Sensible Pretrial Reform: The Importance of Accounting for Risk of Violence in Judicial Release Decisions

Abstract

This study uses data collected from three diverse counties in the United States between 2017 and 2019 to compare the performance of a pretrial risk instrument—the Public Safety Assessment (or PSA)—to a revised version of the tool that accounts for risk of future violence in predicting three pretrial release outcomes. Results indicate the suggested three tiered release levels produced from the current PSA release conditions matrix (RCM) are better at predicting failure to appear in court, while those generated from the violence-informed RCM are better at predicting arrest for a new violent crime. The suggested release levels from both versions of the RCM were similarly able to distinguish between likelihood of a new arrest for any reason.

Keywords

jail pretrial policy risk assessment violence

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Advancing Pretrial Policy & Research. (2023a). About the public safety assessment. https://advancingpretrial.org/psa/factors/

Advancing Pretrial Policy & Research. (2023b). Guide to the release conditions matrix. https://advancingpretrial.org/guide/guide-to-the-release-condition-matrix

Ægisdóttir

White

M. J.

Spengler

P. M.

Maugherman

A. S.

Anderson

L. A.

Cook

R. S.

Nichols

C. N.

Lampropoulos

G. K.

Walker

B. S.

Cohen

Rush

J. D.

(2006). The meta-analysis of clinical judgment project: Fifty-six years of accumulated research on clinical versus statistical predictions. The Counseling Psychologist, 34(3), 341–382.

Andrews

D. A.

Bonta

Wormith

J. S.

(2006). The recent and near future of risk and/or need assessment. Crime & Delinquency, 52(1), 7–27.

Appleman

L. I.

(2012). Justice in the shadowlands: Pretrial detention, punishment, and the Sixth Amendment. Washington and Lee Law Review, 69(3), 1297–1369.

Arnold

Dobbie

Yang

C. S.

(2018). Racial bias in bail decisions. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 133(4), 1885–1932.

Barabas

Dinakar

Doyle

(2019, July 17). The problem with risk assessment tools. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/17/opinion/pretrial-ai.html

Boches

D. J.

Martin

B. T.

Giuffre

Sanchez

Sutherland

A. L.

Shannon

S. K.

(2022). Monetary sanctions and symbiotic harms. RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences, 8(2), 98–115.

Bonta

Andrews

D. A.

(2017). The psychology of criminal conduct (6th ed.). Routledge.

10.

Brittain

B. J.

Georges

Martin

(2021). Examining the predictive validity of the Public Safety Assessment. Criminal Justice & Behavior, 48(10), 1431–1449.

11.

Campbell

C. M.

Labrecque

R. M.

Weinerman

Sanchagrin

(2020). Gauging detention dosage: Assessing the impact of pretrial detention on sentencing outcomes using propensity score modeling. Journal of Criminal Justice, 70, 101719.

12.

Copp

J. E.

Casey

Blomberg

T. G.

Pesta

(2022). Pretrial risk assessment instruments in practice: The role of judicial discretion in pretrial reform. Criminology & Public Policy, 21(2), 329–358.

13.

DeMichele

Baumgartner

(2021). Bias testing of the Public Safety Assessment: Error rate balance between whites and blacks for new arrests. Crime & Delinquency, 67(12), 2088–2113.

14.

DeMichele

Baumgartner

Wenger

Barrick

Comfort

(2020). Public safety assessment: Predictive utility and differential prediction by race in Kentucky. Criminology & Public Policy, 19(2), 409–431.

15.

DeMichele

Comfort

Barrick

Baumgartner

(2021). The intuitive-override model: Nudging judges toward pretrial risk assessment instruments. Federal Probation, 85(2), 22–31.

16.

DeMichele

Silver

Labrecque

R. M.

Dawes

Lattimore

P. K.

Tueller

(2023). Testing predictive biases at the intersection of race-ethnicity and sex: A multi-site evaluation of a pretrial risk assessment tool. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4432449

17.

DeMichele

Tueller

Burtch

Dawes

Lattimore

P. K.

(2023). Validation and predictive bias testing of the Public Safety Assessment for Pierce County, Washington. https://bit.ly/3rn5trf

18.

DeMichele

Tueller

Inkpen

Dawes

Lattimore

P. K.

(2023). Validation and predictive bias testing of the Public Safety Assessment for Fulton County, Georgia. http://bit.ly/3D746PV

19.

DeMichele

Tueller

Janda

Dawes

Lattimore

P. K.

(2023). Validation and predictive bias testing of the Public Safety Assessment for Thurston County, Washington. https://bit.ly/46UaAzt

20.

Demuth

(2003). Racial and ethnic differences in pretrial release decisions and outcomes: A comparison of Hispanic, black and white felony arrestees. Criminology, 41, 873–907.

21.

Desmarais

S. L.

Lowder

E. M.

(2019). Pretrial risk assessment tools: A primer for judges, prosecutors, and defense attorneys. MacArthur Foundation.

22.

Desmarais

S. L.

Monahan

Austin

(2022). The empirical case for pretrial risk assessment instruments. Criminal Justice & Behavior, 49(6), 807–816.

23.

Desmarais

S. L.

Zottola

S. A.

Duhart Clarke

S. E.

Lowder

E. M.

(2021). Predictive validity of pretrial risk assessments: A systematic review of the literature. Criminal Justice & Behavior, 48(4), 398–420.

24.

Dobbie

Goldin

Yang

C. S.

(2018). The effects of pretrial detention on conviction, future crime, and employment: Evidence from randomly assigned judges. American Economic Review 108(2), 201–240.

25.

Dobbie

Yang

C. S.

(2021). The US pretrial system: Balancing individual rights and public interests. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 35(4), 49–70.

26.

Donnelly

E. A.

MacDonald

J. M.

(2018). The downstream effects of bail and pretrial detention on racial disparities in incarceration. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 108(4), 775–813.

27.

Fazel

Burghart

Wolf

Whiting

Rongqin

(2023). Effectiveness of violence prevention interventions: Umbrella review of research in the general population. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse. Advanced online publication. https://doi.org/10.1177/15248380231195880

28.

Greiner

D. J.

Stubenberg

Halen

(2020). Validation of the PSA in Harris County, TX. http://a2jlab.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Validation-of-the-PSA-in-Harris-County-TX.pdf

29.

Greiner

D. J.

Stubenberg

Halen

(2021). Validation of the PSA in Kane County, IL. https://a2jlab.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Validation-of-the-PSA-in-Kane-County-IL.pdf

30.

Gupta

Hansman

Frenchman

(2016). The heavy costs of high bail: Evidence from judge randomization. The Journal of Legal Studies, 45(2), 471–505.

31.

Hanna

(2023). The facts on New Jersey bail reform. http://www.arnoldventures.org

32.

Heaton

Mayson

Stevenson

(2017). The downstream consequences of misdemeanor pretrial detention. Stanford Law Review, 69(3), 711–794.

33.

Latessa

E. J.

Smith

Lemke

Makarios

Lowenkamp

C. T.

(2006). Creation and validation of the Ohio Risk Assessment System final report. University of Cincinnati.

34.

Lattimore

P. K.

Tueller

Levin-Rector

Witwer

(2020). The prevalence of local criminal justice practices. Federal Probation, 84(1), 28–37.

35.

Leslie

Pope

N. G.

(2017). The unintended impact of pretrial detention on case outcomes: Evidence from New York City arraignments. The Journal of Law and Economics, 60(3), 529–557.

36.

Loeffler

C. E.

Nagin

D. S.

(2022). The impact of incarceration on recidivism. Annual Review of Criminology, 5, 133–152.

37.

Logan Koepke

Robinson

D. G

. (2018). Danger ahead: Risk assessment and the future of bail reform. Washington Law Review, 93(4), 1725–1807.

38.

Lowder

E. M.

Diaz

C. L.

Grommon

Ray

B. R.

(2021). Effects of pretrial risk assessments on release decisions and misconduct outcomes relative to practice as usual. Journal of Criminal Justice, 73(1), 1–14.

39.

Lowder

E. M.

Foudray

C. M.

(2021). Use of risk assessments in pretrial supervision decision-making and associated outcomes. Crime & Delinquency, 67(11), 1765–1791.

40.

Lowder

E. M.

Kamara

Z. B.

Kent

(2023). Pretrial decision-making matrices: The role of risk and charge weighting in risk assessment–guided decisions. Criminal Justice & Behavior. Advanced online publication. https://doi.org/10.25384/SAGE.c.6701634.v1

41.

Lowenkamp

C. T.

(2022). The hidden costs of pretrial detention revisited. Arnold Ventures.

42.

Lowenkamp

C. T.

DeMichele

Klein Warren

(2020). Replication and extension of the Lucas County PSA project. https://ssrn.com/abstract=3727443

43.

Lowenkamp

C. T.

Whetzel

(2009). The development of an actuarial risk assessment instrument for U.S. pretrial services. Federal Probation, 73(2), 33–36.

44.

Meitl

M. B.

Morris

R. G.

(2019). Pretrial incapacitation duration impacts the odds of recidivism among unreleased bond-eligible defendants. Journal of Law and Criminal Justice, 7(2), 1–11.

45.

Menefee

M. R.

(2018). The role of bail and pretrial detention in the reproduction of racial inequalities. Sociology Compass, 12(5), e12576.

46.

Moore

Ferguson

Guerin

(2023). How accurate are rebuttable presumptions of pretrial dangerousness? A natural experiment from New Mexico. Journal of Empirical Legal Studies, 20(2), 377–408.

47.

Oleson

J. C.

Lowenkamp

C. T.

Cadigan

T. P.

VanNostrand

Wooldredge

(2016). The effect of pretrial detention on sentencing in two federal districts. Justice Quarterly, 33(6), 1103–1122.

48.

Page

Piehowski

Soss

(2019). A debt of care: Commercial bail and the gendered logic of criminal justice predation. RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences, 5(1), 150–172.

49.

Page

Scott-Hayward

C. S.

(2022). Bail and pretrial justice in the United States: A field of possibility. Annual Review of Criminology, 5(1), 91–113.

50.

Pina-Sánchez

Grech

D. C.

(2018). Location and sentencing: To what extent do contextual factors explain between court disparities? The British Journal of Criminology, 58(3), 529–549.

51.

Pinchevsky

G. M.

Steiner

(2016). Sex-based disparities in pretrial release decisions and outcomes. Crime & Delinquency, 62(3), 308–340.

52.

Pretrial Justice Institute. (2020). The case against: Pretrial risk assessment instruments. https://bit.ly/3XM61mD

53.

Rabinowitz

(2021). Incarceration without conviction: Pretrial detention and the erosion of innocence in American criminal justice. Routledge.

54.

Ross

M. C.

Ochoa

E. M.

Papachristos

A. V.

(2023). Evaluating the impact of a street outreach intervention on participant involvement in gun violence. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA, 120(46), e2300327120.

55.

Sacks

Sainato

V. A.

Ackerman

A. R.

(2015). Sentenced to pretrial detention: A study of bail decisions and outcomes. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 40(3), 661–681.

56.

Schlesinger

(2005). Racial and ethnic disparity in pretrial criminal processing. Justice Quarterly, 22(2), 170–192.

57.

Scott-Hayward

C. S.

Copp

J. E.

Demuth

(2022). Handbook on pretrial justice. Routledge.

58.

Scott-Hayward

C. S.

Fradella

H. F.

(2019). Punishing poverty: How bail and pretrial detention fuel inequalities in the criminal justice system. University of California Press.

59.

Skeem

Montoya

Lowenkamp

C. T.

(2023). Understanding racial disparities in pretrial detention recommendations to shape policy reform. Criminology & Public Policy, 22(2), 233–262.

60.

Smith

(2022). Pretrial detention, pretrial release, and public safety. Arnold Ventures.

61.

Stevenson

Mayson

S. G.

(2017). Bail reform: New directions for pretrial detention and release. In Luna

(Ed.), Reforming criminal justice: Pretrial and trial processes (Vol. 3, pp. 21–48). Arizona State University.

62.

Tabor

(2023). There is no longer cash bail in Illinois: What happens now? http://www.illinoispolicy.org

63.

VanNostrand

(2009). Assessing risk among pretrial defendants in Virginia: The Virginia Pretrial Risk Assessment Instrument. Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services.

64.

VanNostrand

Lowenkamp

C. T.

(2013). Assessing pretrial risk without a defendant interview. Laura and John Arnold Foundation.

65.

Viljoen

J. L.

Jonnson

M. R.

Cochrane

D. M.

Vargen

L. M.

Vincent

G. M.

(2019). Impact of risk assessment instruments on rates of pretrial detention, postconviction placements, and release: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Law and Human Behavior, 43(5), 397–420.

66.

Viljoen

J. L.

Vargen

L. M.

Cochrane

D. M.

Jonnson

M. R.

Goossens

Monjazeb

(2021). Do structured risk assessments predict violent, any, and sexual offending better than unstructured judgment? An umbrella review. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 27(1), 79–97.

67.

Zeng

(2022). Jail inmates in 2021 – Statistical tables. Bureau of Justice Statistics.

68.

Zettler

H. R.

Morris

R. G.

(2015). An exploratory assessment of race and gender-specific predictors of failure to appear in court among defendants released via a pretrial services agency. Criminal Justice Review, 40(4), 417–430.