Progressive Politics and Policy Setting: Examining Criminal Justice Reform Efforts by Black Prosecutors

Abstract

Increasing awareness of racial disparities in case processing and sentencing has led justice reform advocates to challenge locally elected officials, specifically chief prosecutors, to address disparate treatment through criminal justice reforms. Elected prosecutors within across several jurisdictions have attempted to address these concerns by adopting “smart-on-crime” policies. However, the extent to which chief prosecutors have adopted such policies has been unexplored empirically. Additionally, little is known about prosecutors’ support for these changes in smaller jurisdictions. The current study explores the political platforms and reform efforts of progressive-oriented prosecutors, highlighting the reform efforts of Black chief prosecutors. Findings suggest that reformed-minded Black prosecutors adopt policies aimed at addressing disparate treatment and positively influencing public perceptions and legitimacy of the office.

Keywords

courts qualitative minorities

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abrams

D. S.

Bertrand

Mullainathan

(2012). Do judges vary in their treatment of race? The Journal of Legal Studies, 41(2), 347–383.

ACLU Smart Justice. (2019). Unlocking the Black box how the prosecutorial transparency act will empower communities and help end mass incarceration. American Civil Liberties Union.

Alderden

M. A.

Ullman

S. E.

(2012). Creating a more complete and current picture: Examining police and prosecutor decision-making when processing sexual assault cases. Violence Against Women, 18(5), 525–551.

Alexander

(2012). The new Jim Crow: Mass incarceration in the age of colorblindness. The New Press.

American Bar Association. (2022). Women in the legal profession. https://www.abalegalprofile.com/women.php

Armstrong

Gosling

Weinman

Marteau

(1997). The place of inter-rater reliability in qualitative research: An empirical study. Sociology, 31(3), 597–606.

Bazelon

(2020). Charged: The new movement to transform American prosecution and end mass incarceration. Random House Trade Paperbacks.

Bazelon

Krinsky

(2018, December 11). There’s a wave of new prosecutors. And they mean justice. The Ney York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/11/opinion/how-local-prosecutors-can-reform-their-justice-systems.html

Bolton

Feagin

(2004). Black in blue: African-American police officers and racism. Routledge.

10.

Bradbury

M. D.

Kellough

J. E.

(2008). Representative bureaucracy: Exploring the potential for active representation in local government. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 18(4), 697–714.

11.

Bradbury

M. D.

Kellough

J. E.

(2011). Representative bureaucracy: Assessing the evidence on active representation. The American Review of Public Administration, 41(2), 157–167.

12.

Brady

P. Q.

Reyns

B. W.

(2020). A focal concerns perspective on prosecutorial decision making in cases of intimate partner stalking. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 47(6), 733–748.

13.

Brown

J. M.

Sorensen

J. R.

(2013). Race, ethnicity, gender, and waiver to adult court. Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice, 11(3), 181–195.

14.

Brunson

R. K.

Gau

J. M.

(2015). Officer race versus macro-level context: A test of competing hypotheses about black citizens’ experiences with and perceptions of black police officers. Crime & Delinquency, 61(2), 213–242.

15.

Bureau of Justice Statistics. (2018, September 20). 2019 national survey of prosecutors. https://bjs.ojp.gov/funding/awards/2018-85-cx-k040

16.

Cebulak

(2004). Why rural crime and justice really matter. Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology, 19(1), 71–81.

17.

Chew

P. K.

Kelley

R. E.

(2009). Myth of the color-blind judge: An empirical analysis of racial harassment cases. Washington University Law Review, 86, 1117.

18.

Clair

Winter

A. S.

(2016). How judges think about racial disparities: Situational decision making in the criminal justice system. Criminology, 54(2), 332–359.

19.

Cox

Tamir

(2022). Race is central to identity for Black Americans and affects how they connect with each other. Pew Research Center.

20.

Congressional Progressive Caucus. (2023). Congressional Progressive Caucus. https://progressives.house.gov/home

21.

Crenshaw

K. W.

(2017). On intersectionality: Essential writings. The New Press.

22.

Dyson

M. E.

(1993). Reflecting black: African-American cultural criticism (Vol. 9). University of Minnesota Press.

23.

Eder

Kirkpatrick

D. D.

(2021). The police killings were years ago. New prosecutors are reopening cases. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/11/30/us/prosecutors-investigating-police-killings.html

24.

Eisenberg

Preston

(2022, October 26). progressive prosecutors are not tied to the rise in violent crime. Center for American Progress. https://www.americanprogress.org/article/progressive-prosecutors-are-not-tied-to-the-rise-in-violent-crime/

25.

Fair and Justice Prosecution. (2018). 21 Principles for the 21st century prosecutor. Fair and Justice Prosecution. 21 Principles for the 21^st Century Prosecutor (fairandjustprosecution.org).

26.

Farrell

Ward

Rousseau

(2009). Race effects of representation among federal court workers: Does black workforce representation reduce sentencing disparities? The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 623(1), 121–133.

27.

Franklin

T. W.

(2010a). Community influence on prosecutorial dismissals: A multilevel analysis of case-and county-level factors. Journal of Criminal Justice, 38(4), 693–701.

28.

Fogleson

Levi

Rosenfeld

Schoenfeld

Wood

Stemen

Rengifo

(2022). Violent crime and public prosecution: A review of recent data on homicide, robbery, and progressive prosecution in the United States. Report. Human Rights & Justice, Global Justice Lab, Munk School.

29.

Forman

Jr . (2017). Locking up our own: Crime and punishment in Black America. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

30.

Franklin

T. W.

(2010b). The intersection of defendants’ race, gender, and age in prosecutorial decision making. Journal of Criminal Justice, 38(2), 185–192.

31.

George

T. E.

Yoon

A. H.

(2014). The gavel gap. Who sits in judgment on state courts? American Constitution Society for Law and Policy.

32.

Gibson

J. L.

(1983). From simplicity to complexity: The development of theory in the study of judicial behavior. Political Behavior, 5(1), 7–49.

33.

Goldman

(1978). Should there be affirmative action for the judiciary. Judicature, 62, 488.

34.

Hamlet

J. D.

(2011). Word! The African American oral tradition and its rhetorical impact on American popular culture. Black History Bulletin, 74(1), 27–31.

35.

Hartley

R. D.

Tillyer

(2018). Examining prosecutorial discretion in federal criminal cases: Legal and extra-legal determinants of declination and charge change decisions. Justice Quarterly, 35(7), 1195–1225.

36.

Henderson

M. L.

Cullen

F. T.

Cao

Browning

S. L.

Kopache

(1997). The impact of race on perceptions of criminal injustice. Journal of Criminal Justice, 25(6), 447–462.

37.

Herman

M. M.

(2002). Race and ethnic bias trends in 2002: Diversity in the courts (Report on Trends in the State Courts). Trends in the State Courts.

38.

Holmes

M. D.

Hosch

H. M.

Daudistel

H. C.

Perez

D. A.

(1993). Judges’ ethnicity and minority sentencing: Evidence concerning Hispanics. Social Science Quarterly, 74, 496–506.

39.

Hurwitz

Peffley

(2005). Explaining the great racial divide: Perceptions of fairness in the US criminal justice system. The Journal of Politics, 67(3), 762–783.

40.

Johnson

B. D.

(2006). The multilevel context of criminal sentencing: Integrating judge- and county-level influences. Criminology, 44(2), 259–298.

41.

Johnson

B. D.

(2014). Judges on trial: A reexamination of judicial race and gender effects across modes of conviction. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 25(2), 159–184.

42.

Kennedy

(2012). Race, crime, and the law. Vintage.

43.

King

R. D.

Johnson

K. R.

McGeever

(2010). Demography of the legal profession and racial disparities in sentencing. Law & Society Review, 44(1), 1–32.

44.

Kingsnorth

R. F.

MacIntosh

R. C.

(2007). Intimate partner violence: The role of suspect gender in prosecutorial decision-making. Justice Quarterly, 24(3), 460–495.

45.

Krislov

Rosenbloom

D. H.

(1981). Representative bureaucracy and the American political system. Praeger.

46.

Kutateladze

B. L.

(2018). Tracing charge trajectories: A study of the influence of race in charge changes at case screening, arraignment, and disposition. Criminology, 56(1), 123–153.

47.

Kutateladze

B. L.

Andiloro

N. R.

Johnson

B. D.

Spohn

C. C.

(2014). Cumulative disadvantage: Examining racial and ethnic disparity in prosecution and sentencing. Criminology, 52(3), 514–551.

48.

Kutateladze

B. L.

Lawson

V. Z.

(2018). Is a plea really a bargain? An analysis of plea and trial dispositions in New York City. Crime & Delinquency, 64(7), 856–887.

49.

Leatherby

Oppel

R. A.

(2020, September 23). Which police departments are as diverse as their communities. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/09/23/us/bureau-justice-statistics-race.html

50.

Lim

C. S.

Silveira

B. S.

Snyder

J. M.

(2016). Do judges’ characteristics matter? ethnicity, gender, and partisanship in Texas state trial courts. American Law and Economics Review, 18(2), 302–357.

51.

Long

(1952). Bureaucracy and constitutionalism. American Political Science Review, 46, 808–818.

52.

Medina

(2019). Adversariality, plea bargaining, and prison population growth: Evidence from a natural experiment (SSRN 3686925). SSRN.

53.

Meier

K. J.

(1993). Latinos and representative bureaucracy testing the Thompson and Henderson hypotheses. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 3(4), 393–414.

54.

Milkis

S. M.

(2009). Theodore Roosevelt, the progressive party, and the transformation of American Democracy. University Press of Kansas.

55.

Morrison

(2020, November 18). Progressive prosecutors scored big wins in 2020 elections, boosting a nationwide trend. The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/progressive-prosecutors-scored-big-wins-in-2020-elections-boosting-a-nationwide-trend-149322

56.

Mosher

F. C.

(1968). Democracy and the public service (Vol. 53). Oxford University Press.

57.

Muhlhausen

(2004). The determinants of sentencing in Pennsylvania: Do the characteristics of judges really matter? The Heritage Foundation.

58.

Olsen

Courtney

Warnberg

Samuels

(2018). Collecting and using data for prosecutorial decisionmaking: Findings from 2018 national survey of state prosecutors’ offices. Urban Institute.

59.

Pew Research Center. (2021). Beyond red vs. blue: The political typology. Pew Research Center. https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2021/11/09/progressive-left/

60.

Piehl

A. M.

Bushway

S. D.

(2007). Measuring and explaining charge bargaining. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 23(2), 105–125.

61.

Pruitt

L. R.

Showman

B. E.

(2014). Law stretched thin: Access to justice in rural America. South Dakota Law Review, 59, 466.

62.

Rocque

(2011). Racial disparities in the criminal justice system and perceptions of legitimacy: A theoretical linkage. Race and Justice, 1(3), 292–315.

63.

Root

Faleschini

Oyenubi

(2019). Building a more inclusive federal judiciary. Center for American Progress. https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/courts/reports/2019/10/03/475359/building-inclusive-federal-judiciary

64.

Saltzstein

(1979). Representative bureaucracy and bureaucratic responsibility: Problems and prospects. Administration & Society, 10(4), 465–475.

65.

Selden

S. C.

(1997a). The promise of representative bureaucracy: Diversity and responsiveness in a government agency. ME Sharpe.

66.

Selden

S. C.

(1997b). Representative bureaucracy: Examining the linkage between passive and active representation in the farmers home administration. The American Review of Public Administration, 27(1), 22–42.

67.

Selden

S. C.

(2006). A solution in search of a problem: Discrimination, affirmative action, and the new public service. Public Administration Review, 66(6), 911–923.

68.

Selden

S. C.

Brudney

J. L.

Kellough

J. E.

(1998). Bureaucracy as a representative institution: Toward a reconciliation of bureaucratic government and democratic theory. Representative bureaucracy: Classic readings and continued controversies. American Journal of Political Science, 42, 717–744.

69.

Shermer

L. O. N.

Johnson

B. D.

(2010). Criminal prosecutions: Examining prosecutorial discretion and charge reductions in US federal district courts. Justice Quarterly, 27(3), 394–430.

70.

Simes

J. T.

Tichenor

(2022). “We’re here to help”: Criminal justice collaboration among social service providers across the urban-rural continuum. Social Service Review, 96(2), 268–307.

71.

Spohn

(1990). The sentencing decisions of black and white judges: Expected and unexpected similarities. Law and Society Review, 24, 1197–1216.

72.

Steffensmeier

Britt

C. L.

(2001). Judges’ race and judicial decision making: Do black judges sentence differently? Social Science Quarterly, 82(4), 749–764.

73.

Taylor

K. Y.

(2016). From# BlackLivesMatter to black liberation. Haymarket Books.

74.

Tonry

(1995). Malign neglect: Race, crime, and punishment in America. Oxford University Press.

75.

Uhlman

T. M.

(1977). Race, recruitment, and representation: Background differences between black and white trial court judges. Western Political Quarterly, 30(4), 457–470.

76.

U.S. Department of Justice. (2003). Justice department initiates new diversity program, Press Release (03070). February 5.

77.

Van Riper

. (1958). History of the United States civil service. Harper & Row.

78.

Wallach

J. J.

(2018). Every nation has its dish: Black bodies and black food in twentieth-century America. UNC Press Books.

79.

Weitzer

Tuch

S. A.

Skogan

W. G.

(2008). Police–community relations in a majority-Black city. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 45(4), 398–428.

80.

Welch

Combs

Gruhl

(1988). Do black judges make a difference? American Journal of Political Science, 32, 126–136.

81.

Wells

L. E.

Weisheit

R. A.

(2004). Patterns of rural and urban crime: A county-level comparison. Criminal Justice Review, 29(1), 1–22.

82.

Wilmot

K. A.

Spohn

(2004). Prosecutorial discretion and real-offense sentencing: An analysis of relevant conduct under the federal sentencing guidelines. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 15(3), 324–343.

83.

Wooldredge

Griffin

(2005). Displaced discretion under Ohio sentencing guidelines. Journal of Criminal Justice, 33(4), 301–316.

84.

Worden

R. E.

(1989). Situational and attitudinal explanations of police behavior: A theoretical reappraisal and empirical assessment. Law and Society Review, 23, 667–711.

85.

Young

(2020). The facts on progressive prosecutors. Center for American Progress. The Facts on Progressive Prosecutors - Center for American Progress. Munk School of Global and Public Affairs.