This article presents highlights from a larger study tracing the history (1908-1984) of public policies affecting the disposition of delinquent, neglected, and emotionally disturbed anglophone youth in Montreal. The impact of these policies is examined from the vantage point of a single organization, The Boys' Farm/Shawbridge Youth Centres, and its long attempts to control the admission of clients. The analysis demonstrates how professionalization altered, masked, and legitimated organizational strategies for selecting desirable clients and warding off undesirable ones. The effectiveness of these transformed client-recruitment strategies is clearly displayed against the backdrop of earlier, balder and less successful strategies.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Act Respecting Health Services and Social Services of 1971. Statutes of Quebec, c. 48.
2.
Cohen, Stanley
. 1985. Visions of Social Control: Crime, Punishment and Classification. Cambridge: Polity.
3.
Curran, Daniel J.1988. “Destructuring, Privatization, and the Promise of Juvenile Diversion: Compromising Community-Based Corrections.”Crime & Delinquency34:363-378.
4.
Fombrun, Charles J.1986. “Structural Dynamics Within and Between Organizations.”Administrative Science Quarterly31: 403-421.
5.
Hackler, James C.1983. “The Challenge of Legislating Juvenile Justice: A Commentary on the Report of the Charbonneau Commission. Quebec.”Canadian Journal of Criminology25:354-360.
6.
Hackler, James C.1988. “Practicing in France What Americans Have Preached: The Response of French Judges to Juveniles.”Crime & Delinquency34:467-485.
7.
Harevan, Tamara K.1969. “An Ambiguous Alliance: Some Aspects of American Influences on Canadian Social Welfare.”Histoire Sociale/Social History3:82-100.
8.
Juvenile Delinquents Act of 1908. Statutes of Canada, 7-8 Ed. VII, 1908, c. 40.
9.
Klein, Malcolm W.
1979. “Deinstitutionalization and Diversion of Juvenile Offenders: A Litany of Impediments.” Pp. 145-201 in Crime and Justice: An Annual Review of Research, Vol. 1, edited by Norval Morris and Michael Tonry. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
10.
Lang, Claire Larracey
. 1981. “Good Cases - Bad Cases: Client Selection and Professional Prerogative in a Community Mental Health Center.”Urban Life10:289-309.
11.
LeBlanc, Marc
and Helene Beaumont. 1988. “The Quebec Perspective on the Young Offenders Act: Implementation before Adoption.” Pp. 81-92 in Justice and the Young Offender in Canada, edited by Joe Hudson, Joseph P. Hornick, and Barbara Burrows. Toronto: Wall and Thompson.
12.
Lerman, Paul
. 1982. Deinstitutionalization and the Welfare State. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
13.
McRoberts, Kenneth
. 1988. Quebec: Social Change and Political Crisis. 3rd ed.Toronto: McClelland and Stewart.
14.
Mennel, Robert M.
1983. “Attitudes and Policies Toward Juvenile Delinquency in the United States: A Historiographical Review.” Pp. 191-224 in Crime and Justice: An Annual Review of Research, Vol. 4, edited by Michael Tonry and Norval Morris. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
15.
Meyer, John W.
and W. Richard Scott. 1983. “Centralization and the Legitimacy Problems of Local Government.” Pp. 199-215 in Organizational Environments: Ritual and Rationality, edited by John W. Meyer and W. Richard Scott. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
16.
Moyer, Sharon
. 1980. Diversion from the Juvenile Justice System and its Impact on Children: A Review of the Literature. Ottawa: Minister of Supply and Services Canada.
17.
Peyrot, M.1982. “Caseload Management: Choosing Suitable Clients in a Community Health Clinic Agency.”Social Problems30:155-167.
18.
Rains, Prue
. 1984. “Juvenile Justice and The Boys' Farm: Surviving a Court-Created Population Crisis, 1909-1948.”Social Problems31:500-513.
19.
Rains, Prue
and Eli Teram. 1990. Normal Bad Boys: Public Policies, Institutions and the Politics of Client Recruitment. Submitted for publication.
20.
Rothman, Claire
and Christine Scattolin. 1983. Quebec Youth Law: The Youth Protection Act and the Young Offenders Act. Montreal: Legal Information Research Group, McGill University.
21.
Rothman, David
. 1980. Conscience and Convenience. Boston: Little, Brown.
22.
Scott, Robert A.1967. “The Selection of Clients by Social Welfare Agencies: The Case of the Blind.”Social Problems14:248-257.
23.
Teram, Eli. 1986. “The Interorganizational Processing of Clients and Information.” Unpublished doctoral dissertation, School of Social Work, McGill University.
24.
Teram, Eli
. 1988a. “The Politics of Interorganizational Structures.”Canadian Social Work Review5:236-251.
25.
Teram, Eli
. 1988b. “From Self-Managed Hearts to Collective Action: Dealing with Incompatible Demands in the Child Welfare System.”Children and Youth Services Review10:305-315.
26.
Teram, Eli
and Gerald Erickson. 1988. “The Protection of Children's Rights as Ceremony and Myth: A Critique of the Review of Institutional Placements in Quebec and Ontario.”Children and Youth Services Review10:1-17.
27.
Trepanier, Jean
. 1983. “The Quebec Youth Protection Act: Institutionalized Diversion.” Pp. 191-202 in Current Issues in Juvenile Justice, edited by Raymond Corrado, Marc LeBlanc, and Jean Trepanier. Toronto: Butterworths.
28.
Van Dusen, Katherine Teilmann
. 1981. “Net Widening and Relabeling: Some Consequences of Deinstitutionalization.”American Behavioral Scientist24: 801-810.
29.
Young Offenders Act of 1982. Revised Statutes of Canada, 1980-81-82-83, c. 110.
30.
Youth Protection Act of 1977. Statutes of Quebec, c. 20.
31.
Youth Protection Schools Act of 1950. Statutes of Quebec, 8-9 Elizabeth II, c. 42.
