It is commonly argued that Black people may be more likely to be stopped by the police in majority White neighborhoods due to a natural tendency to first observe and then scrutinize that which seems out of the ordinary. Anecdotal evidence of police officers appearing equally drawn to White people in predominantly Black neighborhoods is sometimes presented to suggest that the phenomenon is race neutral. Motivated by such narratives, we examine the extent to which Black versus White racial categorization encourages police scrutiny in out-of-place and in-place contexts. Applying the veil-of-darkness and vehicle search threshold tests, we find that in place or out of place, being seen as White is always an advantage in Philadelphia.
Arizona v. Johnny Soto Dean (1975). 112 Ariz. 437, 543 P.2d 425. Supreme Court of Arizona.
2.
Bailey v. City of Philadelphia (2011). Settlement Agreement, Class Certification, and Consent Decree. No. 10-cv-05952, U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
3.
CarrollL.GonzalezL. (2014). Out of place: Racial stereotypes and the ecology of frisks and searches following traffic stops. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 51, 559–584.
4.
CloseB. R.MasonP. L. (2007). Searching for efficient enforcement: Officer characteristics and racially biased policing. Review of Law & Economics, 3, 263–321.
5.
GloverK. (2007). Police discourse on racial profiling. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 23(3), 239–247.
6.
GroggerJ.RidgewayG. (2006). Testing for racial profiling in traffic stops from behind a veil of darkness. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 101(475), 878–887.
7.
HannonL. (2019). Neighborhood residence and assessments of racial profiling using census data. Socius, 5, 1–9.
8.
HarrisD. (2002). Profiles in injustice: Why racial profiling cannot work. The New Press.
9.
KalinowskiJ.RossS. L.RossM. B. (2017). Endogenous driving behavior in tests of racial profiling in police traffic stops (Working Papers 2017-03). University of Connecticut. https://ideas.repec.org/p/uct/uconnp/2017-03.html
10.
KennedyR. (1997). Race, crime, and the law. Harvard University Press.
11.
LevchakP. J. (2017). Do precinct characteristics influence stop-and-frisk in New York City? A multi-level analysis of post-stop outcomes. Justice Quarterly, 34, 377–406.
12.
MasseyD.DentonN. (1998). American apartheid. Harvard University Press. (Original work published 1993)
13.
MeehanA. J.PonderM. C. (2002). Race and place: The ecology of racial profiling African American motorists. Justice Quarterly, 19, 399–430.
NovakK. J.ChamlinM. B. (2012). Racial threat, suspicion, and police behavior: The impact of race and place in traffic enforcement. Crime & Delinquency, 58, 275–300.
PiersonE.SimoiuC.OvergoorJ.Corbett-DaviesS.JensonD.ShoemakerA.. . . GoelS. (2020). A large-scale analysis of racial disparities in police stops across the United States. Nature Human Behaviour, 4. https://openpolicing.stanford.edu/publications/
18.
QuillianL.PagerD. (2001). Black neighbors, higher crime? The role of racial stereotypes. American Journal of Sociology, 107, 717–767.
19.
RojekJ.RosenfeldR.DeckerS. (2012). Policing race: The racial stratification of searches in police traffic stops. Criminology, 50, 993–1024.
20.
Russell-BrownK. (2008). The color of crime: Racial hoaxes, white fear, black protectionism, police harassment, and other macroaggressions. New York University Press.
21.
SampsonR. J.RaudenbushS. W. (2004). Seeing disorder: Neighborhood stigma and the social construction of broken windows. Social Psychology Quarterly, 67, 319–342.
22.
SimoiuC.Corbett-DaviesS.GoelS. (2017). The problem of infra-marginality in outcome tests for discrimination. The Annals of Applied Statistics, 11(3), 1193–1216.
23.
SmithM.TillyerR.LloydC.PetrocelliM. (2019). Benchmarking disparities in police stops: A comparative application of 2nd and 3rd generation techniques. Justice Quarterly. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1080/07418825.2019.1660395
24.
TaniguchiT. A.HendrixJ. A.Levin-RectorA.AagaardB. P.StromK. J.ZimmerS. A. (2017). Extending the veil of darkness approach: An examination of racial disproportionality in traffic stops in Durham, NC. Police Quarterly, 20(4), 420–448.
25.
ThompsonA. C. (1999). Stopping the usual suspects: Race and the fourth amendment. New York University Law Review, 74, 956–1013.
26.
TillyerR.EngelR. S.WooldredgeJ. (2008). The intersection of racial profiling research and the law. Journal of Criminal Justice, 36(2), 138–153.
WhiteM. D.FradellaH. F. (2016). Stop and frisk: The use and abuse of a controversial policing tactic. New York University Press.
29.
WithrowB. L. (2004). Driving while different: A potential theoretical explanation for race-based policing. Criminal Justice Policy Review, 15, 344–364.
30.
WordenR. E.McLeanS. J.WheelerA. P. (2012). Testing for racial profiling with the veil-of-darkness method. Police Quarterly, 15, 92–111.
