Does capital punishment exert any deterrent effect on homicide, above and beyond the effects of noncapital punishment? We hypothesized that potential deterrent effects should be strongest within a few days of executions because that was when news coverage peaked. We examined data on newspaper and national television news coverage, and found that it was largely confined to the period within a few days of executions. We analyzed state homicide counts for individual days from 1979 through 1998 (n = 372,555 state-days), following the methods of Grogger and controlling for size of the prison population. We found no significant homicide drops corresponding to temporal patterns of news coverage, with one exception: a small but significant drop on the days executions occurred.
BaileyW. C. (1990). Murder, capital punishment, and television: Execution publicity and homicide rates. American Sociological Review, 55, 628-633.
2.
BaileyW. C. (1998). Deterrence, brutalization, and the death penalty: Another examination of Oklahoma’s return to capital punishment. Criminology, 36, 711-733.
3.
BaileyW. C.PetersonR. D. (1989). Murder and capital punishment: A monthly time-series analysis of execution publicity. American Sociological Review, 54, 722-743.
4.
BaronJ. N.ReissP. C. (1985). Same time next year. American Sociological Review, 50, 347-363.
5.
BowersW. J.PierceG. L. (1980). Deterrence or brutalization: What is the effect of executions?Crime & Delinquency, 26, 453-484.
CochranJ. K.ChamlinM. B. (2000). Deterrence and brutalization: The dual effects of executions. Justice Quarterly, 17, 685-706.
9.
CochranJ. K.ChamlinM. B.SethM. (1994). Deterrence or brutalization? An impact assessment of Oklahoma’s return to capital punishment. Criminology, 32, 107-134.
DoobA. N.WebsterC. M. (2003). Sentence severity and crime: Accepting the null hypothesis. Crime and Justice, 30, 143-195.
12.
GravesW. F. (1956). The deterrent effect of capital punishment in California. Medical Arts and Sciences, 10, 137-141.
13.
GroggerJ. (1990). The deterrent effect of capital punishment: An analysis of daily homicide counts. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 85, 295-303.
14.
HjalmarssonR. (2009). Does capital punishment have a “local” deterrent effect on homicides?American Law and Economics Review, 11, 310-334.
15.
HjalmarssonR. (2012). Can executions have a short-term deterrence effect on non-felony homicides?Criminology & Public Policy, 11, 565-571.
16.
KleckG.SeverB.LiS.GertzM. (2005). The missing link in general deterrence research. Criminology, 43, 623-660.
17.
LandK. C.TeskeR. H. C.Jr.ZhengH. (2009). The short-term effects of executions on homicides: Deterrence, displacement, or both?Criminology, 47, 1009-1044.
18.
LochnerL. (2007). Individual perceptions of the criminal justice system. American Economic Review, 97, 446-460.
19.
McFarlandS. G. (1983). Is capital punishment a short-term deterrent to homicide? A study of the effects of four recent American executions. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 74, 1014-1032.
20.
NaginD. S.PogarskyG. (2001). Integrating celerity, impulsivity, and extralegal sanction threats into a model of general deterrence: Theory and evidence.Criminology, 39, 865-889.
21.
National Research Council. (2012). Deterrence and the death penalty. Washington, D.C: National Academies Press.
22.
PaternosterR. (2010). How much do we really know about criminal deterrence?Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 100, 765-824.
23.
PetersonR. D.BaileyW. C. (1991). Felony murder and capital punishment: An examination of the deterrence question. Criminology, 29, 367-395.
24.
PhillipsD. P. (1980). The deterrent effect of capital punishment: New evidence on an old controversy. American Journal of Sociology, 86, 139-148.
25.
PhillipsD. P.HensleyJ. E. (1984). When violence is rewarded or punished: The impact of mass media stories on homicide. Journal of Communication, 34, 101-116.
26.
PrattT.CullenF. T.BlevinsK. R.DaigleL. E.MadensenT. D. (2006). The empirical status of deterrence theory: A meta-analysis. In CullenF. T.WrightJ. P.BlevinsK. R. (Eds.), Taking stock: The status of criminological theory (pp. 367-395). New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.
StackS. (1995). The impact of publicized executions on homicide. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 22, 172-186.
29.
StolzenbergL.D’AlessioS. J. (2004). Capital punishment, execution publicity and murder in Houston, Texas. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 94, 351-379.
