
Feld, Barry C.1984a. “Criminalizing Juvenile Justice: Rules of Procedure for the Juvenile Court.”Minnesota Law Review69:141-276.
20.
Feld, Barry C.1984b. “The Decision to Seek Criminal Charges: Just Deserts and the Waiver Decision.”Criminal Justice Ethics3:27-41.
21.
Feld, Barry C.1989. “Bad Law Makes Hard Cases: Reflections on Teen-Aged Axe-murderers, Judicial Activism, and Legislative Default.”Law and Inequality: A Journal of Theory and Practice8:1-101.
22.
Fisher, Wayne S.
and Lori Teichman. 1986. “Juvenile Waivers to Adult Court: A Report to the New Jersey State Legislature.”Criminal Justice Quarterly9:68-103.
23.
Forst, Martin
and Martha-Elin Blomquist. 1992. “Punishment, Accountability, and the New Juvenile Justice.”Juvenile and Family Court Journal43:1-9.
24.
Fritsch, Eric J.
and Craig Hemmens. 1995. “Juvenile Waiver in the United States 1979-1995: A Comparison and Analysis of State Waiver Statutes.”Juvenile and Family Court Journal46:17-35.
25.
Gardner, Martin R.1987. “Punitive Juvenile Justice: Some Observations on a Recent Trend.”International Journal of Law and Psychiatry10:129-151.
26.
Gillespie, L. Kay
and Michael D. Norman. 1984. “Does Certification Mean Prison: Some Preliminary Findings from Utah.”Juvenile and Family Court Journal35:23-34.
27.
Gragg, Frances
. 1986. Juveniles in Adult Court: A Review of Transfers at the Habitual Serious and Violent Juvenile Offender Program Sites. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.
28.
Greenwood, Peter W.
, A. Abrahamse, and Franklin E. Zimring. 1984. Factors Affecting Sentencing Severity for Young Adult Offenders. Santa Monica, CA: Rand.
29.
Hagan, John
and Kristin Bumiller. 1983. “Making Sense of Sentencing: A Review and Critique of Sentencing Research.” Pp. 1-54 in Research on Sentencing: The Search for Reform, edited by A. Blumstein, J. Cohen, S. E. Martin, and M. H. Tonry. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
30.
Hamparian, Donna M.
, Linda K. Estep, Susan M. Muntean, Ramon R. Priestino, Robert G. Swisher, Paul L. Wallace, and Joseph L. White. 1982. Major Issues in Juvenile Justice Information and Training: Youth in Adult Courts: Between Two Worlds. Columbus, OH: Academy for Contemporary Problems.
31.
Houghtalin, Marilyn
and G. Larry Mays. 1991. “Criminal Dispositions of New Mexico Juveniles Transferred to Adult Court.”Crime & Delinquency37:393-407.
32.
Keiter, Robert B.1973. “Criminal or Delinquent? A Study of Juvenile Cases Transferred to the Criminal Court.”Crime & Delinquency19:528-538.
33.
Mays, G. Larry
and Marilyn Houghtalin. 1992. “Trying Juveniles as Adults: A Note on New Mexico's Recent Experience.”The Justice System Journal15:814-823.
34.
Moore, Joan W.
1978. Homeboys. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
35.
Nimick, Ellen
, Linda Szymanski, and Howard Snyder. 1986. Juvenile Court Waiver: A Study of Juvenile Court Cases Transferred to Criminal Court. Pittsburgh, PA: National Center for Juvenile Justice.
36.
Norman, Michael
and L. Kay Gillespie. 1986. “Changing Horses: Utah's Shift in Adjudicating Serious Juvenile Offenders.”Journal of Contemporary Law12:85-98.
37.
President's Commission on Law Enforcement and the Administration of Justice
. 1967. The Challenge of Crime in a Free Society. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
38.
Royscher, Martin
and Peter Edelman. 1981. “Treating Juveniles as Adults in New York: What Does It Mean and How Is It Working?” Pp. 265-293 in Major Issues in Juvenile Justice Information and Training, edited by J. C. Hall, D. M. Hamparian, J. M. Pettibone, and J. L. White. Columbus, OH: Academy for Contemporary Problems.
39.
Rudman, Cary
, Eliot Hartstone, Jeffrey Fagan, and Melinda Moore. 1986. “Violent Youth in Adult Court: Process and Punishment.”Crime & Delinquency32:75-96.
40.
Sagatun, Inger
, Loretta L. McCollum, and Leonard P. Edwards. 1985. “The Effect of Transfers From Juvenile to Adult Court: A Loglinear Analysis.”Crime and Justice8:65-92.
41.
Shakur, Sanyika
. 1993. Monster. New York: Penguin.
42.
Sweet, Robert W., Jr.1991. “Beyond the Mandates: The Chronic Offender.”Juvenile and Family Court Journal42:1-7.
43.
Teilmann Van Dusen
, Katherine. 1981. “Adult Court Transfer: A Move toward Tougher Handling?” Presented at the American Society of Criminology Meeting, Washington, DC.
Thomas, Charles W.
and Shay Bilchik. 1985. “Prosecuting Juveniles in Criminal Courts: A Legal and Empirical Analysis.”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology76:439-479.
46.
United States Department of Justice
. 1988. Report to the Nation on Crime and Justice. 2d ed.Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics.
47.
von Hirsch, Andrew
. 1971. Doing Justice. New York: Hill and Wang.
48.
Zimring, Franklin E.1991. “The Treatment of Hard Cases in American Juvenile Justice: In Defense of Discretionary Waiver.”Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics, and Public Policy5:267-280.
