The development of “slammer laws,” which require mandatory jail terms for drivers convicted on charges of drinking-and-driving, represents an emotional response to a serious but misunderstood problem. As an alternative to this and other unsuccessful policies now in use, we suggest that consideration be given to the potential utilization of some form of Home Incarceration. An examination of some prevalent myths about the “drunken driver” is followed by a review of recent research that has provided a different picture of the problem. Theoretical considerations are outlined and special attention is given to the obstacles impeding enforcement of various alternate sentences. Home Incarceration is then examined in terms of potential advantages and disadvantages as a sanction for “drunken drivers.”
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aaronson, D. E.
, B. H. Hoff, P. Jaszi, N. N. Kittrie, and D. Sarri 1977 The New Justice: Alternatives to Conventional Criminal Adjudication. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
2.
Argeriou, M.
and D. Paulino1976“Women arrested for drunken driving in Boston: social characteristics and circumstances of arrest.”J. of Studies on Alcohol37, 5: 43-54.
3.
Bacon, S.1968“Traffic accidents involving alcohol in the U.S.A.: second stage aspects of a social problem.”Q. J. of Studies on Alcohol Supplement4 (May): 11-33.
4.
Ball, R. A.
1979 “A theory of punishment: restricted reprobation and the reparation of social reality,” pp. 135-149 in P. J. Brantingham and R. L. Akers (eds.) Structure, Law, and Power. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
5.
Ball, R. A.
and J. R. Lilly 1983a “Home incarceration: an alternative to total incarceration.” Presented at IX International Congress on Criminology, Vienna.
6.
Ball, R. A.
and J. R. Lilly 1983b “The potential use of home incarceration with drunken drivers.” Presented at meetings of American Society of Criminology, San Francisco.
7.
Ball, R. A.
and J. R. Lilly 1984 “Giving birth to electronic shackles in Kentucky.” Presented at meetings of American Society of Criminology, Cincinnati.
8.
Ben-David, G.
, I. Levine, Y. Haliva, and N. Tel-Nir1972“The influence of personal communication on the driving behavior of private citizens in Israel.”Accident Analysis and Prevention4: 269-301.
9.
Bennett, L. A.
1985 “Is electronic monitoring working? A view from the top.” Presented at meetings of American Society of Criminology, San Diego.
10.
Bieda, T.
and F. Ferracuti1980“Alternatives to incarceration in Italy.”Crime & Delinquency26, 1: 63-69.
11.
Bloch, S. A.1982“Administrative adjudication: an evaluation of its applications, effectiveness, and potential for DUI.”Abstracts in Alcohol and Driving3, 8: 5-6.
12.
Borkenstein, R. F.
, R. P. Crowther, R. F. Shumate, W. B. Zeil, and R. Zylman 1964 The Role of the Drinking Driver in Traffic Accidents. Bloomington: Indiana University Department of Police Administration.
13.
Boston Globe1983“Bay state roadblocks to combat drunken driving upheld by court.”November 22: 30.
14.
Buikhuizen, W.
1968 “Size of penalty and recidivism,” pp. 35-45 in W. Buikhuizen (ed.) Alcohol and Traffic. Boom en Zoon, Meppel: Netherlands.
15.
Cameron, T.
1977 “Alcohol and traffic,” pp. 43-51 in M. Arenset al. (eds.) Alcohol, Casualties and Crime. Report C-18. Berkeley, CA: Social Research Group.
16.
Campbell, H. E.1964“The role of alcohol in fatal traffic `accidents' and measures needed to solve the problem.”Michigan Medicine63: 699-703.
17.
Carpenter, J. A.1968“Contributions from psychology to the study of drinking and driving.”Q. J. of Studies on Alcohol Supplement4 (May): 234-251.
18.
Clarke, R. V.
1983 “Situational crime prevention: its theoretical basis and practical scope,” pp. 225-256 in M. Tonry and N. Morris (eds.) Crime and Justice: An Annual Review of Research. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
19.
Conrad, J.1985“The penal dilemma and its emerging solution.”Crime & Delinquency31, 3: 411-422.
20.
Cosper, R. L.
1965 “Drinking and driving in a community setting.”Proceedings of the fourth International Conference on Alcohol and Traffic Safety, pp. 105-111.
21.
Cosper, R. L.
and K. Mozersky1968“Social correlates of drinking and driving.”Q. J. of Studies on Alcohol Supplement4 (May): 58-117.
22.
County Court (Denver)
1968 The Use of Volunteer Probation Counselors with Misdemeanants: A Special Demonstration Project. Denver, CO: Author.
23.
Crancer, A.
and D. L. Quiring 1969 Driving Records of Persons Arrested for Illegal Drug Use: Report 011. State of Washington: Department of Motor Vehicles.
24.
Donovan, D. M.
and G. A. Marlatt1982“Personality subtypes among driving-while-intoxicated offenders: relationship to drinking behavior and driving risk.”J. of Consulting Clinical Psychology50, 2: 110-118.
25.
Douglas, R. L.
, L. P. Filkins, and F. A. Clark 1974 The Effect of Lower Drinking Ages on Youth Crash Involvement. Ann Arbor, MI: Highway Safety Research Institute.
26.
Eelkema, R.
, C. J. Brosseau, B. S. Koshnick, and C. McGee1970“A statistical study on the relationship between mental illness and traffic accidents.”Amer. J. of Public Health60: 459-461.
27.
Galvin, J. J.
, W. H. Busher, W. Greene, G. Kemp, N. Harlow, and K. Hoffman 1974 Pre- and Post-Trial Alternatives to Jail Incarceration (Vol. 4). Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
28.
Gerber, S. R.
, P. V. Jolist, and J. R. Feegel1966“Single motor vehicle accidents in Cuyahoga County, Ohio, 1958-1963.”J. of Forensic Sciences11: 144-151.
29.
Gerety, P.1980“A French program to reduce pretrial detention.”Crime & Delinquency26, 1: 22-34.
30.
Goldsmith, M.1983“The supreme court and Title III: rewriting the law of electronic surveillance.”J. of Criminal Law and Criminology74, 1: 1-171.
31.
Gusfield, J. R.
1976 “The prevention of drinking problems,” pp. 112-130 in W. Filsteadet al. (eds.) Alcohol and Alcohol Problems. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.
32.
Gusfield, J. R.
1981 The Culture of Public Problems: Drinking-Driving and the Symbolic Order. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
33.
Heijder, A.1980“Can we cope with alternatives.”Crime & Delinquency26, 1: 1-9.
34.
Holden, L. T.
, P. Stewart, N. Rice, and E. Manker 1981 Tennessee's DUI (Driving While Under the Influence of Intoxicants) Probation Follow-up Demonstration Project. Washington, DC: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
35.
Hyman, M. M.1968“The social characteristics of persons arrested for driving while intoxicated.”Q. J. of Studies on Alcohol Supplement4 (May): 138-177.
36.
Kaestner, N.
and L. Speight1975“Successful alternatives to license suspension: the defensive driving course and probationary license.”J. of Safety Research7, 2: 56-66.
37.
Krisberg, B.
and J. Austin 1981 The Unmet Promise of Alternatives to Incarceration. San Francisco: National Council on Crime and Delinquency.
38.
LEAA
1971 Volunteers in Law Enforcement Programs. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
39.
Lilly, J. R.
and R. A. Ball 1985 “Home incarceration in Kentucky: an empirical analysis.” Presented at meetings of American Society of Criminology, San Diego.
40.
Marx, G. T.1985a“The new surveillance.”Technology Rev.45: 43-48.
41.
Marx, G. T.1985b“I'll be watching you.”Dissent27: 26-33.
42.
McBride, R. S.
and R. C. Peck1970“Modifying negligent driving behavior through warning letters.”Accident Analysis and Prevention2: 147-174.
43.
McCarrol, J. P.
and W. Haddon1962“A controlled study of fatal automobile accidents in New York City.”J. of Chronic Diseases15: 811-826.
44.
National Association of Counties Research Foundation
1976 A Practical Manual for County Officials on the Treatment of Alcoholism. Washington, DC: Author.
45.
National Advisory Commission on Criminal Justice Standards and Goals for Courts
1973 Report. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
46.
National Advisory Commission of Criminal Justice Standards and Goals for the Criminal Justice System
1973 Report. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
47.
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
1979 Results of National Alcohol Safety Action Projects. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
48.
Niederberger, W. V.
and W. F. Wagner 1985 Electronic Monitoring of Convicted Offenders: A Field Test. Report to the National Institute of Justice.
49.
Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention
1980 Removing Children from Adult Jails: A Guide to Action. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
50.
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)
1978 New Research on the Role of Alcohol and Drugs in Road Accidents. Paris: Author.
51.
Ranii, D.1983“Ankle signal linked to computer to monitor probationers in N. M.”National Law J. (March 28): 3.
52.
Ross, H. L.1975“The Scandinavian myth: the effectiveness of drinking-and-driving legislation in Sweden and Norway.”J. of Legal Studies6: 285-310.
53.
Ross, H. L.
1981 Deterring the Drunken Driver. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
54.
Scioli, F. P.
and T. J. Cook1976“How effective are volunteers?”Crime & Delinquency22, 2: 192-200.
55.
Scoles, P.
, E. W. Fine, and R. Soena1980“Depression in women arrested for driving under the influence.”Focus Women1: 8-12.
56.
Selzer, M. L.
and C. E. Payne1962“Automobile accidents, suicide and unconscious motivation.”Amer. J. of Psychiatry119: 237-240.
57.
Selzer, M. L.
, C. E. Payne, J. D. Gifford, and W. L. Kelley1963“Alcoholism, mental illness and the `drunk driver.' ”Amer. J. of Psychiatry120: 326-331.
58.
Selzer, M. L.
, C. E. Payne, F. H. Westervelt, and J. Quinn1967“Automobile accidents as an expression of psychopathology in an alcoholic population.”Q. J. of Studies on Alcohol28: 505-516.
59.
Sutherland, E.1950“The sexual psychopath laws.”J. of Criminal Law and Criminology40: 543-554.
60.
Voas, R.
1974 Alcohol, Drugs and Young Drivers. Washington, DC: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
61.
Waller, J. A.1968“Patterns of traffic accidents and violations related to drinking and to some medical conditions.”Q. J. of Studies on Alcohol Supplement4 (May): 118-137.
62.
West, I.
, J. Ryan, G. Neilsen, and A. Gilmore1965“Alcohol held big factor in California's July 4 crashes.”Traffic Safety65, 2: 10-12, 34-35.
63.
West, N.1985“N.H. court holds roadblocks unconstitutional.”National Law J. (September 9): 8.
64.
Whitehead, P. C.
and R. Ferrence1975“Alcohol and other drugs related to young drivers' traffic accident involvement.”J. of Safety Research8, 2: 15-21.
65.
Weiner, C. L.
1981 The Politics of Alcoholism. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.
66.
Zador, P.1976“Statistical evaluation of the effectiveness of `ASAP.' ”Accident Analysis and Prevention7: 51-66.
67.
Zylman, R.
1975 “Mass arrests for impaired driving may not prevent traffic deaths,” pp. 225-237 in S. Israelstam and S. Lambert (eds.) Alcohol, Drugs, and Traffic Safety. Toronto: Addiction Research Foundation.
68.
Zylman, R.1976“Collision behavior of young drivers: comments on the study by Whitehead.”J. of Studies on Alcohol37, 3: 211-213.
