The increasing prevalence of minority youth in the juvenile justice system has renewed concerns over racial disparities in juvenile justice processing. Previous research has yielded ambiguous results, with findings complicated by methodological shortcomings, divergent research strategies, and design artifacts. To resolve questions on the extent and source of racial disparities in juvenile justice processing, research is needed on the nature, location, and magnitude of discrimination in the juvenile justice system. This study examines racial disparities in decision making at six points in the juvenile justice process, from apprehension through judicial commitment decisions. Samples of Anglo and minority youth were drawn at each point, controlling for offense severity, other offense characteristics, and extralegal factors in addition to race. The results show racial disparities at each point, with minorities consistently receiving harsher dispositions. Disparities took different forms at various stages of the process, usually for nonserious offenses. Race was a direct, indirect, and interactive influence at various decision points. Disparities were observed at other times only when controlling for other extralegal factors such as family status. The results suggest that the juvenile justice system reflects social and economic disparities endemic in other social domains. The correlates of delinquency in minority and predominantly Anglo populations are similar. Accordingly, base rate differences may be less important than societal reaction in explaining the overrepresentation of minorities in the juvenile justice process. The narrowing of social gaps may also reduce disparate perceptions of minorities in the juvenile justice system, and restore their population balance in delinquent populations.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ArnoldW. R.1971“Race and ethnicity relative to other factors in juvenile court dispositions.”Amer. J. of Sociology77: 211–227.
2.
BaileyW. C.1981“Preadjudicatory detention in a large metropolitan juvenile court.”Law and Human Behavior5: 19–43.
3.
BaileyW. C.PetersonR. D.1981“Legal versus extra-legal determinants of juvenile court dispositions.”Juvenile and Family Court J. XX: 41–59.
4.
BortnerM. A.1985“Race and the impact of juvenile deinstitutionalization.”Crime & Delinquency31: 35–46.
5.
BraithwaiteJ.1981“The myth of social class and criminality reconsidered.”Amer. Soc. Rev. 46: 36–57.
6.
ByrneJ.SampsonR., [eds.] 1986“Introduction,” in The Social Ecology of Crime: Theory, Research, and Public Policy. New York: Springer-Verlag.
7.
CarrollL.JacksonP.1983“Inequality, opportunity, and crime rates in central cities.”Criminology21: 178–194.
8.
CarterT.ClellandD.1979“A new-Marxian critique, formulation and test of juvenile dispositions as a function of social class.”Social Problems27: 96–108.
9.
CernkovichS. A.GiordanoP. C.PughM. D.1985“Chronic offenders: the missing cases in self-report delinquency research.”J. of Criminal Law and Criminology76: 705–732.
10.
ChusedR. H.1973“The juvenile court process: a study of three New Jersey counties.”Rutgers Law Rev. 26: 488–539.
11.
CoatesR.MillerA.OhlinL.1975Diversity in a Youth Correctional System: Handling Delinquents in Massachusetts. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.
12.
CohenL. E.KluegelJ. R.1978“Determinants of juvenile court dispositions: ascriptive and achieved factors in two metropolitan courts.”Amer. Soc. Rev. 43: 162–176.
13.
CohenL. E.KluegelJ. R.1979“Selecting delinquents for adjudication: an analysis of intake screening decisions in two metropolitan juvenile courts.”J. of Research in Crime and Delinquency16: 143–163.
14.
ComerJ.1985“Black violence and public policy,” In CurtisL. (ed.) American Violence and Public Policy. New Haven, CT: Yale Univ. Press.
15.
DanneferD.SchuttR. K.1982“Race and juvenile justice processing in court and police agencies.”Amer. J. of Sociology87: 1113–1132.
16.
DatesmanS. K.ScarpittiF. R.1977“Unequal protection for males and females in the juvenile court,” in FerdinandT. (ed.) Little Brother Grows Up. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
17.
DungworthT.1977“Discretion in the juvenile justice system: the impact of case characteristics on prehearing detention,” in FerdinandT. (ed.) Little Brother Grows Up. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
18.
ElliottD. S.AgetonS.1980“Reconciling race and class differences in self-reported and official estimates of delinquency.”Amer. Soc. Rev. 45: 95–110.
19.
ElliottD. S.HuizingaD.1983“Social class and delinquent behavior in a national youth panel.”Criminology21: 149–177.
20.
FaganJ. A.PiperE.MooreM.1986“Violent delinquents and urban youth.”Criminology24: 439–472.
21.
FarrellR. A.SwigertV. L.1978“Prior offense record as a self-fulfilling prophecy.”Law and Society Rev. 12: 437–453.
22.
FerdinandT. N.LuchterhandE. G.1970“Inner-city youth, the police, the juvenile court, and justice.”Social Problems17: 510–527.
23.
HindelangM.HirschiT.WeisJ.1981Measuring Delinquency. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
24.
JohnstoneJ. W. C.1978“Social class, social areas, and delinquency.”Sociology and Social Research63: 49–72.
25.
KramerJ. H.SteffensmeierD. J.1978“The differential detention jailing of juveniles: a comparison of detention and non-detention courts.”Pepperdine Law Rev. 5: 795–807.
26.
KrohnM. D.MasseyJ. L.1980“Social control and delinquent behavior: an examination of the elements of the social bond.”Sociological Q. 21: 529–544.
27.
LanganP.1985“Racism on trial: new evidence to explain the racial composition of prisons in the United States.”J. of Criminal Law and Criminology76: 666–683.
28.
LaubJ. H.1983“Urbanism, race, and crime.”J. of Research in Crime and Delinquency20: 183–198.
29.
LewisD. O.ShanokS. S.CohenR. J.GrantM.RitvoE.1980“Race bias in the diagnosis and disposition of violent adolescents.”Amer. J. of Psychiatry137: 1211–1216.
30.
LiskaA. E.TausigM.1979Theoretical interpretations of social class and racial differentials in legal decision-making for juveniles. Soc. Q. 20: 197–207.
31.
MartinE.1983“Minorities in the juvenile justice system.” Unpublished manuscript, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, Washington, DC.
32.
McCarthyB. R.SmithB. L.1986“The conceptualization of discrimination in the juvenile justice process: the impact of administrative factors and screening decisions on juvenile court dispositions.”Criminology24: 41–64.
33.
McEachernA. W.BauzerR.1967“Factors related to disposition in juvenile police contacts,” in KleinM.MeyerhoffB. (eds.) Juvenile Gangs in Context: Theory, Research and Action. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
34.
MeadeA.1973“Seriousness of delinquency, the adjudicative decision and recidivism—a longitudinal configuration analysis.”J. of Criminal Law and Criminology64: 478–485.
35.
PawlakE. J.1977“Differential selection of juveniles for detention.”J. of Research in Crime and Delinquency15: 153–165.
36.
PooleE. D.RegoliR. M.1980“An analysis of the determinants of juvenile court dispositions.”Juvenile and Family Court J. 16: 23–32.
37.
ReedW. L.1984“Racial differentials in juvenile court decision-making: final report.”Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, National Institute for Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.
38.
SampsonR.1986“Crime in cities: formal and informal social control,” in ReissA.Jr.TonryM. (eds.) Crime and Justice: An Annual Review of Research, vol. 8. Communities and Crime. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
39.
SchusterR. L.1981“Black and white violent delinquents: a longitudinal cohort study,” in McNeelyR. L.PopeC. E. (eds.) Race, Crime and Criminal Justice. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
40.
StrasburgP. A.1984“Recent national trends in serious juvenile crime,” pp. 5–30 in MathiasR. (eds.) Violent Juvenile Offenders: An Anthology. San Francisco: National Council on Crime and Delinquency.
41.
SmithD. A.1986“The neighborhood context of police behavior,” in ReissA.Jr.TonryM. (eds.) Crime and Justice: An Annual Review of Research, vol. 8. Communities and Crime. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
42.
SumnerH.1970Locking Them Up. Davis, CA: Council on Crime and Delinquency, Western Region.
43.
TerryR. M.1967a“Discrimination in the handling of juvenile offenders by social control agencies.”J. of Research in Crime and Delinquency5: 218–230.
44.
TerryR. M.1967b“The screening of juvenile offenders.”J. of Criminal Law, Criminology and Police Sci. 58: 173–181.
45.
ThomasC. W.CageR. J.1977“The effect of social characteristics on juvenile court dispositions.”Soc. Q. 18: 237–252.
46.
ThornberryT. P.1973“Race, socioeconomic status and sentencing in the juvenile justice system.”J. of Criminal Law and Criminology64: 90–98.
47.
ThornberryT. P.FarnworthM.1982“Social correlates of criminal involvement: further evidence of the relationship between social status and criminal behavior.”Amer. Soc. Rev. 47: 508–518.
48.
TittleC. R.VillemezW. J.SmithD. A.1978“The myth of social class and criminality.”Amer. Soc. Rev. 43: 643–656.
49.
U. S. Department of Justice1985Children in Custody. Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics. Wellford, C.
50.
U. S. Department of Justice1975“Labelling theory and criminology: an assessment.”Social Problems22: 332–345.
51.
WilsonJ. Q.1968“The police and the delinquent in two cities,” In WheelerS. (ed.) Controlling Delinquents. New York: John Wiley.
52.
WolfgangM. E.FiglioR. M.SellinT.1972Delinquency in a Birth Cohort. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
