Traditionally, adjudicatory hearings in juvenile court operated under the direction of the parens patriae doctrine, the state's obligation and license to care for children. Adjudications were achieved in informal, clinic-like sessions. The Supreme Court purportedly transformed juvenile court hearings into criminal-like trials via the Gault and Winship decisions. This research examines the extent to which juvenile court personnel currently perceive remnants of parens patriae in the adjudicatory hearing. One hundred workers (judges, prosecutors, defense attorneys, and probation officers) from three different juvenile courts (urban, suburban, and rural) were interviewed concerning sources of unfairness in the contemporary adjudicatory hearing. The results indicate that court workers see numerous obstacles to fairness in the juvenile court adjudicatory hearing.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Babbie, Earl
. 1992. The Practice of Social Research. 6th ed.Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
2.
Binder, Arnold
, Gilbert Geis, and Bruce Dickson. 1988. Juvenile Delinquency: Historical, Cultural, Legal Perspectives. New York: Macmillan.
3.
Bortner, M. A.
1984. Inside a Juvenile Court: The Tarnished Ideal of Individualized Justice. New York: New York University Press.
4.
Bortner, M. A.
1988. Delinquency and Justice: An Age of Crisis. New York: McGraw-Hill.
5.
Chused, Richard H.1973. “The Juvenile Court Process: A Study of Three New Jersey Counties.”Rutgers Law Review26:488-615.
6.
Cicourel, Aaron V.
1968. The Social Organization of Juvenile Justice. New York: Wiley.
7.
Clarke, Stevens H.
and Gary G. Koch. 1980. “Juvenile Court: Therapy or Crime Control, and Do Lawyers Make a Difference?”Law & Society Review14:263-308.
8.
Cox, Steven M.
and John J. Conrad. 1991. Juvenile Justice: A Guide to Practice and Theory. 3rd ed.Dubuque, IA: William C. Brown.
9.
Drowns, Robert W.
and Karen M. Hess. 1990. Juvenile Justice. St. Paul, MN: West.
10.
Duffee, David
and Larry Siegel. 1971. “The Organization Man: Legal Counsel in the Juvenile Court.”Criminal Law Bulletin7:544-553.
11.
Emerson, Robert M.
1969. Judging Delinquents: Context and Process in Juvenile Court. Chicago: Aldine.
12.
Fabricant, Michael
. 1983. Juveniles in the Family Courts. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
13.
Feld, Barry C.1988. “In re Gault Revisited: A Cross-State Comparison of the Right to Counsel in Juvenile Court.”Crime & Delinquency34:393-424.
14.
Feld, Barry C.1989. “The Right to Counsel in Juvenile Court: An Empirical Study of When Lawyers Appear and the Difference They Make.”Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology79:1185-1346.
15.
Feld, Barry C.
1993. Justice for Children: The Right to Counsel and the Juvenile Courts. Boston: Northeastern University Press.
16.
Ferster, Elyce Z.
, Thomas F. Courtless, and Edith N. Snethen. 1971. “The Juvenile Justice System: In Search of the Role of Counsel.”Fordham Law Review39:375-412.
17.
Fitzgerald, Jack D.
and Steven M. Cox. 1987. Research Methods in Criminal Justice: An Introduction. Chicago: Nelson-Hall.
18.
Gough, Aidan R.1967. “Referees in California's Juvenile Courts: A Study in Sub-Judicial Adjudication.”Hastings Law Journal19:3-28.
19.
Horowitz, Donald L.
1977. The Courts and Social Policy. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution.
20.
In re Gault. 1967. 387 U.S. 1.
21.
In re Winship. 1970. 397 U.S. 358.
22.
Ito, Jeanne A.1982. “Inside Metropolitan Juvenile Courts: How Their Structure Affects the Outcome of Cases.”State Court Journal6:16-22.
23.
Ito, Jeanne A.
1984. Measuring the Difference for Different Types of Juvenile Courts. Williamsburg, VA: National Center for State Courts.
24.
Knitzer, Jane
and Merrill Sobie. 1984. Law Guardians in New York State: A Study of the Legal Representation of Children. New York: New York State Bar Association.
25.
Lefstein, Norman
, Vaughan Stapleton, and Lee Teitelbaum. 1969. “In Search of Juvenile Justice: Gault and Its Implementation.”Law & Society Review3:491-562.
26.
Lotz, Roy
, Eric D. Poole, and Robert M. Regoli. 1985. Juvenile Delinquency and Juvenile Justice. New York: Random House.
27.
Mahoney, Anne R.1985. “Time and Process in Juvenile Court.”Justice System Journal10:37-55.
28.
McKeiver v. Pa. 1971. 403 U.S. 528.
29.
Reasons, Charles
. 1970. “Gault: Procedural Change and Substantive Effect.”Crime & Delinquency16:163-171.
30.
Rogers, Joseph W.
and G. Larry Mays. 1987. Juvenile Delinquency and Juvenile Justice. New York: Wiley.
31.
Rubin, H. Ted
. 1977. “The Juvenile Court's Search for Identity and Responsibility.”Crime & Delinquency23:1-13.
32.
Rubin, H. Ted
. 1981. “Between Recommendations and Orders: The Limbo Status of Juvenile Court Referees.”Crime & Delinquency27:317-335.
33.
Sanborn, Joseph B.1993. “The Right to a Public Jury Trial: A Need for Today's Juvenile Court.”Judicature76:230-238.
34.
Sandhu, Harjit S.
and C. Wayne Heasley. 1981. Improving Juvenile Justice. New York: Human Sciences Press.
35.
Schultz, J. Lawrence
and Fred Cohen. 1976. “Isolationism in Juvenile Court Jurisprudence.” Pp. 20-42 in Pursuing Justice for the Child, edited by M. K. Rosenheim. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
36.
Schwartz, Ira M.
1989. (In)Justice for Juveniles: Rethinking the Best Interests of the Child. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
37.
Siegel, Larry J.
and Joseph J. Senna. 1991. Juvenile Delinquency: Theory, Practice, and Law. 4th ed.St. Paul, MN: West.
38.
Simonsen, Clifford E.
1991. Juvenile Justice in America. 3rd ed.New York: Macmillan.
39.
Sosin, Michael
and Rosemary Sarri. 1976. “Due Process-Myth or Reality?” Pp. 176-206 in Brought to Justice? Juveniles, the Courts and the Law, edited by R. Sarri and Y. Hasenfeld. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
40.
Stapleton, W. Vaughan
, D. Aday, and Jeanne A. Ito. 1982. “An Empirical Typology of American Metropolitan Courts.”American Sociological Review88: 549-561.
41.
Stapleton, W. Vaughan
and Lee E. Teitelbaum. 1972. In Defense of Youth: A Study of the Role of Counsel in American Juvenile Courts. New York: Russell Sage.
42.
Walter, James D.
and Susan A. Ostrander. 1982. “An Observational Study of a Juvenile Court.”Juvenile & Family Court Journal33:53-69.
43.
Whitebread, John T.
and Steven P. Lab, 1990. Juvenile Justice: An Introduction. Cincinnati: Anderson.
