Growing Fears,Rising Crime: Juveniles and China's Justice System

Abstract

While the officially reported incidence of juvenile offenses in the People's Republic of China is significantly lower than that in much of the remainder of the world community, youthful offenders account for about 75% of all criminal cases. This article provides some preliminary insights into juvenile justice in China based on the data available. The study examines survey data from the Chinese Ministry of Public Security and establishes that juveniles in China have a greater fear of crime than their elders and are less willing to cooperate with and less trusting of the justice system. Next, the analysis examines statistical data, both national and provincial, and establishes that youthful offenders account for a disproportionate amount of total crime committed. The work briefly examines crime causation theories forwarded by Chinese scholars and concludes by focusing on gongdu (work-study) schools, examining their philosophy, structure, and their apparent success in reforming juvenile offenders.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Cao Manzhi , ed. 1998. Zhongguo qingshaonian fanzuixue [The Criminology of Chinese Juvenile Delinquency]. Beijing: Qunzhong chubanshe.

China Law Yearbook 1987. 1988. Beijing: Law Publishing House.

China News Analysis. 1989. September 1, pp. 1-3.

Dutton, Michael . 1991. “Policing the People.” Paper presented at Australian and New Zealand Society of Criminology Conference, Melbourne, Australia, October.

Dutton, Michael . 1992. Policing and Punishment in China: From Patriarchy to “The People.” Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Epstein, Irving . 1987. “Juvenile Delinquency and Reformatory Education in Chinese Society.” Unpublished manuscript.

Gang Chen . 1992. “China Reins in Juvenile Delinquency.” Beijing Review 35:23-27.

Gargan, Edward A. 1988a. “Chinese Officials Drop the Portrait of Peace.” International Herald Tribune, July 8.

Gargan, Edward A. 1988b. “To Fail Is Human, to Get Into a University Divine.” New York Times, July 12, p. A4.

10.

Guo Jie and Yang Xiaobing . 1989. “Juvenile Delinquency.” Beijing Review 32:24-26.

11.

Guo Xiang . 1990. “Non-criminal Punishment of Juvenile Delinquency and Alternative Measures of Institutionalization.” Unpublished manuscript.

12.

Han Deng-re, Wang Bing-zhi , and Zhang Shen-chao . 1988. “Exploring the Ways of Correcting the Harmful Need Structure of the Work-Study Students.” Paper presented at the International Symposium on Education of Juvenile Delinquents, Shanghai, China, October.

13.

Liu, Bing-zhong and Huai-de Fu . 1988. “Respect and Love Are the Prerequisites for the Reeducation of Juvenile Delinquents.” Paper presented at the International Symposium on Education of Juvenile Delinquents, Shanghai, China, October.

14.

Shao Daosheng , ed. 1987. Zhongguo qingshaonian fanzui de shehuixue sikao [Sociological Reflections on Chinese Juvenile Crime]. Beijing: Shehui kexue wenxian chubanshe.

15.

Takahashi, Sadahiko and Dae H. Chang . 1985. “Crime and Delinquency Prevention in Japan.” Comparative Criminal Policy, pp. 221-234.

16.

Wang Xichen . 1991. “Preliminary Analysis on Current Situation of Chinese Juveniles' Feeling of Safety.” Public Security Studies 4.

17.

WuDunn, Sheryl . 1991. “Economic Progress in China Has a Seedy Side.” New York Times, April 21, p. 11.

18.

Xin Ming , ed. 1991. Fanzui xue [Criminology]. Chongquig: Chongqing chubanshe.

19.

Yao Jianguo . 1991. “Yunnan: China's Anti-Drug Output.” Beijing Review 34:20-25.

20.

Zang, Chunting . 1988. “Early Precautions of Family Education and Juvenile Delinquency.” Paper presented at the International Symposium on Education of Juvenile Delinquents, Shanghai, China, October.

21.

Zhongguo qingshaonian fanzui yanjiu nianjian 1987 [Yearbook on Chinese Delinquency Studies 1987]. 1988. Beijing: Chunqui chubanshe.

22.

Zhou, Chang-gen and Zhen-min Xia . 1988. “The Psychological Characteristics As Well As the Prevention and Cure for the Formation of Youngsters' Unlawful and Criminal Cliques.” Paper presented at the International Symposium on Education of Juvenile Delinquents, Shanghai, China, October.

23.

Zhou, Qingun . 1989. “China's Policy, and Its Effects, for Educating Middle School Students Violating Laws and Committing Minor Criminal Offenses.” Paper presented at the International Symposium on Education of Juvenile Delinquents, Shanghai, China, October.